Did you recently take on (or consider) a loan of 84 months or longer on a car purchase?
A reporter would like to speak with you about your experience; please reach out to PR@Edmunds.com by 7/25 for details.
Options

Go Green By Driving It 'Til The Wheels Fall Off

1568101113

Comments

  • andre1969andre1969 Member Posts: 26,023
    I actually have AAA, but my plan only gives you four free tows per year, and I think it's 100 miles per tow. Considering the fleet I have, I figure it's only a matter of time before I REALLY need to use it, so I'd rather not waste it on something like this flat tire fiasco.

    It's only a matter of time before one of my old cars ends up leaving me for dead up in Carlisle or Macungie or something. Come to think of it, this past summer, the power steering on my '79 5th Ave died while I was in Carlisle. Didn't leave me stranded, but it did take a little muscle to drive the thing back home. Once you actually got moving, it wasn't so bad, but low-speed maneuvering in tight quarters, such as parking lots, getting it into the garage, etc, were a bit of a challenge.

    I don't think I've had to use AAA to tow a car since 2001/2002. And that year, I actually DID use my four tows! I let a friend use it to get it towed when the transmission on his '98 Tracker died. And then, the other three times, my '89 Gran Fury ate its starter and then two remanufactured units, all in rapid succession. It actually ate a third one, but by the grace of God I managed to get it to start, drove it to the mechanic, and finally, the fourth time was a charm.

    I've had cars die on me since then, but fortunately it was always something that would re-start, eventually. Stuff like my '79 New Yorker intermittently leaving me stranded at work, my 2000 Intrepid doing that once or twice when the crankshaft position sensor started to go, distributor in the truck starting to go bad, etc.

    Oh, and this tragedy with my truck's flat tire isn't over yet. The Catalina's spare was the right bolt pattern, 5 on 5", but I overlooked one little detail. The Catalina's spare is a 14" rim. The truck has 15" rims, and the back brake drums were too big for the 14" to fit over. :mad: In a way though, that impressed me, that GM would actually make something over-sized. GM, of the under-sized THM200 transmission fame. GM, who would put 9.5" Corvair brakes on musclecars with 4x the horsepower.

    I wonder how big the back brakes are on that truck, anyway? I think the Catalina has 11" drums all around. I believe my DeSoto has 12" drums, yet a 14" rim fits over it just fine. I guess maybe with a 13" drum, the outer diameter might be too big for a 14" wheel to fit over?

    So, needless to say, the fat lady ain't sung yet!
  • Mr_ShiftrightMr_Shiftright Member Posts: 64,481
    when I bought my MINI I thought for *sure* I'd need lots of road service, so I bought AAAs premium package, for long tow jobs (I think it's 200 miles).

    Unfortunately, the darn car has proven dead reliable--but I do keep a *really* close watch on it. I don't trust it one bit.
  • andre1969andre1969 Member Posts: 26,023
    My neighbors have AAA, and I swear within the past year, I've seen three of their four cars end up on the flatbed for some reason or other. Those three are a fairly new Hyundai Entourage, a 2004-2008 Maxima, and a ~2001 Ranger. The one holdout, an '89 Coupe DeVille, has had its number of issues, but thankfully they're always able to limp it off to the mechanic before it leaves them stranded.

    I remember one of the times my '89 Gran Fury had to be towed, I inadvertently insulted the tow truck driver. He showed up in this little cabover job that looked smaller than the car, and I asked him if it was big enough to do the job!

    Oh, as for trusting a car, I think my '79 New Yorker dying at work the other day, after a fairly long reliable run, was a bit of an omen. I'm going up to Pennsylvania this weekend, and had planned on driving it! But, I'm over that thought now!
  • steverstever Guest Posts: 52,454
    Geeze, my last tow was in 1975 or thereabouts. Not even sure why I carry a towing rider on my car insurance, but as soon as I dropped it, the van would lose the timing belt on the interstate.
  • isellhondasisellhondas Member Posts: 20,342
    I have carried a AAA card in my wallet since I was in high school and I probably use it MAYBE once every 5-10 years. I pay for one for my wife and son too and they are rarely if ever used.

    But, once about 15 years or so ago I had to have one of our RX-7's towed twice in the same month.

    This prompted a somewhat testy form letter from AAA suggesting that maybe I should take better care of my cars, not use them so much etc and they even suggested that I could be dropped.

    This REALLY ticked me off.

    I called and finally got put through to one of their managers.

    He pulled up my records on his computer.

    " Do you see just how many years I've been with you"

    " Do you see how much money I have sent you over the years?"

    " Do you see how often I use your services?"

    He apologized and said I shouldn't have been sent that letter!

    That was 15 years ago and I've used them once since then when I locked my keys in my car at Home Depot maybe five years ago.
  • xwesxxwesx Member Posts: 17,686
    Mine was not so long ago, but that was the night of my '96 Outback's demise, so I don't care to remember it. :cry:
    2018 Subaru Crosstrek, 2014 Audi Q7 TDI, 2013 Subaru Forester, 2013 Ford F250 Lariat D, 1976 Ford F250, 1969 Chevrolet C20, 1969 Ford Econoline 100
  • isellhondasisellhondas Member Posts: 20,342
    " I don't trust it one bit"

    Not trusting any european car is a very wise thing!
  • andre1969andre1969 Member Posts: 26,023
    Wow, I didn't know that AAA could actually drop you! I just figured that after you used up your four free service calls, they'd start charging.
  • isellhondasisellhondas Member Posts: 20,342
    I don't remember the wording of that letter now but I've never heard of a limit on service calls.

    As with any program some will abuse it and rather than keep raising yearly rates they may have added some restrictions now.

    Every year I think about just dropping them but it does help instill a sense of security.

    Not only that, I keep forgetting that some hotels and even some restaurants offer a AAA discount.
  • steverstever Guest Posts: 52,454
    edited September 2011
    Don't get me started on AAA and their lobbying either. They want to pave the whole world, except for bike paths. They'd roll back CAFE if they could.

    Since this is a "green" topic, if you have to join an auto club, check out Better World.

    Can't see much value in any of them myself though.
  • fezofezo Member Posts: 10,386
    Oh, as for trusting a car, I think my '79 New Yorker dying at work the other day, after a fairly long reliable run, was a bit of an omen. I'm going up to Pennsylvania this weekend, and had planned on driving it! But, I'm over that thought now!

    So what will you take? The other one? :P

    What's up this weekend?
    2015 Mazda 6 Grand Touring, 2014 Mazda 3 Sport Hatchback, 1999 Mazda Miata 2004 Toyota Camry LE, 1999.
  • andre1969andre1969 Member Posts: 26,023
    So what will you take? The other one?

    Well, with luck, I'll be able to take the Park Ave. The tire I ordered is supposed to be delivered tomorrow. I'm going to run the new tire and the old rim up to the mechanic on Friday and hope he can put it on that day, so I can put it on the truck that evening. Then I can turn it back over to the roommate and get my Buick back!

    This weekend is the fall swap meet at Carlisle. Grbeck says I should start looking around for a nice downsized RWD GM B/C body. Which would be cool, but I'm not sure I want another nice old car that I'd get attached to, and only want to drive in nice weather, etc. I look at cars such as my 2000 Park Ave, 1985 Silverado, and that 2009 Altima Hybrid I've been thinking about as cars to drive, use up, and ultimately dispose of once they're too far gone. But something like a late 70's/early 80's Caprice, 98, etc would be something I'd want to hang on to and preserve.

    If the truck tire isn't ready in time, I'm thinking about driving my '76 LeMans up. I could dig my other New Yorker out, the 5th Ave, and drive it, although the power steering's out on it. No problem in most driving, but in tight manuevering it can be a good workout!
  • andre1969andre1969 Member Posts: 26,023
    edited September 2011
    Oh, yeah, finally got the Silverado home tonight, so it's safe and sound, and in my driveway. It looked so goofy with that Pontiac Rally wheel on that I had to take some pics...

    image
    image
    image
    image
  • steverstever Guest Posts: 52,454
    Looks like a Michigan truck. I could walk out my door right now and spot ten more with the same rust spots in about 5 minutes.

    The gas flap is a nice touch though. :)
  • andre1969andre1969 Member Posts: 26,023
    Looks like a Michigan truck. I could walk out my door right now and spot ten more with the same rust spots in about 5 minutes.


    Yeah, but I imagine in Michigan, you'd see rusty trucks like this that are 15-20 years newer!

    My roommate said that one of their regular customers at the restaurant has a similar truck, although it's even rustier. Sometimes my roommate would park next to it and the customer would jokingly say don't do that, it's making my truck look bad! And my roommate would say yeah, I did it so my truck would look GOOD! And last night, when I was up there messing with my truck, I saw that other truck. Good lord, I know this is gonna be like the pot calling the kettle black, but damn that thing was rusty and beat up! It was also an older truck though, and could have had another 10 years on mine.

    The gas flap is a nice touch though.

    Yeah, one of these days, I need to get up under it and see if I can fix that. Either that, or take it off. Improve the aerodynamics, so I'll get better fuel economy. Yeah, that's it! :P
  • dave8697dave8697 Member Posts: 1,498
    I need to take down my mini spare on the '98 Astro and do some restoration. I wonder if a full size spare would fit because I've seen wheels for sale on craigs list for $20 that would save me a lot of rust removal.
  • andre1969andre1969 Member Posts: 26,023
    what bolt pattern does the Astro use? Is it the 5 on 4.75" pattern that GM compact and midsize, and most full-sized Chevies used?

    I've thought about swapping out the full-sized spare in my '76 LeMans, which uses that bolt pattern, for a compact, to free up some trunk space. I think the full-size is actually original equipment. It pre-dates the 225/70/R15 style of measurement. I think it's something like FR78-15, whatever that translates to? Only part I can decipher is the 15, which means 15" rim.
  • isellhondasisellhondas Member Posts: 20,342
    Man, that license plate number is as bad as it get's. I don't think I would even want to walk past it!
  • steverstever Guest Posts: 52,454
    It's definitely a beast. ;)
  • andre1969andre1969 Member Posts: 26,023
    Man, that license plate number is as bad as it get's. I don't think I would even want to walk past it!

    Oh, I actually touched that up, although the first part of the license plate actually is "666". I'm just waiting for some devil-worshipper to steal them...

    But, on that subject, here's a pic I took of the Park Avenue's odometer reading last November...
    image
  • isellhondasisellhondas Member Posts: 20,342
    I once lost a sale on a used car we had on our lot.

    After literally spending all day with this picky lady I finally landed her on a very nice used Accord.

    The deal was done until she just happened to notice the license plate. Yep, 666. She said therre would be no way she would buy that car even though I offered to pull the plates and get new ones for her.

    She was REALLY rattled. She left and I never saw her again.
  • fintailfintail Member Posts: 58,415
    Wasn't from someone who likes "8"s on their plates, was it?

    (my modern car has a pair of 8s, which I have been told are lucky...I was hoping for a 666 and some letters that looked vaguely profane :shades: )
  • isellhondasisellhondas Member Posts: 20,342
    A lot of " new arrivals" are VERY picky about numbers. The think 8's bring good fortune and 4's mean death. they won't buy cars on certain days.

    They won't buy a house that faces in what they think is the wrong direction. If the open the front door and see stairs that is BAD and they won't buy the house.

    Used to drive me nuts sometimes!
  • fezofezo Member Posts: 10,386
    That's some beast of a plate.

    If you want another nice one my Celica has the plate: WTF 34D.
    2015 Mazda 6 Grand Touring, 2014 Mazda 3 Sport Hatchback, 1999 Mazda Miata 2004 Toyota Camry LE, 1999.
  • dave8697dave8697 Member Posts: 1,498
    it uses 5 on a 15" rim. I haven't measured the dia of the bolt holes. About 5 yrs ago I picked a trunk stored mini spare to replace the one under my '87 Astro that was subjected to salt for 19 years. It was $20 and they agreed to take my rusted and dry rotted one. It still held air but had so many cracks in the rubber that I wouldn't trust it. I used it once in the 19 yrs I owned the '87.
  • dave8697dave8697 Member Posts: 1,498
    I once had car trouble right after turning 166,600 on my odo. A hundred miles of worry out of every 100,000 miles. Of course the second time through the vehicle is usually much older. Have never got to the third time. I always felt lucky when I drove my Delta 88.
  • Mr_ShiftrightMr_Shiftright Member Posts: 64,481
    that's pretty funny because the original greek in which that gospel was written uses an alphanumeric system---there were no numbers in greek, you just used a letter that had a numeric value---and if you translate it correctly, some scholars think it's 661 not 666.

    so the REAL devil is 5 short! :P
  • andres3andres3 Member Posts: 13,934
    edited September 2011
    Don't get me started on AAA and their lobbying either.

    Triple A lost all credibility when they stood up to support red light and photo radar speed cameras and video helping sleazeballs generate additional revenue taxation disguised as fines rather than support the motorist, due process, the Constitution, and the right to travel with privacy unimpeded with unnecessary regulation. Harrassment to traveling is what it is.

    AAA = scam artists. Could their position have anything to do with the financial incentive and bias towards their auto insurance division?
    '18 Porsche Macan Turbo, '16 Audi TTS, Wife's '19 VW Tiguan SEL 4-Motion
  • steverstever Guest Posts: 52,454
    bias towards their auto insurance division?

    Gee, you make them sound a lot like the AARP. :-)
  • bismarck318bismarck318 Member Posts: 49
    It was very nice of GM to attach the spare with a flimsy non serviceable cable that eventually will snap. I ended up unintentionally 'throwing' the jelly belly spare onto the highway when this cable let go (nearly causing an accident)... vehicle was 11 years old.

    Kudos to my state for their over use of caustic materials on a daily basis for nearly 6 months out of the year! As we are also breathing this material, no wonder the heart disease rate is so high in this area.

    Gotta keep the local industries going :)
  • dave8697dave8697 Member Posts: 1,498
    edited September 2011
    The cable on the '87 was partly broken through. About 1/3 of the strands were snapped. It never let loose on me. Think of the interior room it saved. It is also low cost and low weight.
  • bismarck318bismarck318 Member Posts: 49
    This was a very late '95 (Mid October '95) & this let loose in '07. The rim was so rusted it didn't hold air, but surprisingly the rest of the undercarrage didn't look all that bad. I wish GM would go back to the space frame with composite materials, no body rust to ever deal with (even the rockers were a heavy plastic) ... aside from this incident this was a pretty good vehicle.... amazing with the yearly chemical baths for at least the 8 years I had it, the vehicle still had the original exhaust in 2009 @ 115K

    Too bad they couldn't have used arm clamps or incorporated a weather cover for the spare, as for me I really wouldn't have missed the room the 3rd row of seats were useless anyway. I would prefer an internal spare at this point especially where I live, they aren't meant to be exposed to that many corrosives.
  • hpmctorquehpmctorque Member Posts: 4,600
    "I wish GM would go back to the space frame with composite materials, no body rust to ever deal with (even the rockers were a heavy plastic)."

    What model of Saturn did/do you own? The Pontiac Fiero also featured a saceframe with composite materials, but wasn't generally considered a very durable car.
  • bismarck318bismarck318 Member Posts: 49
    edited October 2011
    I have a 4th Gen Camaro, & a Vue (which unfortunately has power train issues that were not addressed by GM when still in warranty) & had a Lumina APV which I felt was a very solid vehicle, & provided a decent ride... my Caravan's had rust issues, the Lumina's sucessor (Venture's) I was seeing on the road were falling apart way faster than my Lumina.

    Even the Bonneville I owned had plastic fenders.

    I have never lost a vehicle to a power train failure, all succumbed to rustout. ... though I think the Saturn may be the first.... & the failing components are from Honda. Perhaps if I lived in the Sunny South & not in the Rust/Chemical belt I would have a different view of outer steel body panels... anyhow the manufactures no longer use composites & plastics... probably held up too well... ie: no rust, door lot dings.

    A friend of mine hit a bridge abutment @ 35mph in his Fiero & was still able to drive the car home.
  • Mr_ShiftrightMr_Shiftright Member Posts: 64,481
    Not head-on he didn't. :sick:
  • andre1969andre1969 Member Posts: 26,023
    I don't think ANYTHING can hit a bridge abutment at 35 mph and still be drivable afterwards, unless it's just a glancing blow where it clips it and manages to bounce off. But head-on, I think it would have to be something big enough that somehow actually takes out the bridge abutment.
  • dave8697dave8697 Member Posts: 1,498
    finally took it down for the first time since bought new 13 yrs ago. The spare had an inch thick of dirt inside it and the salt has done it's work. After a couple hours with a rotary wire brush and a hammer and chisel, I slapped some black paint on it. Good thing I never needed it lately because it had no air in it. The rubber looks good so maybe not being pressurized was a good thing. Next up is the full size spare under the silverado that's 10 yrs old. It has less than 1/5 the miles on the vehicle and I've never used it or checked it for air pressure either. Maybe I should drill a drain hole at the low spot so it doesnt hold a pool of salt water.
  • steverstever Guest Posts: 52,454
    edited October 2011
    I'm looking forward to having TPMS on my next car, if my current rides ever die. As some of y'all know, I have a propensity to get flats. Not having a sensor cost me $160 a couple of months ago when I ruined a tire on a gravel road, not knowing it was going flat. At least I had checked the spare underneath before leaving for the road trip.

    And an idiot light saved me a tire change on a rental car a few years back. Was able to drive a mile to a compressor and then make it to a garage to get it fixed.

    Not having the latest and greatest is a problem when you drive them forever.
  • andre1969andre1969 Member Posts: 26,023
    Years ago, I had a 1979 Chrysler Newport that had one of the rear tires go flat on me at work. It had fairly big tires, something like a 225 or even a 235 75 R15, so when I put the tiny temporary spare on, the car listed to port pretty heavily.

    Needless to say, I didn't even notice when the temporary spare went flat on the way home. It was okay at work, totally flat when I pulled into the driveway, so I don't know at what point it went flat. Luckily it was only about a 4 mile drive.
  • steverstever Guest Posts: 52,454
    Heh, I'm surprised the spare's lug nut pattern even fit on the Newport, knowing who's posting. :P
  • andre1969andre1969 Member Posts: 26,023
    Heh, I'm surprised the spare's lug nut pattern even fit on the Newport, knowing who's posting.

    Ugh, don't remind me...I've had enough of a tire fiasco with that Silverado of mine to last a lifetime! Hopefully I don't have to go through that again anytime soon.

    BTW, just got that truck back from the shop...again. Turns out the "new" lower radiator hose that got put on the same time as the new water pump was dry rotted, possibly from simply sitting for too long in a warehouse somewhere.

    That's replaced now, so hopefully I won't have any more fiascos for awhile. I think I am going to start setting a little money aside each month for a new car fund, though.
  • bismarck318bismarck318 Member Posts: 49
    Not pretty & he had to clear the front wells to steer, leaking fluids etc & only had to drive it a few miles home. Claimed he was going about 35 on impact. (??) To me it looked like a center hit.... perhaps it bounced. (??) I wasn't there, but seen it afterward. These cars today can't seem to take a hit from a parking lot basket without causing thousands in damage... but then again this is what the consumer wanted. :)

    The Fiero also had it's issues with salt buildup within the space frame if not properly addressed, this was nearly inevitable in the salt belt.

    From reading over history all these space frame cars had pretty good crash ratings on them, compared to their counterparts.
  • dave8697dave8697 Member Posts: 1,498
    After 10.3 years, the Silverado spare was out of air just like the Astro spare was. I took it down, cleaned it up and filled it. A little touch up paint and lots of wax later today before I hoist it back up under. The hoist cable mechanisms are bolted on for both vehicles. Easily replaceable if ever needed. Good thing i never needed the spares. I have a 12V air pump that works off a cig lighter but I keep it in the Astro under a seat.
  • Mr_ShiftrightMr_Shiftright Member Posts: 64,481
    Yeah, either he bounced or he wasn't going anywhere near 35 mph. If one hits a totally immovable object at that speed head on, you're just about dead, or at the very least your car is totally demolished up to the windshield. A collision of that type at that speed would be incredibly violent to the car, since the bridge absorbs 0 energy.
  • hysterwvhysterwv Member Posts: 5
    Late to the party here, but....

    I've always been a car guy. I'm in sales and spend 15-20 hours per week in my car. I used to get something different everyt 2-3 years (keep in mind I drive 40-50k miles/year).

    4 kids and grown-up responsibilities have schooled me a bit on the car situation. I'm all for keeping a car as along as it's safe and the maintenance costs don't exceed the acquisition cost of a newer vehicle.

    I bought my current car, an '04 Passat TDI in Sept of '06 with 36k miles on the odometer. Today the odometer reads 271k miles. I maintain the car religiously and keep it clean. I haven't had a car payment in years and can't imagine how buying a newer car would make financial or environmental sense.
  • hpmctorquehpmctorque Member Posts: 4,600
    "...the odometer reads 271k miles. I maintain the car religiously and keep it clean. I haven't had a car payment in years and can't imagine how buying a newer car would make financial or environmental sense."

    This pretty much sums up the point of this discussion.
  • lemmerlemmer Member Posts: 2,689
    For me, buying a newer but still used car usually makes more financial and environmental sense at some point. At some mileage level, buying something like a $10K car with 80,000 miles on it makes better sense than continuing to drive an old car. At 271K, I'd be at that point.
  • andre1969andre1969 Member Posts: 26,023
    At some mileage level, buying something like a $10K car with 80,000 miles on it makes better sense than continuing to drive an old car. At 271K, I'd be at that point.

    I guess as long as the car's still reliable, keeping it might not be a bad thing. My Mom and stepdad's '99 Altima is still going, with around 330,000 miles on it, and it's been fairly reliable. If it started breaking down on a regular basis and leaving them stranded, then I'd say get rid of it, but it's holding up.

    However, they don't use it to go on long trips anymore. They used to go to Florida and up to Pennsylvania on a regular basis, and out west a few times, but these days it's just a local errand car.

    At one point they offered to give it to me, and I considered it, until my Mom asked me "how do you intend to use it?" At that point I knew there would be some kind of string attached. Years ago, they gave me an '86 Monte Carlo with 179,000 miles on it. I got T-boned delivering pizzas one night, and when they found out, their first response wasn't "Oh my God, are you okay?!" or anything like that. Nope. It was "Well why were you driving THAT car?" So, I guess they would've been happier if I had been T-boned in my '68 Dart or '79 Newport! :confuse:
  • lemmerlemmer Member Posts: 2,689
    edited October 2011
    Right now, my daily driver has 226K on it, but I have another family car for trips or anything real important. It has been super cheap to maintain but I know I could leave work today and the transmission could slip, and my car just went from being worth $4K to almost worthless in about ten seconds. A car with 80K miles on it is still depreciating, but in a reliable model the prospect of having a huge repair bill is minimal. At some point, the cost of a little depreciation is less than the cost of a huge repair bill, even amortized over a couple of years.

    That being said, they should probably just drive the Altima until something expensive breaks. They've already passed the point where they could sell it and get decent money for it, I suspect. They've done really well if they got that far without any big bills.
  • the_big_althe_big_al Member Posts: 1,079
    edited October 2011
    Wish the officer that answered the call to the accident I was involved in understood that fact. I hit an oncoming car broadside at about 35 MPH as she was turning left in front of me. I was in a 2001 S-10. She was an a 2007+ CR-V. Took out my front end half-way to the windshield. Bent her frame probably at the most, but I hit the A pillar and front passenger door so I could very well have done some serious damage to the car.

    The limit was 35 MPH. Not sure exactly how fast I was going, but I know wasn't going much faster than that if I was even going 35. (Residential street, and the limit had JUST been 25). The officer looked at my truck and the first words out of his mouth were "you were going MUCH faster than 35 MPH. Being a bit shaken up, the thought still occurred to me "have you EVER seen a crash test video? Those are run at 35 MPH into solid objects, and the cars are practically destroyed. Undriveable. Un-rollable even. At least mine you could still sort of roll it, aside from the fender and bumper being smashed into the front tire. All fault was still assigned to the other party however, I ended up with a check for my vehicle rather than it ending up at a body shop. I still miss that truck.
Sign In or Register to comment.