By accessing this website, you acknowledge that Edmunds and its third party business partners may use cookies, pixels, and similar technologies to collect information about you and your interactions with the website as described in our
Privacy Statement, and you agree that your use of the website is subject to our
Visitor Agreement.
Comments
I chose to pay the extra money for the side impact bags. I want my family to have every possible chance of surviving a crash. I think that side impact bags will probably be in all future cars, in the next few years.
I understand that some people may not be able to afford this feature. For me, I chose to skip the DVD player and add the safety features.
Bev
>Show me a '04 Sienna one can buy for "$25-ish" with front seat side
>ABS, side curtain ABS, traction control, and VSC (much less 4-wheel
>disc brakes) - IT DOES NOT EXIST!!"
04 Sienna CE with option Pkg AI: MSRP $25,100; Invoice price $23,366. And it has all the options you mentioned above.
>if anyone thinks side curtain ABS is going to be the difference in
>life and death in more 0.0001% of crashes, this person probably
>believes in the "big bang theory" for the beginning of the earth as
>well.
Have you read this?
http://www.hwysafety.org/news_releases/2003/pr082603.htm
Each year, 9,000 people died in side impacts in US. Side guard curtain is estimated to be able to reduce deaths by a significant 45%. And in case of a two car collision in which a passenger car with side guard curtain is struck by another car or minivan, the risk reduction is even more impressive at 74%.
>Some of these new features are being extremely over-rated.
On the contrary, most people do not realize the potential benefits of Side Guard Curtain. Your "big bang theory" comments appear to me that you may be one of them.
And VSC/ESP is perhaps one the most *under-rated* safety features which are not reflected in any crash testing done today.
Obviously, everyone wants to protect their families.
But some here are making suggestions that if you don't buy a certain feature you are making a poor investment for your family. This is flawed to the core. How can anyone suggest that one or two features should determine whether or not a car should be purchased? So much more goes into purchasing a vehicle...Price, safety, reliability, tow capacity, seating options, gas mileage, insurance, comfort, availability, and the list goes on and on and is different for each person.
Number one, Toyota has TOO MANY packages!
Number two, according to Toyota, LEs make up almost 70% of the vehicles made, XLEs 20%, Limiteds 4% and CEs roughly 6%. So, the "04 Sienna CE with option Pkg AI: MSRP $25,100" which was previously listed, good luck finding one.
These options are great to have (and I'm thankful I do have them), but the fact that they are great does not make them readily available to everyone.
The choice rbell2 made was the right one for him/her at the time the decision to buy was made. They did after all buy one of the highest rated minivans of all time! No one can place fault there. To ask a question, "Will you say to your children after their mother is killed in a side impact that she really wasn't worth protecting?" in IMHO, is at a minimum, improper.
Side Impact SRS can and will save some lives. But overall crash results will prevail despite the presence of one option alone. Some minivans may have this feature, but may perform poorly in other crash tests, we shall see. As for the Ody, it is a proven winner and should be afforded such a distinguished title.
>But some here are making suggestions that if you
>don't buy a certain feature you are making a poor
>investment for your family.
I think you may be referring to me. And no, that's not what I meant at all.
I was just responding to rbell2's decision points. He was obviously concerned about safety as it was listed in his point #2. And he wrote:
>3) The few features on the Sienna you can't get on
>an Ody did not mean a lot to me
which I thought was contradictory. And his "big bang theory" comments appear to me that he may not fully realize the potential benefit of side guard curtain.
Crash testing is important, but it should not be the sole basis of safety assessment. VSC and Emergency Brake Assist will not give any extra star in the crash testing, but it will reduce the chance of having a crash in the first place.
Yes there is alot more to buying a car than just a particular safety feature, but for a nominal amount over the life of the car its relatively cheap insurance.
To get side curtain airbags on a LE, its package BI which costs 1610MSRP/1336Invoice, you can have one for 25870. Another 1300 gets the Trac and so on.
I agree it is good that Honda added the side seat airbags to all models, the only problem is its half the loaf. Most people in accidents die of head injuries, the side airbags do not protect your head, just your torso. Had the new Sienna not offered these, I would likely be driving a very nice Honda Odyssey.
As for the Ford, yes that is a good feature, but if you wear a seatbelt you are very unlikely to be thrown from a vehicle in any case. In the case of the Ford, reliability can be a safety issue and the Windstar has been anything but reliable.
I think the Sienna should offer side curtains as a basic feature on all the Sienna's, just because you have a bit less money or are unaware of the benefits doesn't mean you should not have the best safety features available. As I said before I applaud Nissan for having the curtain airbags in all of their vans.
The active safety system of VSC is also an excellent feature, preventing an accident is as important as the structural performance of the vehicle. If I avoid one, I don't have to do a personal crash test.
Curtain airbags are great...But you miss my point. It appears (and please correct me if I'm wrong) that you assume that you can just walk right into a Toyota dealership with a specific model in mind and drive off. That is not true. Are you not in the middle of a search yourself? Is it not taking a great deal of time for you to decide on who to buy from and wait for your order to come in?
The point I'm trying to make is a lot less complicated than we have made it here. rbell2 was in the market for a minivan. rbell2 did not want to wait an indefinite period of time purchase the Sienna so rbell2 purchased what has been the minivan standard (and a high one at that) for the last five years.
The safety rating on the Ody has received the best marks out there. In fact, even with the presence of VSC, Trac Control, and 4 wheel disc brakes, the Sienna was outperformed by the Ody with respect to handling and braking by Consumer Reports. No, I don't want to argue their tests, tires or surfaces, ect...
All I want to declare is that no one can be faulted or even worse - accused - of making a poor investment for buying one of the safest vehicles on the market.
On this point, you and I will simply have to agree to disagree.
One last thing, your statement on VSC is right on point with trying to prevent accidents, however, there are a lot of people who put too much trust in the VSC system and have a false sense of security. The laws of physics still apply!
Happy and safe driving!
"In fact, even with the presence of VSC, Trac Control, and 4 wheel disc brakes, the Sienna was outperformed by the Ody with respect to handling and braking by Consumer Reports."
VSC does not make the car handle better; and none of Consumer Reports' tests put VSC into test. In addition to slippery road conditions, VSC also helps to correct mistakes by drivers, which does not include professional drivers who did the road tests.
And Consumer Reports Sienna's braking test result was particularly puzzling as it contradicted other road tests by Car & Driver, Motorweek and Toyota internal testing.
But, since you brought it up...
lekn wrote:
"VSC does not make the car handle better; and none of Consumer Reports' tests put VSC into test."
In their Oct. 2003 issue Consumer Reports wrote:
"The Sienna’s emergency handling is secure and predictable, helped by optional stability control, although it posted a modest speed in our avoidance maneuver." They seem to believe that the LE with VSC that they tested does help handling (although it works independent of the driver) and they commented on it?!?
As far as the braking issue, so many issues to argue here...and it's not worth arguing...CR tested an LE with different tires than most I've seen tested and the surfaces are different, etc... I just don't have the mental capacity to argue this one!
But back to my "Main" point:
Despite these minor arguments, it'll take a lot more to convince me or 150K new Ody owners that buying that van is a poor investment in a family when it still has the highest safety ratings in the industry -- with the Sienna, I do hope...
My point is, if you're on here doing research and searching for what pkg. has the most value to you, you are in the minority. Most people don't want to "waste their time" on researching a $30,000 purchase. Believe me I don't understand it, but ask any salesman and you'll find it's true. Why do you think it's so hard for US to find the van we want at a decent price? It's because people walk in every day and take whatever is on the lot, paying MSRP and smiling all the way home!
We're showing our age...
Crash test results are out, btw:
Cars, vans perform well in crash test (MSNBC)
Steve, Host
After the fuel tank is replaced, the Sienna was given the highest safety rating in the crash test.
There are some problems in the first several days, the plastic cover of the center seat of middle row was broken already before I started using it. The service department of my dealer ordered a new cover to replace it. To me the plastic covers (especially the ones under or beside the seats) of the new Sienna look very cheap.
The second issue is that I found when I press on the gas pedal, there is always a slight hesitation first. I hope it is not just me. I also found that unlike what's been claimed by Toyota, it is quite noisy when accelarating. At least my previous Honda Odyssey 1997 was quieter.
The third issue is that whenever I press the gas, I hear a whistling sound under the hood. I don't know whether it is normal for the new Sienna or not. Has anybody got the same noise? I am going back to the dealer this weekend again.
Other than the above issues, everything looks/works fine. I hope there will be no more problems.
Another flaw mentioned here is the manual sliding door that won't stay open if the window is open a crack. Basically on any sort of incline that door is unusable due to safety, a person needs to hold open the heavy door while letting a child climb in. I expect Toyota will face a multitude of lawsuits over this design flaw. I would rather have the door always lock open or never lock open, the lack of consistency is extremely dangerous.
If you want the door to lock on an incline, close the window and then the door will open fully and latch.
The manual door and power windows on that door was a bit of a mystery to me also. If you really want to open the window while having the door open, open and lock the door into place first, then roll the power window down. Once I figured out that you have to close the window before you can open the door to let the children out, I always ensure that the window is closed. It seems to be a great reminder for me to not leave the windows open while leaving the van. You know, for security, rain, or those silly cats that like to jump in when nobody is around.
We want these devices to make our lives easier and more comfortable but we refuse to accept any of the risks they create. So, over stressed designers, engineers, and programmers try to think of every single idiotic misuse we or our duplicitous children might try so that they can compete while avoiding the financial ruin that a class action lawsuit (or even one particularly gruesome case) might bring.
It seems like some other world (and, in fact, it was) when I think of the days of our family of 6 careening down the road in an over packed boat of an early sixties station wagon while the only-recently-available lap belts lay dirty and unused under the seats. What freedom we felt in our blissful ignorance! Those were the days (but not so great for the much, much, much higher percentage of folks who constituted the highway death toll!)....
My problem is that it is not happening all the time, so I can not easily reproduce it to the dealer. But I know it is a problem for sure and it is so annoying. I haven never driven a Toyota car like this before.
The other issue is the whistling noise when I start the engine in the morning, open the hood, couldn't hear anything, but the noise can be heard behind the front tires and underneath and inside the car the noise is obvious. The same case when I am driving, the whistling noise is worse. I went to dealer twice, the technician said that it is normal and there is nothing he can do. This is so frustruting, I had to turn on the radio to try to avoid the noise while I am driving. I chose Toyota for its smoothness/quietness, but now I am not getting what I expected. Is there anything I can do?
cannuck13, I noticed that you are from Canada as well, which City are you living in and which dealer did you deal with? I am living in Toronto, Toyota on Front is my dealer.
Thank.
Regarding the whistling noise, I hope it will go away after some time.
Some people expressed their frustrations with the dealers. I think the only way to reduce this type of problem is to have Toyota improve its initial quality. It is not realistic to expect a dealership to provide quality fix. Shame on those so called specialists! I have to believe they are nothing special except the title after I repeatedly go back to the dealers to fix the same problems. My observation doesn't base on Toytoa alone but the other brands I had as well.
After enough lessons, I concluded something wise men have concluded a long time ago. Avoid first year model! In addition, never buy a car without test driving it and thoroughly examining it. Even a brand/model is praised by all others, the one you ordered can be very different. The reason is simple, minor deviation is acceptable in any engineering. Another words, engineers have long realized the fact that it is humanly impossible to make a perfect item. Therefore, you may get a car at 99.999% close to the design specification or at 99% close. This small difference is enough to translate to a big quality difference among owners.
I am planning to buy a 2005 or 2006 Sienna if Honda's new design could not impress me. Nissan is out of my consideration since I really could not appraciate Nissan's durability although it is far better than a lot of other brands.
This is my 2cents. Good luck with the issues you are experiencing!
I'm just gratefull that the dealers have all fessed up and repaired the problems.
Bev
For the Don Valley North Lexus Toyota dealer you went to, I have been there several years ago to rent some Toyota cars from them, very good service. Is it possible or allowed to go to different dealer instead of the one I purchased vehicle from when I have some issues with the car?
Anyway I will try to go there this weekend.
Thanks again.
Though with the minor issues of the first year production for Sienna 2004, I still love it and hope that it will be a great car once the minor issues are solved.
Anybody has idea what went wrong? Maybe my case is not even as serious as canuck13's. I will keep watching it and find out what I can do. By the way, I sent compaint letter to my dealer, hopefully they can do something about it.
I am not driving a lot, every year I drive maximum of 10,000 KM, so I might not be able to see the situation getting worse.
I went through this with several VW dealers and learned my lesson.
Bad dealers are hurting the automobile industry.
I agree with liujn and am planning to wait for the 2005 model. There are still three reasons I see to wait: to let the Toyota engineers iron out any remaining bugs in the first-year redesign, make further improvements, and to let production rise so that hopefully prices drop.
Remember the first-year Tundra a couple of years ago? Again, a great vehicle but if I remember correctly Toyota had to recall it for a vibration problem that was cracking some frames. I believe they had to add 6 lbs of metal to counteract the vibration.
A couple of months ago I actually went to the Credit Union auto buying service here in Albuquerque, with down payment in hand, intending to order a 2004 Sienna (XLE LTD with HO pkg: DVD and NAV system). However, the best deal they could get was only $500 off MSRP (from Right Toyota in Arizona) and they recommended waiting a few months for production to rise and cost to drop.
I have written a couple of books before and have seen how each draft (or edition) is better than the last, but still has a few errors, and I think car models are similar in this respect. I just hope my old '90 Camry, which has been a great car, makes it another (15th) year.
My question concerns a black mark that appears to have been rubbed on by something or someone in passing. I had Toyota look at it and asked if they would see if they could remove it. They couldn't and told me to take it to a body shop. When they did attempt to remove the mark, it looks like they also removed the glossy finish with it. Can anyone suggest a compound or polish to remove the mark and return the glossy finish?
The mark looks like someone was riding their bike and the black rubber handle grip left this mark, but I'm not sure really what it is. Any suggestions? Thanks!
Some minor issues that I'm not sure are really issues but I thought I'd post them in any case.
1) Be VERY careful with the rear hatch. On closing the tailgate last week using the taillamp as leverage point, a start crack appeared in the middle. I hope that this will be considered under the warrantee when I take it in for the first oil change at 3K.
2) Maybe it's me, but the transmission seems to have a hard time finding the right gear. I have to be very careful if trying to make a quick maneuver on the freeway. The two times I've tried to do so, the lowest gear is selected and the whole van lurches forward. This problem is not too bad for us since most of our driving is local. I've noted the other messages here about tranny slippage but I've not noticed any outward noises or anything that would lead me to believe that is happening here.
3) Our paint seems to chip and scratch very easily. In one case our toddler ran a plastic handle on his trike across the rear quarter panel and put a decent scratch in the clear coat. We have found at least two chips to the bare metal. TG, our touchup paint was available since it was initially put on the 03 Highlander (Salsa Red).
4) Our gas tank was replaced under the recall within about three weeks.
We'll keep you posted.
Chicagoburbs (Wheaton, IL)
All cars now seem to have paint that chips/scratches easily. My previous Mercedes Benz and Lexus cars both had the same paint issues. I think the major cause is the use of water based paints in the last ten years (oil based is not used anymore due to environmental concerns.)
Our Sienna does not take curves or corner well at all. In addition, it does not drive well in windy conditions.
I will not replace our 2004 Sienna with another Toyota..........................................
1): the clock is faster 1 minute in every week.
2): the sound of left power sliding door is not so quiet as when it is new though it works fine. Does anyone know how to lubricate or clean the power sliding track?
Dako-tien, we all don't drive like that in Chicago, many of us are much worse!
With the climate control system in heating mode (determined by being in automatic outlet airflow mode and the system having selected footwell airflow outlets, manual over-ride to other outlets does NOT change the system from heating mode) the upper passenger compartment system airflow will ALWAYS be as much as 20F cooler than footwell airflow.
If the system setpoint is say, 72F, and the passenger cabin has reached the approximate setpoint the airflow from the upper outlets will be as much as 20F BELOW 72F.
The confusion may be caused due to the fact that while the cabin temperature is being raised to the set comfort level the airflow from all outlets will be reasonably warm.
The NipponDenso engineers haven't yet learned that human body comfort is heavily influenced by radiant cooling from the wintertime surrounding landscape and that cooling airflow to the body in this circumstance can be extremely discomforting.
Even on a COLD and quite thoroughly fogging over interior windshield surface.
see:
http://www.globaldenso.com/TECHNOLOGY/tec-report/2001/html_versio- - n/20.html