Did you recently take on (or consider) a loan of 84 months or longer on a car purchase?
A reporter would like to speak with you about your experience; please reach out to PR@Edmunds.com by 7/22 for details.
Options

Real-World Trade-In Values

158596163641100

Comments

  • jusdreaminjusdreamin Member Posts: 63
    Why do you want to get rid of the car so soon?

    If you bought it new, you're going to lose a lot because of depreciation. Especially if you still have payments to be made on it.
  • ddeliseddelise Member Posts: 353
    This is the Grand Cherokee, with the 6 cyl engine. To refresh your memory - 36.5K miles, black, trip computer, cloth, 4X4, no sunroof, certified vehicle, located in NJ.

    TIA - Damon
  • karlkarl Member Posts: 34
    Re: why get rid of the Camaro so soon ?

    Just because I *really* like the TL-S, and living with the limited interior space of the Camaro has been more of a pain that I expected.

    Re: depreciation hit -

    I know I'll take big hit on it after 1 year, but I got an excellent price on it to begin with (low price + GM Card "free money" + low GMAC financing).

    However, PeopleFirst.com is offering good rates right now too - like 6.65% for 60 mo.

    -Karl
  • fastlapfastlap Member Posts: 4
    Located in Chicago suburbs.
    Will be used as trade-in on new vehicle...
    Titanium Silver Metallic over grey leather. Garaged since new. Extremely clean interior. Exterior has a couple of stone chips and one noticeable door ding, otherwise very good. Zymol wax applied every 6 months. 27,500 miles. Original MSRP of $42,345.
    Auto Trans., Fold-down rear seats, Heated front seats, Xenon, In-dash CD, Harmon Kardon, Premium Package (moonroof, wood trim, lumbar, rain-sensing wipers), Sport Package (wheels, tires, seats, suspension, steering wheel).
    What would be an acceptable trade-in offer? Or at least one that I shouldn't walk away from.
    Thanks!!
  • rroyce10rroyce10 Member Posts: 9,332
    ......... Gee whiz, with that kind of intro -- you should retail it ...l..o..l....

    The Vehicle sounds nice, it's for sure the right color and it's an auto ( it expands your market ) and the miles are ok.

    With all the toy's this has, plus the Zenons .. this little puppy dog will do big $$ retail or on a trade. I'm sure any dealer will put a strong $26,000ish in it, or on a phone call ...


    Terry.
  • rroyce10rroyce10 Member Posts: 9,332
    ......... That's a good question..!

    You are in a good geographic area ( I guess ) to determine that.

    Even though your vehicle is a great color ( my favorite ) and it's all loaded up and clean. This a last of a breed, and the dealers ..all over.. get a little weak kneed on appraisels.

    I can't speak for the your particular area, but rear wheel drives as a whole, are weak. And in a couple of months, when the weather changes, that market does dwindle.

    Right now, clean to the bone Camaro's Z's with low miles are doing in the $16's at all the big auctions. So, take advantage of the surrounding area's and throw in a 4/5 liner kinda like the BMW guy's post and see what you get..

    Good luck ..

    Terry.
  • rroyce10rroyce10 Member Posts: 9,332
    ..... The Laredo's, like the GC limiteds are all over the place. Soooo, what this means to you is, that you have some heavy competition.

    Yours is low miles, and it's a 4X4 so that will save you in your area..the 6, doesn't help it though.

    Clean to the bone 97's with all the stuff are doing in the low $10's ..maybe..

    I hope this helps...

    Terry.
  • rroyce10rroyce10 Member Posts: 9,332
    ..... These Corolla's on the used market are "Big" sellers. And you will pay "large" money for the clean ones at the auctions...

    If the vehicle has some minor dings or dents I would even bat an eyelid, if you can clean them up, and make them very presentable, the buyers know these little "King Kongs" will run for ever. Your mileage is right -- and based on what you are saying, it has no toy's , like windows or cruise --- But, they still sell like popcorn.

    If it's nice, $5,500 ( real money )wouldn't scare me at all, and a $7,500 asking price is easy..on the retail side.

    I hope this helps...

    Terry.
  • rroyce10rroyce10 Member Posts: 9,332
    ....... Ps... You will Love that S type Acura.. Now there is a wolf in sheeps clothing..!

    Terry.
  • im_brentwoodim_brentwood Member Posts: 4,883
    I got a puzzler for ya :)

    00 S-Type 3.0. Base car, roof, CD. No paintwork, 3 or 4 love bug marks on hood. Otherwise nice car. Topaz (gold) with Ivory leather. Nonsmoker, stamped service book. Fresh dunlops.

    78,000 on the odometer.

    I hit it at $19,500. Where would you hit it?

    Curious....

    Bill
  • jusdreaminjusdreamin Member Posts: 63
    How the #@$%*~ does ONE put that kinda mileage on a car so soon!?
  • bryancalhounbryancalhoun Member Posts: 13
    Any idea on a trade in for a 1999 9-3 S 5door, light green, auto, leather, roof, etc - 40K. I have gotten anywhere from $14.5-16K and this all seems a little low. I thought more like $17K?

    Any thoughts???
  • im_brentwoodim_brentwood Member Posts: 4,883
    LOL..

    They did come out in May of 99.. So I guess that could extrapolate to 32-33K a year...

    Even so it is a LOT!

    Bill
  • im_brentwoodim_brentwood Member Posts: 4,883
    Is it an SE perhaps?

    If so.. I'd hit the car at $15k. If its' a loaded up base car.. I'd be around $13,500-14K on it.

    $17K is what an SE with well under 30K on it is going to do..in Silver or White (or Black in the Northeast) and in perfect shape on a good day.

    Bill
  • rroyce10rroyce10 Member Posts: 9,332
    ........... OOOH, you are a brave Hia-watha ...

    Base S type 3 huh ..? Well it does have some miles that's for sure. A saving grace here, is that, it's got a slider l...o...l...-- but, no upgrade sound and no Nav.

    Soooo, I'm thinkin' with the new tires and such ( where did this guy drive to ..? Costa Rica for job interviews ...? )
    Unless this thing is like "perfect" I wouldn't be much of a player for much over $15 ..16/$17 on the push.

    I'm paying high $29's for the sunday go to meetin' Jags 3's, with all the stuff, with 17/19/21K. So Kemo Sabi ... how about those Yankee's ...

    Terry.
  • im_brentwoodim_brentwood Member Posts: 4,883
    Ditto here on the S-Types, although they (As in people bidding on them) have been getting dumb over at CFAA as of late. Maybe a little more if its' the right color and equipment.. but about $30,500 to MAYBE $31K is as high as I have ever gone of late, and thenonly if I know where to send it. (Jags be what I deal in a lot.. get me some older ones!!)

    That topaz car was about perfect. Did have a few love bug marks but it was really nice. Sold it to an exporter I know quickly. Speaking of Costa Rica.. I think it may actually be going there!

    This car happened to have a early build date... heck, RDR Date was like end of May back in 99.. so it was 27 months old.. 35K miles a year. A lot but not as scary as it sounds...

    Still, unless I had a home for it Id'a passed...

    Bill
    Wearing my Yankees t-shirt :)
  • rroyce10rroyce10 Member Posts: 9,332
    .... I have to agree with Bill on this one ..

    If you can retrieve $15/$16,000 ( real money ) on the vehicle you need to jump fast, if it's a SE.

    The 40K doesn't help ... and if it's a perfect vehicle, without any parking lot kisses and the interior looks new, and needs -0- across the board, a real figure would in the $13's if it's the base.

    Terry.
  • dardson1dardson1 Member Posts: 696
    golly darn....promise I won't ask again....but a few months ago you said Sienna's were holding their value. I goofed and traded out of a perfectly nice SUV last October. This car is such a yawn I can't image why anyone would want it (I was being practical at the time and thought it was just what I needed..lol). Never mind, of course I can image it.....there's a world of people who care absolutely nothin' about a car and just wanna get from A to B with the least possible trouble and expense. I'm going to spend this week trying to buy something fun-to-drive.
    Is this minivan still bringing good money? It's white, ivory leather, 8k miles, perfect conditions (not one door ding), console, fancy rear view mirror, and one power door (I had to port-order the thing to get an XLE without every option in the book). How much on a trade? How much if I sell it?
  • rroyce10rroyce10 Member Posts: 9,332
    ..... How are you ..? I think I remember you being around the board ..

    So let's see, you want hang the ole' Toyota out to dry, .. huh ?

    There is a still a group of "Cult's" ( l...o...l. )that want these types of vehicle's, and based on what you are saying -- it's super nice and clean, with Zip for miles..and .. it's an XLE. Most of what I have seen, are still drawing large figures, in and around the $25/$26,000ish range .. so you should be fine. As far as retail #'s .. ...I'm going to guess in the ultra high twenties, you know like $28/$29ish figure.

    Terry.
  • john34910john34910 Member Posts: 3
    Nothing wrong with the vehicle.
    It's just not for me, need a more car like ride,
    confortable seat and also a better milage.
    Major reason I bought this was for the 7 seat,
    which turned out to be unreasonable for our family.

    Anyway, here it goes,

    -. Austin, TX
    -. '01 Suzuki XL-7 Plus / Auto / 4x4
    -. Rear air condition
    -. Color Burgundy Pearl
    -. 2000 miles
    -. Dealer installed leather
    -. Very clean in & out.

    I believe I won't be able to get much, but what will
    be the best price?

    Thanks.
  • dardson1dardson1 Member Posts: 696
    kinda makes me wonder what they're seeing that I'm not. Edmunds did a minivan comparison a few months ago.....Sienna came in 2nd overall but all the judges keep saying "I don't like it but" the darn thing does everything well. One compared it to a very fine, mighty reliable washing machine. That pretty much sums up my feelings about it. The resale numbers might be my favorite thing about the car. Thanks for the quick reponse!
  • carleton1carleton1 Member Posts: 560
    Unless you go to Terry, Bill, or one of the honest dealerships represented by these 2 fine gentlemen ( and perhaps a few others in this forum). MOST dealerships will give about $2000 to $3000 LESS than these honest men would.
    There is a 2000 Ody EX-NAV with low miles (seems like 11,000 miles)that had MSRP of $30,100. The owner was quoted $21,500 trade-in value by Honda dealerships (so read the posting here in the Town Hall).
    Sienna have a high trade in value...but NOT nearly as good as does the Honda Odyssey even though Sienna does much better than Grand Caravan, Town & Country, Venture, Quest, Villager, MPV, Eurovan and Windstall.
    I had considered getting a 2002 Odyssey, Sienna, Grand Caravan, or Town & Country. I was quoted a trade-in $1,500 to $2,500 LESS than the honest Bill told me to expect. Bill's number was $601 less than the average of Edmunds and 2 other internet sources.
    I feel dealerships MUST make a profit to stay in business. However, a difference of $6000 to $7000 between what they will pay me for my trade-in and what they will receive when it is resold is exorbitant and completely unacceptable. Sure wish Bill and Terry were in my area.
  • steine13steine13 Member Posts: 2,825
    I don't know that they're all crooks... after all, a first offer is just an offer. And they have the unique advantage over Bill and Terry to have seen the actual car in question.
    When I sold my '98 Prizm recently, I described the car and Terry told me "a strong $6000+" at the auction. I then shopped it at used-car dealerships -- no bites because of 5spd -- and finally went to the biggest and sleaziest dealer in the area. They were professional and courteous and within 40 minutes sent me on my way with a written offer of $6k to buy it, not as a trade-in.
    I put the car in the paper and in two weeks sold it for $7300, which turned out to be the Edmund's "private-party" figure. And I was lucky to sell it, because my next-lowest offer came from an individual offering $6k even, and I had no other interested parties.
    So don't be too hard on the dealerships; if it's a lousy $1500 difference, just make them a counter offer. And remember that there are regional differences, too.
    I think Bill and Terry and others are providing a fantastic service, and I love reading their msgs, but I don't think you can take their figures as the absolute truth unless you're in the same area.

    That said, the $21k on an Odyssey is way too low, agreed.
    Peace.
    -Mathias
    East Lansing, MI
  • jsimonejsimone Member Posts: 4
    This wasn't a bad week at all. We (my neighbor) and I agreed on the price on the 2000 Audi A6 4.2 Quattro at $40,500 and I just sold my 99 Catera last night for $19,700 on the 3rd guy that came over.

    I just wanted to thank you for your help. If I had listened to my "friends" in the business. I would have been paying $30,000 plus the Catera. The Audi is in the garage, and the Catera can stay outside til tommorow (of course my wifes car must have a place to park)
    Many thanks!
    J.Simone
    Again thanks Terry,
  • im_brentwoodim_brentwood Member Posts: 4,883
    Hmm...

    I dunno how this relates to what ya paid for it..

    But looks like its' worth about $16,500-17,000 from where I am sitting...

    Terry?

    Bill
  • im_brentwoodim_brentwood Member Posts: 4,883
    I think it depends on a lot of variables, and as was said.. Remember, we're not seeing the cars.

    Like the guy who posted a couple weeks ago about an Acura TL-S.

    Apparently he failed to mention that the car had been damaged.. Ladies and Gentlemen.. ya gotta be honest with us! Trust me, anyone who knows what they are doing CAN spot paintwork!

    As far as that Odyssey goes.. I think its' worth $23-24K. IMHO, Navi adds little to a cars' resale value.

    That beng said, I remember going to a Jaguar class for Select Edition managers or some such garbage back in 99 I think. It was actually held on the property of Manheim Auto Auction.

    They asked all 30 of us in the room to appraise a 1997 XJ6 with like 25K miles.

    The numbers varied as much as $3,500 from low to high. So while I think that we're doing well here, bear in mind that sight unseen appraisals are tough to do. You should use mine and Terry's info as a guide. If I say your car is worth $14,500, Terry says $14,250 and you're quoted around $14K.. OK, you're within reason. If you're quoted $12K... you might be at the wrong store.

    Like anything else, it does pay to shop around.

    Bill
  • john34910john34910 Member Posts: 3
    Thanks for the info.

    Close as I expected.

    Yeah....it will also be hard to find a person who
    would even take it.

    I should have done more test driving before getting it.
  • dardson1dardson1 Member Posts: 696
    I love the car business. It is fluid, changing day to day. It is a perfect example of the great American market place. I'll take a pass on the Saturn grocery store approach. I'd rather do the homework, and find that place where the dealer and I are both satisfied (and hopefully no money left on the table). It's the most honest of relationships.
  • bretfrazbretfraz Member Posts: 2,021
    At least as far as car shopping and buying goes, the person who commits the most time and energy to shopping for a car usually gets the best deal and has the best buying experience.

    I find it extremely offensive when someone posts a nastygram about the car buying process. It always turns out that the crybaby either wasn't prepared or expected the whole process to be like shopping at Nordstrom or someplace like that.

    Then they demand that everyone should be given the same deal regardless of the amount of time and effort spent to obtain it. That's what really ticks me off - - I bust my butt to get the best all-around deal for myself just to find some other joker expecting exactly the same deal but putting on no effort.

    I like the business the way it is - - Rewarding the smartest and shrewdest shoppers and laying waste to the slackers and the dummies.

    Survival of the fittest, indeed.
  • blume1blume1 Member Posts: 25
    A good friend of mine was needing to know the value of a 1991 Buick Reatta (last year production). It is white with 21,000 actual miles It has all options including sunroof and CD player. He (friend) says he has always liked these -- and this may be a chance to acquire one.
    Thanks for your help in advance. I
  • dardson1dardson1 Member Posts: 696
    exactly!
  • rroyce10rroyce10 Member Posts: 9,332
    ...... Good morning --- A Reatta huh, well you don't see too many of these around. Kinda' like Buicks version of the Allante.

    Well, I think your friend will have alot of fun in it --

    A "Very Xtra " clean one, that does *not* have the original tires, and the roof is *not* in need of any top work -- and has been serviced, will do in the high $9's on the wholesale side, and on the Retail side I'm thinkin' in the $12's ...

    I saw a few run in April/May/June, and they did over $10,000+ at the auctions ( but, they were *Perfect* ) ... now with summer just about over, the buyers are less and less, and most people now, are getting the urge to move on to something else, Suv's ..4X4's, etc -- So this is a great time for your friend to make an offer .... So alot of what this vehicle is worth, will depend on what part of the country you are in ...

    Good luck ..

    Terry.
  • rroyce10rroyce10 Member Posts: 9,332
    ..... Hey, you are quite welcome ... good job on the Catera..

    Terry.
  • criswong2criswong2 Member Posts: 1
    OK...my kid got her driver's permit and hates driving my SUV...I live in NC and this vehicle is loaded with (leather, htd front elec seats, etc). Actually everything but the towing pkg. This car is in extra clean condition Silver w/18K....realistically what can I get for it as a trade? How can I find out the true wholesale is before I hit the dealerships?. I have checked KBB, Edmunds and NADA and there is quite a difference, wish I could find the black book, which is what I know they will most likely use to value my vehicle. I usually sell my vehicle first, and I have tried selling it without much success, obviously. I am one of those buyer who does their homework! I appreciate your input. Thanks!
  • im_brentwoodim_brentwood Member Posts: 4,883
    May I make a suggestion?

    If you have a 16yr old...

    Go find an inexpensive Volvo 240 for them to learn to drive on and keep the Pathfinder instead of letting them learn to drive on a $25K SUV!

    Seriously..
    That being said I think that the Pathfinder is worth about $20,500.

    Hope this helps!

    Bill
  • jusdreaminjusdreamin Member Posts: 63
    brentwood's right about not letting the 16 yr old learn to drive in an expensive SUV. There should be plenty of halfway decent cars in your area that should cost less than $5K.

    Just be glad she hates driving in an expensive SUV. It'll save you $$ in the long run! ;)

    Hey, wrecking a $5K car beats wrecking a $20K SUV!
  • im_brentwoodim_brentwood Member Posts: 4,883
    Plus a car will be easier to handle!
  • jusdreaminjusdreamin Member Posts: 63
    Would you feel comfortable giving a 16 yr old a fairly expensive car to learn how to drive in?

    Just the THOUGHT of it makes me almost want to pass out!!

    No offense cris...8D
  • rabbitrun3rabbitrun3 Member Posts: 23
    Calypso Green (!)
    Hatchback LX
    107K (!)
    5-speed
    Alloys, spoiler, upgraded (but broken) stereo, AC, Rear Defrost
    No Cruise or power anything
    Looks sharp, runs great

    Also, wondering if this is an example of a car MUCH better off sold privately than traded.

    Thank you so very, very much!!

    -Scott
  • thebigkahunathebigkahuna Member Posts: 83
    2001 Honda Civic EX Coupe, 3000 miles. Obviously it is in brand new condition. I'm not interested specifically in selling right now but within the year I might consider trading in (or selling myself) for a Jeep Wrangler. Also, what would the dealer's reaction be to take a trade-in that could be worth more than the price of a slightly used Jeep? Is that done? I'm sooo indecisive when buying cars! Thank you for your reply!
  • pcbrspcbrs Member Posts: 57
    Bill-

    Thanks for the advice. Ended up getting between $5500-$6000 on the purple Legend, just as you predicted. Traded it in for a Mystic Sea LS430. Both are fantastic cars. Thank you for all your professional help. You're an asset to Edmunds.

    Jeff
  • rroyce10rroyce10 Member Posts: 9,332
    ..... Calypso what ...?

    Well for starters, it's a handshaker ..no help there. It's doing the 100,000K run, no help there. No tunes, no help there .... and it's "no sale green" no help there ...aaaah, lets see --- let's hope it has cold breeze, knee deep in rubber - runs like a rabbit, and it needs -0- across the board ( spend $50 bucks at w/mart and get a radio ).

    I don't feel you should trade it ... go retail, on a trade you are looking at less than than a "Gee Whiz" ... Clean it up, drop it in the paper, and ask $2,499 for it and take what you can get, probably "around" $1,500/$1,800 I'm thinkin' --- don't forget the trip to Wal-mart.
    Escorts are just like rabbits --- They are all over the place.

    Have fun ....

    Terry.
  • rroyce10rroyce10 Member Posts: 9,332
    .......... Is this a Auto per chance...?

    Is it "mystic green" per chance ..l...o...l..

    Great vehicle, no klicks .. if it's an auto, right now they are doing in and around the $15's ...

    Depending on the type of dealer -- they will have no problem trading with you, this type of trade is done everyday ..

    Terry.
  • soberssobers Member Posts: 496
    My friend is looking for a car to use for a year or two! We had a look at 91 Accord Lx (power everything, cruise, ac, cassette not working)
    It has 145000 miles. Car looks great except a bit of rust on the rear (most 90/91 Accords have it)

    The dealer is asking 2800 & would not go down a bit! (It has good rubber on it, worth atleast 20-25k miles more)

    It was sold at 25,000 miles to second owner & he traded it in after driving for more than 120,000 miles! Does that mean it ws maintained properly ??
  • rroyce10rroyce10 Member Posts: 9,332
    ..... "If" it's as nice as you say it is ---- and run's like a rabbit ..l...o...l... and the vehicle is all there, needs -0-, tires are super etc.. ( have it checked out ) ... I wouldn't be surprised if the dealer has $1,500 or so in it..

    If it checks out, buy it ..

    Good Luck..

    Terry.

    Ps -- Where can you buy a nice car today, for less than $3,000 -- it's tuff for me, and I do this 365 24/7 ..
  • rabbitrun3rabbitrun3 Member Posts: 23
    ('bout what we thought - good thought on the Wal-Mart wadio, too)

    Regards,
    Scott
  • stulstul Member Posts: 6
    I am looking at a 2001 X5 3.0 with 9k miles. It has the Auto Trans, Climate, Activity and Prem packages, along with xenon lights and in-dash CD. New, the MSRP is around 46K, including the destination charge. They are asking 43k, which is above the new invoice price. Anybody have any ideas on what I should be willing to pay for a slightly used model? I do not have much experience in negotiating for a used vehicle, so any insight is appreciated. This is in the Phila., area, if that matters.
  • raybearraybear Member Posts: 1,795
    Stuart-

    Is it certified? That pushes the warranty out to six years and 100,000 miles from the original in-service date. Figure that adds $1500 to the value of the car right away.

    Other than that, the price would be too high. You can buy a new one for $2000 off MSRP in some areas right now. I think the car's worth invoice or a bit less, even certified, but it's just my opinion.
  • stulstul Member Posts: 6
    Thanks raybear. It is not certified. The dealer thinks it would not add enough value over the new car warranty. I was thinking that even invoice is a little high, with the 2002 model coming out soon.
  • raybearraybear Member Posts: 1,795
    Yep, sounds too high to me. I disagree with the dealer on the certification issue also.
Sign In or Register to comment.