Subaru XT Turbo Forester

11920222425131

Comments

  • corkfishcorkfish Member Posts: 537
    I wonder if this will fit the XT. Wouldn't a larger scoop equate to a larger intercooler only easier to install and more warranty friendly? I also wonder if it would not only improve performance, but could it also help turbo longevity?

    http://www.kastleskorner.com/store/product_info.php?products_id=3- 4
  • lfdallfdal Member Posts: 679
    subkid - thanks for the reply - I'm not feeling so bad now about what I paid. The package they put on for me included the front bumper, the fenders (about to where a bra would cover), the hood, and the side mirrors. It also included the plastic areas around the lights, I think. I need to look again to be sure - wherever it totally covers, it really is hard to see. I'm not sure how thick it is, I wasn't educated enough to ask.

    I used Turtle Wax colored wax on my last Forester's bumper - it comes with a crayon and some dye laden wax. It works really good for filling in the chips. I covered it with plain carnuba wax after it dried and it looked great.

    Thanks again

    Larry
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    The XT's turbo is low boost, remember. The entire engine is majorly over-engineered, from the block to the pistons to the crank. I would not be that concerned, honestly.

    I would let her warm up before wringing it out, and also let it cool down, just drive slowly the last mile before your destination (probably a neighborhood anyway). You should do that with any engine, really.

    -juice
  • bsumpterbsumpter Member Posts: 35
    Just another comment on fuel mileage - I've had my XT 5 speed for a month, about 2,600 miles so far. My usual daily commute is about 70% highway/30% heavy stop & go traffic, been averaging 22 mpg so far. On mostly highway trips cruising at 75-80 mph I'm getting 26 mpg - all this is with a/c on btw. No complaints from me in this department at all!
  • stoner420stoner420 Member Posts: 165
    Like Juice said, probably not much in the way of extra performance, but it'd probably make the car look even more badass though ;-)

    deadeye: overall I would not worry about turbo longevity.. these things are well engineered, the XT uses the same turbo as the WRX but with even less boost pressure, so that would lead to an even longer life, as well as the cooling system is designed to prevent any oil cooking when you shut down the engine. I've not really heard of anyone's turbo going bad in WRX over the last couple of years, except when they start playing with manually increasing boost pressure, etc..
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    Brett: if you ever want to sell yours, I call dibs on it! :-)

    -juice
  • lfdallfdal Member Posts: 679
    I posted last week about the steering column in my new XT being indexed clockwise. Enough so the boost gauge 0 is pointing noticeably off of horizontal.

    Just called the service department and was told "tough luck charlie - that's the way it is"
    I suspect when I go to pick up the car in an hour or so things are going to get contentious.

    If Subaru wants to sticker a car out at over 29K and tell me that steering column is normal, they've got another thing coming.

    Will keep you all posted......

    Larry
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    Try to spot another one at the dealer and see if it's the same way.

    That should be covered under the standard adjustments you can request for 30 days or however long that period is.

    -juice
  • dcm61dcm61 Member Posts: 1,567
    Adjustment warranty was 12mo/12k but it's now 3yr/36k.

    Per http://www.cars101.com/subaru/forester/forester2004.html :

    Warranties-
    Bumper-to-bumper: 3 year/36,000 miles
    3year/36,000 Service Adjustment (adjustment performed one time)
    3yr/36000 miles roadside assistance (through Cross Country Motor Club, call 800 261-2155)
    3year/36,000 mile Wear Item Warranty covers keyless remote battery, brake pad/shoe linings, clutch disc lining, wiper blades
    Roadside assistance: 3 year/36,000 miles
    Powertrain: 5 year/ 60,000 miles
    Corrosion: 5 year/100,000 miles

    DaveM
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    OK, then it ought to be covered - IF they are normally aligned differently than yours. Accessories are covered if you buy then within the first year and a dealer installs them.

    Compare and let us know?

    -juice
  • lfdallfdal Member Posts: 679
    I looked at 3 other XT's on the lot tonight. They're all perfectly aligned. My XS I just traded was also perfect.

    The song and dance I'm getting is "There's nothing to adjust". It bolts together and that's that.

    I'll try to post some pictures tomorrow and let you folks decide. Its not terribly bad, and if the person that put on the boost cage had compensated by setting the gauge to counter the effect, I'd be more inclined to let it go. They also refused to remount the gauge.

    Tonight I had my wife sit behind the wheel of the car for the first time - she noticed it right off and said it looked ridiculous.

    My major gripe is that on a 12k Hyundai, I might tolerate it, but on a 29k Subaru, no way. If they want to compete at that level, they're going to have to learn what the competition is like it terms of fit and finish.

    And if it really is bolted together correctly - what's causing the misalignemt? Is the whole unibody off? Is the entire dash incorreclty mounted? That worries me as much as anything else.

    They've promised to call Subaru on Tuesday - I actually had the sales manager sit in the car and dared him to tell me that it was all right the way it was. He couldn't do it.

    Larry
  • samlatersamlater Member Posts: 12
    Just installed a trailer hitch myself. Ordered from 1stsubaruparts.com. Not difficult, but time consuming - 3 hours from start to finish including installing the harness and cleaning up afterwards.
    Looking for a bike rack. I think I'll settle on a Hollywood Road Runner HR310 - anyone have any experience with Hollywood bike racks?

    2004 2.5XT 5-sp Silver.... ;-)
  • p0926p0926 Member Posts: 4,423
    The higher the price of fuel goes, the less extra (in terms of percent) it costs to use premium gas ;-)

    -Frank P.
  • lfdallfdal Member Posts: 679
    I went the through the service manual for the 03 last night and this morning -there's a steering beam that runs from left pillar to right pillar, then there's where the column attaches to the beam.

    No adjusmentents other than trying to shim the mounting somehow. Guess I'm just blessed with one of those rare(?) Subaru miscues. With a 29k sticker on it. Deeeelightful.

    I couldn't get my imagestation link to work, but if anyone would like a picture, e-mail me and I'll be happy to send one.

    If anyone wants to comment about my whining, feel free.....

    Larry
  • njswamplandsnjswamplands Member Posts: 1,760
  • lfdallfdal Member Posts: 679
    Sorry 'bout the pix, it used to be possible to do that with imagestation. Like I said if anyone wants to see them, I'll be happy to e-mail them.

    Trying to be proactive about this mess, I dismantled my nice new 10 day old car today and ended up shimming the left hand side of the steering column where it mounts to the beam by 0.25 inch.

    A friend of mine who works on GM products says that GM actually makes an official shim that adjusts from about 1/8 inch to 3/8 inch. That would put my adjustment right in the middle.

    Why I've got the only Subaru in America that requires this is another matter.

    My plan is to get the dealer and SOA to bless the fix so that there's no warranty issues down the road.

    I also saw why they don't want to realign the boost gauge - there are two screws that go from inside the top of the shroud through a plate that attaches the boost gauge. All that would be required is to elongate the slots a bit and move the gauge down. BUT - clever fellows that they are, they didn't leave themselves enough slack under the dash to ever remove the shroud.

    So well see what SOA has to say on Tuesday.

    Larry
  • subearusubearu Member Posts: 3,613
    You can link Imagestation PREVIEW pics, just not the full image. When in your album, if you click on a picture, the url will have something ending in .orig.jpg. Just remove the .orig.jpg and the link can be used here. My profile has one such photo (the patio) that is linked from Imagestation.

    -Brian
  • jrobsonjrobson Member Posts: 10
    Thanx for the info Brett... finally someone else to corroborate my gas mileage findings of at least 22/26 MPG. .. thought I'd gotten some kind of mutant XT and was about to check my rear axle ratio to see if they'd made a mistake and dropped in a 4.11 or 3.94!!

    Now have 2800+ miles on my Silver mt-XT, and mileage is still improving... over 23 on last commuting tank. It's now getting better mileage than the 100hp, '87 Nissan Multi 4x4 that it replaced.

    Jim

    Jim
  • subearusubearu Member Posts: 3,613
    I was able to see 'em. Glad it's straightened out (pun intended). Not glad they miffed up the dash. Can you use a permanent marker or something to 'color' up the scuffs? At least it would blend in better.

    -Brian
  • njswamplandsnjswamplands Member Posts: 1,760
    1st fill was just under 15 mpg
    2nd fill was just about 18 mpg
    3rd fill was back down to about 14.5

    mostly rolling hill country type driving. some stop signs and lights. no a/c on last tank. driving with moderate acceleration ( no above 4k rpm ). no buried foot on accelerator. no hard stops.
  • ace1000ace1000 Member Posts: 151
    Car and Driver did a short take on the Baja Turbo in its October issue. In addition to saying that the engine "has also been fitted to the oddball Forester cube-ute," C/D said this about the automatic transmission:

    "The only faux pas in the powertrain's performance is the automatic transmission that is reluctant to downshift. And when it does finally shift - up or down - it doesn't do it smoothly. The automatic comes standard with a manual-shifting feature that allows you to get your gearchange whenever you please. But with only four gear ratios - necessarily widely spaced - it ain't that much fun to play with."

    Has this been the experience of the XT AT owners?
  • imyodaddyimyodaddy Member Posts: 20
    I picked up my silver XT yesterday from Subaru in Milford, NH. They were very good to deal with, and while my price wasn't the best (it was beat by another dealer, but that dealer killed their credibility with some shady dealing) I am happy with them.

    Going from a 2000 Golf to the XT I took particular care to note the headlights. Low beams are much better in the Golf. The pattern in the XT has dark areas, and it does not shine that far out. Good around town maybe, but not in the boonies. The high beams are much better in the XT. The give good range, but still with some dark areas. The foglights make the difference when using the low beams.

    I can't wait until it snows. I am jazzed.

    One thing else I have noted, that I doubt anyone else will. The smell of the new XT interior is close to the smell of one of my favorite Cuban (that's right, Cuban) cigars. I have found that to be intoxicating. I know that there is no way Subaru has planned that, but holy cow I love being in the car.

    If they had produced a car that smelled like Heidi Klum I would have bought that one also.
  • steverstever Guest Posts: 52,454
    New car smell is a bunch of nasty chemicals outgassing.

    I guess the Cuban comparison is pretty apt!

    Steve, Host
  • samlatersamlater Member Posts: 12
    3rd tank = 22.3 MPG
    Mixed driving, A/C on 100% of the time.
    Seems like the MPG is improving with each tank.
    Also, just reading the posts, looks like the M/T's are getting much better mileage than A/T's. But then again, that is almost always the case, regardless of what the EPA number state.
    P.S......
        Only 60 miles left before the break-in is over
               :-))))
     - - - 2004 2.5XT 5-sp.
  • miamixtmiamixt Member Posts: 600
    Steve, too funny about the Cuban thing! I work at a Cuban Radio Station, don't know the Spanish though. Just picked up one of the only 4 available XT's in the Miami-Dade area, beautiful, Black Pearl, 32 Miles, fully loaded, and at a decent price. I have noticed the AT Transmission does need a little help, hoping it will smooth out during the break in period. Gas mileage seems like it wont be too good in this land of perpetual Air Conditioning. Also have this tiny rattle/buzz from the Front Drivers side panel that needs to be looked at. What a great little SUV this XT is, especially after dumping my 2000 Honda CRV, no comparison between the two, except Price!
  • lfdallfdal Member Posts: 679
    2nd fill up = 17.2 to the gallon.

    Reset the ECU while I was working on the steering column, we'll see what tank 3 gives.

    jack - if you're still around interested in hearing your opinion / recommendation on the steering column - already had one friend suggest I get a lawyer and get Subaru to give me a refund and or another car claiming the car has structural flaws from the factory.

    Another friend who knows much more than I do about body work says it can only be one of three things (none of which I like).
    1) they put the steering support beam in cockeyed.
    2) the beam is no good.
    3) the column is no good.

    1 or 2 being the most likely.

    I'm thinking about dropping the $200 and getting the car put on a frame machine to confirm the major datum points.

    Really curious to see what SOA and the dealer come up with tomorrow. Bet this is going to go on for a while, especially since the dealer sys he's never, ever, ever, seen one of these.

    And contrary to conventional wisdom for the Subie boosters out there, when its your new car that's hosed it really doesn't matter how great the rest of them are, right then you only care about the one.

    Larry
  • stoner420stoner420 Member Posts: 165
    Yes! The smell of the XT is really nice! All those polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, yum!

    BTW, our steering column is perfectly straight. Sucks to be you :-(

    We have auto, to me it is the smoothest auto I've ever driven. I have been playing with leaving it in D most of the time, it usually downshifts reasonably well for me. You do have to stomp it to force a downshift to pass, and it takes a moment, but it doesn't seem abnormal for an AT to me, maybe there are ATs that do it faster, but it seems pretty typical to me. The downside I found is that it likes to upshift too soon... We just hit 1000 miles on ours, so I was letting it all hang out, got to 6000 and barely let up pressure on the pedal and it upshifted :-( Not sure how it will do on long hills, it usually seems ok except when you try to rev really high.

    PS: The XT at 6000 rpm is a MONSTER!! The gas pedal really motivates the hell out of this thing!!!

    Ok, on to business: has anyone installed the Subaru security system add-on, done it themselves? I ordered a kit from subaruwrxparts.com, they had a separate listing for XT security kit, but the diagrams and wiring shown in the install document don't seem to match up with what's in the car, I'm wondering if it is really different than the X/XS and if they sent me the wrong kit.. PN# H711SSA200, it just says "Security System Upgrade Forester"
  • corkfishcorkfish Member Posts: 537
    All three of the possibilties sound pretty dramatic and I would think you would definitely notice a steering/handling problem if they were true. Since I can't see it, I can't really comment, but could'nt it just be a problem with the plastic column shroud being defective or misaligned?
  • lfdallfdal Member Posts: 679
    stoner420 - thanks loads. I'd love to tell you how much I really, really, really appreciate your oh so insightful remarks in general, but since I want to keep posting here, I won't. Wonder if people like you are one of the reasons non-Subaru zealots don't feel entirely at home here? BTW - too bad about the alarm instructions, guess it sux to be you too. :<(

    corkfish - If you get a chance take a look at the links I posted the pics to, Brian showed me how to get imagestation working - they display pretty quick. The shroud is "lockstepped" to the column, no rotational adjust at all. When I dropped the left column bolt, the column "unwound" to about the position I ended up shimming it to. Car definitely in need of minor alignment, i.e. steering wheel straight car drifts slightly left. I was planning on waiting until the 1k mark as its not that bad and its not that unusual to get misaligned new cars.

    Larry
  • tidestertidester Member Posts: 10,059
    Be nice!

    tidester, host
  • subewannabesubewannabe Member Posts: 403
    has figured out the best line yet to tell the wife why she smells cigar in the car:," Honey, its just the new car smell in this Subaru".
    I am in awe!
      Now, if I can just pull this off in my Legacy GT next summmer," Honey, all these new Legacy's smell like Heidi Klum."
    Mark
  • subewannabesubewannabe Member Posts: 403
    If the steering column "untorqed" back to its nuetral position when you unbolted it, that means that the steering column was under an unnatural torque when it was bolted in its original position. Most state's "Lemon" laws say that you're entitled to relief (usually re-purchase) if its a defect that substantially affects the performance or safety of the car which cannot be cured by the dealer in 4 attempts. You have cured the appearance issue and the torque load on the column with your shim "repair", so the only way your going to get anywhere is if you can make a convincing argument that performance or safety have been adversely affected by the misaligned brace, which would require an engineering opinion. FWIW.
    Mark
  • lbhaleylbhaley Member Posts: 91
    I just got the best mileage yet with my MT XT on a trip to Vermont. I got 24.6 mpg. Two thirds highway, very little AC. Cruise set to 78 mph. I now have 3300 miles on the car and it's still getting better. I am totally satisfied with this car.

    -les
  • lfdallfdal Member Posts: 679
    Mark - I agree, as long as they validate my fix, we're not going to have any problems. I really, really like this car. It's if they say my fix is unacceptable and voids the warranty the stuffs gonna hit the fan.

    In any event I logged the case with Subaru this morning, and am going to call the service manager to set up an appt to have a Subaru rep look at the column.

    Larry
  • krccrkkrccrk Member Posts: 36
    I've been getting 23-26 mpg with my 5-speed XT. I do very little highway driving, AC is on low half the time. When I first got it I used the boost guage to learn not to accelerate too quickly when it is not needed. My 2001 S was getting 27-29 mpg when I traded it in.

    Ken
  • p0926p0926 Member Posts: 4,423
    "And contrary to conventional wisdom for the Subie boosters out there, when its your new car that's hosed it really doesn't matter how great the rest of them are, right then you only care about the one."

    Larry- Even the most ardent Subie booster will admit that there's always the potential of getting a lemon (same holds true for Honda and Toyota), just that the odds of it happening are less than with some other manufacturers. Of course as you pointed out, that's no comfort when you're the one with the problem. Why again was it that you accepted delivery with the steering column shroud so visibly crooked? ;-)
    In any case, if you're happy with the fix and it turns out that there's no other damage, I don't see SOA voiding the warranty since it sounds like they would otherwise have to replace the steering support beam.

    -Frank P.
  • lfdallfdal Member Posts: 679
    Frank - letting that get by me has been the cause of banging my head into a wall at least once a day for being so stupid. The only thing I can think of is that with all the other things I've seen leave different auto factories screwed up, this is the first time I've seen a companies quality control so sloppy as to miss the entire steering column. Sort of a "Couldn't see the Forest(er) for the trees" thing....

    Larry
  • imyodaddyimyodaddy Member Posts: 20
    I got 23.9 mpg, only 220 miles on the odometer, 75%/25% hwy/city driving to work. Gentle acceleration, drove mostly at 70+ mph, sometimes 80. But then again, I milked 65.1 mpg out of my Golf TDI.

    Concerning the smell: Ahhh, the rest of you are so used to incense burners, and wouldn't know a pleasant smell if your life depended on it. Cuban cigars are rich, aromatic, and definitely worth the price of admission. One of these days go to another country and try one. May I suggest Cohiba.

    Back to the Subaru. What a car! I can't wait for winter!
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    Man, that's good to hear. My '98 Forester had that rotten egg smell of the undercoating burning off. Maybe they apply it differently now? I used to call it New Car Stench!

    Cubans sure sound good in comparison!

    -juice
  • steverstever Guest Posts: 52,454
    I got a Cuban up in Kimberly BC back in April while driving my new (to me) Subaru home (note the attempt at content?). Lasted me all summer. Tasted pretty good... for a cigar. I think Castro smokes the Cosmoline brand ones.

    Steve, Host
  • lfdallfdal Member Posts: 679
    Had a meeting between the sales GM, the head of the Service dept and myself. I went armed with my pictures (several more than I had posted) and the applicable pages from the tech manual. They understood I had done my homework.

    They were unhappy when I told them I opened a case with Subaru until I got them to understand I wasn't trying to grind any axes; that all I wanted was a slip from them (or Subaru) saying they acknowledged the problem, verified my corrective work was up to snuff, and my warranty was in no way voided.

    I am now the proud possessor of said slip. Right into the file folder it goes for safe keeping.

    They even agreed that yeah, maybe the boost gauge is still off more than it should be and they'll fix it when I bring it on for the 1k service. They'll even give me a loaner for the day.

    I think when I left the sales manager was happy he was keeping me as a customer (figure I bought $75k worth of cars off them in the last 14 months, and they've made at least another 5-7k in retailing my trades - all 3 of which were sold from their lot within 3 or 4 days (OCD people are good people to get cars from).

    The service manager was happy they didn't have to do the work, and more or less acknowledged the beam may not have been angled just right in the first place. I wanted to work hard to keep the dealer / client relationship viable as I do believe they're the best around here.

    Also, I don't like to act like a knuckle dragging neanderthal until all other options are exhausted.

    For the constructive advise and opinions, received from the usual constructive sources, my thanks to all.

    Larry
  • subewannabesubewannabe Member Posts: 403
    I am constantly trying to encourage consumers of all sorts to get what they paid for...for most of us, the stuff we pay WITH isnt that easy to come by.
      And now i have a new layer of turbo wannabe anticipation...a car that smells like a Cohiba!
    Mark
  • samlatersamlater Member Posts: 12
    I ordered and installed the OEM security system - piece of cake - 30 minutes. Just make sure you order one specifically for the XT.
  • aa717driveraa717driver Member Posts: 41
    The wife and I drove the XT and the WRX Wagon back-to-back today. My Lexus-loving wife really likes the XT.

    Amazing...TC
  • p0926p0926 Member Posts: 4,423
    I've only had one and after smoking little more than half of it, it felt like I'd had the equivalent of a six-pack of beer. I swear that the room was spinning! So, my advice is to think twice before you smoke and drive your XT (Steve- even lamer attempt to keep on topic).

    -Frank P.
  • p0926p0926 Member Posts: 4,423
    Larry- Congrats, sounds like everything worked out okay.

    Sam- 30 mins? So what exactly did you have to do to install the security system?

    -Frank P.
  • buffagmbuffagm Member Posts: 21
    ahem, I hope not to be flamed for this, but any put regular gas in their XT? I'm trying to convince my dad to spring for the XT over the XS but the fact that it requires premium is a sticking point. Any one to share the experiences with regular?
  • steverstever Guest Posts: 52,454
    About that spinning - now you know why mine lasted half the summer. They do help keep the skeeters away.

    More off-topic rambling (well, it's a Subaru, and it's a Turbo):

    Follow-Up Test: 2004 Subaru Baja Turbo

    Buffagm, this link was posted in the Highlander board this morning:

    Why use premium gas when regular will do? (USA Today)

    Steve, Host
  • corkfishcorkfish Member Posts: 537
    Car and Drivers recent writeup on the Baja was interesting. Depite weighing over 3700 pounds and having an automatic transmission, it did 0 to 60 in 7.3 seconds. I was looking at a non turbo one in the dealer while waiting for my XT and you could really get a feel for the heft. The doors and tailgate are very heavy.
This discussion has been closed.

Your Privacy

By accessing this website, you acknowledge that Edmunds and its third party business partners may use cookies, pixels, and similar technologies to collect information about you and your interactions with the website as described in our Privacy Statement, and you agree that your use of the website is subject to our Visitor Agreement.