Did you recently take on (or consider) a loan of 84 months or longer on a car purchase?
A reporter would like to speak with you about your experience; please reach out to PR@Edmunds.com by 7/25 for details.
A reporter would like to speak with you about your experience; please reach out to PR@Edmunds.com by 7/25 for details.
Options
Comments
Anybody know about that? Just curious with discussions about tighter supply lowering discounts.
Bill
Exactly!
2019 Kia Soul+, 2015 Mustang GT, 2013 Ford F-150, 2000 Chrysler Sebring convertible
"I've got to start getting paid," said Ron Morehead Jr., general manager of a Honda dealership in Kingston, N.Y. "Enough is enough."
Morehead decided this morning to suspend clunker sales. He has already had to turn customers away. He said he has yet to receive payment for any of his 42 clunker deals worth about $175,000.
Morehead isn't the only one. More than 70 dealers out of about 580said they also had suspended clunker sales because of repayment concerns and other headaches they've had managing the program.
Duke Brubaker, general sales manager of Champion Ford-Lincoln-Mercury-Mazda in Owensboro, Ky., said Champion stopped clunker sales Friday night.
"It's just a mess, an absolute mess," Brubaker told Automotive News. "There is a billion dollars of dealerships' money on the road."
$1.72 billion in claims
As of today, dealers had submitted claims to the U.S. government for 411,624 clunker transactions worth $1.72 billion. The government has not said how much has been reimbursed to dealers. But at the end of last week, only a small fraction had been paid, according to the National Automobile Dealers Association and some state dealer associations.
With its 50 deals, Champion is owed about $210,000, Brubaker said. He has received no transaction approvals from the U.S. government even though he submitted his first deal on July 27. Several were rejected in what a program administrator later described to the dealership as a system error on the government's end, Brubaker said.
Even dealerships that are sticking with the program for now are debating their continued participation.
Joe Cardello, general manager of Jay Wolfe Toyota-Scion of Kansas City, Mo., said he had decided Monday to suspend clunkers deals because of lack of payment. "I was getting a little nervous," Cardello said.
But his majority partner opted to continue clunker sales -- for now. The dealership has written 77 deals and has been paid for 18 so far, Cardello said. That leaves the dealership waiting for $250,000 or so in reimbursements.
Accountant's warning
Carl Woodward, a dealership accountant in Bloomington, Ill., is warning his clients to be careful about writing any new deals.
"If the government is this far behind, those dealers that submit deals at the end might not be paid," Woodward told clients in an e-mail message.
Dealers expressed anger and frustration about how the program has been administered so far. One told Automotive News that he took a baseball bat to the windshield of one of the vehicles turned in by a customer.
Said Morehead: "Good thing I had a clunker here on the lot. I took my frustrations out on the car, instead of throwing my computer through the window."
I think Automotive News keeps a weekly tally of inventory. From what I've seen new inventory is less than zero. Friday when I was at my dealer I reported that there was just a few big guzzlers left on the lot. Monday I was back and even the showroom was empty.
I wonder how long it take to get new product delivered to a dealer? Assuming there is any left at the factory does it take days, weeks or months to get more.
When I inquired about factory ordering some time ago I was told times that varied from 3 weeks to 3 months to "we stopped making cars".
Any dealers care to comment?
2019 Kia Soul+, 2015 Mustang GT, 2013 Ford F-150, 2000 Chrysler Sebring convertible
Wow.... a statement like that really says a lot about your self.........
The auto business is a "market" business.... If the market is calling for window sticker on vehicles why should we only charge people that are buying CFC and not someone who isn't doing it.... Prices are reflected on what is going on in the market once again just so you understand.
Just like seafood.... The price of Lobster one day could be $6 / pound and than two days later be $9/ pound.....
The new car market has been hurting for quite some time.... Now the market is hot and you want to call us scum bags... well everyone is entitled to their opinion.
Just curious what do you do for work? do you work for free?
GP
Or a $6.00 coffee at name brand shops (Starbucks?).
2014 Malibu 2LT, 2015 Cruze 2LT,
Anyone paying $5 plus for a cup of coffee really should watch the movie Black Gold.
It's pathetic how little they pay the coffee farmers for those premium coffee beans. They can't even send their kids to school.
I guess some people don't expect dealership employees to send their kids to school, either.
I have to double over on that one. I'm still laughing.
2014 Malibu 2LT, 2015 Cruze 2LT,
Dealers are free to go to a fixed price model, such as places like Fitzmall have.
"We simply attempt to be fearful when others are greedy and to be greedy only when others are fearful."
I heard of some large auto group somewhere that has 1100 completed clunker deals done and they have been paid on three of them.
Obama has also ordered dealers not to require the buyers to promise to make up the $4500 credit if the federal govt. doesn't pay up.
NHTSA has decided to classify trucks with GVWR under 8,500 lbs. and curb weight over 6,000 lbs. as Category 3 trucks.
They will be adding a FAQ on this issue tonight, so it should be on cars.gov by tomorrow.
www.fueleconomy.gov
However, I do not beleive that my Suburban is "over" 6000lbs "Curb Weight".
Does anyone have any info? I have been going back and forth with these guys trying to get resolution. Does Cat3 mean no car, only $3500, but a "TRUCK"?
I have not been able to find out if those overflowing storage lots we saw pictures of last year are still full. I did ask a golf buddy that manages or dispatches for one of the largest motor carries specializing in the delivery of cars and light trucks. He says their business is booming. He has guys back at work that have been laid off since Christmas. So, I guess there is some new inventory being delivered. I would think for inventory sitting in storage, deliveries could probably start up within a week, at most 2 weeks even for those that have to be loaded onto rail and hauled to distribution centers then loaded onto trucks for final delivery. Those that have to be built before shipping could take a little longer. I saw where Ford, GM and Toyota are upping production some, but if this a short term buying spree and demand goes back down not sure if there is much long term benefit.
Heck, go to Brazil and you haggle on just about everything, even fruit.
I think the real difference, though, is the expectation that a customer can walk in and pay the dealer's cost for any car they want, even if said car is in short supply. Dealers don't work for free, they have to try to make a profit the few chances they get.
You had an actual Mulroney label from a new car in your hand? The real sticker that is put their as a requirement from gov't on every new car and cannot be removed till it is sold.
No one leaves with the window sticker of a new car unless they bought that car.
You sure the car on the floor and the car you had priced out before were the same car?
According to Edmunds you can price out a Accent above 17,000 MSRP.
link title
The small used car lots are suffering since a lot of nice cars they would have been happy to have on their lots are now being distroyed.
This is not Brazil.
I hope your intent is not to attempt to perpetuate the mythology that the invoice prices, available here and many other places, represent actual dealer cost.
I do agree that one should expect the market price to rise when demand is high compared to supply. Dealers are even free to demand over sticker price, if buyers don't like the price that a dealer is offering, they should just go eleswhere (or more conveniently just email some other dealers), not whine that it is unfair or whatever. By the same token car salesman should stop their perpetual whining about buyers "forcing" them to sell cars at little or no supposed "profit". It is not the buyer's responsibility to ensure that prices are high enough to provide you with what you feel is an adequate commission.
When I bought my first Ody it was in the days when you couldn't touch one for less than sticker but that was what I wanted. I had a few choices - buy used, which I declined because the used ones were going for as much as the new ones because they could be delivered immediately; pay over MSRP, another declined option because I plain don't believe in doing such a thing. Others might do so and they will have no complaint from me but I won't do it - or more specifically nothing has tempted me to do it. I settled on option three which was one of several dealers who would take a deposit to sell you one at MSRP but you ware on a waiting line. Turned out this dealer had another location and I ended up with a much shorter wait than quoted so I was happy.
The folks that are preaching wait until the clunkers program is over and teh prices will drop back down are correct.
Even if the marketer/carmaker has created buzz about demand that DOES NOT EXIST? Remember the Acura TL of late 2006 (2007) models...... What a JOKE! Dealerships were expounding the rarity of the car while "lot queens" sat all summer getting sunburned while managers cried out "Hold the line!' Nice car but definitely NOT exclusive!
If you're selling dogs that nobody wants (or they want it at a price that is more in line with competition) but the manufacturer is in another universe with their "take" on marketing.... suffer the little dealerships. The latest "false buzz" is Minii's..... Good luck - nobody cares!
Cash for Clunkers has created false demand with hype. The first (factual, just tune into your local news) reports are coming out that the dealerships are....... waiting for the money. They have obviously never dealt with the Federal Government before. They're in for a rude surprise.
My little "Area 51" that I'm not suppose to talk about is MASSIVE inventory that is hidden from public view and warehoused.... If the public only knew!!!!!
The Feds changed the rules that the car doesn't have to be on the lot anymore...
As long as its already on the "production line", it can be used for C4C.
Seems to me the supply/demand issue should be null at this point.
Is it that the dealers are still trying to hide this fact, so they can claim short supply, and kick up the prices?
Or is it that even the "on production line" vehicles are already sold as well?
Can't the various car manufacturers just allocate the VINs ahead of time for the "soon to be built" vehicles?
Yep, anyone who does not have a clunker should sit on the sidelines and wait if at all possible, IMO. That is especially true if they are looking to buy something that has been popular amngst the clunker dumpers.
That would work for me, would it work for You?
Over all, oddly enough, he still seems to support the program.
I've seen variations on this idea over the years, and it seems to me to have merit. I'd like to see some objective research done on this to prove or disprove it. The problem is I don't know where the money would come from; that is, who would stand to gain by it, to justify the expenditure?
A related topic on "News & Views" is "Go Green By Driving It 'Til the Wheels Fall Off." Take a look, and see what you think of the comments.
A sound principle, in theory. But basic economics suggests that most people will reduce the money they are willing to invest in maintenance as the vehicle depreciates. Thus, at some point the vehicle may become an ill-maintained "gross polluter" while still in the hands of the original owner, or it may be sold to someone who does not care that certain features no longer work as designed--and that new owner will not have the money to continue to maintain the car properly.
Admittedly right now if they said 'we'll give you $4,500 for the Accord" I'd probably decline since I could get that for it by selling it and it's still got life in it. Just a thought.
They know they'll get their money and I doubt this is the only situation where dealers have to wait a few weeks or a month for someone to pay a bill.
link:
http://www.irs.gov/newsroom/article/0,,id=205863,00.html
Also what everyone keeps ignoring is that most manufactures make the dealership wait a month before their get their rebate money anyway.
Now if there is still a big bottleneck on getting deals processed at the end of august when the program has been live for a month we will hear a lot more complaining.
Aug 19 02:00 PM US/Eastern
By DAN STRUMPF
AP Auto Writer
NEW YORK (AP) - Hundreds of auto dealers in the New York area have withdrawn from the government's Cash for Clunkers program, citing delays in getting reimbursed by the government, a dealership group said Wednesday.
The Greater New York Automobile Dealers Association, which represents dealerships in the New York metro area, said about half its 425 members have left the program because they cannot afford to offer more rebates. They're also worried about getting repaid.
Many dealers have said they are worried they won't get repaid at all, while others have waited so long to get reimbursed they don't have the cash to fund any more rebates, Schienberg said.
"The program is a great program in the sense that it's creating a lot of floor traffic that a lot of dealers haven't seen in a long time," he said.
"But it's in the hands of this enormous bureaucracy and regulatory agency," he added. "If they don't get out of their own way, this program is going to be a huge failure."
http://www.breitbart.com/article.php?id=D9A63RC81&show_article=1
Says who?? That is kind of like the chicken and egg deal. Nobody knows who started this mess.
It was started the first time a seller and a buyer agreed to it. There is no mystery here. Two people found an arrangement that benefitted both parties and the rest is history.
tidester, host
SUVs and Smart Shopper
That’s irrelevant. They agreed and a sale was made. There's nothing more to it.
tidester, host
SUVs and Smart Shopper
This undated booking photo provided by the Maricopa County Sheriff's Office shows Timothy M. Kissida. Kissida, 23, who is accused of trading in his BMW using the Cash for Clunkers program to get rid of it after a fatal hit-and-run crash, is due in a Phoenix court Thursday, Aug. 20, 2009. Prosecutors have charged him with leaving the scene of a fatal injury accident and tampering with evidence.
(AP Photo/Maricopa County Sheriff's Office
Tomorrow any dealer can end it by following the model of Fitzmall and others and just saying "no" to any offers other than their set price.
"As Cash for Clunkers enters its fourth week, Edmunds.com, a Web site for car buyers and sellers, reports the number of people taking advantage of the program appears to be on the decline.
"Now that there is plenty of money in the program and the most eager shoppers have already participated, the sense of urgency is gone, and the pace of intent decline is accelerating," said Edmunds.com CEO Jeremy Anwyl. "Inventories are getting lean and prices are climbing, giving consumers reasons to sit back."
Edmunds.com concluded that sales activity last week was down 15 percent from the peak in July."
How I wish I could divulge the dealer’s name. However, I think this is not limited to this dealership as the usual ads highlighting the benefits for the CARS program last weekend in the L.A. Times were toned down. Likewise, I called several dealerships and their usual first question was whether I had a clunker. I would just hang up the phone because I knew what was coming. Of course they have all the right to give discounts or not. Don’t these dealers realize that these CARS recipients were the ones that brought them back to life? Now they want to screw the goose that lays the golden eggs. If this is not greed I don’t know what you can call it.
Is there a way we can get the truth out there and ask those planning to buy a new car to postpone doing so for a month or so and put these dealers back to where they were a month ago?
I can see the dealers not giving much of a discount as the govt. is slow in giving them the C4C money, so that would affect the price, but not by much.
Also, I see no reason why you cannot disclose the dealers name.
The gas mileage provision was just part of a compromise to get experimentalists to vote for it.
Its called a compromise that is how legislation gets passed.