Did you recently take on (or consider) a loan of 84 months or longer on a car purchase?
A reporter would like to speak with you about your experience; please reach out to PR@Edmunds.com by 7/22 for details.
A reporter would like to speak with you about your experience; please reach out to PR@Edmunds.com by 7/22 for details.
Options
Comments
My first cars were Beetles, a 60 and then a 73. I've driven two Toyotas and a Subaru since then.
I'm shopping now and have narrowed down my choices to an Acura TL and a Passat. I'm leaning towards the Passat because it's less boring and has more room in the back seat.
That said, I'm kind of astounded at the shoddy quality that people just sort of put up with here and on the Vortext forums. ("I love my car even though I've had to take it in twelve times, the sunroof doesn't close and my dog fell out of the back yesterday.")
My Subaru has 80K miles and I've done nothing but regular service. No repairs. We have a 91 Toyota with 210K miles and we just did some clutch work worth about $1k and that was the first thing.
I understand that generally on the web people are negative, but I've found the Edmunds forums to be more balanced. I wish there was some independent source for reliability information.
By the way, I love my 1.5 GLX 5 speed... so far.
INKY
Smart words. It's very petty to ridicule someone for choosing proven reliability over a percieved, better driving experieince.
Many VW owners seem to think that unflappable reliability and a good driving experience are mutually exclused. As long as they buy into that, VW doesn't have any reason to tighten up their quality control... no reason at all.
Why can't VW do it both was???
As I have mentioned, I have been fortunate enough to own most of the Passats competition in the '90's and based my decision to buy the Passat on the pros and cons of those ownership experiences. My "spouting" is not based on what I have read, or what friends tell me, it is based on actual ownership, a credential that I truly believe very few have.
The Accord is a fine product, believe me it is not perfect either. Anyone aware of the "chronic" sunroof rattle in the 1998 EX Accord that their is no fix for? Sure the dealer is able to "grease it" every time it is in for service but that is the best they can do. It is just one of those things.
I think people are looking too closely at this whole issue, face it cars break.
My fathers '00 S-Class has been in the shop more times than that in the same time period. Should we label that unreliable too?
No one in the S-Class forum is whining about reliability issues there.
What I am saying is half the stuff that you read about reliability is bull [non-permissible content removed]. Don't believe it.
The numbers don't lie: in the class that is occupied by the Passat, Camry, Accord, etc., VW owners are more likely to have to deal with some service or parts issue than the Toyota/Honda group. How important that is to you is strictly up to you - but the volume of traffic on the internet boards doesn't make [or fail to make] this point. Powers, CU, and other independent data sources all agree on this issue. These online chats are invaluable for experience-sharing, but they represent too small a sample to attack or defend any given make or model of car.
btw...Where on the planet did you get your info on the S-Class?????
Heres the point. If someone contacted my family member that owns the car, she would state, with enthusiasm mind you "I love my Honda!!!" with absolutely NO mention of this chronic rattle.
If this was my car, my reaction would be much different, I really could not deal with the problem or their solution.
Thats the issue. Car people tend to offer more praise and be much more unforgiving when problems occur than John Q. Public tends to be when driving their cookie cutter appliance back and forth to work everyday.
The only problem was a power steering leak that was caused by the mechanic during a routine maintenance. Otherwise, the car is as tight, quiet, and rattle-free as the day I bought it a year ago. This is an interesting discussion on car reliability. Hope my experience helps.
My wife and I own a 2000 Passat GLS V6, 5 speed that currently has just under 20k on the odometer. The car has been absolutely trouble free, and after driving it for 1.5 years (including 2 3000+ mi round trips to Florida) I can say that it is an OUTSTANDING automobile. It is comfortable to ride in, exhilerating to drive, has tons of room, great handling, and gets excellent milage for a V6 (30 mpg on our recent FL trip, cruising @ 85-90mph in heavy traffic - no cruise control).
I highly recommend the Passat to all those who enjoy driving and great cars. I am confident enough in the car to recommend it to even my closest friends, and guess what. . . some of my friends have bought Passats after seeing and driving ours. We now know 3 couples who now have Passat V6s, and none of them have reported any problems either. All love the cars.
These message boards are filled with stories of issues and problems (that's what they are here for). The messages here should not be taken as a representative sample.
Any car can have problems. I bought my previous car, a Subaru Legacy, in large part because I bought into the "myth" of legendary Subaru reliability. I was just out of grad school, and traded my Taurus SHO (high performance, but high maintenance) in for a much less exciting but "more reliable" car. I wanted to get 10 years and 150k out of the Subie with minimum expense on my part. To make a long story short, upwards of 80k the car suffered a number of failures, including a nasty oil leak that couldn't be ignored and was expensive to fix. Then at 91k the transmission blew, and I traded the car. I figure if I get at least 90k out of the Passat I'm ahead. The 10/100 powertrain warranty is a comfort.
So for all of you folks out there sitting on the fence, I say go out and buy a Passat if you enjoy driving. If you are not that interested in the quality of the driving experience and care more about a reputation for reliability, buy an Accord or Camry. If you never want to pay for a repair, buy a Hyundai Sonata. The bottom line is you should buy what meets your needs and what appeals to you.
I've put on 30K+ miles in less than eight months with absolutely no other problems.
Another thing worth noting is that all cars have improved in build quality and reliability in recent years. Even Chrysler and Hyundai products today probably are as reliable as Toyota and Honda were ten years ago. Moreover, the gap between the most reliable cars and the rest has narrowed significantly.
Statistically, the Passat is not as reliable as a Camry or Accord. In reality this may mean that 3% of Passat will have major troubles as opposed to 2.5% of Camry and Accords and 2.75% of Subaru, the other wagon I looked at seriously.
I was happy to assume this small additional risk after test driving several mid-size wagons. The Passat is so much more pleasant to drive than the Outback, Taurus or (shudder) Large Saturn that the choice was very easy to make.
In its June issue Car and Driver reported that it replaced the clutch on its 1.8T Beetle at almost 29,000 miles. It went on to say that "we're aware of two other magazines' 1.8T New Beetles that burned up clutches in less than 15,000 miles. We have to wonder if the drivetrain needs a little beefing up to handle the turbo engine." Car and Driver uncovered the problem with the Mazda Miata engine that lead Mazda to offer to buy back all of the 2001 Miatas sold. I wonder if it has uncovered a major problem with the 1.8T manual transmission clutch. I wouldn't be surprised if Edmunds discovers that it has to replace the clutch on its Passat sometime during its test period.
Edmunds records the destination charge in their price breakdowns as well as all the options. Other than those prices the only other thing on my invoice was TTL and state sales tax (which in Texas was plenty!!!).
It's a Silverstone Grey GLX Sedan 4-Motion with grey leather. I love it!
Extended warranty - they offered me a 7 year 75,000 mile warranty for $1550. I said I'd think about it.
It is too bad how a dealer can get you to the point that you would not buy the brand again. The other local dealer, West Side VW, is really not much better.
2001 GLS 1.8T, auto, Ink Blue, tan leather pack, Lux pack, Monsoon radio, CD player
I previously had a '98 Passat GLS and the only option I had was a moonroof. I got all the above on the 2001 for just $15 more a month than what I was paying for my '98!I have been looking for months at other cars and, for the money, the Passat is still hard to beat.
There has been a lot of talk about reliability lately and here is my experience. When I first got my '98 I had a bad rear door lock that caused a problem w/ my alarm. The dealer quickly replaced it and I didn't have another problem until almost 3 yrs later. That final problem dealt w/ the Control Arms. They went bad and needed to be replaced. The car was driveable but made a lot of noise going over bumps, such as speed bumps, or turning at slow speeds. Needless to say that cost me almost $300 in labor to fix them (they didn't charge me for the parts). The only other fault I found w/ the car was the breaks tended to be noisy. I had them checked and they tuned out to be normal. They said the squeaky breaks are caused by the semi-metallic pads. My friend has a '99 and doesn't seem to have that problem so it must be something VW resolved/changed.
Overall, I was extremely happy w/ my '98 and I didn't hesitate to consider a VW again as my lease neared it's end. There were a lot more positives w/ the car than the negatives which is the main reason I returned.
I pick it up on Wed and I can't wait. I am expecting another enjoyable 39 months w/ my new car. Who knows, 39 months from now maybe I will end up in a new Colorado...
You sound like one of the "seldom right but never in doubt" types. I've been driving manual transmission cars for nearly 40 years and never had a clutch wear out until I had the Passat. Now tell me how I abused the clutch. The problem was not that the clutch was a short throw design but that the clutch never engaged smoothly. The new clutch operates fine, which I believe confirms that something was wrong with the original clutch. Read Edmund's discussion of the clutch in its long-term test. Edmund's said the clutch felt like it was worn out, and its drivers didn't have a chance to abuse the clutch.
The drivers at the car mags probably treat all their cars to the same driving styles. The clutches on most cars seem to hold up to these "uncaring" drivers; the clutches on the VW's apparently don't seem to hold up as well.
Thanks
I felt GLX is the same as GLS, with all the options included. I thought, I'll buy a fully loaded 2001.5 GLS V6. Is it the same as GLX V6..Any suggestions ?
Also, does anyone know of a good VW dealer in the Chicago/Schaumburg area in Illinois?
Thanks..
of the Passat...The same designations apply to the Jetta/Bora frames...the
most recent being A4 adopted in the 1999 remodel.
The Antenna placement on ALL VWs is based on common sense...highest point
on the car, and away from the engine...Is it removable or movable? Clarification
here would be good, due to the fact that I gather you do not like it's present
location.
I regret that you had such a disappointing test drive experience that you were
not made aware of the differences between the GLS & GLX. The GLX Flagship VW
offers the owner 8 Position Bilateral PowerSeating with 3 Different Person/Position
Memory that also controls the mirror positions both Port & Starboard, as well as a
collapsible option...and a Back-up feature as well. The GLX owner also gets to enjoy
Climatronic AirConditioning, and for Performance 16" Wheels & Tires are Standard, as
opposed to the GLS which only offers 15".
Contact Greg Stoll @ Larry Roasch VW, 11845 Southwest Highway in Palos Heights, IL.
708-448-6750
Recently, I read in Road & Track or Automobile or Motor Trend that they wondered why anyone would get the V6 over the 1.8L. Personally, I know that the 1.8 gets better gas mileage, 10 HP less than the V6, weighs less, etc... But not being a "car guy", I am not sure if of the benefits of the V6 other than it probably will wear better and is easier to fix (from a mechanics point of view according to a mechanic I know).
Any advice would be appreciated...
Thanks.
KRM
With that said, my wife and I love the V6. I think what you will find is that the performance of both engines will be roughly equal. The 1.8 is probably more "sporty" around town, and will get better mileage in city driving. The V6 will be smoother, quieter, and is most likely the better engine for extended high speed highway cruising. On a recent 2500mile road trip our V6 got over 30mpg cruising at 85-90, which I think is exceptional milage.
Test drive them both, and see which one you like, and whether the V6 is worth the extra money to you. I've heard of many people who are choosing the 1.8 because the differences are so slight.
g20eng
I have the same problem with the short front seat cussion. No thigh support. I've become used to it, but still wish it were better.
I talked to the dealer, and he says there is no way, I could move the postion of the antenna. I know it sounds foolish, but now, I'm rethinking the whole passat buying process just beacuse of the antenna !!!
I noticed that the motor was running at around 1500-1800
rpm at the speed of 70mph. At that point, the turbo would
have not kicked in yet. So the car is very quite.
I agree completely. It's funny how many manufacturers are "copying" VW's FUBA antenna. Example... the new Mazda Protege 5, Honda S2000, etc.
yaob,
Are you sure about that RPM? That is a DRASTIC difference from the previous cars.
My '99 1.8T, 150hp, runs at 2900-3000rpms at 70-75mph in 5th gear (manual). It always has me wishing fo r a 6th gear on long trips... or a taller 5th.
He even stated this is a known VW problem and that they are making pot-pourri smelling cleaning fluid just to remedy this problem...
Does this sound like a line of BS or what?
There is a pink washer fluid that came in my car that smells decent, almost fruity. The blue stuff I always use smells like Windex (amonia) though and I do get a wiff of it when I wash the windshield.
he he! Thought so...