Mazda Protegé

1237238240242243453

Comments

  • vocusvocus Member Posts: 7,777
    Take it to the dealer so they can tell you they never heard of the problem before and don't know how to fix it, like they told me.

    They are probably going to tell you if the OD light is not flashing, then there is no way for them to find it. The OD light works like the engine light, a code is "stored" when it flashes. So there you go. Mention it to the dealer though, so you at least have proof it was checked out.
  • mdaffronmdaffron Member Posts: 4,421
    Crap should be pretty easy to find. You can, in fact, make it at home.

    ;-)

    Meade

    P.S. What's the best cracker for crap dip anyway? I would suggest Keebler Out House Crackers. ;-)
  • rbrooks3rbrooks3 Member Posts: 174
    I agree you you MD. That's why I got the 5 spd ES over the auto. But since we are now on attempt 3 for the dealer to fix my car, one more brings me into Lemon Law status here in NY. Add to that the fact that I seriously doubt their ability to fix this problem, at least without causing more, and the sport auto is something I may consider.

    Actually, had I even known it was going to be available on Feb and later 02 models, I might well have waited to get it.

    As usual the reason is simple, while I prefer manual and that's all I've driven, the wife won't. Not can't (she drove my MGBs in the far past), but won't. The new breed of sport autos is a good compromise IF the trannys are done well. Usually, the only problem is the amount of time it takes the "sport" autos to shift. Audi's is notoriuosly slow, but there are simple chip fixes to these available. I don't know Mazda's setup on the Pro, but I would have waited to test one before deciding.

    So, if I hit the Lemon level on my Pro, a Sport Auto might be somehting for me to consider. Maybe not get, but at least consider.

    So again, if anyone out there has driven the new sport auto, let me know how you thought it did and felt.
  • shriqueshrique Member Posts: 338
    Anything else about the "death rattle" from the 2.0 liter engine when it's cold? I know people were talking about a possible TSB on this.

    Thanks

    Shrique
  • protege_fanprotege_fan Member Posts: 2,405
    I've heard of the problem...it sounds TERRIBLE!!! But I haven't had it in my car..yet!
  • shriqueshrique Member Posts: 338
    Personally I havn't had the really bad sounding rattle but it does run rather strange when it's cold. They were talking about a EMC reprogram or something.
  • rbrooks3rbrooks3 Member Posts: 174
    I MAY have this. It occurrs only when the car is first started and sounds like loose heat shielding and seems to occur in any gear between 2000-2750. I change gears before 3,000 until the car reaches normal temp and I noticed it starting about 2 weeks ago. It sounds to me just like loose heat shielding. It goes away quickly as soon as the engine runs a bit. On my car about 3 minutes is enough. The dealer is supposed to be checking on this sound along with replacing the wiring harness. By the way, we are now into day 3 and they doubt they'll be done today. Not a real big deal since I'm putting mileage on their loaner Pro rather than my Pro.

    Am I describing the same sound as the "death rattle"?
  • dsm6dsm6 Member Posts: 813
    That's the same sound I have, at least. Please let us know if your dealer comes up with anything. Thanks.
  • dsm6dsm6 Member Posts: 813
    Well, Mazda says if you are rough on the car, do it every 5,000 miles. So I'm taking their word for it and doing their worst case scenario of every 5,000 miles. Every 3,000 wont hurt (the car that is, but will the wallet), but I personally doubt it will help significantly. Just my opinion.

    Yes, I realize this topic is old hat here, but someone new brought it up so I thought I'd "help."

    As a side note, a service rep where I bought the car said "Because of conditions here in Colorado, we recommend 3,000 mi." Someone here in this forum mentioned in passing something about someone saying something similar about Ohio, I think. I remember hearing the same thing in Michigan. Anybody else hear this about conditions in their area?

    I smell a conspiracy. I bet almost everywhere you go, service reps will tell you conditions there necessitate more oil changes than the manufacturer says. I mean, is any area "normal" per the manufacturers specs? If not, then why do they publish those specs?

    Let me guess, so your engine will wear out sooner. Then you'll buy a new car from them. Hmm, so car manufacturers like Honda, Toyota, Mazda, etc., don't want their engines to last, 'cause nobody ever buys them for their longevity, right?
  • tomcivilettitomciviletti Member Posts: 207
  • vocusvocus Member Posts: 7,777
    Pete has those, and so does Big H. They look pretty neat.
  • the_big_hthe_big_h Member Posts: 1,583
    i have the JDM clear corners, not the aftermarket ones from procarparts. the JDM ones are of the same quality as the factory amber ones, can't guarantee that with the aftermarket...

    although they do look pretty cool :-D

    here's a pic of my JDM clear corners, notice how the surface pattern is different from the procarpart ones:

    image

    corner close-up:

    image
  • vocusvocus Member Posts: 7,777
    They fit differently on the front of the car, from what I have seen in pics. Never saw any in person though but yours, at MAPP II.
  • the_big_hthe_big_h Member Posts: 1,583
    how different? mine's identical to my factory amber ones except the color, and it fits perfectly.
  • vocusvocus Member Posts: 7,777
    I mean the other aftermarket ones. They just don't look as tight fitting. Not yours, the other ones.
  • the_big_hthe_big_h Member Posts: 1,583
    nevermind then :-)
  • shriqueshrique Member Posts: 338
    on first?....
  • rbrooks3rbrooks3 Member Posts: 174
    Well, the dealer called and said the Pro is back together in one piece with a new spine/wiring harness. I hope they got it all right. I'm also looking forward to finding out what they say the death rattle is. I'll let everyone know tomorrow.

    Hopefully Zooming home in the dealer loaner for the last time.
  • chicagoprochicagopro Member Posts: 1,009
    ...actually look a little different than Hank's. Pete got them from Corksport, which unfortunately doesn't have a picture of them on their website.

    If you look in Pete's album on the yahoo site, though, there is still a pretty good pre-crash photo that shows how they look installed on his car.

    And good luck, Ron...hope everything is fixed to your satisfaction.
  • the_big_hthe_big_h Member Posts: 1,583
    so pete and i have the same JDM corners. Probably just the way I took the pics made them look different.

    well you can see it for yourself dale, when you come to MAPP3...
  • chicagoprochicagopro Member Posts: 1,009
    Do your corners have those bumps on the sides, that kinda sorta act as side markers? Pete's do; didn't look to me like yours did. Maybe I'm wrong. As usual :)

    Yes, looking forward to seeing how the clears look in person, especially on Tammy's P5, since her car is white like mine. Then I'll make my decision.
  • vocusvocus Member Posts: 7,777
    Tammy doesn't have clear corners on her car, does she? Since when?
  • the_big_hthe_big_h Member Posts: 1,583
    they have those yellow reflectors on the bumper....
  • chicagoprochicagopro Member Posts: 1,009
    What Hank said.

    :)
  • ajewelajewel Member Posts: 2
    Hi all! I am actually thinking of buying a Mazda Protege soon, I have already test-drove an Lx and now I'm thinking of trying the Es. I am really interested in buying a Millenium Red Es that comes installed with automatic transmission, floor mats, moonroof deflector, power moonroof, and perimeter alarm w/ shock sensor. I would like some info from owners of the Es and Lx as far as how you like the car, how it drives, etc. The alarm is the thing I am not sure about as I know those sensor ones can be a pain in the a**. Would like reviews from you Lx and Es owners so that I can figure out what to buy. Thanks!
  • snagy1snagy1 Member Posts: 55
    after further discussion with my service rep, "because of conditions here in ohio, we recommend changing the air filter also at 15 K." the filter didn't look bad at all, so i passed on it. if i had done everything they recommended at 15 K because of ohio conditions, it would have cost me about $ 220 dollars.
  • dsm6dsm6 Member Posts: 813
    Bought the car because of the way it handles, road feel, and brakes. All are quite good, IMO. Car is nice and light too, relatively speaking. Flat and stable with good feel through steering and brakes. Stops quickly, too, for this class, with four wheel discs - only on ES - don't know about the disc/drum set-up. I prefer the looks of the ES over LX, and like the grip of the wider tires, prefer alloys to steels with covers.

    About the only thing I don't care all that much for is the engine. A bit weak and buzzy for my taste. But, the price, and especially how that relates to the car's handling, sold it anyway. Besides, I find that ultimately the power is at least adequate to pull it around - with the 5 speed anyway.

    Hope that helps.

    Oh, I don't have the factory alarm/shock sensors. Sorry.
  • jamhjamh Member Posts: 11
    I just got my new ES 5 speed. I find it is hard to get into 1st gear from the 2rd. After I stop for a few second, and all the gears are smooth. But, when I come to a stop from higher gear, I find it is not so easy to get into the 1st gear while all the other gears are fine. Is this normal or something I am not doing right?
    Also, what are the differences between the Pro5 and a ES, mechanically, other than the body shape. I saw the strut tower brace of Pro5 is not in my ES. And Pro5 also has blue sway bars underneath the car, if I remember right? Car and Driver recorded a 0.77g for the Pro5. Does anyone know if ES handles better than Pro5 or not? How many g's with the stock 16' tires for a ES right out of factory, and what's the 0-60?
    Also to ajewel, I just bought a new red ES last weekend. I like it very much. I like it better than a civic, and both the interior and exterior look nicer. It handles nicely. Also, you can get $1500 factory rebate and an addtional $500 for a recent college graduate.
  • protege_fanprotege_fan Member Posts: 2,405
    I've got an '01 LX 2.0 L 5-speed manual in black mica. I love my Pro. I've got ABS, air, and power locks w/ keyless. In Canada, the LX does not come with power windows (for 2001 at least). It drives great (ie. superior handling), gets good mileage, and looks excellent. The 2.0 L engine is good and I've taken it on many trips over 7 hours long (about 600 km) one way. It has power to pass and is comfortable for long drives. I highly recommend the Protege.

    Now between the LX and ES, that's a personal preference.

    For the alarm, ask jbollt and his daughter how that is... :D
  • protege_fanprotege_fan Member Posts: 2,405
    Better transmission fluid (I've heard redline is highly recommended) is supposed to help a lot with the gear changes, especially from 3rd to 2nd and 2nd to 1st.
  • sarahnbuasarahnbua Member Posts: 7
    LOL jbollt's daughter here . . . yeah, the shock sensor thing is a pain in the butt. There's supposed to be a way to change the sensitivity (although not according to Mazda), but I haven't actually checked on that yet.

    I've got a Shimmering Sand '02 LX automatic with moonroof, alloy wheels, factory alarm, power everything, and I decided on it after driving a '96 LX for 5 years (it was my first car -- yes, I know, I'm young). So I guess my opinion might be a bit biased, as I don't have much else to compare to, but I love the Protege. I would say the main downfall of the Protege is how much it loses its resale value after the first year. If that kind of thing is important to you, I'd say go for something that'll hold its value better. And the only other thing is the size of the engine . . . although I have to say my 2.0 liter engine does a lot more than the dinky 1.5 liter I had in my '96. It's definitely not a V6, though.

    And I absolutely love the moonroof.
  • curt3curt3 Member Posts: 101
    I remember one of the times that I took my 2000 LX 1.6L in for pinging(way back when it had the warranty) the service representative told me that he had seen many Proteges with rattles coming from the heat shield although this was never the case with my particular car.

    DSM6--the oil change crowd down here in Southeast Alabama also claim that oil changes are needed every 3,000. It must be the peanut dust...
  • curt3curt3 Member Posts: 101
    How many miles did you have on your 1996 trade and which model was it? I am in the process of trading my 2000 LX with 5-speed and 63,000 miles. I have found a 2000 ES with automatic at a good price. I am debating, however, to jump on a new one if the financing/rebate offer stays as tempting as the deal I got on my 2000 model. Even with the 0% financing that I got on it I was still eligible for a small rebate to go along with it.

    Congratulations on your new purchase!
  • th83th83 Member Posts: 164
    have first-hand experience with both a 1.8 and 2.0 litre Protege(3rd generation, of course)? Is there much of a difference in power, refinement, etc.? I test drove a new '02 Protege auto and manual so I'm familiar with the new Proteges but, I'm also considering a used '00 ES as a less expensive option. If you've driven both, please relate your experience with them. Thanks!

    Tom
  • mdaffronmdaffron Member Posts: 4,421
    Good morning from "way up here" in Richmond. I own a 2000 ES 5-speed that has just about 50 miles shy of 36,000 miles on it. No problems and loving every mile. My wife bought a 2002 Protege5 (with the 2-liter engine) automatic back in January. So far a little over 3,000 miles and no problems to report. I can't really compare the two as far as performance goes since (a) they have different transmissions, and (b) I'm only a passenger in the Protege5!!!


    BTW, if you're really interested in Proteges and you're not too far from Virginia, please consider coming to our third-annual Mid-Atlantic Protege Picnic (MAPP III) up at Shenandoah River State Park, outside Front Royal, Virginia, on Saturday, May 18. So far we have about 20 Proteges of all generations and about 30 people signed up to attend. For more information, check out my Yahoo! group:


    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/mazdaprotege


    Meade

    mazdaprotege moderator

  • rbrooks3rbrooks3 Member Posts: 174
    I've had my '02 ES for a few months and approx 3800 miles. Unfortunately, I have had a problem with my cruise control and while I'm certainly not happy about it, I cann't have any complaints about the way Mazda went about fixing the problem. The warranty gives you a loaner or rental car, so, you're not left without transportation.

    My ES has the factory alarm and although it wasn't an option I wanted, I have not had any problems with it.

    For the price new, there is not a better handling car on the market. That's what made my decision. I test drove the Sentra and Saturn models, but the Protege was head and shoulders above them. Of course, I'd doubt you'd find anyone in hear who has bad things to say about the Pro. For me, it just came down to feel. The Pro had it. I liked the Sentra SER (the Spec V was out of my price range), but didn't care for the rear suspension or the overall look. For the money the Pro is a classier ride in my opinion.

    As for Lx vs. ES, mechaically they're the same. The tire/wheels are different. It's really just a matter of price. Start adding options to the LX and you just might find yourself in ES territory anyway. That's what happened to me. Plus, personally, I love the black/blue interior on the ES and those factory 16" rims.
  • fowler3fowler3 Member Posts: 1,919
    Is that the Light Sandalwood with a different name? I'm anxious to see how much it shimmers. LOL!

    I have a '01 2.0L LX with AT and like it very much. It rides firm at first but after 3000 miles the suspension loosens up a bit, the ride is much better. From what others here ahve said, the difference in firmness between the LX and ES is mainly due to the 16-inch wheels and low profile tires on the ES, the suspension is the same. The LX At gets 28mpg around town and 36mpg higway, depending on how you drive. If you have heavy foot the fuel economy will be considerbaly less. Handling is great. Have had NO problems in the first year. I don't have the security system and from what I have read here am very happy it isn't on the car.

    After one year driving the Pro, there isn't another car out there I would have bought had I the opportunity to do it again. None are as satisfying to drive, none have as nice an interior, none have the cabin room, none handle as well -- without costing thousands more.

    Security alarms are more profit for the dealer, do not substancially increase the car's security, and provide a maintenance headache the dealers appreciate = $$$.

    fowler3
  • rbrooks3rbrooks3 Member Posts: 174
    Got my Pro back last night. Thank God everything seems to be right on now. The cruise control works and I spoke to the tech who worked on the car for a while. Turns out the wiring harness is $1800 and the labor was 2 1/2 days! I don't know what the profit margin on the Pro is for Mazda, but I'd venture to guess they've not made anything on my car. Anyway, it runs great, the dealer's tech could not have been more pleasant and my baby is back home. I even got to use cruise control for the first time. I like it. It engages very quickly and doesn't let the speed drop and then accelerate like mad for a few seconds to get to the speed you set it like some others do.

    ONE WORD OF WARNING FOR MANUAL CARS: I set the cruise control at 60, was coming to a light and shifted into neutral. As soon as you hit the clutch it disengages the cruise system. As I coasted towards the light, it turned green. I then made the dumb move of pushing the Resume button BEFORE I put the car back into 5th (stupid me thought I had it in gear). Well, as soon as I pushed the resume button the engine flew to redline! I hit the brakes and depressed the clutch and the engine returned to idle as the system disengaged. I don't know whether it was the clutch, brakes or the system sensing the approach of redline that made the car return to neutral. I also have not intention of testing it again to find out. I can't believe that Mazda would design the system to blow the motor by letting the engine max out at redline and stay there until you did something to turn the cruise system off. But, I'm also surprized to find that the cruise system can be made to Resume without sensing that it's in gear. Seems odd.

    As far as the first start death rattle goes, I unfortunately have to report the obligatory and maddening "could not duplicate" result from the dealership.
  • shriqueshrique Member Posts: 338
    I made that same mistake in my P5. Luckily I was just using it to avoid a speeding ticket on a 30mph cop zone. The clutch will not disengage the cruise control. Only the brake will.
  • vocusvocus Member Posts: 7,777
    I test drove a 2000 ES 1.8 automatic, and ended up buying a 2.0 2001 model. I liked the 1.8 better, because it had a free-revving nature that was not in the 2.0. But also, the 2.0 had more power down low than the 1.8 did. Drive both and see which one you like.
  • vocusvocus Member Posts: 7,777
    I had a 1999 DX with 14-inch tires, then got a 2001 ES Protege. I prefer the 4-wheel discs to the disc/drum setup alot, because they feel alot stronger when braking.

    I would get the ES, just because the wheels alone are worth the price increase from the LX model. Also, the ES has the red dash lights which I like as well. Drive both and see which you prefer though.
  • protege_fanprotege_fan Member Posts: 2,405
    What if you don't want to pay for the wheels?
    Steel rims=cheap to replace
    Mazda alloys=expensive to replace

    Some people prefer less frills for (basically) the same car.
  • vocusvocus Member Posts: 7,777
    That's why I advised the person to drive/look at both and take which one they like better.

    I prefer alloy wheels, even though they are more expensive to replace, because steel wheels with wheel covers = cheap to me. The wheels on my VW right now are $390 EACH and the tires are $180 EACH, but I still got the car, knowing that.
  • rbrooks3rbrooks3 Member Posts: 174
    I just drove a friend of mine to drop her car off at the local shop and decided to test my cruise control on the way back.

    I got the car to 55, shifted into neutral, then turned the cruise system on, hit "set" and wham! The engine raced upwards.

    So, that means on my car I the car will allow me to activate and attempt to maintain a speed when the car was never in gear with the system on.

    I just called Mazda USA's customer number and the customer service person said this was NOT normal and should not happen. he said the system should not be able to be activated in neutral. You can turn the system "on" in neutral but it should not accept a "resume" or "set" command while in neutral. BUT, he did also say he would check with the engineering dept as this would be classified as a technical question on which he would not be the final word, being as he works in customer service. I await his return call and I'll let you all know what the final word from Mazda is.

    By the way, he also said categorically, the system should disengage when the clutch is depressed. So, to the fellow who posted above about the Pro5, you may want to test that again and if the rpms shoot up when you depress the clutch you may well have a problem.
  • dsm6dsm6 Member Posts: 813
    I too prefer alloys over steels with covers. So much so that I put my snow tires on a new set of alloys. To each his or her own.
  • protege_fanprotege_fan Member Posts: 2,405
    Wow...that doesn't sound right at all. I've only had experience with cruise in automatics; never in manuals. I hope they get back to you and say it's not supposed to act like this. It'll probably be inconvenient losing the car again, but this sounds like something that needs to be fixed!

    BTW, do you still have the death rattle?
  • dsm6dsm6 Member Posts: 813
    I tried this a few weeks ago - my cruise control disengages with the clutch.
  • dsm6dsm6 Member Posts: 813
    IIRC, per the discussion a while back, the 2.0 is a stroked 1.8. When you stroke an engine, it improves low end torque but increases rotational mass thereby decreasing the engines ability to rev.
  • mdaffronmdaffron Member Posts: 4,421
    In fact, the only funky quirk about the cruise control in my 2000 ES 5-speed that I've learned is, don't press in the clutch when it's accelerating up a hill! Because even though depressing the clutch pedal will disengage the cruise control, it takes about a second for the cruise to get the message -- and that's usually enough time for the engine to get up to about 5,000 rpm (with a nice throaty growl, I might add) before it comes back down.

    BTW, one thing I really like about the Protege's cruise control, which makes it better than the one I had in my Saab, is, even though it disengages under 25 mph, it remembers your setting as long as you don't switch off the main or turn off the car. So as soon as you're back up above 25, you can hit resume and be back where you were. Makes it nice when you're taking a state route (instead of an interstate) and you come through one of those little tiny towns with a traffic light and a grocery store (and a trigger-happy deputy who just got enough budget money to buy a radar gun). ;-)

    The Saab suffered from cruise-control anemia if you dropped below the cut-off speed, making you have to reset it.

    Meade
  • rbrooks3rbrooks3 Member Posts: 174
    Mazda's Customer Service tech got back to me already. My Pro is going back AGAIN!

    He said that he spoke to engineering and if the Protege is in neutral, the cruise control system should not respond to either a "set" command or a "resume" command. No mad death dashes to redline should occur.

    Back to the dealer we go.
Sign In or Register to comment.

Your Privacy

By accessing this website, you acknowledge that Edmunds and its third party business partners may use cookies, pixels, and similar technologies to collect information about you and your interactions with the website as described in our Privacy Statement, and you agree that your use of the website is subject to our Visitor Agreement.