Edmunds dealer partner, Bayway Leasing, is now offering transparent lease deals via these forums. Click here to see the latest vehicles!
Popular New Cars
Popular Used Sedans
Popular Used SUVs
Popular Used Pickup Trucks
Popular Used Hatchbacks
Popular Used Minivans
Popular Used Coupes
Popular Used Wagons
Comments
Be interesting to see the demographics. Having driven as long as I have I personally feel that there is safety value in having extra power - I have expereinced the need for it from time to time in emergencies to get out of the way of someone or something. Many people simply react by braking in all emergency situations, when applying more power would be the better and safer alternative.
A 190 HP 4 cylinder with AT in a 3400+ pound car? Uh...no. A 177 HP 4 cylinder? Even worse. Lose 700 pounds and then I would say you are ok. E.G. the Series 1 Acura Legend - 161 HP V6 in a 2800 pound car. In that case there was plenty of power. The 240 HP in a 2700 pound S2000? More than enough.
4 wheel anti lock disc brakes? Great - conversely the engine should have equal "go" power.
I don't want to admit to the number of years and number of miules I have under my belt including a period in my life when I would do 35,000 miles a year in Los Angeles traffic.
I can't honestly remember even once using power to get me out of a jam excelt of one time when I got out of the way of a guy who had run a red light and was heading for my driver's door. The Dodge Intrepid (no powerhouse) I was driving did the job.
But, some people feel as you do and for those people we do make V-6's
3.5 liter OHC V6 214 HP - it moved pretty good, and lots of torque, which many people overlook as the primary factor in acceleration.
Hey, if a person feels strongly about the "need" for a V-6, I have no argument with them. I just think the fours are more than adequate and I'm not alone in my thinking. We sell a whole lot more fours than sixes.
Depends on your driving style, habits and location. I drive in heavy traffic and feel the need for the extra power almost daily. Were I in a rural or light traffic area I am sure the 4 would suit my purposes just fine. Where are you located?
...you certainly do have traffic!
Last October rush hour driving: Hotel Deca - Seattle waterfront (ferry) was interesting. My Navy reunion shipmates agreed big time.
Still, my 6M calc'd out at 21 mpg around your city (but south on I-5 enroute home.......would you believe 35?)
..great car.
best, ez....
http://www.edmunds.com/apps/vdpcontainers/do/vdp/articleId=123532/pageNumber=2
I loved the way they blamed scraping the alloy wheels on the car's design instead of on themselves for being careless had hitting curbs!
http://blogs.edmunds.com/roadtests/2008/06/2008-honda-accord-ex-l-v6-econnoying.- html#more
Another variable with VCM could be weather and temperature. It seems that more of the complaints regarding VCM are coming from drivers who live in parts of the country where there is colder weather(?). The Edmunds test was conducted in nice weather in California, and it's possible that VCM performs more smoothly when the climate is warmer(?). Just speculation, however.
Sorry - have to agree with them there - the "spokes" of the wheel DO protrude further than the tires themselves and ARE susceptible to curb damage even when the tires themselves are not in contact with the curb. Bad design. These wheels are too expensive to expose them to being that easily damaged. They should be redesigned. Now if they were simply scraping the RIM of the wheel where the treadwall bead is secured to the wheel because they were too close - different story.
1). "Wind and road noise are well isolated" - Huh? What car are they driving?
2). "The Accord is so quiet, comfortable and smooth on the road you don't get a sense of how fast you are really going" - This is so off, even by remote standards. Did they really test any of the other cars to compare? Changing the brand of tires helps some but this car is nothing but loud. The loudest Honda I've owned to date.
3). Not one mention of the VCM? Hearing a comment, either about the roughness (or smoothness) or even something related to MPG and how the VCM affected that would have been interesting.
The only negative, if you will, was regarding speed times decreasing? This is not a race car. Come on Edmunds, I know you want to keep your sponsors happy but this is blatant.
1) Wind noise is almost non-existent at legal speeds and among the quietest I've been exposed to, tire and road noise is ever present and about the worst I've been exposed to.
2) Not so quiet do to the road noise, very comfortable no problems with the seats that others have had issues with and speed is apparent, any tickets issued while driving this car can only be attributed to in-attentiveness, 35 MPH can sometimes feel like 45.
3) VCM is present in varying degrees depending on the terrain, cruising speed and attitude towards the throttle, and I'm inclined to include temperature as the recent 10-30 degree New England temps have raised my awareness of it's activity.
"I know what you're thinking, the actual cylinder deactivation process is annoying; there must be a shutter or a jolt when the system active and deactivates. Wrong. The annoying part is the light."
This was a test involving 20,000 miles with multiple drivers, environments, driving styles, terrain, and intended/unintended biases. So lack of comment about the surging/vibration is relevant, IMO. It doesn't mean other cars don't have it, but this test example seemed to operate fine to the point hardly anyone even noticed abnormal cylinder operation, surging, vibration. The lack of comments does not suggest an incomplete review, as sunnfun said.
The long term testers obviously didn't have the same problems with the car, that you have. I'm sure if the car exhibited the same surging, and vibrations, some posters on this board describe, at least one of them would have mentioned it. According to some, ALL VCM Accords exhibit these "annoying" and "totally unacceptable" sensations. Apparently, NOT ALL of them do. Even Honda can make a Lemon or two out of 400k, and it seems you were one of the unlucky few. Maybe you will do a more thorough test drive next time, instead of assuming every car on the lot is perfect. I have read reviews on my car (03 EX V6) that were very critical, but my car has been every thing I could have hoped for. I've test driven two cars from the same dealership before, that were very different, despite being the same model and trim.
I think your missing my point. Honda spent a considerable amount of money to market the benefits of VCM. And for them to not even mention it, positively or negatively tells me there is more to this story behind the scenes. I have read other articles regarding MPG and VCM, both for and against. I would have assumed Edmonds would have at least mentioned it.
The good news is that I am going car shopping this weekend. I bought my wife a Lexus ES350 back in the summer and she loves it. I like driving it much more than my car. Provided I don't take to much of a loss, bye bye Honda. It is sad since I have been driving these cars for almost 20 years. But enough is enough.
So what you are saying is, All VCM Accords do it, and all of these testers were oblivious to it? As irritating as you all say VCM is, don't you think the testers would have noticed it? And commented on it? Do you think the testers felt the vibrations, and surging, and decided not to say anything, in effect lieing to the readers?
Pat/Karen - would you be willing to disclose what type of relationship Edmunds has with Honda? Is it financial or some other type of agreement with Honda?
Meanwhile the parts to fix the noise and vibration on my 08 Accord are on back order. According to the parts dept at our local Honda dealership, the parts were not in stock "due to the number of Accords needing the same repair."
My previous Accord was an '03 and it did not have the problems that many others had with that particular model year. I don't expect perfection in a product that is mass produced; however, I do expect the manufacturer to step to the plate, address the problem, and at least attempt to satisfy the customer. So far, Honda's response has been less than you'd expect from a company whose past reputation was built on quality.
Actually the part that gets scraped isn't the spokes. It's the lip of the wheel where it meets the tire.
I love it when someone blames carelessness on the manufacturer.
Funny, I've never scraped one of mine but I do tend to be careful when I pull up to a curb!
"I might be wrong here, but didn't Hondas used to have a "cute" aspect to them? You know, kind of like a Mini Cooper or a VW Beetle? They're tough little machines with personality to boot, right? You can still see Honda's cute look in the CRV and Pilot. But where is it in the sedans? I don't want to offend any loyal Honda fans - I know there are many of you out there. But can someone please explain this identity shift? Do you like it?
"
So I went to the previous reviewer, Mike Hanley, and he had this to say about VCM.
"Honda's integration of VCM is exceptional; it's nearly impossible to tell when the car is running on three, four or six cylinders.
Which baffles me, because some owners claim they test drove 5 different cars, and "they all were exactly the same". :confuse:
Nor have I EVER had anyone else mention this or perceive a problem.
Our latest is a 2008 Accord EXL-V6 with VCM. We traded in an 04 Acura TL which was a fine car, but we tired of the harsh ride, especially here in Ohio with all the bad winter damaged roads. The new Accord rides very nice but we had to drive a number of months before we got used to its bigger size, and we still have a 2003 Accord EX-V6, which is noticeable smaller.
We continue to notice the VCM but now do not pay any attention to it. However, if I had a choice, I would have Honda have a lockout switch so those who find it offensive could disable it. The new Accord does not get the advertised MPG on the road but does better in town. Our Acura got much better MPG but used premiumn gas. I asked our Dealer if there was a lockout command to the onboard computer but he said they were not aware of one.
In the end, we are still happy Accord owners but suggest Honda look long and hard at VCM to see if it reallty benefits anybody, since it is not in the V6 coupe with manual transmisson.
For what it is worth, I am a senior citizen.
"I hereby retract all my comments about having a VCM problem. I made a mistake. My Honda does not in fact vibrate or surge at certain speeds and has always, since the day I bought it, given me the driving experience I expected. I have either been too sensitive to these issues or I have been deceptive in my statements. I apologize for the lies and deception in my previous postings and I hereby appeal to all of you who are complisent in this conspiracy to cease and desist and stop posting in this forum. Further, I applaud isellhondas and others in their persistence in exposing this fraud for what it is"
There, does that make you feel better? You finally got at least one of the six of us to admit it. After all, that is why you post here, right?...
Now smile and go sell some more Hondas!
You really don't need to be sarcastic. I don't doubt you are experiencing "something". It just that this "something" is a condition that I have heard nothing about except in this forum.
So. carry on...maybe those with problems will be able to find a solution.
That said, there is no reason for members to repeat the same things over and over. So those of you who are guilty of doing that, please let it go.
Thanks.
My 08 also uses a quart of oil every 3000 miles. This problem has been to the regional manage level and the official response is "A quart of oil every 3000 miles is normal. Yea right! This means if you followed the maintance minder system which shows the oil life is still 50% on my car at 6000 miles it would require adding 3 quarts in between oil changes. Again Honda......this is not normal
This will be my last Honda
Strange that you "feel" with your ears, but anywho....
I purchased an '09 Accord EX-L V6 with VCM between Christmas and New Years. I traded an '07 Ridgeline. The Ridgeline would constantly up-shift and down-shift on the Interstate because of grade changes. The Accord, on the other hand, rarely shifts, but rather, the VCM modulates the power/torque to get up steeper grades without shifting the transmission. I can, in fact, feel the VCM at work, but it is nowhere near as bad as the Ridgeline's constant shifting and change in RPM.
The only vibration I have ever felt with this new Accord is in the throttle pedal at low speed. The engine mounts and active noise cancellation appear to be doing their job of keeping vibration and noise from the VCM at bay.
This is not the only place to find comments/concerns about VCM in th '08 Accord V6. Try starting here http://en.autos.sympatico.msn.ca/reviews/article.aspx?cp-documentid=6119166
To save some the trouble I'll just quote directly from the author below;
On the sedan, you can feel when VCM is activated - the engine relays a slight gravelly tingle through the toeboard. Even when all six cylinders are at work, the larger engine is not as turbine-smooth as its predecessor. The underhood sound track is a little gruffer, more aggressive. But it's certainly not unpleasant. Arguably, it's a good fit with the new Accord's sportier persona.
I have struggled with this issue from the beginning. To answer some earlier questions, I am late 30's and live in Southern Ontario. Very cold winters, very hot summers. Same issues years round. Vehicle is now 16 months old and has 45,000 klm. It stutters constantly when attempting to drive at a consistent speed over 70 klm/hour. Go ahead, pick one - 80, 110 - don't care. Cruise actually makes it better which has caused me to discuss throttle issues with dealership. They have acknowledged problem and that's it.
It gets better, brake shoes replaced at about 20,000 k and rotors warped. Climate control system now blows little bits of white crap (plastic?) out of the front vents when it hasn't been on in a few days (really nice on a black interior). For that matter, the entire HVAC unit often seems like it is possessed and blows at high volume unexpectedly. Seats are brutally uncomfortable on long hauls. But you know what, mileage is better than I anticipated.
All this for the bargain price of $37,000 Canadian dollars. What really shocks me right now is that this vehicle is the finest Honda Passenger Sedan available. Think about that, this is their best Passenger Sedan. And it is a horrible car.
I owned a 2003 Accord V6, a 2005 Accord V6 and now this one. I will never purchase another Honda.
This is not the only place where Accord VCM issues are being discussed. There are many sites/forums and dealerships that are currently trying to do something to fix this problem, hopefully before it blows up just like the 2003-2007Accord Odometer SNAFU that resulted in your recent class-action lawsuit. I wait anxiously to receive my $450 in excess mileage charges I am now owed by Honda Leasing for the two vehicles I owned that had faulty odometers.
Did you defend those accusations as well?
Try this link
http://en.autos.sympatico.msn.ca/reviews/article.aspx?cp-documentid=6119166
Strange, they can sense somethings not quite right either.
http://www.driveaccord.net/forums/showthread.php?t=24338
Get the hint.
Don't try to fix our opinion. FIX THE PROBLEM.
Reply to This Message Attach Quote to Reply
http://www.vtec.net/forums/one-message?message_id=738154&page_number=2&
I have horrible VCM problems. Vibration around town and the car struggles to find correct gear on highway. Actually, I don't believe it actually changes gears but it feels like it. It appears the VCM engaging and disengaging is causing some pausing and RPM change.
I HATE the VCM. If anyone knows a trick to turn it off I will do it in a heartbeat. Honda has driven the car and stated everything is "normal" . Riiiiight.
P.S. Please don't bother replying I am a liar. The last time I was on this board everyone jumped down my throat that I was flaming the board. I have owned many accords and loved them with the exeception of my 2008 V6. THe VCM ruins it.
I may be wrong (and biased) since my VCM equipped Accord runs fine, but I think VCM works best in steady state driving. Not saying that you do, but I found most drivers are constantly moving their right foot on the gas pedal; up/down, up/down, it's annoying to ride as a passenger sometimes! And this is in a non-Honda car! All my roads where I live are 55 mph, so anywhere between 55 and 65 I set the cruise on where possible to achieve the best mpg's I can in my commute, even in between lights. I know when I'm in 4 cyl vs 3 cyl mode (due to vibrations or harmonics I feel and hear) and I try to keep in 3 cyl mode as long as possible. Sort of like driving a hybrid I guess, trying to drive as efficiently as possible. But when the driver in front can't make up their mind if they want to go 50 or 65, it can make it hard to drive at a steady speed. The only annoying thing for me so far was being a quart of oil low at 5,700 miles. I have over 6,400 miles now with no add'l oil usage and I'm still at 30% oil life.
http://www.canadiandriver.com/2008/11/05/test-drive-2009-honda-accord-ex-l-v6-na- vi.htm
and I quote When matched up with the automatic tranny, the Accord’s V6 gets Honda’s Variable Cylinder Management system, the latest version of which can shut off two or three cylinders to save fuel. It works well - a green “eco” light on the dash is the only obvious clue that the car isn’t running on all six cylinders - but keen drivers will notice a slight surging sensation during steady highway cruising as the engine switches among its three-, four- and six-cylinder modes.
Nice to know that I'm not losing my mind......
Good bye and good luck.
"
I love it when someone blames carelessness on the manufacturer" - while I am NOT careless I am not a good parker - but the design is defective. Road testers have noted it too. Be honest about what you sell.
What does that have to do with VCM (not sure who started that issue,but really?)?
Thanks!
Other off-topic and/or personally directed posts have been removed.
Brian83, you, just like everyone else, are welcome to post here as long as your posts are civil and respectful and otherwise conform to the Membership Agreement. No one is preventing you from talking about the issues you are having so please feel free to carry on.
I took the car over to the dealer (Goodson Honda North in Houston) this morning to have the above mentioned problem checked out. The technician acknowledged the sound/vibration and he checked all the active engine mounts. Everything came back normal. Apparently, the sound/vibration is indeed endemic to this vehicle. My service adviser said she would keep an eye out for service bulletins related to this issue, but other than that, I was told nothing could be done.
For me personally, this is just picking nits. I can definitely live with this. It really doesn't bother me that much and I just wanted to make sure that nothing else was wrong.