Edmunds dealer partner, Bayway Leasing, is now offering transparent lease deals via these forums. Click here to see the latest vehicles!
Popular New Cars
Popular Used Sedans
Popular Used SUVs
Popular Used Pickup Trucks
Popular Used Hatchbacks
Popular Used Minivans
Popular Used Coupes
Popular Used Wagons
Comments
The problem with these 'safety' features is that they must be calibrated (or set to intervene) for what I'll call the 'lowest common denominator' driver - otherwise they wouldn't be a 'safety' feature at all. Why the car buying public is so 'hot-to-trot' for VSC/TRAC equipped vehicles is beyond me. Perhaps if I was 90 years old, had bad eyesight, arthritis, and extremely poor reaction times I could understand. IMO, it ought to be law that these systems be easily switched off!
On another note I think I remember reading there is a way to disable the VSC/Trac but it is a lengthy procedure that has to be done every time the car is started.
2023 Mercedes EQE 350 4Matic / 2022 Ram 1500 Bighorn, Built to Serve
2023 Mercedes EQE 350 4Matic / 2022 Ram 1500 Bighorn, Built to Serve
i'd be weary about disabling these safety features.
what would happen if one was in an accident and by some means, the investigating authorities or insurance company working with the manufacturer could inspect the last x-seconds of ECU/TCM/ABS data just prior to air-bag deployment and determine the systems were disabled?
i'm reminded of a post claiming vsc activated erroneously, applying the brakes and sending the driver into the oncomming lane... also a few posts on unintentional vehicle acceleration (supposidly caused by a floor mat applying force to the accelerator pedal).
scarey, but i see a market for high-tech vehicle forensics to review post-crash data.
the VSC/TRACs and to some extent the ABSs now in many vehicles are there to make cars 'idiot proof' and must, to some extent, limit evasive capabilities for those that may not be quite the idiots that the systems were designed to accomodate. The 'problem' that I see is what I perceive to be a common notion that these systems somehow improve a car's dynamic capabilities - which, of course, they don't!
2023 Mercedes EQE 350 4Matic / 2022 Ram 1500 Bighorn, Built to Serve
2023 Mercedes EQE 350 4Matic / 2022 Ram 1500 Bighorn, Built to Serve
The VSC/Trac option must be a good money maker for Toyota because here in the northeast every single model I looked at from XL to Limited had the option installed.
2023 Mercedes EQE 350 4Matic / 2022 Ram 1500 Bighorn, Built to Serve
Just curious - what would you do in that unlikely event that you HAD to move more quickly than your truck's computer thought was prudent - bail?
I've been following the VSC/TRAC/ABS posts for years now. I grew up in northern Canada (NWT/Alberta Border). 6 months of the year we are up to our eyeballs in snow and ice. -40 F from mid Dec - Feb. I grew up driving FWD and RWD without anything electric in it. (No I'm not talking about 40 years ago, I'm on 26). If you drive on snow and ice long enough you'll realize that my fathers adage of "pretend there is a duck egg beneath your gas peddle" is true and that if you are gentle with the gas you'll find yourself up many hills others in there large SUV's/cars with Electronic nannies can't touch. It's not the cars/SUV's fault its the drivers. If you are pressing the throttle hard enough to spin the tires in the first place either a) your pressing too hard or b) the roads are so icy your co-eff of friction is so small between the tires and the road you had best not be on the roads because nothing will help.
Just my two cents.
Netwon
PS - My mother drives a 99 Avalon XLS which only came with TRAC as an option. (VSC came in 2000 MY) She called me last winter (she's owend the car since new) and asked what the Amber flashing light was when she was pulling away from a traffic light. 6 years with the car and she turned the light on once (that she noticed). Perhaps the electrics are making us poorer drivers, as when I tested her car I was not as lucky and couldn't stop the light from coming on. And got an earful of why I was on the gas so hard in her baby.
2023 Mercedes EQE 350 4Matic / 2022 Ram 1500 Bighorn, Built to Serve
Not to mention, those time honored traditions to get yourself unstuck - spinning the drive wheels (effectively burning off the ice under your tires), back and forth until you have managed enough of that momentum in one direction or the other to get yourself moving. Another thing a TRAC equipped vehicle would likely not permit.
I got a 2007 Touring for 500 under invoice!!
A few predictions: 1) complaints from motorists (rightly or wrongly) contending that 'the car went dead and wouldn't let me avoid this accident', or things like 'the brakes went on by themselves' or 'I pulled out and the car wouldn't move' - will become common and possibly even rampant; 2) because of the federal mandate these systems will not be allowed to be disabled - no VSC off switch; and 3) there will be a new market created for those that can figure out how to shut off/adjust these systems especially for the driving enthusiast.
NAPA stores are listed as dealers so I called my local store. They DO have them but didn't know that Trico now supplies 26 and 28 in. blades. He said he could special order them till they get on the shelves. (He said the 24 in. refill cost $18.)
I will take my car in and see how close they are and will post my results.
P.S. Love everything about my Limited.
My experiences with the RX's VSC/Trac activation have been very few, 2 or 3 at the most, and there were at times that I was totally unsuspecting of any traction problem/issue. I'm relative sure that there was an indication of same, both visual and aural, but the "event" was so short of duration and so occupied my total attention that I had no time to look or "acknowledge" the indications.
Insofar as I can say the Porsche's PSM has never activated, not even with pushing it so hard at Daytona that the "tail" tried to come around a few times.
But there is a significant difference in the two "stability" implementations. The Porsche system actually delays the activation of PSM for a few hundred milliseconds to give the driver time, an opportunity, to react and correct the situation on his/her own.
If VSC ends up being mandated, and I would champion that being the case, maybe a switch can be provided to indicate to the system that the driver is an experienced one as relates to the dynamics of maintaining control on adverse roadbed conditions.
I could readily see, otherwise, where there will be cases wherein simultaneous system activation and driver corrective measures would result in over-correction and possibly an otherwise avoidable accident.
And I still think VSC should be used to prevent ABS activation unless directional control is threatened.
Most of the other dealers I dealt with couldn't believe the offer I was given and tried hard to beat it but said there was no way.
Of course there are - and this would be where I can see many drivers having problems with the mandatory/non-disengageable VSC/TRAC. The implementation (or intervention settings) for those cars that are not 911's; must, by any reasonable definition of a safety feature, be set to help those drivers of limited capabilities.
I am certainly do not have the same reaction times etc. that I did 20 years ago when I messed around in parking lots (AC) and hill climbs, and I am likely a more capable driver now than I will be in another 20 years. Note that I didn't say 'better'. And I would guess, for however unrealistic the average driver (including myself) is about their individual abilities, most would concede that those abilities to handle a car in adverse conditions does erode with age.
So, in the cases, of the average family sedan/SUV like the Avalon/RX - how must Toyota 'program' its VSC intervention levels? To keep me out of trouble when - me of 20 years ago, today, or 20 years from now? I am afraid that the answer to that question is exactly where the difficulties may be with mandated/non-switchable 'safety' systems..
This somehow calling for me to go out and drive like a crazy fool in order to convince a silly computer that I either do or do not know what I am doing?
But your point is well made, very well made and an important one too.
At Daytona I was fully alert and fully prepared to quickly react to any untoward event.
But in point of fact NONE of us, regardless of age, can be constantly alert and prepared for these "events" for all the time we spend behind the wheel. Great to have VSC, PSM, Trac for backup.
Never happened again though. But very weird!
Do you have the DVD Nav? I do on both cars. I wonder...
Pete
I got the JBL Synthesis, Pwr Moonroof, and floor mats.
Too bad the navigation system is getting such a bad rap. Although using it isn't the most efficient, with it's poorly designed controller, I still would recommend it. (I know, ...too late for you).
It is still very effective and I use it all the time. I do use some choice words when programming it though, but I love it when it directs me to my destination!
Anyway, good luck with your Avalon -keep us posted with your solution -if you or the dealer find one.
Titanium Metallic
Options:
JBL stereo
Sunroof
VSC
Invoice:
$29,342
MSRP:
$32,545
Price paid:
$29,332
Customized features:
32% tint - back 3 windows
Autostart remote start system
Clearshield clear bra system
Soon to be added:
XM radio
Ipod interface
Toyota Avalon Limited wheels
manual on PDF for buy it now of $1.99,$7.95 shipping (is on
cd).looks like a decent buy to me.
And FWD cars, like our Avalons, kind of the opposite situation with the same weight bias to the front. For whatever benefits in traction and stability come with that, the ultimate corrections to the same at the limit situations are 'intuitive' or power off. I contend FWD a generally safer condition for the average driver, although it is foolish to even entertain the notion that a 50/50 (or so) weight distribution, rear wheels driven setup isn't ultimately better, if that limit behavior is a mild understeer condition.
I am concerned that there seems to be a large portion of the car buying public out there that doesn't seem to understand what VSC/TRAC/ABS actually do. They spend their money and think somehow they are getting a better handling car and/or the 'car' is impervious to gross errors. They may definitely be buying a 'safer' car, but not without a price in overall drivability. Thankfully I don't live in snow country anymore - the first thing I think I would want to do on snow covered roads is turn the VSC/TRAC off!
did have a situation about a year ago where I avoided an multiple car accident with a violent, accelerating high speed swerve onto a gravelly shoulder, breaking the rear end loose as I did. Can't imagine that any VSC system worth its salt would have 'allowed' me to do that, and my Avalon should have been toast. But, from your perspective, I certainly can't 'prove' what could've happened, had my Av been VSC/TRAC equipped. And never will.
The only danger I foresee is the possibility of over-correction if the driver happens to "sense" the out of whack condition and act to correct it at the same time as the system.
And I have no idea of how it was done, but Porsche has removed the "snap" type of tail wagging, at least in the newer 996 series.