Subaru Crew Cafe

1164165167169170343

Comments

  • lark6lark6 Member Posts: 2,565
    ...I don't know where you are (vacation?) or what news you'll get first on your return - here at Edmunds or somewhere else - but I just saw this news article and thought of you.

    http://story.news.yahoo.com/news?tmpl=story&u=/ap/20040801/ap- - _on_re_us/terror_threat

    Be safe when you return to work. Hosts/moderators: please delete if you feel this is inappropriate.

    Thank you,
    Ed
  • rshollandrsholland Member Posts: 19,788
    Yes, be safe my friend.

    Bob
  • kenskens Member Posts: 5,869
    Yes, I heard about the potential areas of concern and I immediately thought of juice.

    I wonder what the mood at work must be like.

    Ken
  • njswamplandsnjswamplands Member Posts: 1,760
    i am sure nothing is being done and just lots of talk over the walls...
  • kenskens Member Posts: 5,869
    My brother in-law recently purchased a bare-bones Magnum STX and I had a chance to check it out this past weekend.

    He needed a work vehicle and ordered one with basically no options other than the Bluetooth phone hook up. From the outside, the Magnum looks fairly distinctive with it's very slim side windows. As expected, the slim windows make it seem a bit dark inside.

    The interior fit and finish wasn't anything to write home about. The plastics and fabrics were fairly plain -- not offensive, but definitely not memorable. The chrome shift gate pattern looked a bit flimsy. Apparently it's the same one used in the 300C.

    The seats were comfy and wide but had very little side support. The rear cargo area was wide, but relatively shallow due to the lower roofline of this vehicle.

    The 3.5L V6 made a typical Dode truck-like roar, but pick up was fairly leisurely. Again, this was a bare-bones STX and it came with just the 4-speed auto. Perhaps the optional 5-speed would do better.

    The steering felt overly boosted and had little road feel. Body lean was relatively controlled considering the size and soft suspension settings. The brakes took quite a bit of effort to engage and pedal modulation was difficult. Overall, I wasn't very impressed with the driving experience.

    Things that I did like:
    - Optional Bluetooth handsfree cellphone integration. Very cool feature that will automatically lower stereo volume, announce a call and let you speak using the built in mike.
    - Adjustable pedals -- great for small drivers.
    - Highway milage of 30mpg. Impressive for a vehicle of this size.

    Ken
  • locke2clocke2c Member Posts: 5,038
    it's not the same shift gate as used in the 300C. they have a nice gate and it's a 5 speed automatic.

    it could be the same as a 300 Touring though. I haven't been in one of those.

    ~c
  • bigelmbigelm Member Posts: 995
    is a world of a difference.

    You're brother's bare bones Magnum SXT is kinda like the 3.5 V6 300 (Touring) NOT C.
    Even the seats are slightly different...
  • rshollandrsholland Member Posts: 19,788
    http://www.media.subaru.com./

    Legacy and Outback up, everything else down.

    Bob
  • kenskens Member Posts: 5,869
    I've only sat inside a 300C but yeah, the two looked quite different. Anyway, I was a bit underwhelmed by the STX.

    Ken
  • njswamplandsnjswamplands Member Posts: 1,760
    what is SoA doing wrong? they got cars that rock and the sales numbers are down.
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    I'm back, and yes they checked my ID 3 times coming in each day this week. Yesterday they did a (random) search under my Miata and in my trunk, too. You see and feel the extra security presence.

    I drove the Forester on Monday and didn't get searched so perhaps that looks less suspicious? ;-)

    mike: go for it, I'm sure you'll use every inch of space and every lb-ft of torque to tow. You may be the poster boy for real truck needs. Plus, GM's engines are actually more efficient than similar Dodges or Fords.

    Bob: saw that lazy Susan thing on the Ody. It has run-flats (Michelin PAX) so that occupies the space vacated by the lack of any spare tire. Are the PAX equipped cars out there now working well with that system? I'd be concerned about ride quality and unsprung weight.

    At least it's not the first generation of that technology, it's been out for years now.

    The production RL indeed doesn't look quite as nice as the concept I got excited about, but it's still a huge improvement.

    I see a tiny bit of that Bangle Butt you mentioned, but it's so subtle, and reminds me more of the Hyundai XG350 than the BMW 7.

    What's funny is that the nose reminds me of Colin's EVO. The headlights, at least.

    -juice
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    Sto-and-go seats I sampled in Detroit didn't seem too bad, but people are complaining about long-range comfort. I only tried it for a few seconds.

    The GM vans I've rented weren't much more comfy in the 2nd row, but I'm sure the captain's chairs in the Ody or Sienna are. The Venture's seats are too low for me.

    Bob - thanks for that chopped Cayenne. I'm sending you the bill for the new keyboard, since that made me barf all over it. The picture actually looks like a Magnum rear ended a 911. It sort of makes you...sad.

    M-B going turbo, eh? I wonder why. I bet it's gas mileage. Off boost, you get much better EPA mileage numbers with a turbo. I bet they cut their CAFE fines in half.

    -juice
  • locke2clocke2c Member Posts: 5,038
    actually numerous Mazdas have headlights like the Evo (or vice versa), especially the Mazda 6.

    the reasons for M-B going turbo were articulated pretty well in the article. efficiency is one, and modern turbos' ability to spool quickly is another. the latter defeats erodes any advantage a supercharger would have.

    ~c
  • mimasmimas Member Posts: 6
    any suggestions on buying an economy car? can't afford another subaru. wife has short listed corolla and civic because of safety and milage estimates. our budget is 15000+taxes and not a penny more (says so the wife).
  • cusafrcusafr Member Posts: 184
    What is the safety and milage problems with the civic? Milage estimates for the civic are something like 32/37. Safety issues?

    cusafr
  • rshollandrsholland Member Posts: 19,788
    Next-generation Avalanche is much more tasteful in styling!

    http://www.autospies.com/article/index.asp?articleId=3194&cat- egoryId=12

    Same with the next Tahoe. Both are MUCH better looking vehicles!

    http://www.autospies.com/article/index.asp?articleId=3193

    Bob
  • rshollandrsholland Member Posts: 19,788
    http://www.autospies.com/article/index.asp?articleId=3204

    It will offer optional 8-passenger seating.

    Bob
  • locke2clocke2c Member Posts: 5,038
    no, he said she 'short-listed' the Civic and Corolla due to safety and fuel economy. that means they are on the final cut, or in high consideration.

    besides those two I'd look at the Mazda 3. unfortunately in the case of all three, $15,000+ttl is likely only enough to get base models. I wouldn't suggestion optioning them to the moon, but I just don't know what you'll be able to do... maybe a year-end special?

    I'd consider used an low mileage. the Mazda 3 especially, it probably depreciates faster than the Civic or Corolla.

    ~c
  • cusafrcusafr Member Posts: 184
    Sorry, read it wrong.

    You should be able to buy a new (2004) civic for that price. I just bought a new civic-ex-5-speed for 16,000, so the LX should be in reach. For sure the VP, but for just that little bit more, the EX...

    cusafr
  • locke2clocke2c Member Posts: 5,038
    interesting that they had all those numbers yet nothing firm at all on what the Legacy launch cost.

    I'm curious, because I didn't think the Legacy launch was all that successful. I'd particularly wonder how much the Legacy launch cost compared to the 2005 Outback launch (or if that's one and the same), the 2004 STi launch and the 2002 WRX launch.

    ~c
  • rshollandrsholland Member Posts: 19,788
    is that the Legacy and Outback are one and the same. I also think that when they say "launch," it involves everything that would be involved from engineering, converting the factories, etc., and not just the marketing aspect.

    Bob
  • locke2clocke2c Member Posts: 5,038
    aha. good point, Bob. I bet retooling Indiana for the 2005 Legacy/Outback was fairly expensive.

    ~c
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    Next Avalanche looks like a Trooper nose on a current Sierra. Rear doors look small on that Tahoe. But they look evolutionary and a bit better, especially the Avalanche.

    That Ody link takes you to the JDM model which is different, so I'm not sure I'd trust that source.

    OK, under $15k is slim pickings, if you stretch a little Fitzmall.com has an RS sedan 5 speed for $15,949.

    Below your limit, here is what I found:

    Accord DX manual, $14,320
    Civic VP auto, $13,175
    Civic VP auto w/SAB, $13,403
    Mazda 3i manual, $14,490
    Nissan Sentra, $13,399
    Toyota Corolla LE 5 speed, $13,940
    Corolla LE auto, $14,405
    Matrix, $14,722
    Scion xB manual, $13,856
    Scion xB auto, $14,656
    Scion xA auto, $13,426

    Honda prices are from brownscar.com, the rest are fitzmalll.com. I listed the cheapest car, so ones with more options would cost more, obviously.

    I also threw in some wagons and hatchbacks because they're more practical and still fall within your price range.

    You didn't specify if you want auto or manual, though.

    -juice
  • ladywclassladywclass Member Posts: 1,713
    we keep seeing more and more of the B's here on the road ... they must be popular at least in this neck of the woods ...
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    It's all about their price. I cut them a lot of slack because $14k for a roomy wagon with stability control is nearly giving them away.

    Just keep in mind you have to spend about $33 grand to get that from Subaru, to this day.

    -juice
  • volkovvolkov Member Posts: 1,306
    I think that you will be hard pressed to go wrong with either, or to find a definite better choice. Safe, consistently reliable, cheap to run and depreciate at a snail's pace. They were my 2 prime choices last time when I was looking for an economical commuter.
    You've done the research, now just drive them and let emotion make the choice from this point. One other little tidbit of advice - see if the dealers have any 2 year old versions lying around. Not to buy, but rather to give you an idea of how they wear, squeaks rattles etc. 2 of 3 used Hondas I tried had squeeky/rattly (?sp) seat belt latches, but their seats held shape better than the Corollas.

    Nicholas
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    Corolla and Sentra still use a torsion beam rear suspension that isn't fully indy. That would be their "catch", IMO.

    The Civic lost the double wishbone front suspension for this latest generation, but at least it's 4 wheel indy.

    The Mazda3 is my pick because it's new and shares a platform with a Volvo, so you get that trickle-down goodness from the luxury manufacturer's input. OTOH you might consider it a Ford product now.

    The Scions wins for space. But they too have the rear torsion beam, I believe.

    -juice
  • tincup47tincup47 Member Posts: 1,508
    Both the Volvo S40 and Mazda 3 are based on the Focus C platform. This is the European Focus platform that is not currently available in North America.
  • goneskiiangoneskiian Member Posts: 381
    I know Ken, Karen and Craig have been testing out some of the FM transmitters, but my wife came across an article in the NY Times from last week (Thursday, Aug. 5th to be exact) that listed a product from Dension. It's called the ice>Link:iPod: http://www.dension.com/main.php?pageid=50&topid=42

    It says it's compatible with Subaru factory stereos but I sent them an email anyway just to double check. I'll let you know what they say.

    Anyway, seems like a pretty seemless integration as it will keep the iPod charged and let you control it with the CD changer controls.

    Has anybody heard how well it works?

    Cheers!

    -Ian

    Edit: Just found another site with info on this product: http://www.densionusa.com/x/index.php?option=content&task=vie- - w&id=375&Itemid=79. It says that this system will work with any 2001+ Clarion OEM Subaru system. Of course it also mentions that it's not yet available. Maybe if we all put our email addresses on the wait list it will get them to speed things up. ;-)
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    I know, but Ford of Europe is still Ford. The current Focus is a great car dynamically but still suffers from iffy reliability and terrible resale value. Would the new one improve on those merits?

    I wonder if Mazda did massage that 2.3l enough to make it noticeably more reliable? What about the other stuff like the tranny, and other parts of the powertrain?

    Once bitten, twice shy, our experience with a 626 has me skeptical about Mazda. It didn't help that the new 6 has rust/staining problems and Mazda never really resolved that issue.

    -juice
  • kenskens Member Posts: 5,869
    Ian: I sent them an email expressing interest too. Hopefully they'll get enough to consider it worth their time to develop a Subaru specific solution.

    What would be fantastic is if the fourth (down) position on the stock head unit would be usable for an iPod.

    Ken
  • mimasmimas Member Posts: 6
    cusafr, volkov, locke2c - thanks for all your input.

    juice: Wife is particular about auto this time as she has a 50 mile daily commute. I am concerned about Mazda's reliability after warranty. Moreover, comparably equipped Mazda-3i costs well over $18,000. Scion mileage is just awful for a 105hp engine. I know it has to do with the shape. Matrix seems to be ok but when comparably equipped costs more than Corolla/Civic when comparably equipped and doesn't get as good mileage. I will look into Sentra numbers. We have to buy Civic EX to be able to get ABS which sucks. So wife is leaning towards Corolla.

    To be honest, I have only owned Subarus and it is hard to convince myself to shell out $$ on a non-subaru car now( :
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    Yeah, that 3i was a manual and probably stripped. They're still new, so I bet in a year prices drop by a grand at least.

    Civic VP doesn't have ABS? Man, Honda is pathetic on the low end of their models with safety content.

    Every Subie since MY2002 has had ABS standard, no excuses, every model, every price.

    Go for that RS, though. Get the Chase Subaru card and you'll even make it up slowly as you pay for service. $900 won't take much time, 2 years or less if you charge a lot.

    -juice
  • c_hunterc_hunter Member Posts: 4,487
    I like the iceLink a lot -- it's almost equivalent to what BMW is doing (and predates the BMW solution too). Last time I posted a link to the Dension website, Edmunds deleted it, so I hope you have better luck than me!

    CRaig
  • goneskiiangoneskiian Member Posts: 381
    Hmmm, wonder why they'd delete it. Did you get an explanation. I didn't see any forums.

    <scratches head in wonder>

    Oh well, the links are still there. We'll see.

    -Ian
  • c_hunterc_hunter Member Posts: 4,487
    Something about promoting third party products, which is odd, I thought we have done that before...

    I guess I'm not clear on the rules, I thought things had loosened up.

    Craig
  • hypovhypov Member Posts: 3,068
    Clarion?
    I believe the 6 CD headunit on my '03 WRX is a Panasonic :(

    -Dave
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    You gotta wonder if FHI's pressure on SoA to move upscale is gonna backfire.

    Already the 2005 Legacy is being sold for invoice or less. The more prominent upscale brands stay close to MSRP for a whole lot longer.

    One person said they paid $400 under invoice, which means dealers are already dipping into their holdback. That'll hurt residual values down the road.

    Saito was canned because he was "just" targeting Audi? That means FHI is aiming higher, at BMW and Mercedes I presume?

    Oh boy...

    -juice
  • rshollandrsholland Member Posts: 19,788
    while a big leap forward in many areas, is still IMO, not in BMW or the Audi league, at least not yet. The basics are right there with the Germans, but it needs more frosting (HIDs, NAV, etc.) to be truly compared with those German cars.

    I don't fault Subaru, as they are "easing" in to the premium market, and are not trying to make this move upmarket overnight, in one model year.

    Also&#151;and more important&#151;the public does not yet perceive Subaru in that "premium" light yet. Again, this will take several years to change.

    Bob
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    I guess what I'm saying is I'm not sure I want them to change.

    I don't want to own a luxury car.

    -juice
  • locke2clocke2c Member Posts: 5,038
    as long as they always offer a base model with cloth seats and no frills, and ideally a model with the biggest engine and yet still cloth seats and no frills, I don't see a problem at all with Subaru offering optional near-luxo gear.

    ~c
  • rshollandrsholland Member Posts: 19,788
    the Halifax/Tribeca will be a good indicator as to what Subaru has in mind, in terms of what they consider as being "premium." I'm very curious as to what the spread will be, both in terms of content and price, from the base model to the top model.

    Also, keep in mind that this crossover will most likely always be positioned above the Legacy, just as the Legacy will always be positioned over the Impreza.

    So if the crossover scares some of us because of costs, that doesn't necessarily translate into the same for existing Subaru models. Yeah, they will get more expensive too, but will not be nearly as affected with the upmarket push as the crossover is. Remember, Subaru still will have to court younger, less affluent customers, and bring them into their family.

    On a similar note, the Europeans are very interested in entering the premium small car market. I see them offering models that will compete with future Imprezas&#151;which will be more premium than they currently are, but not "so premium" as to scare off too many customers.
  • rshollandrsholland Member Posts: 19,788
    Here's how I see it, from top to bottom:
    ________________

    Halifax/Tribeca
    ________________

    Outback, Legacy
    ________________

    Forester, Baja
    ________________

    Impreza
    ________________

    Bob
  • goneskiiangoneskiian Member Posts: 381
    have listed above?

    I don't know that I've ever heard of the Subaru Bob.

    ;-) LOL!

    -Ian
  • rshollandrsholland Member Posts: 19,788
Sign In or Register to comment.

Your Privacy

By accessing this website, you acknowledge that Edmunds and its third party business partners may use cookies, pixels, and similar technologies to collect information about you and your interactions with the website as described in our Privacy Statement, and you agree that your use of the website is subject to our Visitor Agreement.