Mazda Protegé

1163164166168169453

Comments

  • the_big_hthe_big_h Member Posts: 1,583
    and not SIMULATED 90/100? I believe Nokya doesn't make actual overwattage bulbs for their Arctic White series, they just use the blue tint to claim it's the same brightness as 90/100, when in fact it draws standard wattage (60/55)...

    I'm actually fine with it in the rain, the extra lighting of the reflectors is actually more comforting to me, making sure I'm not swerving off the lane. Personal taste I guess...
  • newcar31newcar31 Member Posts: 3,711
    I don't have a scanner. I have the directions as an attachment to an e-mail. If anybody wants the directions, e-mail me. If anyone has a scanner, I can send you the directions.
  • elec3elec3 Member Posts: 160
    Fair
    60°F Feels Like: 59°F

    UV Index: 3 Low
    Wind: From the Southwest at 8 mph
    Dew Point: 15°F
    Humidity: 17 %
    Visibility: Unlimited
    Barometer: 30.30 inches and falling

    But then of course tomorrow will be even better, check this out:

    Sat Hi Lo
    Feb 23 Mostly Sunny 78°F 41°F

    Awww yeah :) BTW, the rear speakers in my Pro5 are most definitely cheap Pioneers rated at 25watts and I don't remember how many ohms. I would imagine the front speakers are also rated at 25 watts. This means the head unit is at very best 25x4=100watts if you're a marketing guy. It's probably somewhat less than that. The speakers are very cheap with thin paper cones and small, light magnets.
  • tradrcttradrct Member Posts: 7
    if you still have your receipt for those PIAA's contact PIAA and they will hook you up with a replacement set of the same or newest bulbs on the market for FREE.. all the bulbs made by PIAA have a 1yr warranty if you can provide proof of purchase!

    they have the best warranty in the biz.

    I had my left headlight burn out recently when I discovered their replacement program. finding a number to contact them might be a pain but is worth it.

    good luck..
    David
  • yooper53yooper53 Member Posts: 286
    Just curious. Where did you get the instructions? Spoke to Mazda 02/19 evening. He said he'd get the instructions in the next day's mail. From his description they sound well detailed.
  • protegextwoprotegextwo Member Posts: 1,265
    "Vocus....you've probably made this clear but what is your next car choice going to be?"
    by shrique


    Paul King's next few car purchases-

    Well,... this is rumor only:

    1.) Summer of 2002, VeeDub Jetta out, 2003 Toyota Matrix in.

    2.) Spring of 2003, Toyota Matrix out, 2003 Mercedes-Benz ES320 4matic wagon in.

    3.) Winter of 2004, Mercedes-Benz ES320 4matic wagon out, 2004 BMW 330i in.

    4.) Summer of 2004, BMW 330i out, Lincoln 2004 Blackwood Limited in.

    5.) Fall of 2004, Lincoln 2004 Blackwood Limited reposssed, 2004 Hyundai Accent in.

    6.) Spring of 2005, Hyundai Accent bursts into flames and burns down to it's tires, while Paul is picking up a coffee at mini-mart, 2000 Kia Rio purchased at Al's Auto Mart for $850.00 cash and a 2lb bag of JuJu fish.
  • dinu01dinu01 Member Posts: 2,586
    You crack me up every week! As for the Paul comments, I was going to bring up a similar list, but since you already wrote it, I'll let Paul get in on this one while it's still "hot". He he! Seems like yesterday when Paul traded in his PRO for "a luxurious Jetta with Monsoon stereo and sunroof"... Now it's on to the Matrix hunt.

    Paul: For your own sake, BAN YOURSELF FROM SHOWROOMS until the Jetta is 6 yrs old. I feel Meade might say it anyway, so while Larry took the car list idea I already thought of, here's my suggestion.

    Weather: You guys sound like the weather network! Since I feel this board needs an international flavour... "It was a sunny Friday in Toronto today, with a high of +5 and a low of 0".

    Good chat last nite! If you weren't there, BE THERE next Thursda@9PM!

    Dinu
  • dinu01dinu01 Member Posts: 2,586
    Sunday@3PM EST:

    Can -vs US!

    Oh baby! Bring on the gold! Go Canada Go! :)
  • protegextwoprotegextwo Member Posts: 1,265
    it would be nice if your country won a gold medal in something other then Curling or Women's Hockey.
    ;-))))

    -Larry Love Train
  • the_big_hthe_big_h Member Posts: 1,583
    Canada won the gold in curling? amazing!
  • narenjinarenji Member Posts: 161
    Those Matrixes look nice, but Toyota went cheap and put a beam suspension at the rear on all but the AWD vehicles. A car like the Matrix calls for proper ind rear sus. I would test drive to see Toyota's attempt at beam suspension. I really wasn't very impressed with Nissan's beam suspension on the Sentra, Maxima, or the I35 (the handling felt less secure as the car got bigger)
  • protege_fanprotege_fan Member Posts: 2,405
    No, we got Bronze in Women's curling and silver in Men's curling :(
    However, Gold will be ours on Sunday!!!!!!!
    Go Canada Go!!!!
  • ladyzoomladyzoom Member Posts: 2
    Hello. This is my first time participating on this chat. I'm not sure how it works. I have a 2000 Protege. I take it in every three months to have the oil changed. Last Friday evening, my check engine light came on. The hesitated a little then began to run normally. I took her to the dealer repair the next morning. They said the COILBOX needed to be replaced. Before the repairman told me about the coilbox, I saw my sales rep, he said that if the gas cap is not on tightly air can get into the line and that will make the check engine light come on. Someone mentioned to me that sometimes the part that is ordered can be a rebuild part rather than a new part. Now I'm wondering if my car is a lemon. I'm a little uncertain about this replacement, which is still under warranty, but there is nothing that I can do but get it fixed. They said the light would go out, which it was out by the time I drove off, and that it was not yet burned out but was only a warning so it would be best to replace while still under warranty. Has anyone every heard of this stuff before?
  • fowler3fowler3 Member Posts: 1,919
    You are right, the same dealer in High Point. I think I was the one who suggested them to you in a post on here, way back when you started looking for a car.

    newcar31, if you have a digital camera you could take a shot of the instructions, most digicams have close-focus.

    Meade, I remember the storm of '96, I was in Hawaii that week and saw it on TV just before heading to the beach. It was a terrifically beautiful day with cloudless blue sky and 85 degrees (in Hawaii that is). I remember thinking -- Oh well, it will be gone when I get home. The heck it was -- a snow drift four feet high blocked my front door. The snow was two feet deep in the driveway. Two weeks later it was still a foot deep. That's why I moved to NC!

    The other thing I always feared was tornadoes. Right after I moved to NC the area had five, one touched down about a half mile from my house.
    You can't win there's always something the weather will hit you with.

    My dad and I went to Florida for Christmas a couple months after my mom died. It turned cold and there were snow showers on Christmas Eve in Daytona Beach. Palm trees with Santa Clauses hanging from them just don't go together, even with snow flurries.

    fowler3
  • the_big_hthe_big_h Member Posts: 1,583
    Since the car is still under warranty, I strongly recommend getting the coilpack replaced ASAP. Better safe than sorry.

    As for the gas cap, make sure that whenever you close it, you tighten it until it 'clicks' a couple times.

    For a new car warranty repair at a dealership, I can almost guarantee you that they are REQUIRED to use NEW OEM parts as replacements.

    Did you buy this car new? A lemon is defined as a car that's CONSTANTLY having MAJOR mechanical/electrical failures, or something similar. This is your first (and hopefully only) warranty repair since you had the car, yes?

    Parts failure do happen, even to our reliable Proteges. It's no biggie, just get it replaced, that's what a warranty is for!

    And, welcome to this forum! Hang around and ask questions, folks here are friendly (most of the time :D) and very helpful in Protege-related topics!
  • number42number42 Member Posts: 67
    I went back to that dealer where I was going to get the DX. He couldn't find one anywhere (in NYC).

    Since I had him look though, I discovered that I am Eligible for X-plan through my employer. So I went back and asked him if he found the DX I was looking for. He said no.

    So I decided to look at his LX models. His answer was that he only had 2 and they were loaded, but these ES's.....

    Needless to say I told him 'thanks but no thanks... can I have my deposit please?' Eventually the Sales manager said that he would give it back.

    From there we went to a larger dealer. We were in an out with a X-plan deal in an hour. I am getting an LX (sandalwood, Moon roof, alloy rims, wheel locks and alarm) for around 14k. (xplan - current incentives)

    Here's my question. are mud flaps a good idea?
  • alternatoralternator Member Posts: 629
    Front mud flaps will generally protect the area in front of the doors from collecting hard-to-remove tar deposits, etc. Definitely recommended, and very easy to install yourself. Rear mud flaps not much use and don't add to looks in my opinion.
  • zoomzoom79zoomzoom79 Member Posts: 272
    number42: Congratulations ... I think you'll be much happier with the LX vs. DX.
  • draymond2draymond2 Member Posts: 134
    What a great post! That guy is allready posting on the trade in board for the value of his Jetta. He must have a lot of money to be trading cars every 6months.
  • newcar31newcar31 Member Posts: 3,711
    Install complete. It's a piece o' cake with directions and the right parts. The hardest part about it was removing the stickers from the parts.
  • dinu01dinu01 Member Posts: 2,586
    A little friendly Olympic International contest wouldn't hurt, rite? So that's why tomorow we will find out who can play and who can't:) I know the US has a great team, and so does Canada. It's a tough one to call...

    LadyZoom: I wouldn't call that a lemon. It's a part failure like Big H said. It happens on all cars...even PROs.
  • the_big_hthe_big_h Member Posts: 1,583
    don't forget to post testimonials on how the strut bar greatly improves handling! :D
  • newcar31newcar31 Member Posts: 3,711
    I won't be able to tell a difference until I get these nasty spongy winter tires off. I need my SP 5000s now!
  • mazdafunmazdafun Member Posts: 2,329
    Motorweek's Pat Goss had a good talk about this on one episode. Here's the breakdown:

    OEM: Just as it sounds. Original equipment manufacturer, built to original design.

    Refurbished: Taken from a junked car and cleaned up. Not parts that were damaged. Used OEM, basically.

    Rebuilt: Also known as remanufactured. Usually an improvement in some fashion over OEM (such as improved balance on a countershaft, or adding fillets to avoid stress fractures in OEM design etc.), but not always. Rebuilt or remanufactured means that some redesign over the OEM design occured, to improve reliability or performance. I guess cat-back exhaust systems that are less restrictive would fall into this category. So would camshafts and other engine bits that improve power output or smoothness over an OEM part.
  • mazdafunmazdafun Member Posts: 2,329
    Nobody's said that in a while. :)

    What a fun little car.
  • chicagoprochicagopro Member Posts: 1,009
    ...but who's counting?

    Windshield installed Tuesday.

    Can I get the car washed tomorrow (Sunday)?
  • mustang87mustang87 Member Posts: 129
    A rebuilt part is used part that was refurbished back to OEM specs, i.e. alternators. A brand new exhaust system would not fall under rebuild category. Its a new aftermarket part made to OEM specs or supposedly better.

    Here in florida a lemon is a car that breaks down 3 or more times under waranty. The part that breaks down must be the same. If your steering wheels falls off then radio stops working and then steering wheel falls off again after being fixed, it is NOT a lemon.
  • dinu01dinu01 Member Posts: 2,586
    Before I forget: You know that country north of the US? Remember how they only won womens' hockey and figure skating golds? Well I heard they might have won the mens' hockey gold medal. Maybe I didn't hear it right, I don't know... Did they Larry?

    Dinu :)

    Jokes aside, it was a great game. Congrats go to the US team for putting up a solid fight in the first half of the 3rd period. Great game for the Olympics!
  • fowler3fowler3 Member Posts: 1,919
    they did win the gold medal, 5 to 2. Congratulations!

    mazdafun: Thanks for the definitions of OEM and Rebuilt. My experience with rebuilt parts was bad. I had a 1997 Audi Fox, which had a bad alternator. It was replaced with a factory rebuilt model, supposedly to OEM quality. If the OEM alternator failed, the rebuilt one was no better, it failed in 24-hours. And so did a second one and a third one.

    That's when I traded for a 1981 Mazda GLC. Kept the Fox running long enough to drive it to North Carolina and trade it in. The reason for not buying from the Virginia Mazda dealership where I lived-- they had a very bad rip-off reputation. Learned that when I bought a used VW Beetle from them.

    The Beetle story was: I took it in for service, went back at 5:00PM to pick it up. The car had not been moved all day from where I parked it that morning. I had put a chalk mark on a rear tire and on the pavement under it to be sure they did the work. At the service desk they handed me a bill for $250. I told them I wouldn't pay it because they had not done the work. (There was a long line of people waiting behind me to pay their bills.) When I told the service manager about the chalk mark he trashed the bill and said, "We didn't have time, bring it back tomorrow!" As I left I told the others...'Good luck! If I were you I would go elsewhere.' The next man up told the service manager he was a lawyer and he had BETTER BE SURE his car was repaired or face fraud charges.

    What are the odds of a mechanic doing a test drive and parking the car in exactly the same spot, matching the chalk marks? LOL!

    fowler3
  • sfratsfrat Member Posts: 208
    After seven years of flawless driving, I accidentally cut someone off while trying to merge into a lane to get onto the DC beltway. I never saw her. She did her best to stop, but unfortunately was impossible. The fortunate thing was damage was minimal. The impact was more of a "glancing blow" rather than a direct hit, and scuffed up my rear passenger side wheel; nothing else. Her car had a scuffed bumper and not much else. Everyone involved was fine. I was going slow to try to get on the exit, and she tried to stop, so the actual speed at impact made it more like a minor parking lot incident. She of course is filing an insurance claim, but other than that, it could have been a lot worse. My car is fine, like I said I was able to completely rub out the marks on my wheels, so it looks like nothign happened. I was thinking of having my car looked at just in case, but if the impact didn't leave any scratches on the wheels, could it have done anything else? We were both moving at the time. Looking for the opinion of the collective here. I was going to get a strut tower brace this month, but looks like I will be paying my insurance deductible instead. Rats. It could have been worse, much worse. I'll throw some pics up on the yahoo board so you all can take a look.
  • protegextwoprotegextwo Member Posts: 1,265
    ROMANIA....????
  • wrgrahamwrgraham Member Posts: 112
    I have generally chosen to own Toyotas in recent years, but my sister has a 91 Mazda 323 that has worked very well for her. She now has 160K miles on her car, it still runs fine, but she will need a new car soon. I only hear good things about the Protege, so certainly it is a good choice. However, I wonder why toyotas and hondas seem to get better gas mileage than other brands, including Mazda. Previously my sister had a Honda Civic, and she got better mileage with that than the current 323. I checked the specs here on Edmunds, and a new Protege DX with Manual trans is rated at 25-31. But a basic Accord is at 26-32 and a basic Camry is at 24-33. The Accord and the Camry are both much heavier cars and the 4 cylinder engines are quite a bit larger also.
  • mdaffronmdaffron Member Posts: 4,421
    Isn't it one Matrix, and two or more Matrices???

    One Jetta, two or more Jettae???

    Larry, I loved your post. Made me laugh, it did. However, I'm shocked that you got it by the Edmunds censorship committee. I'll wager it would have been removed (and I would have received an e-mail) if I had posted that.

    Meade
  • mdaffronmdaffron Member Posts: 4,421
    Steve, you might consider posting a message on the Yahoo! group to explain the photos you posted in the photos section. I visited the group before I visited the Town Hall when I came back to work this morning, and you really had me guessing for a while until I found your post from the 24th here! Glad everything's fine. BTW, if she's filing an insurance claim, it's HER insurance, right? No proof of who was at fault?

    Meade
  • boggseboggse Member Posts: 1,048
    Well, needless to say, there are differences in how Toyota & Honda and Mazda do things. If you scroll through this forum you will see numerous discussions concerning why the Protege may be better or worse than any other model of car. Yes, Hondas & Toyotas get better fuel economy. If that is your priority, then they are a clear choice. For me the difference comes down to overall ownership cost. I decided that it would cost me less to own the Protege than a Civic or a Jetta. This was based on invoice price, financing (0% x 48 months), insurance (I seem to be the oddball here), current price of gasoline, and potential maintenance costs. I was paying 5.9% x 60 months on my much more expensive Jetta at the time, plus higher insurance, plus buying premium fuel, and it was in the shop on a monthly basis. Obviously, the Jetta was going to cost me more overall than the Protege. When I considered the Civic, I realized I couldn't get similar financing, insurance was slightly more (again seemingly only for me), and if anything went wrong out of warranty (which was shorter mileage - 36k vs. 50k - and didn't include roadside assistance - it does now) it would cost considerably more to fix. Invoice price was higher on a Civic EX than a Protege ES, but not by much. Fuel economy is where the Civic had the advantage. When I looked at my driving patterns, the cost of gas, and the fuel economy of each car, I realized that the Civic would save me about $50 per year over the Protege in fuel costs. That would offset the difference in the cost of insurance, but none of the other 3 factors I was considering. Satisfied that I had found the more economical vehicle, I then considered which one I liked better. I really liked the firm suspension and sporty handling on the Protege more than the Civic. The Civic was no slouch, but the Protege definitely had the advantage. My wife preferred the seats in the Protege. Also, I doubt I could have gotten the Civic for $100 over invoice as I did with the Protege. For me, the choice was clear, but I suggest you would need to take into account the factors that are important to you. I didn't really consider the Corolla, because it was under powered in 2001, but it has more power now and gets better fuel economy than the Protege. My question would be, how does it drive?
  • vocusvocus Member Posts: 7,777
    Looks like some people here have no life, if they have to keep tabs on the posts I make. Glad to feel so important sometimes...

    I never made it to look at the Matrix this past weekend. I did, however, sit in one at the car show when I went. I could only remember 3 cars at the show when I was telling a friend. They were Passat (like them alot), Protege (thinking about it to lower my monthly costs, but they hold no value), and the Lexus IS300 (like this one alot too). The next car isn't coming for awhile though, unless this one happens to be wrecked.

    PS: I almost have 10,000 miles on the Jet already. I just did the 10K servicing this past Saturday. It's resting at 9600 in the parking lot at work right now as I speak.
  • mdaffronmdaffron Member Posts: 4,421
    Keep in mind that Car and Driver magazine named the Protege No. 1 out of 13 small cars tested two years ago, had nothing but accolades for its sportiness, comfort and handling, and summed things up by saying the Protege had "BMW verve for less than half the price."

    Here's what the same magazine has to say about the 2003 Corolla:

    "Well, sure, the Corolla isn't a particularly flamboyant car to drive -- that's why Toyota invented the Matrix -- but it is a perfectly modulated form of transport.

    "Furthermore, this latest iteration steers with poise and even flaunts some deliberate heft at the wheel. Its ride motions are well controlled, as are any sounds of exertion. Bolted together as if to last an eternity, Corollas fulfill a need for inoffensive transportation like no other car. Yes, it's too subtle and restrained for the enthusiast, but in this iteration, at least, it defines the role of the car like almost nothing else can."

    Sounds kinda like they're trying to sugar-coat a way of saying it's an extremely well-built but uninteresting car ... doesn't it?

    "Form of transport?"
    "Inoffensive transportation?"
    "Defines the role of the car?"

    LOL!

    Meade
  • vocusvocus Member Posts: 7,777
    The Matrix was designed to try to be everything to everyone from the start. If they would have just added traction control as an option with the ABS on the 2WD model, it would be cooler. (Also, it would be nice for the Protege to have traction control too, since its Ford kin (the Focus) has it too.)

    C&D always has a bunch of crap to say about cars that makes no sense though. And they love them some Toyota too. Those cars can do nothing wrong.
  • mdaffronmdaffron Member Posts: 4,421
    What do you mean Proteges hold no value?

    When I totaled my '92 LX, it had 28,000 miles on it and it was still 1992. But the check from the insurance company was enough to get back into ANOTHER '92. And I thought we'd all been through this depreciation debate until our sexual organs were blue -- the depreciation on a Protege vs., say, a Civic, is negligible once you figure in the original price and the value of the car five years down the road.

    You may *think* the car has no trade-in value because you took such a big hit trading in your high-mileage 2001 that wasn't in such great condition (hey, I saw your paint). I can't wait to see how much you scream when you go to trade in your 1-year-old Jetta next year with 40,000 miles on it, LOL!

    Meade

    P.S. Funny, I like Car and Driver and think they're very accurate in their road tests and commentary. That's why I subscribe to the magazine.
  • vocusvocus Member Posts: 7,777
    I won't be trading in a one year old Jetta or screaming, thank you very much. I mighr be getting a second car soon though, for my dad. We will see how that works out for us. (It will be a cheap used car though.)

    And I still think the Protege lot a LOT of its value in only 20K miles and 8 months. I mean come on, the car retailed for $18,545 and 8 months and 20K later (with one noticeable scratch on it), I got $11,500 for it? Makes no sense to me at all!

    Also, did you put money down when you bought the first 1992 Protege? Maybe that's why you ended up with enough money to get a second 1992. Because I didn't wanna have drama if I had an accident with the jetta, I got GAP insurance this time. So I wouldn't worry about it if my car were totalled.
  • mdaffronmdaffron Member Posts: 4,421
    You mean like a 1950 Volkswagen Beetle? If the Matrix was designed to be everything to everyone, they left something out -- and I think Edmunds picked up on it:

    "Though Toyota says Matrix has the styling of a sports car, it acts like an economy model in terms of soft ride, a tendency to exaggerate irregular road surfaces and to lean in corners and turns, when the soft, cushy cloth seats could use larger side bolsters to better keep your body in place."

    Sorry Paul ... by the sound of that, I don't think I'm a member of this Matrix love clan.

    Meade
  • mdaffronmdaffron Member Posts: 4,421
    "Also, did you put money down when you bought the first 1992 Protege? Maybe that's why you ended up with enough money to get a second 1992."

    No sir, actually I went into the car UPSIDE DOWN, back when I was like you and learned my lesson. I traded a 1988 Hyundai Excel with 115,000 miles on it for the first 1992 Protege (in September 1991, so the Hyundai was only three years old with 115,000 miles on it). The mileage and manual transmission made it worth only $300, and then the fact that it had no air conditioning made them deduct another $400. Guess what -- I had to PAY them to take the car!!! I had NO down payment on the Protege.

    DING DING DING!!! Sorry, you lose -- but we do have a nice consolation prize for you. Thanks for playing "Guess Meade's History."

    Meade
  • vocusvocus Member Posts: 7,777
    I don't love them, but I think they look neat. They are something different though, and that's what I like.

    I can't believe people are paying MSRP and over for them now! That makes no sense at all. If you wait for a couple of months, then they will be at invoice like every other small car on the market is.
  • mdaffronmdaffron Member Posts: 4,421
    You said, "I mean come on, the car retailed for $18,545 and 8 months and 20K later (with one noticeable scratch on it), I got $11,500 for it? Makes no sense to me at all!"

    I think we need to get real here. I just priced a 2001 ES on the NADA site with everything on it including moonroof, side air bags and ABS -- every available option -- and the price came to $16,461 invoice, $17,695 retail. (I have NEVER heard of ANYONE -- except you -- paying more than $18,000 for a Protege! Heck, even our loaded 2002 Protege5 was under $17,000!!!)

    Anyway, I then took that same car -- a 2001 ES -- and put 20,000 miles on it, and found it to be worth $12,400 trade-in, $14,500 retail.

    Methinks:

    (a) Thou wast taken to the cleaners when you bought the car (or failed to negotiate a price closer to invoice than retail), and

    (b) Thou art exaggerating a bit on what you got in trade (or you didn't negotiate that either).

    Meade
  • zoomzoom79zoomzoom79 Member Posts: 272
    I only paid $15,000 for my Protege ES 5-speed. It had a sticker price of $17,000. The car is now probably worth $11,000, give or take $500. That isn't terribly bad.

    BTW: Canada may have one a few battles but the US won the war;
    Final medal count: US-34 Canada-17 :)
  • boggseboggse Member Posts: 1,048
    Well, I was being kind since I hadn't driven one. I would hope that any improvement would be worth mentioning WRT the Corolla. It was positively anemic for a 125HP/lb-ft engine. Of course, I drove it after the 145HP Sentra, 130HP Protege and the 127HP Civic.
  • vocusvocus Member Posts: 7,777
    You forget that now the sunroof is a discount item. It was made standard on the 2.0 models. Back when I got my car, the sunroof was a $700 option or else in the Premium Pkg., which was like $1600 or something like that. The car retailed (MSRP) for $18,545 with automatic, Premium Pkg., and cassette player. I have the price sticker framed at home (because it was my first new car), I know what it said.

    Also, I did NOT pay MSRP for the car. I got it through the S-plan if you remember correctly. I paid $17,200 for it out the door. That was not the point though. It fell from the $17K that I paid for it to $11.5K in only 8 months and 20K.

    The NADA numbers are not BLACK book, which is what car dealers use to evaluate trade-ins. Go right to the "Real-World Trade-In Values" discussion in "Smart Shopper" here at Edmund's and ask them what my car would be worth. (I did, as a matter of fact.) They said $9500-10K trade-in and said I got a deal getting $11.5K for it. (For references, check posts 4051 and 4054 in that section.) They told me the car would be worth $9500-10K trade-in. Also, the windshield was broken when I traded it too (forgot that one). KBB value was $10,715 on the car. It was $7500 on the 1999 DX I traded, and Carmax only said $6500 back then (the dealer gave me $7500 for it) and KBB runs high they say.
  • mdaffronmdaffron Member Posts: 4,421
    I priced that car using 2001 pricing on the Protege, where yes, I had to add that $700 for the moonroof.

    And so now we're down to $17,200? I'm sorry, I thought you said you went from $18,545 to $11,500 in only 8 months.

    You still probably got screwed doing the trade-in on the Jetta, but $5,700 depreciation in the first year ain't too bad in my book. Especially when you put close to two years' mileage on that car in only 8 months.

    Meade
  • vocusvocus Member Posts: 7,777
    I still think that's alot of money to lose in 8 months on a car.

    And in essence, the car did go from $18,545 to $11,500 in 8 months. They don't go by what you, as the shopper, paid. They go by value. The MSRP of the car was $18,545.

    For the record, the Jetta (according to Kiplinger's Personal Finance magazine) will hold 50% of its value after 5 years, the best in its class. I don't remember right off what the Protege's was, I think it was the low 40s or high 30s though.
  • vocusvocus Member Posts: 7,777
    Glad to hear you are ok after the little scuff. It could have been alot worse. Believe me, I drive 495 every day and know how it can be. (UGH!) I was driving at 75mph in the fast lane once, and this car stopped DEAD (to 0mph) in front of me for no reason at all. NOTHING in front of her. My ABS saved my butt though, but still. People need more sense on that highway.
Sign In or Register to comment.

Your Privacy

By accessing this website, you acknowledge that Edmunds and its third party business partners may use cookies, pixels, and similar technologies to collect information about you and your interactions with the website as described in our Privacy Statement, and you agree that your use of the website is subject to our Visitor Agreement.