BMW 3-Series 2005 and earlier

1186187189191192585

Comments

  • bwmbwm Member Posts: 11
    Hey when is the Speedvision rebroadcast? That will be much, much better than the ABC crew. It is difficult doing the broadcast with the F1 World
    feed and not knowing what will come next but they were really bad. I had to laugh, on two occasions Cheever said "Lets just listen to what's going on" then proceeded to go in to such long explanations about what we were going to hear that before he was finished both times the camera had changed to something else.
  • brave1heartbrave1heart Member Posts: 2,698
    I'm glad to hear that at least one more person loves BOTH CART and F1. To me, they are different flavors of the same ice cream and both taste great. Oh, I think WWF and NASCAR should merge and form a joint league. This way I'd have to make sure I only need to skip one event instead of two :o) Their audiences seem to be very similar so it would make it more convenient for them as well.
  • bmw323isbmw323is Member Posts: 410
    The latest issue of CR tested the 530i against an A6, MB 320 and a Jag S-type. Of course the BMW was the best, but it became their "top rated car ever." I know some of you don't think much of CR, but I appreciate their ability for total objectivity (unlike the car mags). So what if their average testers' age is 76! By the way, 0-60 in 7.2 seconds with an automatic, no sport package. Almost as fast as my lowly 323.
  • gurumikegurumike Member Posts: 442
    Just didn't seem possible that Jason would be doing something like that. Guess that's ABC's genius managements idea.
    Sure I can root for Ferrari ! I did say I wanted McLaren to DNF - that was so the BMW engine team would pass MBZ !
  • tenet1tenet1 Member Posts: 354
    Anyone. At what point was the steering changed back to the original heavy feel on the 2001 models??

    People talk of the heavy steering feel on this forum, but my steering feels quite light. I own a July Production 2001 325i.

    Thanks
  • jasonkureejiijasonkureejii Member Posts: 210
    This is the quote I received from BMWNA when I asked them to sign me up for the retro fit:

    "The model of vehicle that you indicated in your correspondence, a 2001 BMW 325i , was produced with the steering feel that the steering equipment level change provides."

    I have a post June 1st production model 325i....the steering seems to be quite light, but I have grown quite accustomed to it. I hope you've found yours to be as intoxicating as I have!
  • gurumikegurumike Member Posts: 442
    Oh God - is the troll king back with a new spin on his name ?! Look - I subscribe to that one, if you go back and look again, the S4 came out first, WRX second and 330xi third. Quite frankly the only thing I thought was weird was that the S4 came out first. My placing might have been: 1. WRX 2. 330xi 3. S4.
    Tough to pick between the Subaru's explosive, addictive performance and hero inducing driveability and the BMWs perfect to live with everyday, never puts a foot wrong perfection. But I'm not so sure about the 'Oh God, 6 months old and creeks and rattles from all round the car' and 'sorry honey, I can't do that because I've got to take the car to the shop, again' ownership experience one should expect from the Audi.
    I assume that you were aCuLeX in a previous life, right !?
  • tenet1tenet1 Member Posts: 354
    Since my 325 was produced in SA in July, I assume it got the original "pre-2001" steering, but I might call to doublecheck anyway.

    Overall, I like my steering a lot but was wondering about the so-called "heavy feel", because mine certainly is not heavy.

    Thanks
  • shiposhipo Member Posts: 9,148
    My understanding is that the best (heaviest) of the 2001 steering (Production or Retrofit) is still lighter than the 1999 and 2000 cars. While drivers used to cars without powersteering would not consider mine heavy, my 1999 328i certainly cannot be parked with just one finger. Maybe the next time I get up to Boston, Brave1heart and I can swap cars for a few miles and give y'all a definitive answer.

    Best Regards,
    Shipo
  • derprofiderprofi Member Posts: 250
    Careful gurumike, As far as I can tell, Pat will delete your post if you so much as think the name of another Edmunds member in all but the most glowing terms :) Never mind that the shoe usually fits. You might also want to get ready for personal emails from some self-righteous lurkers who aren't familiar with the vernacular usage of the term "troll" and instead think you're acusing hondaculexota of being a smallish, ugly, wart-covered person living under a bridge

    tenet1, that's still a pretty good rate you got and would indicate to me that your dealer tacked on their extra 1% of pure profit (which is their option) to the 4.9% BMW rate. I talked to the finance guy at Passport this morning and confirmed that the 4.9% (5.9%) rate is for MY 2001 leftovers only. The best they could do for me on a 2002 was 7.75% (6.75%+1) so I told them I'd have to pass. I think I can get a rate better than that at my bank, and better still from my credit union. On the car, I was able to negotiate $1400 over ED invoice price.
  • shiposhipo Member Posts: 9,148
    I just picked up my car from the dealership sporting new front control arms (I still have no idea why) and a new seatbelt tensioner, which works great I might add. Sitting out in front was a 2002 330xi, Titanium Silver Metallic, Premium Package, Step, Xenon and Cold Weather Package. I walked around it several times and would like to offer a few comments. Overall, it will be very hard to visually distinguish this car from a pre-2002 model; however, there are a few queues that one can see.

    The front of the car is the most obvious change what with the new headlight openings, grill, bumper and pinhead fog lights. I must admit, after looking at the pictures of the 2002, I was pretty sure that I would hang on to my 1999 when the lease expires next spring, however, I REALLY like the new light openings and grill. Those feelings do not include the new slab, uh, air damn, uh, I mean uh, front bumper, I think it looks a little tacky. Never the less, I actually like the new overall look on the nose of this car (the jury is still out on a 330i SP).

    From the rear, the only real change is the taillight assembly, which has the amber turn signal moved from the top to the middle, still amber. My guess is that the bottom of the assembly is for standard taillights, the middle is now the Reverse (outside) and turn signal (inside) and the top is the brake lights. Overall, I like the look.

    The only clue from the side of the car that this was a 2002 was the body side crease, up until now, said crease traveled forward from the taillight assembly all of the way to the headlight assembly. As of 2002, said crease travels only as far forward as the rear of the front wheel well. This change is one that I am ambivalent about; I just cannot get too worked up about it either way.

    One interesting item of note, I noticed a new button located on the button strip just above the ashtray. It featured a pictogram showing a car proceeding down a steep grade, I assume that this is the button to activate the “Hill Decent Control” system that I heard was going to make its debut here in the USA on the 2002 model.

    Best Regards,
    Shipo
  • tenet1tenet1 Member Posts: 354
    Shipo-You are right about the lighter feel even with the older steering. This is the sense I get from reading all the posts and then driving my car. I will, however, give my car the "park-with-one-finger" test.

    Derprofi - Either my dealer took me for a 1% ride or they may not have given me the 4.9% since mine was a pre-ordered/pre-sold car and not a 2001 left over. Either way, I guess 5.9% is not bad at all.
  • jasonkureejiijasonkureejii Member Posts: 210
    what some of the leftover '01 3ers are going for at the lots...
  • brave1heartbrave1heart Member Posts: 2,698
    Shipo, I'd be most happy to switch cars with you next time you make it to Boston. How far is Albany from where you live in NJ? I think NYC is 130 miles from Albany - if we meet halfway, I'm guessing it would be about a one-hour drive for each of us, as long as there's no heavy traffic.

    As far as the steering, I have driven a '99 323 with the original heavy steering, a 2001 July build 330, and of course, my '01 325, which was built at the end of March with the boosted steering and now has the steering retrofit. Here's how I rate them in terms of steering weight from heaviest to lightest:

    '99 323
    My '01 325 retrofitted
    '01 July build 330
    My '01 325 before the retrofit

    The difference was smallest between the '01 July build 330 and my '01 325 before the retrofit. In other words, the post-June fix (same as the one '02 models will have) is closer to the boosted steering than it is to the retrofitted steering. Also, the retrofit is not as heavy as the original heavy steering (still love it, though!!).
  • brave1heartbrave1heart Member Posts: 2,698
    I read the C&D article when it came out a 3-4 weeks ago and I thought it was very well written. For me personally, it would be a tossup between all these 3 great cars. I really think I could be happy with any one of them (if I wanted an AWD, that is). The primary reason why the 330xi lost is because BMWNA does not offer it with a true performance sport package. It doesn't help that the S4 is much better equipped for the money. The WRX is a great competitor and honestly, I doubt I'd pay 15 grand extra for the 330xi or the S4. There's no denying that both of them are much better equipped but 15-grand better? Keep in mind that the performance numbers (acceleration, braking, and handling) are very similar between the 3 cars and the WRX also has a great engine sound and road feel.
  • brave1heartbrave1heart Member Posts: 2,698
    I doubt that there are too many '01 models left on dealer lots but it may be possible to find good deals on color/option combinations that are not very popular. Oh, I priced my 5-month old 325i with 7K miles on it on Carpoint and came up with a value of 34.5K. I bought for 31.5K. Go figure...
  • shiposhipo Member Posts: 9,148
    I just priced my 2.5 year old 328i with 30,000 miles. My negotiated price was about $36,500 and the Carpoint site shows the following:

    Suggested Retail: $34,060

    Not a bad idea, according to mapquest.com, it is 127 miles from my house to Albany, maybe a long lunch in the next couple of weeks.

    Best Regards,
    Shipo
  • tenet1tenet1 Member Posts: 354
    Since I will eventually have to wash my now 1-week old silver 325i later this week, I wanted to get advice on products/methods that you all have used to wash your car.

    I am looking for a good soap for the car and any product for the wheels (that will not stain) and a good quality sponge and brush (for the wheels). Any help is appreciated. I guess I dont feel like taking it through a car wash just yet.

    Thanks
  • iam0378iam0378 Member Posts: 10
    Is the Vehicle Inventory Tax something that the dealer should consider a cost of doing business? Or is this a legitimate customer-paid tax? Also, what is the best way to negotiate out of a dealer services fee? My dealer is charging almost $400 and all signals point to the "pay it or someone else will" stance. Has anyone received anything in return for this fee, lifetime detailing, extended warranty/servicing, etc.?
  • dave330idave330i Member Posts: 893
    take it to the local car wash that'll hand wash and dry. It's not that expensive, plus pretty quick.
  • brave1heartbrave1heart Member Posts: 2,698
    Vehicle Inventory Tax is NOT a legitimate fee. The only fee passed down to the consumer is MACO, which would vary by geographic area (typically $100-500). Do NOT pay anything other thean MACO and a reasonable fee for document processing ($100-150). If your dealer insists on it, they don't deserve your business and I'd take it somewhere else.
  • shiposhipo Member Posts: 9,148
    In my above post about the 330xi that I saw this morning, I made the following statement:

    "From the rear, the only real change is the taillight assembly, which has the amber turn signal moved from the top to the middle, still amber. My guess is that the bottom of the assembly is for standard taillights, the middle is now the Reverse (outside) and turn signal (inside) and the top is the brake lights. Overall, I like the look."

    Well, almost. Actually, the Reverse lights are on the inside of the middle amber band mounted on the trunk lid. The turn signal lights are mounted on the outside (so as to wrap around to the side of the car) mounted on the body portion of the light assembly.

    Best Regards,
    Shipo
  • derprofiderprofi Member Posts: 250
    shipo, wow I haven't seen a 2002 "in the flesh" yet. What a pity the one you saw didn't have the SP! I ordered one sight-unseen and I'd love to find out what the SP actually looks like before I get to Munich.

    tenet1, if you got a 2002 for 5.9% then I think that's a great deal. Like I said, the best I was offered today through the dealer was 7.75% :(

    aculex, very few here know you but I'm sure many know of you. As long as you don't troll, you're definitely welcome! And my comments to gurumike were merely to relate a recent personal experience. Re: the WRX, the best line I've read about the car was actually today. It went something like, "The only problem with the WRX is that I can't get past the looks. It's like an ugly (guy/girl) with a fantastic personality. You want to date (him/her) but you just can't bring yourself to do it!" Still, I'd love to take one for a spin just for S&G.
  • brucec35brucec35 Member Posts: 246
    I would buy the new 2002 325i and spend 2-3K more, rather than taking a risk on a 3 model year old 328i. Other than a slight performance difference, the 325i seems a better deal. Why?

    1. The '99 was the first model year for the newest iteration of the 3 series (E46?) Potential teething troubles.

    2. Can't remember if yours was an auto or not, but I think the '99's did not have steptronic.

    3. The economy is tanking and new car prices (even BMW) will start to drop off soon. The typical demographic on 3 series buyers is "nuevo riche" 20 and 30 somethings who have good jobs and want to spend some of their newfound money. They are usually the first to go in corporate layoffs. I suspect you will see 3 series sedans selling for $1000 less than "the norm" of the last few years. Higher level 5 and 7 series buyers are less affected by economic fluctuations.

    4. There is always a significant degree of risk inherent in a used car, warranty or not. Time spent getting it fixed is a pain regardless of if you pay for it or not. Buying new means those problems that fall between the warranty cracks get fixed.

    5. You get the first 36K mi of service free on a new one.

    6. You may get free loaner cars from your dealer if you buy new. Not sure on the CPO.

    7. I think you're saving roughly $10,000 off what the original '99 328i owner paid. That's only $3,333 for each year of use. Not much of a bargain to me.

    8. Resale: A new 325i will have 60,000 mi on it in 4 years of avg use, and be readily marketable. A '99 328i would be out of the CPO warranty and have over 100K mi, I assume. I found when trying to sell my '97 540i that NOBODY wants to pay a good price for a high mileage BMW. Potential repair costs mean that your car becomes a $12,000 car, no matter how nice it's running. Also, it's harder for a buyer to get financed on the 7 y/o car you'd be selling. Usually people buy based on payments (dumb, but true). They often just go buy a new car and finance for 72 mo rather than for 36 mo on your used model. Cars w/ lower mileage/age can often be financed more easily.

    9. 2002 sedans are restyled somewhat. It might look "newer" to a buyer down the line, when you're ready to resell.

    10. Resale value is just too good on the 328i's to make it a good used car purchase right now. One big advantage of buying used is that you can buy from a private seller and avoid sales tax (at least here in GA). Buying CPO means you still pay the sales tax. You will also be paying a much higher price for a BMW dealer's CPO car than you would from a private seller, even if you also purchase an aftermarket used car warranty.
  • shiposhipo Member Posts: 9,148
    "1. The '99 was the first model year for the newest iteration of the 3 series (E46?) Potential teething troubles."

    Oddly enough, the 1999 and the 2000 model year cars have actually had less problems than the 2001 cars. The fan recall business has been something of a pain for many of our members who own/lease 2001 325i and 330i automobiles.

    In my case, I have had two $2.00 taillight bulbs fail on my 1999 328i with 30,000 miles on it. I would say that is unusually good for a first year car, regardless of manufacturer. Based upon my participation on this board (off and on) for over three years now, I would say that my experience with my 1999 is not atypical.

    Best Regards,
    Shipo
  • derprofiderprofi Member Posts: 250
    all evening for some picture, any picture, of the sport package on the US '02 330i--not the Euro version with the M aero kit, the US one. For some reason there don't seem to be pix anywhere. Even the fellows at bimmer.org are all clamoring for someone to post one. But unless I've missed a post somewhere, no one has any pix despite the fact that '02s are being delivered right now to the lucky ones who were first in line. Is this some kind of cover-up? :)

    The BMWUSA web site now has the '02 plugged into the "Build your 3er" utility. However, although the wheels show the proper change to Type 68M when one selects the SP, the front end doesn't change one bit. Huh? Tomorrow morning on my way to work I'm planning a detour out to Fairfax BMW with my digicam to see if I can catch a glimpse of this elusive beast.
  • edward5555edward5555 Member Posts: 15
    What's the better deal folks, A 2000 323ci (coupe)(pp,leather,Step) for $29,500 or a 2000 323i sedan (pp, sp, leather, Step) for 28,500? Any opinions on the coupe vs the sedan? All input appreciated. Thanks

    Easy Ed
  • jrc330jrc330 Member Posts: 15
    I was at BMW of Peabody yesterday and they had a black 2002 330XI with Sport Package. The front end looks just like the 2001 SP with the slightly larger round fogs then the new 2002 face and a more aggressive air dam. It looks really good, but not as good as what the Europeans are getting with the M II Aerodynamic package that looks just like the front end of an M3 with minor differences. It also did not have white lights as my early literature said it would.

    I have a 330I SP on order for early Nov delivery, so I am still holding out hope that the white lights will be included on the 330's, but after seing the 330XI SP, I would say that once again the US market is not getting the best looking options.

    We will see.
  • merckxmerckx Member Posts: 565
    Design is always subjective,but I do think the coupe is really a stunning car. You do give up a great deal of back seat space,though,to the point it is almost unusable for adults. The driver also loses a small amount of headroom-you might have to consider foregoing a sunroof.
    Overall,the sedan is quite nice,but the coupe is really outstanding.
  • shiposhipo Member Posts: 9,148
    I think I remember reading somewhere (I have no idea where) that the "M" aero package for the 330i was to be different than that of the 330xi for model year 2002.

    Does anybody else remember such?

    Best Regards,
    Shipo
  • kominskykominsky Member Posts: 850
    I have a 'Ci' and, not too long ago, got an 'i' as a loaner car. I agree with most of what merckx said except for the back seat space. It's harder to get into the coupe and the seats are 'sculpted' on the sides so getting three adults in there would be very tight in the hips, but I've had many different adults in the back seat and have never heard a complaint (were they just being polite? maybe).

    The coupe 'feels' sportier because of the lower seating position. The only other issue I would raise is the length of the doors. If you park in tight quarters, the coupe can be a little scarey during ingress and egress.
  • edward5555edward5555 Member Posts: 15
    I agree with you guys about the coupe. The sedan is nice, but the coupe is stunning. Perhaps I am being dramatic about this, but I think the current iteration of the coupe is one of the best looking street cars EVER (highly subjective of course) I just think that every now and then, a design comes along that endures with time (Jaguar, Bentley, Aston Martin to name a few), and at think the 3 series coupe could be one of those cars. Maybe I'm being too dramatic though. I guess although I love the coupe, I didn't want to get it, and then trade it in a year or two because it was impractical. Kominsky, how is the visibility for drivers given the lower profile of the car? (given that I'm only 5'9). Of course I'll need to drive it, but sometimes when you are test driving, the excitement clouds your long term judgment. Thanks

    Ed
  • dave330idave330i Member Posts: 893
    if you get the sedan with SP, it looks quite aggressive as well. The coupe front/back, and M wheels makes it really stand out.
  • tchootchoo Member Posts: 93
    I have a coupe and I find the visibility to be excellent. I don't even notice its lower when I switch between the coupe and a Camry. The narrow B and C pillars provide a great all round view with minimal blind spots. Head room is also more than adequate for me (6'1). The rear seats are ok for 2 adults, but getting in/out is a hassle. And you really have to be flexible to reach for the seatbelts.
  • jrc330jrc330 Member Posts: 15
    I have the 2002 delaer sales guide and it just says M aerodynamic package for the 330XI and 330I but it does not differentiate between the two. I would be very interested in hearing if anyone has seen a 2002 330I SP yet? It seems like all the late August Builds and early September builds just started arriving at the dealers this week. Mabey someone out there has seen one.
  • jasonkureejiijasonkureejii Member Posts: 210
    I must say that I find the coupe to be more "stunning" as well. From the back at different angles, the slope of the roofline towards the tail creates a more sportier look....by intent. I can't say I've been in one, however, I can only assume that entrance into the back seat wouldn't be as convenient, obviously. I bought the sedan instead almost solely for that convenience. I've had 3 back there a few times, and no real complaints, except for my abrupt driving now and then. I've always been the driver when I go out with friends, and the sedan is definitely a plus. Hopefully, I will have a couple of little ones back there in the near future as well. But with the SP and (this will be very subjective!) steel gray w/black interior, I find my sedan to be almost as sporty-looking. Oeverall, you really can't go wrong with either!
  • kominskykominsky Member Posts: 850
    I'm also 5'9" (okay, maybe a little closer to 5'8") and I don't have a problem with visibility. My proportions are all kinds of screwed up, though. I have very short legs and a long torso so my seated vantage point is probably similar to someone much taller than I am. I would recommend that on your next test drive, have your fun but save the last mile or so for concentrating on issues such as this.
  • dgodwin1dgodwin1 Member Posts: 1
    I was wondering if any one has any suggestions regarding purchasing a 2002 325i? I have spoken with my local dealer and they said the most I could get off the sticker price was $500 because of the vast demand. If anyone has any suggestions on local dealers they have dealt with in the area or sales people, it would be much appreciated.
  • mfeldmanmfeldman Member Posts: 140
    I posted my nagging steering question on the e46 board and got the following response. What do you guys think?

    Question:

    I got the retrofit primarily because there was a steering imbalance, with less effort required to turn left than right. With the retro, everything is heavier. But there still appears to be an imbalance, tho not as much as before.

    Its not noticeable when turning from a stop at a light. It appears at speed when taking gentle 5 to 30 degree curves. Another way to describe it is that the dead spot is off center 5 to 10 degrees to the left, while ther is immediate resistance even a couple of degrees to the right.

    The alignment seems ok, maybe a slight tendency to drift right, but it could be road crown sensitivity.

    What the hell is this? Tires? Can I cross rotate the fronts?

    Something other than the steering rack?

    ANy ideas?

    Response:

    Sounds like too much toe-in makes the car hyper-sensitive to turning, even though it steers straight... imagine front wheels are like this /\ instead of like this ||. Or in your case, it steers too easy to the right, it may be like this /|... just my opinion...

    BTW although I have the sedan, I have to admit that the coupe looks better-- longer and sleeker.
  • iam0378iam0378 Member Posts: 10
    Thanks. What exactly is the VIT tax, though, and what is MACO? I live in Texas.
  • silverprincesssilverprincess Member Posts: 75
    I posted the same message in Smart Shopper/BMW Certified Preowned, but I'll repeat it here in case anyone finds this useful...

    I took delivery of a CPO 1999 323i about a month ago and my advice to any buyer is on the day you take delivery at the dealership, make sure that the dealer parks the car under direct sunlight when you're doing your final inspection!!! Mine is jet black and I was too excited and gullible to let the dealer park the car in-doors where the lighting was not good enough to detect all the dings in the paint and other imperfections. Make sure to check the underbody carriage also as I found that on my car, the front, rear and sides all had paint scratches. Although I accepted the dealer's argument that under the CPO program, they are not responsible for paint "under the vehicle" (I still don't know if this is true or not), and the fact that I purchased my car in San Francisco (horrible terrain and potholes), and the fact that it has the Sport Package (ie. lower suspension), I nevertheless crawled underneath the car and looked VERY carefully and had the him put it down IN WRITING on the paperwork (what's called a "DUE BILL") for me to bring the car back on another day to be worked on. Believe me, it would be VERY hard to convince the dealership to do any touch ups (especially body related work) if you found out the imperfections after-the-fact, after you've driven off the dealer lot! My salesperson was cooperative to do the work and honest too by telling me that he was glad that I noticed the problems off the bat. All in all, it has been a wonderful experience so far - I love the 1999 heavy steering, handling, agility, and the drop dead gorgeous look of my 323i 4dr sedan/ manual/SP/jet black/sand interior/moonroof/rear- folding seats.
  • iam0378iam0378 Member Posts: 10
    I got $750 off a coupe but they want to charge for mats. We'll see.... My current car runs like a champ, so I don't "need" a new car, just would like one. I fully expecting to walk on this deal if they don't take of mats. Charging for mats on 40K is outright robbery.
  • brave1heartbrave1heart Member Posts: 2,698
    You make some great points in your 328 vs. 325 post. I just wanted to add that contrary to popular belief, the average 3-series owner's age is 43.

    "I found when trying to sell my '97 540i that NOBODY wants to pay a good price for a high mileage BMW. " - This is true for the 5-series and especially the 7-series but less so for the 3-series. The 3-series are popular among a much wider consumer group and are more marketable, all else equal. I bought mine new for the same reasons that you describe and I am planning on driving it into the ground (200,000 miles or 10 years, whichever comes first). However, if the 4-year old used 3-series value remains that high AND there are new exciting models that I am interested in, I might consider upgrading in 4-5 years. I think 90% I'll stick with my 325i regardless of my financial situation.
  • brave1heartbrave1heart Member Posts: 2,698
    I also think the coupe looks better. I like the longer-looking, sleek body and especially those long, narrow reflectors in the front and back. The sedan looks great but there is something about the overall shape of the coupe that makes it stand out a little more. Having said this, I chose the sedan because:

    - the coupe's roofline is a little lower and we felt like we had more headroom in the sedan, especially with a sunroof (I am 6'1).
    - the windshield's slope is 2 degrees steeper than the sedan's and I like a more vertical windshield when I'm sitting in the driver's seat. It's not as good ergonomics-wise
    - visibility - Because the B-pillar is pushed further back, visibility immediately to the left is a little better in the coupe. However, when I maneuver fast, what really matters to me is visibility behind me, looking over my shoulder. Well, there isn't much of it in the coupe because the B-pillar is far back.
    - doors - They are heavy as they are in the sedan. The coupe's doors are much longer and therefore much heavier. Not to mention that parking in tighter spots would be a pain.
    - Seat belt: it is pushed way back there in the coupe and you have to stretch unnaturally far to reach it. Pain for the driver and the passenger.
    - The sedan is a more mature-looking car. I am 32 and would not like to be in the category most popular with 23-year olds.
    - Insurance rates for the coupe are higher than those for the sedan (I did check with my insurance company)
    - With a sedan, you are more likely to get away without a ticket if you get pulled over and are more unlikely to get pulled over in the first place.
    - BMW invented the sports SEDAN segment, not the sports coupe segment.
    - Attaching a baby seat back there would be a royal pain. Shoving passengers in and out would be almost as inconvenient.

    In short, the Coupe looks better, sportier; the sedan is more of a mature, family car. They both perform phenomenally well.
  • brave1heartbrave1heart Member Posts: 2,698
    $500 is probably the best you could get right now. All new model year cars are typically pre-ordered and the dealers can charge more money for them. If you get a little more than $500, there would probably be additional fees that all translate into $500 off or better. You'd have to wait till the Spring to get a deal that is $1,500-2,000 off invoice + freebies like mats. It was worth the wait for me last year, plus your car doesn't take a beating all winter long.
  • bavarianbavarian Member Posts: 63
    In Chicago I park every day on the highest deck of an indoor parking lot,next to a silver 330 coupe and a black 330 convertible. Both handsome cars as is the shiny green 325i snuggling between them...15,800 miles and no door dings!

    The coupe is a sleek looking car and I love the shape, the profile,the long door handles whether Myrtle or Titanium,the lower more agressive stance etc.

    When I build my BMW on the website I most often build coupes but there is only one caveat and that concerns getting into and out of the car for rear seat passengers.

    The front seats will ingeniously move out of the way,which is a help,but in my case, I do occasionally carry passengers on opera nights and country trips-one of them being an 80 year old lady (who adores the car by the way and gets a kick out of riding at 100mph) and so I have concerns about loading passengers,particularly in heavy rain where the doors will be open for longer than is optimal as the front seat passenger has to step out and wait while the rear seat passenger embarks.

    Does any coupe owner have regrets in such circumstances?

    The coupe is indeed a beauty-but the sedan is hardly a "dog"
  • twoof1twoof1 Member Posts: 308
    I also debated this very seriously prior to my sedan purchase. Here are my reasons for going with the sedan:
    1. The coupe doors (virtually any coupe) are HUGE when trying to open in tight spaces.
    2. Dealers are less willing to deal on a coupe.
    3. Insurance.
    4. I am in and out of the back seat constantly (loading and unloading printing proofs and briefcase) having to raise and reset the seat was a hassle
    5. Headroom
    Having said all that I almost went ahead and bought the coupe because I LOVE the lines and look.
    I am glad in hindsight that I didn't buy the coupe but that is only because of my needs and criteria. I still give every coupe driver a thumbs up when I see them.
    Performance wise I don't think you would find any difference between a sedan with the SP and a coupe with the SP.
  • rizzo7rizzo7 Member Posts: 8
    iam0378-i also was in the market for a 02 330 back in august, and live in the downstate NY area. Anyway, a buddy of mine referred me to his dealer (where he got 2 M3s) - I think Gallery BMW in boston. I gave the salesperson a call, and he was just not willing to even talk about an 02, and was instead trying to jam me into an 01 he had left over, and that too at a mere $1k off MSRP. Instead, that weekend I ended up just going to my local dealer here, Wide World of Cars in Spring Valley, NY, and we easily agreed to an 02 330i at invoice +1500+MACO (200) - easiest purchase I've ever made with a really nice guy, and a great price to boot. So, i guess it really matters by market, but I've heard many doing much better than your guy.

    If you want, I can give you a referral to WW if you were willing to order in NY. Good luck.
  • topspin627topspin627 Member Posts: 67
    I love the coupe but I bought 330i sedan with sp.
    I think it looks richer and I actually like the lines better which seems to put me in the minority. I love having a car that is much faster than it looks. As an earlier post mentioned, the coupe is a big hit with the 25 and under set so as I'm in the mid 40's range, I too believe that it is a little more mature looking.
    Both are great looking but to me the sedan is a bit more understated yet with sp still looks "mean" enough. Oh, and the practicality is a big plus for me.
  • skobolaskobola Member Posts: 207
    I prefer the sedan, and I bought it in 99, when coupes were not available. But even now, I would go for the sedan, although I drive alone most of the time, so I could use the coupe as well. But I like the sedan primarily because of its stealthness. I believe that sedan performs as well as the coupe, especially when having SP. In my view, the coupe is kind of obvious in reminding you that it is a fast, mean machine while the sedan looks like an ordinary car, with subtle hints of its performance. And, I believe that we will all agree that they perform oh-so-well...
Sign In or Register to comment.

Your Privacy

By accessing this website, you acknowledge that Edmunds and its third party business partners may use cookies, pixels, and similar technologies to collect information about you and your interactions with the website as described in our Privacy Statement, and you agree that your use of the website is subject to our Visitor Agreement.