Edmunds dealer partner, Bayway Leasing, is now offering transparent lease deals via these forums. Click here to see May lease deals!
Options
Acura TL vs Infiniti G35 vs BMW 330xi
This discussion has been closed.
Popular New Cars
Popular Used Sedans
Popular Used SUVs
Popular Used Pickup Trucks
Popular Used Hatchbacks
Popular Used Minivans
Popular Used Coupes
Popular Used Wagons
Comments
You have to understand that AWD does not beat the laws of physics so you can't go flying down a snow covered expressway like it is summer! But for starting out in low traction situations, AWD always gets you going faster then RWD or FWD. We now have two AWD vehicles in our house. My wife used to fight me to get the AWD Mini-van instead of the Passat GLX FWD once the snow flew. Now I fight her to get into the G35x
If tl was awd, i would have bought it in a heartbeat.
But to be honest, i would take the tl over an older awd car with no traction control/mgmnt.
The TL with snows would be a formidable snow machine, but no beast like the g35x.
Head and leg room felt identical, front and back.
Although I've read that people like the TL interior more, I liked the G35 interior better.
I liked the G35 driving experience significantly more than the TL. Yes, the G35 ride can correctly be called a bit stiff, but that is OK with me. A personal preference thing. I would say the G35 is on the edge of being overpowered for normal driving. Again, that is OK with me, personally.
I like the nav system on the TL. Did not get to see it on the G35. (Generally, the Acura dealership I went to was a better experience than the Infiniti.)
Even though I liked the G35 better, I will probably buy the TL because I think I can bring in the the FWD Acura for several thousand less then a comparably equipped AWD G35.
TL a good family sedan :confuse: right, good one...
Depends on the 3 series model you are talking about in regards to HP differential. I believe the 330 has a little more than the TL.
What does a vehicle being RWD have to do with allowing one to "press accelerator hard?"
:confuse:
'21 Dark Blue/Black Audi A7 PHEV (mine); '22 White/Beige BMW X3 (hers); '20 Estoril Blue/Oyster BMW M240xi 'Vert (Ours, read: hers in 'vert weather; mine during Nor'easters...)
One question for the TL purchasers (vs G35x or even Lex IS250 AWD): did you think about the keyless start that TL does not offer? Seems like a combination of convenience and mondo coolness - something making me lean towards G35x more than TL.
Also, any feedback from the post-purchase experience on reliability of Infiniti vs Acura? When Automobile magazine tested G35 vs BMW vs Audi (no TL in the comparison) G35 had more interior rattles and squeaks.
Lastly, what kind of discount from MSRP are people finding on purchase (not lease) for G35x vs TL? Adding the options to make G look like TL (at least on paper) gets one into the very high 30's.
Thanks.
Say you drive 20,000 miles per year with an average speed of 30 mph, you will have spent over 650 hours driving. If you average 4 trips per day and the keyless start saves you 30 seconds, you will have saved about 12 minutes per year. Compared to the amount of driving, keyless start is really just bragging rights and more money for the manufacturer.
At least when I bought (end of '04, '05 TL) buying at invoice was fairly easy. Two dealers were at invoice, my issue was trade value of my 300M (good car!). Didn't expect much and expectations were met . G35 are heavily discounted, too.
After over a year with the TL, not much to report other than it is a smooth, powerful, economical, fun to drive, handsome car with a great stereo! I'm scheduled for my second service next week where I have one rattle that needs to be addressed. But it only happens when the sunroof is in the "vent" position, so not a bid deal. At first service, a computer module had to be replaced (for the onboard computer, outside temp would occassionally read ---, rumor has it that left in that state it could drain the battery) but that's about it.
Great car.
'21 Dark Blue/Black Audi A7 PHEV (mine); '22 White/Beige BMW X3 (hers); '20 Estoril Blue/Oyster BMW M240xi 'Vert (Ours, read: hers in 'vert weather; mine during Nor'easters...)
I tested a Passat and the "keyless" is really a joke. So you stick the fob in the car instead of a key. I am talking about the system like the Lexus IS I tested (but the car is too small) where you keep the fob in your pocket and press start.
I think it's a giant convenience factor on the Infiniti, but in all other areas I am leaning towards the TL.
As for the calculations of time savings w/ the keyless fob, I think this whole market segment is more emotion than math. If you made a calculation including horsepower for the money and resale value, it would point to an Accord LX V6 or Maxima. The entry luxury market is all about emotion and features that don't necessarily compute on a calculator but in aggregate offer an emotional value for the person who, depending upon how you look at it, has the money to purchase the luxury (my opinion ) or is a sucker enough to fall for the gimmicks (kind of what my wife thinks )
My $0.02
And the 325 leaves the TSX in the dust. Not even a comparison.
As an aside, I think the TL nav w/ voice recognition is one of the coolest things out there. It's a great system.
I’ve never gone 10 years (lucky to get to 2), so I can’t image all the things that can go wrong.
Strictly highway mpg is very good. I believe you can get 30mpg at 70+ mph. Hopefully your mpg will improve as the engine breaks in and weather warms up...
'21 Dark Blue/Black Audi A7 PHEV (mine); '22 White/Beige BMW X3 (hers); '20 Estoril Blue/Oyster BMW M240xi 'Vert (Ours, read: hers in 'vert weather; mine during Nor'easters...)
Thanks!
When I hit 105mph the other day I had it in 3rd gear up to 85 or more, and she sounded wonderful.
I really like the IS 250 AWD, but it's too small, and as Motor Trend notes, it's a slow heavyweight - too bad Lexus put all the emotion into the IS 350 which only comes in RWD (no good for New England - my specialty car is my convertible for the summer - the fixed roof needs to work in the winter)
G35 is very nice, feels fast, when behind the wheel looking straight ahead seems to be a similar experience to the TL. G35 brings AWD for the 10 days per year I might need it and has the really cool remote keyless feature (as does Lex IS) but G has no trip computer unless I get Nav (don't need it) and w/o nav remains about $4k more than TL w/o nav. And G35 mileage is substantially lower (not that after spending $30+k on a car I cannot afford the gas, just the environmentalist in me is also infuriated that oil companies post a record profit on our collective backs at the pump :mad: :mad: ).
I have a 2005 G35x with around 12K. Mixed around town driving average about 20 mpg. Highway only around 25 mpg. Not that bad for fuel economy and that is with winter gas. Trip computer is not that big of a deal, and I have the NAV. I haven't used the trip computer yet!
Bought it last July for $36,500 loaded. Could have paid $34,500 without the NAV.
I think the body style of the G 35 is ok. Its not spectacular but ok and the TL may be a bit more ok than the G 35.
The thing is if i buy the G35, without nav for about 32,000 a 3,000 premium off of sticker, it will be obsolete after when they come out with a re modeled G 35 in september?? Is it worth spending the money, even though the G will be redesigned ?/
If you are considering the Lexus GS, have you test driven the M 35x? That car is more in the same price range as the GS. Have you test driven any of the German offerings like the Audi A6? There are a ton of really nice cars in this classification.
Do you really need the AWD? If you don't live in snow country, that would save you another $2,000.00. Good luck with your decsion, any of these cars will probably be a pleasure to drive and own.
It was a brand new, light blue TL.
I immediately wanted one, and that's why I am here reading all your posts.
A previous poster wrote that he wouldn't get one because it looks too much like an Accord. I must strongly disagree-no contest in the styling dept.
For the record, I too can't stand the new 3 series' tail-lights. I have driven a new 330i and you feel every bump. The 5 is much better suspension-wise.
How is the TL's suspension?
But a light blue TL? That's not a factory color.
I agree with you on the TL styling, imho the best looking Acura since the original Legend Coupe (an homage to the earlier BMW 6 series?).
I think the TL offers a nice blend of ride and handling. Honda probably does the best handling fwds. I chose my '05 Abyss (darker) blue TL over the G35 because, among other reasons, a smoother, quieter ride (and superior external/internal style). Not as smooth/quiet as the Lexus ES, but I didn't want quite that level of isolation.
Give the TL a test drive, you probably already have quite a benchmark in the 5. Let us know what you think.
'21 Dark Blue/Black Audi A7 PHEV (mine); '22 White/Beige BMW X3 (hers); '20 Estoril Blue/Oyster BMW M240xi 'Vert (Ours, read: hers in 'vert weather; mine during Nor'easters...)
I have an '04 in a dark green metallic. In sunlight, it looks green metallic, on overcast days it looks dark green and at night it looks black. I haven't seen a computer photo capture it correctly under any lighting circumstances.
'21 Dark Blue/Black Audi A7 PHEV (mine); '22 White/Beige BMW X3 (hers); '20 Estoril Blue/Oyster BMW M240xi 'Vert (Ours, read: hers in 'vert weather; mine during Nor'easters...)
Perhaps it was silver and the way the sun was hitting it, it looked like a light silvery blue? Doubtful, right?
Is the RL a real looker from behind? This car was gorgeous.
I sure hope I see it again.
It couldn't possibly have been an RL then! :P
I am quite sure it was a TL. I got close enough to see the "TL."
I have to say-that is surely one of the best looking cars out there.
Both handsome cars, imho. The problem with the RL styling is it is generically handsome. It blends a little too much. The TL is a great, aggressive wedge with nice details including the pronounced character line along the flanks (mimic in the door handles and parking lamps) and the side rear window treatments (windows drop) as the roof continues to flow into the (thankfully non-Bangled!) trunk area.
Let us know when you solve this mystery and once you are sure, are you going to act upon your new found lust???
'21 Dark Blue/Black Audi A7 PHEV (mine); '22 White/Beige BMW X3 (hers); '20 Estoril Blue/Oyster BMW M240xi 'Vert (Ours, read: hers in 'vert weather; mine during Nor'easters...)
It WAS the TL and the fourth thumbnail photo in the top row from the left in the photo gallery was close to the color I saw-so I guess it was silver with the sun giving it a light blue appearance since there is no TL available in light blue, in which case I must say that was the most beautiful silver I have ever seen on a car.
In Florida, the TL is kind of rare. Seems everybody here is driving a pickup truck, SUV, Accord or Camry.
When I go visit back on Long Island where I am from, the TL is much more prevalent-could be the FWD-more popular up north.
I liked it enough to test drive one-see if I agree with CR.
I will post here again after I do so.
I drove the 330i-nobody has the 330xi down here-and expect the TL to have a better interior and more room.
IMO, the TL is a better looking car than the 330i.
I hate the 330i's tail lights as much as I like the TL's.