Did you recently take on (or consider) a loan of 84 months or longer on a car purchase?
A reporter would like to speak with you about your experience; please reach out to PR@Edmunds.com by 7/22 for details.
A reporter would like to speak with you about your experience; please reach out to PR@Edmunds.com by 7/22 for details.
Options
Comments
Hunter, the car is "cheap" not because it is an abomination, but because it is unpopular. Popularity, however, is no great indicator of value. This is why the RL has been, and continues to be, a vehicle for those who don't need too much "popularity." The word 'disgrace' which you apply to the RL's engine is a word usually applied to teenagers who've stayed out all night, politicians, auto salesmen, and (in my neighborhood) certain clergymen, not engineers. Thank you for not liking the car -- it may encourage Acura to come up with a really passionate redesign. Meanwhile, Acura dealers will give a good price to people like Kenny.
Take care.
Joe W.
Did you know it was basically the same vehicle as the other?
Why did you choose it over the other?
Please submit your response to jfallon@edmunds.com no later than Wednesday, May 15.
MODERATOR /ADMINISTRATOR
Find me at kirstie_h@edmunds.com - or send a private message by clicking on my name.
2015 Kia Soul, 2021 Subaru Forester (kirstie_h), 2024 GMC Sierra 1500 (mr. kirstie_h)
Review your vehicle
There is plenty of technology that goes into the RL which makes it much more expensive. I've spent plenty of time in the current generation TL and its nowhere as refined as the RL.
Hunter,
If you don't like the RL, don't buy it. Before purchasing my RL, I only considered a TL because it was in my price range. When I was able to get the RL at invoice, I jumped at the chance. To me an RL is a big upgrade from the TL.
My NSX-T is slower than the M3 and Z06, in 0-60 times, and it has a 90 degree V6, but I certainly wouldn't call it a disgrace. I purchased it for its technology, build quality and fun to drive factor (and, it certainly is fun to drive.
The difficulty is heightened by the fact that the TL is a nice car, has almost all of RL's comfort features and is priced right. Auto makers and dealers expect to make a lot more money in selling luxury cars (such as the RL), but when the market says that the car is not in demand despite moderate price concessions, either the price needs to be further adjusted (as was done in year end 2000) or the car needs to be re-configured and re-engineered. Also, offering attractive lease deals may be unsuitable for certain customers such as myself, who drive no more than 5k miles a year. It is undisputed that the RL is a fine luxury car, however, the current design is more than 6 years old and a new and better design must be implemented soon. Acura should not leave the flagship car in the shadow of its junior siblings -- the TL and the MDX. Nonetheless, I think the RL is probably the right car for me. All I am waiting for is the right deal -- around $37k to $38k(nav included).
Thanks for any help.
The ES is a compact car and the RL midsize. The RL will provide a smoother ride over bumps. The RL wheelbase is 114.6 in long and the ES 107.1 inches long.
The RL is a large car with a lot of low end torque. 231 ftlbs @ 2800 vs 220 @ 4400. This provides more useful power during everyday driving.
My advice is to test drive both and buy the one you like the most. Both have a completely different feel.
The engine power of the ES is fine with me since I don't drive fast and it does have enough power to merge into the traffic, and it is VERY smooth and quiet.
I943973,
IMHO the ES will not cost more than the RL with comparable options, becuase the fully loaded ES including navigation system is close to 40K (MSRP $39,963), and the fully loaded RL is over 45K. And RL does not even offer some of the ES options(rear sunshade, AVS, wood steering wheel, etc.). If you can get a huge discount on the RL which is very likely, then the purchasing price of RL can be close to the fully loaded ES.
If I have to select one from these two fine cars, I will still go with the Lexus if purchasing is required, but go with Acura if leasing is prefered.
If we talk about the tires which I think they are very important to the handling of the car, my ES comes with Toyo high performance tire v-rated(I forget the name of the tire), and RL comes with Michelin MXV4 energy also v-rated, the Toyo tires are much quieter than the Michelin, but do not seem to have the cornering capability as the Michelin. I think Lexus is trying to cut the cost, but they can be replaced later with better tires.
Fortunately, my ES has the AVS, and if I set the AVS to a more sporty level, the road feel is actually quite good, it can reach a point where the cornering and emergency maneuvering are better than the RL. And the length of the RL is another disadvantage for maneuvering.
As mentioned by kennyg5, the steerling wheel of RL is overpowered so it feels light, not sure whether Acura fixed it for the 02 RL. On the contrary, the ES feels much tighter and precise than the RL, and I like the feel very much. The ES steeling wheel is also smaller than the RL's.
IMHO, the ES is more sporty (cannot compete with BMW or other sport sedans though, including Acura TLs), and RL is a luxury crusing sedan. Both cars can be a very good vehicle for daily drive.
My last feeling is that the ES ML stereo is really better than the RL BOSE(I listen to the Classical and Jaz music all the time).
vs MB -- interesting: in mid-winter, I was visiting the lux dealer here and parked near the MB shop while I visited the Audis. Afterward, I dropped by to look at the floor models of the Merc. A salesman said:"I thought you'd come back. Since you drive a Mercedes you know their quality." I didin't say a word, but enjoyed the $18k I'd saved vs. the E in his showroom!
Before someone has a hissy fit, I'm not the one comparing the RL to the MB, but they do look alike, and they both do run on six cylinders.
Take care.
Joe W.
99-01 RLs used 215/60s on 16x7 inch wheels. I think the 02 wheel size is the same with a more aggresive tire profile. I've thought about getting a lower profile but wasn't sure if 225/60s were too aggresive. I guess its ok since the 02 models use this size.
Both a 215/60 and 225/55 tire can be used on 16x7 inch wheels with little change on the speedometer.
http://www.hondanews.com
400 horsepower, mid-engine, all-wheel-drive hybrid powertrain including:
o 3.5-liter, DOHC, i-VTEC V-6 engine
o Integrated Motor Assist (IMA) system
o 6-speed clutchless manual transmission with automatic-shift mode
Independent double wishbone suspension
Wheels and Tires:
o 18-inch alloy wheels with 225/45ZR18 tires/front
o 19-inch alloy wheels with 255/45ZR19 tires/rear
Electro-Mechanical Brake (EMB) System with 4-wheel disc brakes
Steer-by-wire with variable power assist
Active Torque Transfer System (ATTS)
Variable Stability Assist (VSA)
Intelligent Driver Support System
o Front and rear cameras
o Adaptive Cruise Control
o Lane Keeping System
Intelligent Technology instrument panel
o 3-D display meter, center display and pop-up information monitor with voice recognition
o Night vision, GPS navigation, e-mail, Internet, cellular telephone
Individual bucket seats
Active Headlights for enhanced vision around corners
Night Vision system with infrared camera
Ultra-aerodynamic body with integrated front upper spoiler
Touch sensor door switches
Variable dimming window glass blocks infrared and ultra-violet light
Just joking. RE: the above posts -- I wish!!!
Take care.
Joe w.
Also, I can't get any sound out of my rear speakers, no matter how I adjust the fade. A simple solution or am I off to the dealer?
Thanks greatly for any help anyone might have.
Just replaced my auto dimming mirror because it was only dimming 85% of the mirror. I tapped it a few times and now the dimming is 85% gone.
My advice, don't tap it. Anyways, I called about 10 dealers around my area and the lowest price for the rearview mirror was $413.15 not including labor. The original mirror is very difficult to remove but finally got it off after 45 minutes.
The acura service manual is wrong. Putting on the new mirror took about 1 minute.
Also my passenger seat panel was creaking on the top front panel below the headrest. Removed the back panel and found out that a metal piece was rubbing against the seat foam when the seat was pressed in. I inserted a piece of felt in between and the creaking is gone. Put back the panel and hopefully saved some money by not going to the dealer.
Also found out my local dealer is selling RL OEM filters for $4.99. Thats a steal.
After 3+ years, I just found out that my rear seat head rests tilt just like the front headrests. Thought that was interesting.
Edmund's doesn't like the car because it doesn't have a V8. But recall the design was intended to compete with cars that were, at that time, 6 cyl. in their base model. It'ws just that the RL doesn't have a V8 or a 'tuner' edition.
Take care.
Joe W.
Edmund doesn't simply give the RL a low rating in the power/acceleration department (due to lack of a V-8), 15 of the 25 criteria are rated at 5 or below. IMO, this is harsh. On the other hand, as noted, many consumers very much like or love the car. It seems that these consumers are much more influenced or pleased by the luxury features of the RL than its sportiness. Although I have not done or seen any demographic survey, I would guess that most owners of RLs are more mature (I hate to say older) than those who own TL-S, but they are not as mature as those who own Crown Victorias or Grand Marquises :-) Any thoughts?
Lots of RLs around here in comparison to Lexus LS and other large luxury sedans... RL is affordable, and Honda shouldn't go crazy wasting money to put a V8 into it, unless they have indications it would sell like mad.
No premium Luxury car manufacturer, including Lexus, BMW, Mercedes, Audi, Jaguar (hell, even Infiniti) etc., has a FLAGSHIP with a Front-wheel-drive layout, even if we were to discount the absence of the V8. The only luxury car maker that plods on with FWD in its flagship is Cadillac and that is one maker who is a real "has-been" in this field as is rarely taken seriously nowadays.
Front-wheel-drive is okay in a starter product (Near Luxury like the 3.2TL, Lexus ES300, Infiniti I30 etc) in the Luxury line-up but in a FLAGSHIP ?? Not acceptable, in my Lexicon.
A FLAGSHIP product of a company is something extraordinary sporting technology that later on percolates down to the lower-end products, and is manufactured in relatively small numbers. More along the lines of something that one looks forward to owning after one has "really arrived" - an aspirational product. The lower-end 3.2TL/TL-s sports dual-stage variable valve timing technology with a super-broad torque/power band, which works along a 5-speed Adaptive Automatic and what do you find in the FLAGSHIP (3.5RL) ?? A low-tech non-variable valve timing engine with middling power output working with a econo-4-speed Automatic setup. The Acura FLAGSHIP, leaves one with the sense of a pretender. Slightly better than the near-luxury product of theirs (3.2TL) - in some build quality respects, which in my reckoning does not reach the lofty level of the flagship of a Luxury car manufacturer, which is why Acura (inspite of being the Luxury arm of Honda) is considered as a fringe player in the Luxury car arena. This is similar to the position occupied by the large Front-wheel-drive Toyota Avalon in the Toyota lineup. You will not find it anywhere close to a flagship in the Lexus line-up, would you ??
As an aside, I am a Honda fan and in this particular aspect, I am not too impressed with Honda.
Later...AH
I live in the Northeast and so a FWD car makes more sense during the winter time; although an AWD would be great. I don't know if there is any real advantage of RWD over FWD, except as pointed out by Hunter that the prestigious nameplates all have RWD in their flagship cars. That said, I do agree that the RL needs a more advanced engine (does not have to be V-8)such as VTEC and 5-speed transmission. A motorized rear sunshade would also be nice.
Have you seen the Letter from the Town Hall Manager on the Town Hall Welcome page? If not, you might want to follow that link to have a look.
And hang on to your seats. Change is never easy - for any of us - but resolving the Search problems we've had will be worth the pain.
Pat
Sedans Host
Everyone I know who has bought an RL has had a high quality car and a great experience. However dealing with the acura dealer in my area...now that's another story.