Edmunds dealer partner, Bayway Leasing, is now offering transparent lease deals via these forums. Click here to see the latest vehicles!
Options
Popular New Cars
Popular Used Sedans
Popular Used SUVs
Popular Used Pickup Trucks
Popular Used Hatchbacks
Popular Used Minivans
Popular Used Coupes
Popular Used Wagons
Comments
The other issue is "drive by wire". I am not at all impressed with this electronic method. Yes, jets use this technology, but they do not "shift" gears. They simply increase air and fuel intake. I am not an engineer, but it seems to me that the car is maxed out in terms of weight to horsepower/torque. The small increase in HP and torque for the 330 was not at all substantial. This car should definitely be in the 250 - 275 range. That would not make it a BMW, nor do I want a BMW. It would simply mean there is ample power on tap to respond to today's driving demands in a safe and efficient manner.
Also what I don't get is that this'd be something easy to catch for those that do when test driving the car, b4 buying it. Why did they still buy it?
To repeat the problem, get going to about 40 mph, then pull back on the gas so the gas flow drops off. Then reapply the gas. The reapplication of gas after dropping off is when the shuddering tends to occur on an unmodified transmission.
The problem is not as evident during highway driving as it is in stop and go traffic.
A person test driving the vehicle may not know what to do to repeat the problem and therefore might not feel it during a test drive.
If it's this tricky for me to find it I guess even it's really there it's no big deal. I'd hardly feel 'it' anyhow. Of course I'd never understand why some people are so 'frustrated' with it as I am just as frustrated finding it.
One more thing tho, is this shuddering really what the tranny problem is. It does not seem to be the abrupt downshift or upshift hesitation issues also mentioned for it. Anyway, a few K miles already in the bag for me on both local and hwy. I am just about content with whatever tranny it's under the hood of my 300, unless it can occur only after certain mileage.
I had a Camry for several years before I bought my ES300 and the Camry did not do anything like that. I suspect that Lexuses with 4 speeds do not do it. Also, for the other Lexuses, I believe fixes were issued by Lexus. I have test driven several ES300s (only 2002s, however) and they all do it.
And yes, I think this is what people are complaining about. It can be scary when there is that delay when pulling out in traffic.
I am convinced that an individual's motor skills or lack of them contribute to the problem, not only the frequency of the problem but the severity as well.
Have you ever been a passenger in a vehicle where the driver could not keep up a constant gas flow? Where they kept speeding up and slowing slightly? I have, and it drives me crazy. The ES300 would perform very poorly for a person like that and I suspect that those few people who cannot stand the transmission tend to be that type of driver.
That said, I recalled my friend mentioned his 92 Camry having hesitation problem in merging but that's after quite a few years' miles on it. And also for most cars when you hit gas fast all the way from a stop line (like racing) you'd feel a sudden delay-and-burst. That seems normal but I am assuming that's not the one we're talking about for ES here.
You are among the owners who are not experiencing the symptom. Just thank your lucky stars and enjoy your car.
I only drove it for about 10 miles last night. I found the car to be much more responsive and definitely an improvement from the way it was. However, there are still issues. Instead of hesitating, it may surge a bit after a quick start. It stills shudders a bit as well.
Since my wife is now driving the car, I will ask her if there are any ongoing issues and will post them if serious enough to warrant it.
1) Those who don't feel it drive differently.
2) Those who don't feel it have a different perception of the same problem. For example, they think it's normal and acceptable.
3) Everyone who feels it differently than you do(or I do) is lying, exaggerating, or in denial. Those like kreativ and lenscap, who say they don't feel the problem are lying. Those like texas83, who says it is dangerous, is lying. The Lexus dealers who say there is no problem are lying. Lexus is lying.
It is human nature to believe 3. However, I don't think that helps anything. Deep down, I know that the people who perceive things differently than I do are not lying, not in denial, and not exaggerating. So, it has got to be 1) or 2) or something I haven't thought of.
How do YOU explain it?
If we were all convinced that Lexus will never under any circumstance, fix the problem, I'm sure you'd hear the conversation cease.
If we were certain that Lexus would not fix the problem, then I agree with you. Live with the car, or trade it in.
But until it is very obvious that Lexus will not fix the problem, life IS short - too short to throw lots of money away trading in nearly new vehicles when there is a possibility the problem may be fixed.
I think the biggest benefit of boards such as these is to enable a wiser choice for those considering a new ES. We who have prior experience need to inform possible new owners so that they may take this into consideration when deciding.
As long as Lexus can sell every ES they make at the price close to MSRP, they will not be moved to fix the transmission.
My previous posts document two procedures to check out the characteristics of the ES drivetrain on a test drive. If you can't feel what I and others have described here, chances are you will be happy with the car. If you do feel the symptoms, please be forewarned that Lexus will not be able to help you out.
The new ES330 continues to have the same problems unfortunately.
For those of you considering the new ES330, or even a older ES300, I would suggest he following two tests:
First, accelerate lightly on a plain road to about 38-39 mph. As the torque converter locks at about that speed, you will notive a distinct drivetrain shudder accompanied by a low frequency rumble. This will happen in the range of 40-45 mph.
Secondly, at any speed between 35-50 mph or so, after travelling at a steady spped for a few hundred yards, floor the throttle as if needed for a traffic maneuver. The engine will bog down, jerking the car very distinctly almost always, and occasionally for as long as one-half to one second, before taking off as it should do in the first place.
Like I said before, if you do these two things, and are either unable to feel these symptoms, or are not bothered by them, then you will be happy with the ES. Otherwise, you will be miserable, perhaps not as much as I was, but will be disappointed by Lexus.
I give this advice as my experience only, without any overt emotion or ulterior motive. I am quite happy with my ultralux LS430. I just don't want people to be unhappy with the ES because they did not have complete information, and that is what my intent is posting on this forum. Please feel free to ignore my post as the drivel of a raving lunatic.
3-4 Upshift Minimum Throttle = 45 mph
3-4 Upshift Wide Open Throttle (WOT) = N/A
Minimum TCC Apply -- Third Gear = 28 mph
Minimum TCC Apply -- Fourth Gear = 45 mph
mrogers - Driving in 4th gear definitely improves the situation.
And then some of us just accept the problem. As I have said before, if I had it to do over, I'd purchase my 2002 ES300, transmission problem and all, again. It is annoying to me, but not a huge, huge deal.
My only regret is that I did not find a deal where I could have bought a "used" one whose owner traded with low miles because they did not like the transmission!!
I have a 2K2 ES300 w/11.4K miles which I bought new in July of 2002. It has a manufacture date of 6/02. I read vcheng's description of the transmission issue and attempted to recreate the symtoms as described. I drove on a straight, flat road, accelerated moderately up to the indicated speed, then 'booted' the gas pedal. The engine revved up and within .5 seconds the car was underway and approaching 60mph w/o any drama at all. The shifting (such as it was) was extremely smooth and I could not detect any unusual sounds. I tried this several times and the results were the same. The transmission was very smooth in each situation and the car got up to speed promptly. I am quite perceptive and aware with excellent hearing (hence buying a such a quiet car) but could not duplicate the issue that seems so prevelant with some owners.
I must add that I have used premium fuel since taking ownership and I usually drive in a sedate/composed manner which may affect the overall behavior of the car. On rare occassions I have driven the car 'hard' - taking off in a brisk manner and 'booting' it at 60mph which quickly climbs to 80mph and find the car has plenty of power and performs as expected.
I have not had the tranny 'upgrade' due to others voicing their displeasure with the results and see no need to as I'm quite pleased with the car.
Regards -
M. J. McCloskey
During the initial test I did drive for a time at 40mph and didn't notice anything unusual although there was a 'lugging' sensation that I attribute to the RPM's being in the 1,200 range while in top gear/lockup. I didn't detect any low freqency rumble as you noted but there was a distant mechanical noise that I suspect was the drivetrain attempting to keep the vehicle moving with very little throttle input.
During my efforts to emulate the transmission issues noted in your post, the audio and climate control systems were off to fully detect any apparent audible abnormalities. The road surface was smooth asphalt and no tire/road/wind noise intruded.
I am driving my other vehicle today and will give the ES another workout this coming weekend to see if it will 'slip up' and disappoint me. Results to follow.
BTW - contrats on your Ultralux LS430 - a very stately car indeed.
Regards -
M. J. McCloskey
Early on I experienced the torque converter lockup shudder but it soon went away (probably I adjusted my driving habits at that crossover speed). I also had problems in that the transmission would not downshift unless I pressed the accelerator down very far (it should go from 5th to 4th with little pedal travel). When the transmission finally downshifted it seemed to go from 5th to 3rd and took off like a bat out of hell since the pedal was pressed down so far. It also hesitated before downshifting and the revs went up (but no where near redline).
The "fix" made downshifting much more responsive. It downshifts from 5th to 4th with very little pedal travel and shifts to 3rd with additional pedal travel. The only down side I have experienced is that it now has a slight hesitation between all gears when accelerating. Previously it shifted VERY smoothly through the gears from 1st through 5th. I am satisfied with the trade off. The car now feels like it has 210HP.
But here is the key: if owners do not feel or view the problem consistently, how can we ban together to demand that Lexus do something about the problem?
This has been the root of my frustration. Until all owners or most owners express dissatisfaction, Lexus will not be motivated to spend a lot of money fixing the problem. And I am convinced that it would be a very costly problem for Lexus to fix.
You state that you had a car right on your rear quarter, then tried to "thread the needle" by cutting between that car and the car in front of you (a little too close there, too, perhaps?).
Then, you had to "floor it" to do the deed - these aren't normal driving issues - get a Viper or a Porsche, or a stickered-up Honda Civic with a big rear spoiler of you want to drive like you're racing at Lime Rock Park.
Sorry for the judgement call, but I'm sure Lexus didn't dseign the transmission management system to respond to autocross-style stab and steer driving.
The 195W stereo spec they listed on the previous generation model was PMPO (maximum output). They switched to listing the more meaningful RMS (average output) with the new generation ES. Doesn't sound as impressive, but at least it's not corrupted in the name of marketing. It's a common tactic to market crappy stereo equipment will high PMPO ratings to lure in unsuspecting customers. This is, of course, not the case with the ES stereo of any year. But may explain why they ditched using this rating system in their advertising.
After reviewing some of the recent posts from mrrogers and atoews, I decided to try driving in 4th gear while commuting on side streets under 45mph. This has decreased my perception of the transmission "shudder". I had noticed it most while coasting between 45-38mph, when it would downshift from 5th to 4th. Taking 5th gear out of the picture at these speeds seems to improve things.
When I accelerate to over 45, I move the gear lever into D for highway speed driving.
When in gear D, I haven't noticed the down-shift hesitation while rapidly accelerating that others have complained of. I just feel a quick response and surge in power as it shifts down to 4.
(btw, I haven't yet had the upgrade)