Did you recently take on (or consider) a loan of 84 months or longer on a car purchase?
A reporter would like to speak with you about your experience; please reach out to PR@Edmunds.com by 7/22 for details.
Options

Real-World Trade-In Values

16696706726746751100

Comments

  • kenyuanakenyuana Member Posts: 3
    I need to look into a private sale as I don't have any experience going down that road. Are there any links on this board that may be able to help me? Thanks everyone for your help!
  • kenyuanakenyuana Member Posts: 3
    Yeah I have never really been in an accident other than being rear ended. People need to pay attention when driving. I just want to look into all my options. I was told that a car dealership can use some type of lamp to detect a paint job so that's one of my concerns. As far as the DV I hired an independent appraiser who composed a report. I then submitted it to my insurance company who hired their own independent appraiser. This has been a very depressing situation for me because the car was basically new when hit ... :(
  • [Deleted User][Deleted User] ColoradoPosts: 0
    Looking for a trade value on this one in Denver please...

    2004 Odyssey EX-RES, Auto, V6, FWD, 41K miles, Sage with gray,
    new tires, original brakes, all service done at dealer, body straight, interior needs good cleaning (three kids..) Thanks
  • dash5dash5 Member Posts: 421
    Looking to trade this in:

    Location: New Jersey
    Year/Make/Model: 2004 Infiniti G-35
    Body Style: 2DR / Coupe
    Engine: 3.5L V6 DOHC 24V FI
    Mileage: 38000
    Color: Diamond Graphite / Black (leather)
    Major Options: Automatic, Moon Roof, Premium package, aero kit (spoiler, ground) - No NAV
    Condition: Mechanically meticulous, well kept with records. Has some scuffs and a crack on the front ground effect aero pannels. Was broken into once, lock popped. Never in an accident.

    Other: Would it be worth my while to have the scratches, scuffs repaired? How about the lock that was popped? Will I make that back on trade in?

    Thank you in advance.
  • volvomaxvolvomax Member Posts: 5,238
    VW wagons can be hard to figure.

    I'm thinking somewhere around $13,000
  • volvomaxvolvomax Member Posts: 5,238
    Figure trade in @ $16,000
  • volvomaxvolvomax Member Posts: 5,238
    Under the BEST of circumstances, the online guides are nearly useless.
    None of them use real world auction values, and whatever info they do use is out of date by the time they publish.
    Right now, new car sales are not doing well and that is spliing over into the used car area.
    Dealers, who aren't making any money on new cars are very hesitant to step up on used cars, that they may not be able to sell either.
    Used car wholesalers aren't buying as much as they used to either.
    If you are going to send a car to the auction,it is better to be low than high.
    In your case, the delaer simply didn't think he could retail your trade in, so he bid it accordingly.
    Extra's like leather and chrome wheels on a Camry don't mean anywhere near what they would on say, a BMW.
    Personally, I'd shop around and see what else you can get.
  • volvomaxvolvomax Member Posts: 5,238
    Probably about $1500 low.
    63k is ALOT of miles for a 4 yr old car.
  • volvomaxvolvomax Member Posts: 5,238
    Figure trade in @ $15,000
  • volvomaxvolvomax Member Posts: 5,238
    I would get the lock fixed for sure.
    You should be able to fix the front bumper for a couple hundred as well.

    In its current condition, I'd say its worth $17,000 or so.
    Put back together, maybe $18-19,000.

    Cosmetics really matter in lux cars.
    If a lux car comes in beat up, esp with things that are easily fixable, dealers worry about what else the owner didn't take car of.
    It just sets off alarm bells, and it hurts at trade in time.
  • [Deleted User][Deleted User] ColoradoPosts: 0
    Thank you, nice to know we have a little equity to play with. I appreciate the quick response!
  • richiehrichieh Member Posts: 17
    Thanks for the reply...................dude................you were right on the money............got 2 offers for $14.5K...........................just heard back from one of the dealerships willing to increase their offer to $15.5K...............I don't think I'm going to do any better than that offer.

    Thanks Again!

    Rich
  • iontrapiontrap Member Posts: 139
    Location: Augusta, Ga
    Year/Make/Model:2004 4 Runner SR5
    Engine: 4.0 V6
    Driveline: RWD
    Mileage:60,500
    Color: Gold/Tan
    Condition:
    Interior is in good shape, just needs a good carpet shampoo.
    Exterior is also in good shape, there are a couple of spots on the front bumper that need a little touch up paint.
    Tires - New tires @ 48K, plenty of meat left.
    Maintenance - I changed the oil based on the oil life monitor roughly every 5K.
    Other: It has not been involved in any accidents. The windshield has been replaced.

    I'm considering trading out of my lease early and I'm interested in trade in and private party values.
  • skiguy02920skiguy02920 Member Posts: 11
    providence ri
    1998 toyota corolla ce
    4 door
    manual
    108000K miles
    black exterior, grey interior
    power locks, windows, alarm system
    no accidents, insurance claims, etc
    brakes and clutch 1 yr old
    minor scratches front hood from scraping off ice
    full maintenance records available
    tires 25% worn
  • njexpressnjexpress Member Posts: 170
    Hi,
    I am considering trading in my vehicle to CarMAx. It is a 2002 Honda S2000 with Hard top, 35 K miles, excellent condition, except for a dime sized dent in the passenger side, clean title. I am the third owner, vehicle shows one accident on Carfax from 3 years ago, which did not show at the time I purchased.
    I was made aware of this and seller showed me pics - Minor brush in the driver side hood, fender.
    KBB has it at Excellent- $17,025, Good - $16,090, Fair - $14,430.
    I live in NJ and I am reluctant to take the 125 mile drive to Maryland.
    Any thoughts would help!
    Cheers!!
    --njexpress
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    I doubt they will consider that condition "excellent" given the past repair and the current damage.

    I'm not even sure it would qualify as "good" unless you fix the dent first (that may be worthwhile).

    I bet they lowball you, at or below the Fair value. Car Max has a simple buy low, sell high policy.

    Are you looking at the big Car Max store in Rockville, MD? I live close to them.
  • volvomaxvolvomax Member Posts: 5,238
    Another car w/ lots o miles.
    Trade should be @ $15,000
  • volvomaxvolvomax Member Posts: 5,238
    prob a $2500 car.
    you should sell it yourself.
  • volvomaxvolvomax Member Posts: 5,238
    You are definitely going to at the "fair" end of the scale.
    Car w/ a bad Carfax, repainted hood fender.
    Trade should be in the $14,000 neighborhood.

    Carmax usually offers stupid money for trades, but this is the wrong time of year for a convertible or sports car in the East.
  • njexpressnjexpress Member Posts: 170
    Thanks, Volvomax and ateixeira!
    That bad, Huh? I am looking to go to Rockville. This doesn't sound too encouraging. Even If I averaged at good, I was reluctantly willing to consider. The vehicle looks spanking new, with some 20 coats of zaino detail products on it...
    Bummer.. The vehicle has been in the market 3 weeks with no serious inquiries and it sounds like Carmax will really lowball me..
  • tindallastindallas Member Posts: 9
    Just got back from CarMax today - people coming in non-stop to get appraised, I had a 2004 Honda Odyssey EX-L white 49K miles, very clean, no dents, slight chipped paint on front bumper, came in at $14,000 which is $2,000 lower than my dealer said he would give me on a trade-in. So, I think they are bidding low, but also looking to make a lot of profit on a car like this.

    Good luck all!!
  • woodywwwoodyww Member Posts: 1,806
    third owner, one accident on Carfax

    Questions: do you want to/need to sell? Or can you afford to keep it & drive it summers? It's only "worth what it's worth", & private buyers are gonna hate the accident carfax report at least as much as Carmax will...... regardless of 20 coats of zaino detail products......
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    The new Ody has a $2000 dealer incentive right now, not sure what the long-term repurcissions will be, but residuals may drop a tad.

    Of course this is on left over 2007s, so it's very short-term.
  • njexpressnjexpress Member Posts: 170
    Yes I need to - I will consider purchasing a family car as a replacement. It used to be my summer only car / garage queen in a three car household. My third car just got sold last month after 151K (Camry). I need a family car plus I am in a situation where I cannot afford a third car. So, yes - I need to sell it or trade it in.
    The nasty part is, I have had no serious inquiries at all. If it at least got to a point where a buyer wanted to find out about the accident, I could show them the pictures of the vehicle when in the body shop but, considering the time of the year, I am not getting anywhere :-(
    --njexpress
  • volvomaxvolvomax Member Posts: 5,238
    Like I said, you have 2 problems.
    1 is the time of year
    2 is the Carfax.

    If Carmax hits you @ $14,000 or so, they aren't lowballing you.
    They are paying what the auction would say your car is worth regardless of what some site says.
    The sites don't buy cars. Their info is sometimes worse than useless.
  • njexpressnjexpress Member Posts: 170
    Thanks again, Volvomax. I guess since I can't do anything about the carfax report, I will have to grin and bear it till spring then... What do you think?
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    Wait 'til the first warm spring day, put the top down, and park it in an area with heavy foot traffic. :shades:
  • iontrapiontrap Member Posts: 139
    Thanks volvomax, that's about what I thought it would be.
  • njexpressnjexpress Member Posts: 170
    Thanks! I guess that is what I always wanted to do but I jumped the gun given my present circumstances. Thanks again!
    Cheers!!
    --njexpress
  • soylentgreensoylentgreen Member Posts: 62
    Thanks. That seems kinda low for a trade in. Would it be any higher if I sell the car outright?

    If an Acura dealer appraises it, say $18K, can they buy it at that amount?
  • Mr_ShiftrightMr_Shiftright Member Posts: 64,481
    I'm looking for a fair RETAIL selling price on the following:

    California
    1996 BMW 318iC
    convertible
    1.9 L 4 cylinder 5 speed
    99,000 miles
    black on black
    fully loaded
    nice clean car all around
    good records
    clean CARFAX

    Seller wants $7,500, I think he's high, he insists no.
  • british_roverbritish_rover Member Posts: 8,502
    My gut says he is a couple of grand high but I am in the wrong part of the country at the wrong time of year to be more accurate then that.
  • volvomaxvolvomax Member Posts: 5,238
    If an Acura dealer appraises it, say $18K, can they buy it at that amount?

    Well, that depends.
    Sometimes appraisals are just overallowances to get you to buy a new car from that dealer.
    Other times, it is actual cash value.
    You would have to ask the Acura dealer if they had an interest in buying your car outright, even if you didn't want a new Acura.
  • volvomaxvolvomax Member Posts: 5,238
    Kelley retail is $8200, so he is certainly asking all the money.
    If the car was PERFECT, I'd be thinking $6000 at the most.
    But, its probably closer to a $5k car.
  • Mr_ShiftrightMr_Shiftright Member Posts: 64,481
    It's a nice car. He's dropped down from $8900! I see the owner's point about being rewarded for all his good care, but enough's enough.

    Thanks for the numbers. I suppose premium price for premium car isn't so dumb but I think $7K sounds about tops after being here in the consultation room.
  • british_roverbritish_rover Member Posts: 8,502
    Glad to see my instincts are still pretty good.
  • Mr_ShiftrightMr_Shiftright Member Posts: 64,481
    Well I think $6K is really FMV but extra nice cars often squeak past that.
  • woodywwwoodyww Member Posts: 1,806
    So, yes - I need to sell it or trade it in.

    I guess since I can't do anything about the carfax report, I will have to grin and bear it till spring then...


    My opinion: you say you "need to sell", so drive it to carmax, & hope they give you the $14K Volvomax has mentioned. How much more will it be worth Next Spring, with the accident, the carfax, & 6 months older by then??? (The carfax report will still be there next Spring)........
  • njexpressnjexpress Member Posts: 170
    Hi,
    Edmunds says the invoice is 27413 plus 660 destination.
    Carmax, Carsdirect and actual dealer (at least one I contacted) are off by $590, at 28,659.
    Carsdirect goes on to say the following:
    What are the three prices that you show for each car?
    CarsDirect.com Target Price is for research purposes only. It reflects a typical, negotiated price (before taxes and other customary fees and charges, such as dealer documentation fees, tire and battery disposal fees, license and registration, and where applicable, finance charges) generally found in your area for the vehicle that you selected. The Target Price is NOT a price quote from CarsDirect.com or any other dealer. If you request a price quote from a dealer via CarsDirect.com, your price may differ.

    Invoice is popularly known as the published amount that the dealer paid the manufacturer for the vehicle. This may or may not bear close relation to the dealer’s actual cost, but can be useful as a benchmark. This figure is available on many other web sites however only CarsDirect.com adds an estimate of local and regional fees from manufacturer to the dealers to this price, which makes it very close to the actual sticker invoice amount for cars at your local dealer. No other source has this level of detail. Most other sources of Invoice are not accurate.

    An estimate of these manufacturer to dealers fees (such as an advertising fee) is provided for each car and is added to the Invoice to make this figure as accurate as possible. We make this estimate for most cars in most regions, there are some regions and vehicles for which we do not have estimates of these fees.

    For this model, we have added $586.30 to the Invoice to represent these fees.

    The local dealer quote, AND CARMAX quote, along with Cars direct quote are higher?
    Since when did these fees get grouped under Invoice???? Are they passing off their fees to buyer??
    Please advice.
    Thanks.
    --njexpress
  • volvomaxvolvomax Member Posts: 5,238
    Most manufacturers bill their dealers for advertising on a per car basis.
    This charge is usually printed on the invoice.
    It is as real a charge as the destination fee or sunroof, or any option on the car.
    Because advertising costs vary from region to region there is no universal charge.
    Consequently, national websites and buying services don't quote it(but they DO let you know the charges exist)
    Toyota also may have some additional regional fees, depending on the distributorship.

    The web sites and services are not meant to provide bottom dollar quotes, but only general information.
  • steine13steine13 Member Posts: 2,825
    It's a nice car. He's dropped down from $8900! I see the owner's point about being rewarded for all his good care, but enough's enough.

    Not only is enough enough, it's also a 4cyl BMW, and a model that sold so dismally in the US that it was discontinued.

    I'm about the last guy to insist I need a six-cylinder, but the fact is that the BMW four sounds like a pepper mill in high gear, and that any BMW inline six is a wonderfully sweet engine.

    So if I'm ever gonna get a Bimmer, which isn't all that likely, it's got to be a six. I fail to see the point of a 318, and I don't understand why anyone would pay a premium for one. Supposedly it handles well, but the suspension setup was from the previous generation, so it's 15-year-old technology now. About the only thing it's got going for it is the roundel... for those who are into badges...

    -Mathias
  • njexpressnjexpress Member Posts: 170
    Thanks, Volvomax - The deal kind of fiizzled out after the dealer wouldn't remove the doc fees. I genuinely appreciate your input though!
    --njexpress
  • malibuskimalibuski Member Posts: 3
    I am working on a deal with a private seller right now on a one owner 2006 Armada SE 4x4

    Its about has loaded as an SE can get, Dvd, moonroof, leather , 8 pass, tow package , clear bra etc. 13,000 Miles. One owner, no accidents not smoker.

    We are at 26,750 right now.

    What do you think. Good deal or should be less?

    What would the real world trade in value be?
  • Mr_ShiftrightMr_Shiftright Member Posts: 64,481
    Well a 318 is good on gas. It was the wrong car at the wrong time. I bet you'll see more 4s from BMW.
  • volvomaxvolvomax Member Posts: 5,238
    I would bet against that,at least in the US.

    Even the 1 Series comes w/ an I6
  • volvomaxvolvomax Member Posts: 5,238
    Depending on where you are, wholesale is @ $24,000
    So, the seller isn't being outrageous.
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    Make sure to drive it on the highway and listen for that buffeting noise from the roof and early Armada owners complained about.

    In some cases Nissan removed the headliner and added bracing on the roof, IIRC.
  • volvomaxvolvomax Member Posts: 5,238
    "Added bracing to the roof"??

    Great.
    In a rollover that trucks gotta fold up like an empty beer can. :sick:
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    Something like that.

    I know that had to remove the headliners on some of them to get the noise to stop. I'd be afraid of shakes and rattles, not to mention proper fit on the headliner.

    Just inspect the headliner closely and listen for the buffeting sound.
  • woodywwwoodyww Member Posts: 1,806
    I'd just ask the OP, or anyone here, what would an equivilent year/model 3 series convert. with a 6 cyl. sell for? Maybe if you could save 20-25% by getting the 4 cyl., it could be worth it. Maybe. I did know a guy who sold his WRX for an early 90's 4 cyl. 3 series, & he really liked it, even after the WRX.

    The only 4 cyl. bmw I ever drove was a new E30 318is--it was great fun to drive, & like $19K new I think?. Not the Monster that I recall the then 325is being, but priced a lot less new.....

    'Course now, I'd just pay extra (if any) for a 10-20 y.o. 6 cyl. bmw vs. a 4, all things being sort of equal.....
Sign In or Register to comment.