By accessing this website, you acknowledge that Edmunds and its third party business partners may use cookies, pixels, and similar technologies to collect information about you and your interactions with the website as described in our
Privacy Statement, and you agree that your use of the website is subject to our
Visitor Agreement.
Comments
Malibu Maxx plusses--
1. great engine and transmission. Some may [non-permissible content removed] about the low tech nature of ohv and four speed transmission. Don't believe them.
2. Wonderfully versatile.
3. Comfortable for long trips.
4. Did I mention the low tech engine? Well, great mileage/kilometerage and long oil change intervals are big plusses.
5. Lots of gadgets in base car. Good DIC, useful OLM.
Maxx minuses--
1. You get used to the steering, but a drive in a more responsive car (my other is a Kia Optima) reminds you of how vague it is.
2. Read all those steering suspension/complaints. I didn't enjoy paying $800 for a replacement steering column. Others have put many steering columns (and racks) in. That can get old fast.
4. I think the Maxx is much better looking than the 4 door, but it's still not a thing of beauty. The front clip, especially the pre-06's is ungainly.
5. Each year gets better. The 04's were the most troublesome.
6. Interior grows on you but seating surfaces are ugly (but durable).
On balance it's the best car I've had out of 30+. On the other hand, one more steering column or (god forbit) a rack and I'll have real second thoughts.
Browsing the warranty booklet, this seems like exactly the type of rust that is NOT covered by 99% of manufacturers.
I haven't yet taken it to my friendly local dealer to see what they say about it.
Any thoughts/suggestions? I'm not excited about the prospect of a several hundred dollar repair, but the prospect of a rusty rear end is equally unappealing.
This issue, and the mediocre fuel economy combined with $3.50/gallon gas, has got me thinking about selling our Maxx even though I like the car and it has been relatively trouble-free.
I was also looking at the Chevrolet Equinox, Tracker and Ford Escape.
as far as the rust repair.....I would take it to the local body shop vice a dealer...if it is our to warranty...doesnt hurt to ask the dealership first....doesnt sound too bad at this point.....I dont think you are alooking at a big repair...
Thanks again.
Because not everybody is doing as well as you in the fuel economy department.
Our 2004 started out great in terms of fuel economy, but I have grown tired of getting 24-25 mpg in mixed driving that includes probably 60% highway @ 73 mph. I don't know if the swings are caused primarily by winter blend fuel and colder temperatures here in Michigan. Maybe that is the case, because our last few tanks have been in the 28 mpg range -- although that was with 80% highway driving @ 73 mph or so.
Sure, the Maxx has a V6 but it doesn't have the power of the competitors' V6s. And there are plenty of fairly peppy 4-cylinder competitors out there that beat the pants off the Maxx in terms of fuel economy.
comparing V-6s to other competitors....power wise..perhaps.....but again...quite happy with the MPG and HP in the Maxx.....and yes.....the 4 cyl....MPG will of course be better...but the utility of the car suffers too....so we are comparing apples to oranges...
Does the steering clunking affect the mechanics of the car or is it merely a pain in the rear?
Thank you.
Either way, it seems doubtful that the dealer can fix this under my GM Major Gard extended warranty -- aren't paint and surface rust issues both non-covered once you go past something like 12 months / 12,000 miles? I need to get the car in to the dealer so they can tell me what they think.
Could well be. Aluminum has to be meticulously prepared to accept paint and if not done well water will lift paint film. Still, it is of some comfort realizing the defect is cosmetic rather than structural. I don't know what GM's policies are for these kind of things but do ask.
Left front strut
Steering gear
Both sway bar links
Right front strut
Both ball joints (loose)
The steering gear was replaced in Dec 06 and my car has travelled approx. 8000 Km (5200 miles) since then. So far the car is running fine ;no unusual noises...Dave
Tomorrow will be my first semi-long drive in the car. I'll be driving about 120 miles one way, so we'll see how it goes.
One thing I noticed about the '08s in general is that the standard Malibu will be built on the same 112-inch wheelbase currently used by the Maxx (and by the Saturn Aura, which we were also considering). Has the Maxx been doing well enough that they will keep it going forward?
at all.
And a shame because most reviewers praised the car, only giving the original model a few negative comments-later models were just fine.
What really suprised me was that the Forbes website actually gave the car a good review, something they pretty much never do for any car under 40k.
And to another comment above, I don't have an '07 but I do own an 06' Maxx SS and so far no problems with anything, it's a wonderful car. I also owned an 04' Maxx and the only problem I had with that was the bizarre noise when I accelerated.
As for whether to buy an Aura or Malibu... So far they look like virtual clones to me (aside from some /minor/ aesthetic changes). Get whichever you think looks better.