Edmunds dealer partner, Bayway Leasing, is now offering transparent lease deals via these forums. Click here to see the latest vehicles!
Options
BMW 3-Series Lease Questions
This discussion has been closed.
Popular New Cars
Popular Used Sedans
Popular Used SUVs
Popular Used Pickup Trucks
Popular Used Hatchbacks
Popular Used Minivans
Popular Used Coupes
Popular Used Wagons
Comments
Doesn't that get extremely expensive over time? So far I have been buying my cars outright with the plan of holding on to them for 10 years. But in reality I get a new car every 4-5 years or so. I think about 6 years is my practical limit before my drooling over new cars gets excessive. So I'm trying to figure out how much more expensive it is to do 3 year leases instead of what I've been doing.
Thanks!
I think it may not make sense to buy a 328i outright right now as long as you can earn more than 3.36% (MF = .0014) +$625 acquisition costs on your money after tax. If your financing a car on an outright purchase, the interest rate would have to be low (about 4.0% as the $625 acquisition cost is really a big upfront interest expense) to beat the lease.
In a state like mine, where taxes of 9% is on the lease payment only, it's especially a no-brainer to lease. First, in terms of taxes on say a $39,000 car, again in my state, I would have to choke-up $3,510 in taxes on Day 1. Over the term of the lease, the same car at a 9% tax rate would incur only $1,500 in tax payments over the duration of the lease.
My decision to lease is simple, I've saved the $42,510 I need to buy my $39,000 car outright but I'm leasing. Why? I'm earning about $165 per month on that money now versus the expected payment ($405 depreciation + $57.69 in finance costs after 7 additional MSDs + $41.69 taxes = $505). My $165 in interest earned per month will come down each month because I'm making the $505 payment out of that account, but after 36 months, I'll have made about $18,177.91 in payments that are offset by roughly $5,000 in earned interest (ignoring income taxes for now). My cash on hand at the end of the lease will be $26,534 plus $2,800 for the returned MSDs or $29,334. My residual will be $24,400 at that time so I can buy the car outright or release another car.
Basically, if I keep running this, and assuming the lease deals and low-risk re-investment rates on cash are as good as now in the future, my $42,500 will buy about 10 to 11 years worth of cars that are all under warranty.
I will not have a $5K to $10K car to sell at the end of that decade, but I will have avoided roughly 4 to 5 Inspection I and IIs (total cost of $4K to 5K if you're lucky), 3 incremental sets of tires (about $1,500), rotors ($450 per time as they'll never turn), and whatever additional repairs I'll need in that time. My 1999 328i currently requires about a $2,000 annuity to my mechanic.
Boy was that ever wordy.
Cheers and have fun with your cars folks!
Not so much, and helpful words to boot. Interesting analysis.
I can't emphasize enough that leases only make sense to people who can't write them off as business expenses when the manufacturer "supports" them with artificially high residuals and/or low interest rates. BMW is in there with botht feet at the moment, but that could change. Always pays to do exactly the analysis that you presented so well. Even considering the tax implications, with today's lease rates, it does appear to make sense to lease . . . right now . . . but maybe not next month.
Car_man
Host
Prices Paid: Buying & Leasing Experiences Forum
Car_man
Host
Prices Paid: Buying & Leasing Experiences Forum
Car_man
Host
Prices Paid: Buying & Leasing Experiences Forum
Car_man
Host
Prices Paid: Buying & Leasing Experiences Forum
Car_man
Host
Prices Paid: Buying & Leasing Experiences Forum
Car_man
Host
Prices Paid: Buying & Leasing Experiences Forum
Not only are you paying full MSRP for this car, but the dealer that you are working with is marking its money factor up as well. BMW Financial Services' current buy rate lease money factor for the 2007 328i Coupe is only .00160 with the payment of a security deposit and .00175 with the deposit waived. Make sure that the dealer uses this rate to calculate your car's monthly payment.
I suspect that you will be able to beat this deal by shopping around.
Car_man
Host
Prices Paid: Buying & Leasing Experiences Forum
The selling price that you were quoted for this car is OK. Consumers who are in an area that has a decent level of competition are usually able to beat Edmunds.com's TMV for vehicles. Make sure to stop by the following discussion to see how much others have paid for similar cars lately: "BMW 3-Series: Prices Paid & Buying Experience".
Also, the dealer is marking up your car's money factor to add additional hidden, back-end profit to your deal. BMW Financial Services' buy rate lease money factor for the '07 335i is currently only .00175 with the payment of a security deposit at lease signing. Try to get the dealer to use this money factor to calculate your monthly payment.
I am not personally all that familiar with what the Austin, TX market is like, but I suspect that you will be able to beat this deal by shopping around with a couple other dealers.
Car_man
Host
Prices Paid: Buying & Leasing Experiences Forum
Car_man
Host
Prices Paid: Buying & Leasing Experiences Forum
Car_man
Host
Prices Paid: Buying & Leasing Experiences Forum
Car_man
Host
Prices Paid: Buying & Leasing Experiences Forum
Car_man
Host
Prices Paid: Buying & Leasing Experiences Forum
Car_man
Host
Prices Paid: Buying & Leasing Experiences Forum
The other negotiable aspect of your deal is your car's selling price. You should try to negotiate as low a selling price as possible on the vehicle that you want. Ideally one would negotiate as low a price as possible before placing the order for the car that they want.
Car_man
Host
Prices Paid: Buying & Leasing Experiences Forum
Car_man
Host
Prices Paid: Buying & Leasing Experiences Forum
Can you please let me know if this is a decent deal for the Los Angles area? What would be the monthly payment if the drive off is only $2,000? Thank you for your assistance.
2007 BMW 328i Sedan base plus automatic transmission.
MSRP $34,450
Selling $33,155
Lender BMW Financial Services
Term 36 Months
Mileage 12,000/year
Money Factor 1.65
Residual Factor 63%
Selling Price $33,155.00
Bank Fee $825.00
Total Capitalized Cost
$33,980.00
Residual Value $21,703.50
Total Depreciation $9,991.80
Capital Reduction $2,284.70
Monthly Depreciation $277.55
Monthly Rent $88.11
Monthly Payment $365.66
Tax (7.75%) $28.34
Monthly Payment + Tax $394.00
Capital Reduction $2,284.70
Cap Reduction Tax (7.75%) $180.55
License & Registration $284.75
Documentation Fee $45.00
First Payment $394.00
Security Deposit $0.00
Drive Off $3,189.00
I guess what I'm trying to say is that you will get an answer, but it may not be anytime really soon. At least you gave them every possible scrap of information, which is helpful.
About all I can say is that $825 "bank fee" is the thing that many dealers mark up from the $625, which is what it should cost. Oh, and the "cap cost reduction" usually isn't a good idea. You only got ~$1300 off the sticker price on a car that's about to become a year old when the '08s come out.
Thanks for the helpful information. So, I shouldn't pay for any cap cost reduction at all? I like to keep the drive off as low as possible given this is a lease. Thank you!
2007 328i sedan
auto
Red
$34,450 msrp
32,450 selling price
36/15k
$443 plus tax ($470 all in)
0 due at signing- out the door-sign and drive
Also 9k trade in for '02 325i
with 90k miles, auto, premium package
Thanks for your imput..
I'd be tempted to try and sell this myself...
Edmunds Price Checker
Edmunds Lease Calculator
Did you get a good deal? Be sure to come back and share!
Edmunds Moderator
Can you provide the variables for a 36 month lease of a 2007 335xi sedan for both 10K and 12K miles/yr? Looking of course for:
money factor
residual
acquisition fee
over mileage fee
security deposit requirement
Assume top tier credit rating. Also, are there any special lease programs or dealer incentives on this vehicle?
Thanks!
-Jabber
I have 3 options to choose from. Need some help to decide the best one:
1. 2007 328i with Auto
$328/mo + tax for 24 month
$3490.00 total drive off due at lease inception, includes $1747.43 cap reduction and $0 security deposit
10000 Miles Per year
Selling Price $33,527.80
MSRP $34,925.00
2. 2007 328i with Auto
$399/mo + tax for 36 month
$1675.00 total drive off due at lease inception, includes $0 cap reduction and $0 security deposit
10000 Miles Per year
3. 2007 BMW 328i with Auto (Sedan Lease Offer from BMW)
http://www.bmwusa.com/vehicles/3/2007328iSedan/programs.htm?PanelID=4
$339 p.m. + Tax
10k miles/yr
$339 First month's payment
$2,500 Down payment
$350 Security deposit
$3,189 Cash due at signing
MSRP of $34,450.00
Or does it make sense to just wait till the 2008 models are out and hope to get lease specials on 2007 models??
Your inputs would be greatly appreciated.
Thanks!
:confuse:
$448/mo includes tax for 36 month
$888.00 total drive off due at lease inception.
10,000 miles per year
I think I could have gotten the deal with 12k/yr.
Can you also provide me the same lease details for the 335xi Coupe as well as the Sedan??
Thanks.
-Jabber
I've started to ask for quotes from different dealers on the upcoming 2008 328i coupe with following options ~
Premium package
Automatic transmission
White color with aluminum trim
MSRP $40,600
However, I went to several dealerships and they are not willing to give me much discount on the car price. The best I've got so far is $39,800. But I know some people in this forum got a better deal than that on the 07 model. :confuse:
The dealers told me the 328i coupe is very popular and sold out quickly before it hits the showroom. And I have to pre-order! :surprise:
Also, another dealer quotes me a lease plan as follow ~
Car price: $40,000 ( $600 off MSRP )
36 months
15K miles
$2000 drive off
$612 per month
P.S. Anyone in Los Angeles area can recommand a dealer to me?
Thanks,
Sil
In addition, sedans are in less demand than coupes and both are in less demand than the convertible. You want an '08 convertible, you pay sticker or more -- an '07 sedan, possibly invoice or less.
MSRP $40600
Selling price $39800
36 months
15K miles
$999 drive off
$639 + tax monthly
I very much doubt you can get an 07 328 for invoice or below, a good deal is $500-1000 over invoice for a 328i. BMW does not give holdbacks so a dealer would lose money if they sold a car for less than invoice (the fees would help).
Anyway BMW's are cheap in the US when compared to Europe so stop trying to get a great car for $1.99!
He thinks we are paying too much for that in US...
Don't know how true is that? :P
Just look at bmw.co.uk and the option prices. Steptronic is GBP1200 which is a 1:1 exchange rate even though it is $2 to GBP1. Metalic paint and comfort access are also much more expensive options in the UK than in the US even though the same factory is used and the delivery distance is much shorter.
It is true that BMW is very popular in Germany, but that just shows that Europeans don`t mind paying for excellence. Whereas lots of Americans what something on the cheap so they buy Hyundai etc. Korean and Japanese manufacturers do not sell well in Europe (just check out Lexus sales comapred to Audi, MB or BMW - they are tiny).
Now let's take a look at its selling price. This car's dealer invoice price is $31,795. The price that you were quoted is $1,360 over invoice. Plus this dealer is marking up BMW FS $625 base acquisition fee by $200, so you are really paying more like $1,500 over invoice. I would not be surprised if you were able to beat this price if you are in an area that has a decent level of competition. It wouldn't hurt to comparison shop with a few other dealers. Also, make sure to stop by the "BMW 3-Series: Prices Paid & Buying Experience" discussion to see how much other community members have paid for similar cars lately.
Car_man
Host
Prices Paid: Buying & Leasing Experiences Forum
Car_man
Host
Prices Paid: Buying & Leasing Experiences Forum
Assuming that all of the selling prices of the three deals that you mentioned are the same, the number two looks the best to me because it has no capitalized cost reduction. I always advise consumers against making down payments on leased vehicles. Those who make them risk losing part or all of them if their vehicle is totaled in an accident or stolen and never recovered.
It is difficult to say what BMW's lease program will be like on the 2008 3-Series when it arrives at dealers in the near future, but if I had to make an educated guess I would say that you will probably get a better deal on a leftover '07 model now than you will be able to get on an '08 when it is first available.
Car_man
Host
Prices Paid: Buying & Leasing Experiences Forum
Car_man
Host
Prices Paid: Buying & Leasing Experiences Forum
Car_man
Host
Prices Paid: Buying & Leasing Experiences Forum