Did you recently take on (or consider) a loan of 84 months or longer on a car purchase?
A reporter would like to speak with you about your experience; please reach out to PR@Edmunds.com by 7/25 for details.
A reporter would like to speak with you about your experience; please reach out to PR@Edmunds.com by 7/25 for details.
Options
Any Questions for a Car Dealer?
This discussion has been closed.
Comments
Too bad the other dealer can't keep the deposit.
Ed
It sounds as if the first dealer did not even try to work with you. It sounds as though they switched straight to the typical high pressure crap that characterizes the buisness. Some dealers are worth paying extra for. I have gotten customers to pay more than other offers, but only in exceptional circumstances where they believe I am worth the extra money.
2. Dealer1 told me that he search all dealer inventories and could not find a car and we had to go with one in transit from Germany. That's why I was angry when I saw the silver (one of desirable colors) at another dealer's lot. The dealer1 later told me that he called dealer2 and they told him that this silver car was taken for a demo. Is this statement is true or not I do not know.
3. I did not offer dealer1 to match the deal since I believe that it would be a blackmailing. I told them that I prefer black and it was obvious from the conversation that I would rather get black car if I could get similar deal. I told him that $1500 is to much for a color so I left the door open for his offer.
4. Dealer1 spent no more that 1 hour with me and we mostly chat about things not bargained hard. E.g. he told me that they can give me between 24K and 25K for my trade and I said 25 is OK. and so on.
5. I would prefer dealer1 to politely tell me that they cannot much deal2 and will keep my deposit (I still will be $1000 ahead) that get all upset and make me feel guilty.
3.
JP
A quiet man already knows the truth ..and needs not, to speak to others.
Hmmmm ....
Terry.
http://www.iihs.org/vehicle_ratings/ce/html/99008.htm
Car_man
Host
Smart Shoppers / FWI Message Boards
No I'm not necessarily set on a Spectra. It just seemed to be a nice size and the right price. The only other car near the price range is a Hyundai Accent, which we're also considering...although it's less car (in terms of size). What do you recommend?
The reason for the wildly divergent crash test score between the IIHS and the NHTSA is their method of testing. The government crashes their cars into a flat wall whereas the the IIHS uses offset crashes at a slightly higher speed. For this reason, I think the IIHS is a better gauge of frontal crash performance. I do, however, like the NHTSA's side impact tests.
Having said all that, I think that at the $10,000 price point, one can find the following used cars, all about 3-5 years old (a little older in the case of the Volvo):
Subaru Impreza (good crash tests and AWD)
Volvo 850 (built like a tank and fun to drive. Really.)
Toyota Corolla (safe, economical, more reliable than an anvil)
Chevy/Geo Prizm (same car as the Corolla, but with Chevy resale)
Honda Civic (see Corolla)
Mazda 626 (Nice cars that the market seems to ignore, hence lousy resale. Hence, one can find one cheap. Avoid the four cylinder/automatic combo, though. Get a manual or find a V-6.)
I can think of a whole bunch of others, but you get the idea. Looking at a used car gives you lots more options at this price point, sometimes with a warranty. Keep in mind, too, the "instant depreciation" from driving a used car off the lot is nearly nil, whereas with a new car (especially a Hyundai or Kia) it's a huge percentage of the car's purchase price. Even if you don't decide to sell the car, say your son wrecks it. The insurance company will give you market value, which wouldn't be a lot.
I hope this helps.
One point I differ. we find the 626 to be better with the 4 cyl than the 6cyl concerning reliability. The 6 cyl engine is mated with a Ford auto tranny that is less than perfect also some require premium gas...the 4 cyls can be had very reasonably and are more reliable...plus I'm not sure the new driver needs the extra HP.
I figure that this will be good for everyone because the dealer will get the holdback/sale and I will get invoice price drama-free.
Does this sound like a good idea? Will dealers be willing to go for this? Just curious, because in my head its just too simple to actually work.
Despite how wonderful the ordering/buying process may seem, the dealer is always going to try to sell you something off the lot, its an "instant gratification" thing. Plus, the dealer has to worry about you changing your mind during the months that you're waiting on your car. Someone on this board the other day proved this by backing out of a deal on a new BMW that he'd special ordered. He didn't tell the dealer that he'd ordered from that another color might be suitable, he just decided on a whim that he didn't want to wait.
I hope this helps,
Ed
2001 Prelude Type SH, 2022 Highlander XLE AWD, 2025 Camry SE AWD
Ed
I wouldnt put 50% down on a special order, why tie up the money?
As far as pricing, Im not sure that an IS300 can be bought for invoice. Also, bear in mind that dealers arent always willing to do a cheap deal on an ordered car due to allocation reasons.
I.E. Back in 1998 when I was with a Jaguar store, we could sell every XJR we could get at MSRP. Many stores were over MSRP on them. Bt the key was, Jaguar would only give us a small handful of the cars, we couldnt order as many as we wanted, if that was the case, we'd order 20 of them a month!
As far as an IS300 goes.. your best deal will always be on an in-stock unit.
Bill
I abhor finacing and putting myself into debt so my current plan is to keep making "car payments" to my bank account until I have enough to get something in the IS 300 range. If my current car breaks down irreversibly before then, I will shop around for whatever is in the price range of my bank account.
Once it come time to buy, I plan to demo 3-4 cars in the range I can afford and choose whichever I like best. When I go into buy, I plan to have the actual cash on me (I know $30K may be alot, but I'm willing to chance it). I figure this will keep the negotiations simple (no down payment/monthly payment/finacing to argue, only price) and if nessecary, it can be used as a bargaining tool (to show the saleman I'm serious) plus I'd getting the bonus of seeing some surprised expressions ; )
I know there lots of things that easily can go wrong with this plan (early breakdown, emergencies, etc), but I think it would be fun to pay off a car the same day I buy it. Also, once I get that much money saved I may be more tempted to invest it rather than spend it.
Is there anything inherently stupid about this plan? (mental planning can oftentimes overlook important things)
1. Car dealers are likely not impressed by someone's ability to buy a car cash. Handling that much cash is more of a pain in the a** than anything else. Do them a favor, and write a check!!
2. Buying a car outright deprives the dealership of some opportunities to make additional profit on your loan. So, if you want to order a popular car and pay for it in cash, your price may be higher than someone who finances a car off the lot.
3. While it might be nice to be "debt free", I'm not sure of the wisdom of putting a substantial amount of cash into a depreciating asset. Some options might be to borrow money secured by your cash. In this case, you'd pay 1% or 2% above the rate you're being paid, but when the loan is paid off, you still have your cash!! You could also find a reasonably safe investment that might actually return more than the prevailing interest rates for automobiles. In this case, you could buy your car with borrowed money, invest your own, and at the end of the loan term, you might just have all your cash, plus a vehicle.
Obviously, you have to do what is most comfortable for you! I wish you luck in whatever you choose.
I don't understand the advantage of this system. If you have the discipline to save (as the original poster did) why not instead pay the cash, and then put whatever a loan payment would be into the bank each month. When you're all done, at exactly the same time that the loan would have been paid off, you'll have the full amount PLUS that extra 1% or 2% that you would have been paying in excess interest.
Let's assume a 30,000 cost for the car, a savings rate of 4%, and therefore, a 5% secured loan rate.
If you pay for the car outright, then save 500.00 per month so you'll have your 30,000 back at the end of 60 months, you will earn 3,149.49 in interest, so at the end, you'll have the car and 33,149.49.
If you choose to secure the loan with your 30,000 cash, borrow 30,000 to pay for the car, you'll pay 3,968.22 in interest. Your 30,000 will grow by 6,629.90, so at the end of the term, you'll have the car and 36,629.90. However, the car will have cost you the additional interest expense, so the net difference is 6,629.90 - 3,968.22 = 2,661.68. (This works because you're earning interest on an increasing base, while you're paying interest on a decreasing base!)
Additionally, you'll have the 30,000 at all times, so if you wish to pay off the car early, you can do so. Also, the lending institution may be willing to release part of the money as the outstanding principal gets reduced.
I'm not saying that this is the best idea in the world, but for me, the discipline it would take to get the money together in the first place would be difficult enough -- I'm not sure I'd be able to do it all over again. My example provides a way to force you to protect the money you've accumulated without any financial detriment.
I'm interested in picking up a brand new 2001 Prelude SH (a model which has been discontinued, but there still are some laying around for those of you who are unfamiliar). I emailed a local dealer who I've been communicating back and forth with. He's gone through the trouble to locate the car I'm interested in. The car has an MSRP of $26,100. He's offering to sell it to me for around $23,800 which is invoice. The guy obviously knows I want this car (because I contacted him first and asked him to do a locate). If you were to go through a similar situation, would you take $21,500 for the car (it is after all a 2001 which has been sitting on another dealer's lot for at least 6 months)? What about the rest of you? Thanks in advance for your help!
2001 Prelude Type SH, 2022 Highlander XLE AWD, 2025 Camry SE AWD
Also whenever I get a new car my insurance rate will undoubtedly jump a few notches, so I may not be able to save as much....definately worth thinking about though if the percentages were a little better. Thanks for the numbers!
Again, I'm not trying to tell you what to do, rather throwing options out on the table. I just wish I was in your position of having to make such a decision!!!
Good luck in whatever you choose to do!!
The loan interest could be deductible if it is a home equity loan.
Also check to see if you could really earn that interest rate above without tying the money up in a CD (penalty for early withdrawal).
I knew this looked too good to be true....
It would actually cost you 487.81 to keep you cash and borrow the money secured by you're savings. Apparently, my spreadsheet was turning water into wine!!! That's the trouble with spreadsheets, they're only as good as the nut behind the wheel!!
So, this is not such an attractive option if you have the discipline to save after paying cash for the vehicle....
I'll crawl back into my shell now......
Let me get this straight, you want a rare and hard to find car that has been discontinued, and you want your local dealer to trade for it, and you want him to sell it for under invoice?
Did something fall off a bookshelf onto your head?
Ed
Raybear: I haven't gone back to him with a counter offer yet becauae I wanted to pose the question to some of you gentelmen on the thread who's advice I find to be quite helpful, so I really don't consider myself an "Inconsiderate Buyer."
abtseller: That's why I asked you guys first.
I figured that the Invoice would be his best price, so I'm happy with that. It doesn't hurt to ask the thread though does it?
Thank you again for your help and your timely responses.
2001 Prelude Type SH, 2022 Highlander XLE AWD, 2025 Camry SE AWD
Thanks for putting up with the warped sense of humor, its been one of those days.
Ed
Warped Sense Of Humor...Is there any other kind?
2001 Prelude Type SH, 2022 Highlander XLE AWD, 2025 Camry SE AWD
2001 Prelude Type SH, 2022 Highlander XLE AWD, 2025 Camry SE AWD
I'm guessing a fair figure might be $36,900.
Good luck ...
Terry.
But, WHY would a dealer take the time to locate a car, send a driver (and pay that driver) to get the car only to lose 2000.00???
So, ah..yeah..if they will sell it for invoice, you ought to buy it. I see a future collectable car too down the road maybe.
Heck...you should pay 2000.00 OVER invoice!!
Thank you again!
2001 Prelude Type SH, 2022 Highlander XLE AWD, 2025 Camry SE AWD
2001 Prelude Type SH, 2022 Highlander XLE AWD, 2025 Camry SE AWD
Thanks again for your quick response!
2001 Prelude Type SH, 2022 Highlander XLE AWD, 2025 Camry SE AWD