Certified Pre-Owned Cars: A Reality Check

Edmunds.com

Certified pre-owned (CPO) cars are popular with buyers who want to minimize the risk of buying a used car. They also can typically get more car for their money with a CPO vehicle than they can with a new car.

To be a CPO car, a vehicle needs to meet specific age and mileage requirements. It then must go through a thorough inspection at the dealership. If a car passes, it gets an extended limited warranty and will carry a higher price than a non-CPO model. Many people feel comfortable in paying that premium, though, because of the peace of mind a CPO program gives them.

Read the full story here

danish170

The certified pre owned cars facility is really very good and very much helpful for the normal people that they can afford more CPO cars with their existing money rather than new car. So, it is really going to be a favor for the new people. Here, I want to share some of my experience regarding cars like after having a car we have to maintain our cer else we have to face large number of problems. So, we have to maintain our cars like, we have to service it after particular kilometers of run and also we have to repair our cars from good repair centers whenever required to get better performance from it and for our cars smoother running. I have given below a link for good repair center. .

cobraj007

I would never buy a CPO car again. The checklist is great but if the item fails don't expect the integrity of the dealership (Joe Myers Ford) to adhere to the requirements.

I'm still working with Ford but even after opening a case I'm told Ford can not enforce the dealership to do the right thing.

rch1945

In 2010 I purchased a Toyota Certified Used Car from Jim Bishop Toyota in Tuscumbia, AL. Everything has been great until I tried to trade the vehicle today and found out it had been wrecked in 2008. The Toyota Certified Used Car information states that 1 of the 160 point inspection is a CarFax history. I was never give the CarFax and stupidly assumed that if it had been wrecked Toyota would have to advise you. Wrong again! I know there is probably nothing going to be done by Toyota and certainly not by the dealership but would like your suggestion as to who would be best to contact about this situation. Thank you.

grlfirefighter

After going to 3 different non-lexus dealer only to find the cars they were selling had in fact been wrecked, I decided I was going only to purchase CPO vehicle from an actual Lexus dealer. I purchased my CPO LS460 from Woodfield Lexus in Chicago. I flew up from Orlando, they picked me up at the airport, all was nice and well. There was a major chip in the paint in the front, I asked the salesman who explained they could not repair it, because in doing so they would not have been able to certify the vehicle. Ok. At least I figured they were honest. I drove my car home happy. However, when I took it in to a body shop to inquire about getting the chip fixed, I was told the reason it was chipped, was that the front end had been damaged and "bondo" had been used to repair it so the paint was not adhering to the bondo. The body shop actually said it would have been an easy fix. The plastic on the front bumper was the only thing damaged, and could have easily been replaced. Still $1800.00 for a car I had owned for 3 weeks!! So I did some research. Clean carfax.....However, when I found that the car had actually originally been sold on lease at Miami Lexus I was able to find the entire dealer history. Which included repair of front end, right there in the vehicle history. The work was actually done by Miami Lexus. I took it to my local dealer to have them repair it, since the "bondo" job was done by an actual Lexus dealer, I figured the work must be warrantied. Only to find out all Lexus dealers are individually owned and are not in any way obligated to repair anything, even if it is under warranty. Lexus of Orlando, where I live told me I needed contact Woodfield Lexus in Chicago where I bought it. I called them, they told me I needed to contact Lexus of Miami who had done the work. I called them, they told me I needed to take it to the dealer nearest where I live and have it serviced. Needless to say...CPO means nothing and no one will take the extra step and assume responsibility! In my eyes...Lexus is Lexus, I don't know who owns each dealer and I don't care. A company is a company and it's their product and whatever was done, by any one of their dealerships is the companies responsibility, they can sort out the money amongst themselves. Not in this "NO CAN DO" society! Customer service and loyalty no longer exist!

edmundshoya

Interesting. Curious how the carfax was clean but then you found additional repair history. How did you obtain that additional info? Thanks!

stever

At first glance, it sounds like the Miami dealer did the work "off the books" so that there wouldn't be any reason to report the damage to Carfax or AutoCheck. Whether that was intentional or not is another question....

Have you opened up a case with Lexus corporate and asked for an investigation and explanation?

ae1606

Warning to consumers: BMW has thrown in the towel on their vehicles as credible long-term products. Go to this link from their website http://www.bmwusa.com/Standard/Content/CPO/Warranty.aspx , look about half way down to "See what is not covered for CPO vehicles retailed on or after 1/1/2014". The "not covered" list includes things like door locks, sunroof, electronics, bushings, struts, tie-rods, headlights, door handles, water leaks (not a joke), mounts (as in transmission and engine mounts, not a joke), light bulbs, interior dashboards (not a joke) and on and on. If your dash-board goes dark and it's not covered, what's the point behind "CPO" again? Seems kind of important. What's worse, BMW used to sell policies for $1,500-$3,000 allowing you to upgrade their CPO "warranty" effectively to bumper-to-bumper coverage. They no longer do this. Some dealers try and get around it by working with third party insurers but the prices are staggering and that's because these are PRECISELY the things that often fail on BMWs inside 60k-70k miles. I've owned 5 BMWs, have LOVED driving them, love the cars but have had chronic quality problems with all but one of them. Wonderful cars to drive but the changes to the CPO warranty and the lack of supplemental policies seems to be a clear flag that declining BMW quality makes these vehicles more toys for enjoyment rather than also being reliable vehicles for transportation.

carperso

There is a 2014 kia optima with less than 10k miles at a local audi dealership. It is used however not certified. I asked the sales guy why it wasnt certified, and he told me that the car can only be certified by a kia dealership. The group that owns the audi dealership also owns a kia dealership across the road. The car is listed under blue book value. I was wondering why they couldnt transfer it to the kia dealership and certify it and sell it for more. I checked out the car and didnt find anything too wrong with. But then i am not a pro at these things. Also the car used to be owned by the sales manager at the groups VW dealership who traded that in for a new audi. Carfax seems clean. Is the sales guy telling the truth that they cannot transfer the car back to the kia and certify it?

william3481

Carfax is not accurate alone, it gets information at different timess. You have to use the other ones as well

william3481

I'm in a situation where I might be able to get a pre-owned car from a Kia dealership but the problem is I don't want a pre-owned KIA. Is there anyway I can get a pre-owned car that isn't certified by said dealer and get it certified elsewhere. Carfax costs too much for not giving enough information.

I don't have a choice. I mean it's better than getting a used car from a non-new car dealership.

carboy21

CPO is better then Carmax and other used car dealers who buy cars from an auction. Atleast the CPO is usually a leased return vehicle with known service records from the same dealer.

hondalover1979

Hello there. Love your website. Question for you. I'm wanting to buy a Honda 16 civic sedan with 1,500 miles, , that is "autonation certified" rather than honda certified. I was worried about this from the geto go, and the dealer said its only for 2 months of coverage, as compared to the EXTRA YEAR on the honda cert warrant. So my question to you is
1. would you buy it without the honda cert warranty with only 1,500 miles?
2. They are saying I have to buy that official HONDA certification.
3. Is this them just trying to find ways to make more off the deal???
4. Is it reasonable for me to demand they pay for it??
5. Does the honda certification add value?

HELP!!!
No negotiations have happend yet, only submitted my credit app. THanks.
Chris in Jax, Florida
[Email removed]

hondalover1979

PS it is an AUTONATION HONDA DEALER

stever

I wouldn't buy a non-manufacturer warranty.

If AutoNation is giving it to you for "free", then that's okay. But the price is probably buried in there somewhere. You can check that by using our What's My Car Worth tool.

Another option is to wait until you are close to the expiration of the factory warranty and then think about buying a Honda Care® extended warranty.

hondalover1979

thank you I appreciate it a lot

arachnyd

grlfirefighter - Unfortunately, "Lexus is Lexus, I don't know who owns each dealer and I don't care. A company is a company " is incredibly flawed. That would be like saying you got a hamburger at McDonalds and return it to Burger King because a "Hamburger is a Hamburger". Two lexus stores are totally different companies. Each one buys lexus' to resell them to people like you, but they have no connection to eachother. a "Lexus" car is a product, like a hamburger, but the dealership is its own company unrelated to Lexus.

This is why I only buy from good dealers I trust and would never farm around for the "best price" between different states. That way even a "new car" warranty works is that the dealership does the work and then calls up the company that made the car and said "Can you reimburse me for this repair since it was a problem with what you built"?

Buyers need to be aware that a "A company" is not "a company", when its not the actual company that you are dealing with. When you go to a Lexus dealership, that is not "Lexus" you are dealing with, its an independent company selling Lexus products, just like Home Depot selling Whirlpool washers. That doesn't mean Home Depot IS Whirlpool.

I hope you learned from your experience and others can as well, that a used car is a used car no matter where you buy it from. A "Brand" does not have bearing on the dealership or the treating of a used car, and thats why you need to trust the dealership selling to you. If you can't trust the dealership, you shouldn't buy it.

Michaell

arachnyd said:

grlfirefighter - Unfortunately, "Lexus is Lexus, I don't know who owns each dealer and I don't care. A company is a company " is incredibly flawed. That would be like saying you got a hamburger at McDonalds and return it to Burger King because a "Hamburger is a Hamburger". Two lexus stores are totally different companies. Each one buys lexus' to resell them to people like you, but they have no connection to eachother. a "Lexus" car is a product, like a hamburger, but the dealership is its own company unrelated to Lexus.

This is why I only buy from good dealers I trust and would never farm around for the "best price" between different states. That way even a "new car" warranty works is that the dealership does the work and then calls up the company that made the car and said "Can you reimburse me for this repair since it was a problem with what you built"?

Buyers need to be aware that a "A company" is not "a company", when its not the actual company that you are dealing with. When you go to a Lexus dealership, that is not "Lexus" you are dealing with, its an independent company selling Lexus products, just like Home Depot selling Whirlpool washers. That doesn't mean Home Depot IS Whirlpool.

I hope you learned from your experience and others can as well, that a used car is a used car no matter where you buy it from. A "Brand" does not have bearing on the dealership or the treating of a used car, and thats why you need to trust the dealership selling to you. If you can't trust the dealership, you shouldn't buy it.

You do realize that you're responding to a post that's almost two years old?

stever

And unlike Home Depot that has 1,000s of brands, Lexus only offers CPO cars through their franchised dealer network. A lot of dealers just pay lip service to the checklist though and when something is overlooked or ignored, the issue should be escalated to Lexus so they can get the problem fixed and the offending dealer retrained. The customer should be able to get satisfaction from any Lexus dealer when that happens. Otherwise, why even bother buying a car backed by manufacturer's CPO program?

kelprod1

I bought a Certified Audi A5 back in March of 2013. I am now looking to trade the car in on a new Audi S5, however, the dealer is telling me my A5 has a low trade in value because....the car, according to Carfax (which I confirmed) was in an accident before I bought it. Audi presented and sold me a car as Certified and now is saying that it is not worth going trade in value because it was in an accident before they presented and sold the car to me as Certified! Ridiculous. A clean Carfax is a part of the Certification process....but apparently that is total BS. Word of caution...do not believe any of this Certified nonsense from car manufacturers and ABSOLUTELY do not be fooled by the Audi Certified program. I bought an Audi product based on the integrity of their Certified program...and learned the hard way that their program is crooked (even when trying to upgrade to a new Audi product!!). Beware!

stever

Best contact Audi customer service and complain since you didn't get what you paid for.

brian125

Back in the day a car like this was stripped down and never found.

tomm444

I bought a CPO -RDX Acura from an Acura dealer in the past 30 days. I have two questions which I hope you can help me with. 1). After purchasing the car, I read where there is a takata air bag recall on it. It states ' incomplete ' on Acura's site and on any site I check. I called the dealership and Acura and they both told me the recall was completed. HOWEVER, they said they can not change the status on the Vin# to show ' completed ' !?? It has been 3 weeks now and it still shows ' incomplete ' . I asked both the dealership and Acura if they will send me a letter stating that it was done and both said they could not send me a letter. They expect me to just believe them I guess. How poor is that. Stressed out here. What should I do? Who can help me? I am scared to drive the car ... .... 2). As for the CPO 12 months/ 12k mile extended warranty. Does that take affect from the day I bought it OR does the additional 12/12 start from the date when the car was first sold/ dated, which was 8/2014 and I was told it was a lease car. .... I bought the car with 30K miles just a month ago on 4/29/2017. Please advise. Thank you very much.

tomm444

ALSO ^^^^... I was never given a CarFax report from the Dealership when I bought my RDX either. I thought Acura CPO purchases should include one. Would that not have had my recall info on it. They said the recall was done/ completed on 4/13/2017. ... Again I bought the car on 4/29/2017. It is now 5/22/2017, and I have no answers / or conclusion to this ordeal. ..... Please advise. AGAIN, Thanks

tomm444

The RDX I bought was a 2015 tech ... ^^^^ ( sorry, I forgot to give you the year I bought )

Mr_Shiftright

Well they must be getting that completion date from somewhere--so maybe go visit the dealer and ask to at least look at what document or computer screen they are getting their info from. It's plausible they haven't corrected the records yet, but whoever told you 4/13 must have the info in front of them. Tell them you just want some peace of mind here.

ridgevillegu1

I purchased a Certified Pre-Owned 2015 Z4 on June 12,2017. The dealer assured me the CPO cars go through a rigorous vehicle inspection. Today June 24th,2017 I discovered the engine air filter was FILTHY and the filter compartment loaded with debris. A blind technician could never pass this car for inspection. Did they really inspect anything? I contacted BMW corporate and they basically said they won't do anything; according to BMW website all CPO cars are thoroughly and rigorously inspected. Very unhappy with BMW . No wonder people don't trust car dealers.
Be careful when buying a CPO car.

nogmcertified

Buyer beware, according to GM, it is normal for the door panels on their cars to come off with less than 35K miles to the tune of $500 (Maybe I should feel lucky it’s a two door so only one more to fall off!). This was after taking it as far as 'they' would let me to the Customer Careless manager who although he initially agreed with me then said even though I did not cause the problem it was not a defect for my 2014 Camaro door panel to start falling off so it was wear and tear (the only exclusion that would get them out of this). GM should be ashamed calling this 'normal'!

brian125

nogmcertified said:

Buyer beware, according to GM, it is normal for the door panels on their cars to come off with less than 35K miles to the tune of $500 (Maybe I should feel lucky it’s a two door so only one more to fall off!). This was after taking it as far as 'they' would let me to the Customer Careless manager who although he initially agreed with me then said even though I did not cause the problem it was not a defect for my 2014 Camaro door panel to start falling off so it was wear and tear (the only exclusion that would get them out of this). GM should be ashamed calling this 'normal'!

American cars have gotten so much better these past 10 years but I noticed a lot GM models especially lower end still have cheap materials and parts inside the cabin.

You know the old saying .............you get what u pay for

jark

Found a Nissan 370Z that has 1100 miles on it. Story is, somebody bought it and returned it a month later cause he wanted an automatic. Car is pristine. But it is being sold as used without a certified warranty. Is this a red flag? I know these cars are driven hard and that’s what I’m concerned for. But if i asked them to certify the car, will that void the existing new car warranty on it? Thanks.

Michaell

jark said:

Found a Nissan 370Z that has 1100 miles on it. Story is, somebody bought it and returned it a month later cause he wanted an automatic. Car is pristine. But it is being sold as used without a certified warranty. Is this a red flag? I know these cars are driven hard and that’s what I’m concerned for. But if i asked them to certify the car, will that void the existing new car warranty on it? Thanks.

If it's been registered, it can only be sold as a used car. Not sure if the new car warranty can be transferred.

I, too, would be concerned that it's not being offered as CPO, with only 1100 miles on it.

Mr_Shiftright

If you have a VIN, post it

tylercarnahan

Mr_Shiftright said:

If you have a VIN, post it

I have many VINs all with full carfax at your disposal and links to them at my dealership in Ohio.

Jeep_Joe_OBX1

I find it interesting how dealerships and manufacturers try to justify the "Certified Pre Owned" designation on "USED CARS! They are used, not almost new. There is no such thing. I have been in the retail automotive sales business for 35 years. Over 25 years ago manufacturers finally found a way to make money on previously owned, i.e., used cars and trucks. They came up with the CPO designation and then marketed the heck out of it.

The operative words here are that they "marketed the heck out of it". They spent money advertising a false sense of security to consumers by making vehicles sound "like new" when there is no such thing. A used car is a used car is a used car, plain and simple. Then they implemented glorified used car checks, that should be done on any used vehicle being retailed on franchise dealership lots anyway. They charge the dealerships for the CPO designations.

Read that again. The manufacturers charge new car franchises to sell their CPO designation. The dealerships in turn charges consumers more, all for a false sense of security. It's all mirrors and smoke, smoke and mirrors.

That's how manufacturers began making money on used cars, Crazy! Does any of this make sense to you if you are paying $2,000 more and well up from that on CPO vehicles?

Just asking..........

Jeep Joe

Mocha

I'm looking at Lincoln Navigators 2018-19 models with 25 to 30 thousand miles. The factory warranty is good until 50 thousand miles
so would it make sense to purchase a CPO unit or just purchase a extended warranty after the warranty expires? I understand the
Lincoln CPO warranty covers 6 years or 100,000 miles with a 100 dollar deductible but the 6 years starts from when the car was first purchased.

kyfdx

Mocha said:

I'm looking at Lincoln Navigators 2018-19 models with 25 to 30 thousand miles. The factory warranty is good until 50 thousand miles
so would it make sense to purchase a CPO unit or just purchase a extended warranty after the warranty expires? I understand the
Lincoln CPO warranty covers 6 years or 100,000 miles with a 100 dollar deductible but the 6 years starts from when the car was first purchased.

I would shop for an extended warranty, and see what you find, and the cost. If you are looking for six more years warranty from when you buy it, that might be hard to find, and very expensive. You may find it more cost effective to pay up for a CPO model.