BMW 3-Series 2005 and earlier

1563564566568569585

Comments

  • blackiblacki Member Posts: 6
    I meant bulb burns out. By the way, I was quoted $875 for a 60000 mile schedule II maintenance by the dealer I am thinking about trading with. That alone infuriates me with the BMW. I remember now why I sold my BMW1200LTC cycle and bought an 1800 Honda Goldwing. Same price handles just as well and far exceeds in power and dependability, service at a fraction of the BMW service costs. :mad:
  • div2div2 Member Posts: 2,580
    By the way, I was quoted $875 for a 60000 mile schedule II maintenance by the dealer I am thinking about trading with.

    That's ridiculous; the most that I ever paid a dealer for an Inspection II(including a coolant service) was $700. My last Inspection II cost $357 at my independent BMW tech- and that price included Mobil 1 lubricants in the engine, gearbox, power steering and final drive. The only thing my tech didn't do was change the microfilter, as I do that myself- along with the brakes, Oil Services, and Inspection 1).
  • blackiblacki Member Posts: 6
    Is your independant BMW tech located anywhere near northwest Arkansas? If so, name pleeease.
  • tjutju Member Posts: 20
    I have an '01 330i. Its xenon headlights sometimes flash off and on an random. I took it to the BMW dealer but the lights wouldn't flash for them. There is no test for this problem. They did mention prices for components in this system (bulb $300, switch $300, igniter more than that, plus labor), so the $1000 that someone else mentioned is realistic if not low. Has anyone else experienced this problem?
  • clackclack Member Posts: 2
    Maulana:

    We own both a (2005) 325i and a (2006) 330ci which is the recent replacement of a 2002 330ci. The 325 is a manual/sport package car, the 330ci has a steptronic transmission. Certainly the 330's thrust is greater under nearly all conditions. However, the 325 is no slug and is a very rewarding/entertaining drive and the acceleration is more than adequate under all circumstances. Furhermore, with the 325's sport package all four wheels/tires are the same size which: 1. produces better handling balance, less understeer and 2. gives you tires you can rotate every 5000 miles or so. With the offset tires of the 330 (larger wheels/tires at the rear) you won't get more than 20,000 miles from a set of $1,000 tires since you cannot rotate the tires. There are always trade offs. Overall, I feel the 325 (when properly equipped: eg- manual, sport) is a superior car value. The extra $5-$10K for the 330's horsepower advantage simply isn't worth it for my money--my wife loves the coupe though. In the end, you must judge.

    Clack
  • brave1heartbrave1heart Member Posts: 2,698
    I just picked up my car from TMS and I am still grinning with the TC Kline suspension that I put in. TMS did a great job with the install and very reasonably priced too!

    Here are my impressions:

    - Even with rebound set to max - 1/4 turn, the ride is noticeably less jarring than it was with the worn out factory shocks. The car seems to be gliding over bumps. Even though the ride may be a little busier, it is noticeably more supple and comfortable. With the rebound set to min, the ride will be even more comfortable.
    - That wander that the E46 has at high speed is gone even with the camber that I am running. The car feels really tight and solid, reminds me a lot of E36 M3s.
    - Turn-in is immediate and very crisp, there's no "thinking" at all. From driver perspective, this is the biggest adjustment that I have to make to get used to it.
    - Grip is stupenduous!
    - The car sits much lower than I had ever thought it would. Even though the drop is supposed to be just an inch in the front, it looks closer to 2 inches. Very aggressive stance but I know I'll be plowing the snow next Winter
    - I picked up -.3 degrees of negative camber with the lowered suspension - it went from -2.1 to -2.4 at the min setting with the TMS fixed camber plates. TMS is saying that even the fixed plates can be adjusted within a tight range and I could go to -2.8 if I wanted to. Sweet! I am keeping it at -2.4 year-round so I won't eat up the tires
    too fast and I'll take it from there.
    - Unfortunately, the R/D strut brace does not fit any more because of the camber setup. I will be getting an M strut brace (it is adjustable), which sits flatter on the strut towers anyhow.

    If anyone needs a R/D strut bar cheap, let me know.
  • brave1heartbrave1heart Member Posts: 2,698
    I had mentioned it and I had the same flickering problem a couple of months after I bought my '01 325i (purchased 5 years ago new). The dealer replaced the full assembly under warranty. I remember the total was just over $1,000 parts and labor...
  • gordonwdgordonwd Member Posts: 337
    I assume that this was installed on a 325i? My only reservation about suspensions that lower the car is that there is no getting around the fact that you are reducing the available suspension travel before you're into the bumpers, and that has to have an effect on the ride and how well it will take a nasty bump. There are probably modified snubbers that can get a half inch or so back, but it still seems like something I'd hesitate to do.

    On a track you are not going to encounter really rough pavement, but on the street I would imagine you'd have to be really careful.
  • akv25akv25 Member Posts: 42
    My driver's side xenon will not switch on once in a while. I have to switch on and off multiple times for it to work.

    The warning bulb goes on when this happens. The problem is intermittent and once the lights are on, they stay on.

    Dealer is 100 miles away so I am waiting for the day that the bulb dies!
  • shiposhipo Member Posts: 9,148
    The bet is that it ain't the bulb, it's most likely the electronics that light the bulb (i.e. the ballast, similar in nature to the one sometimes found in fluorescent lighting).

    Best Regards,
    Shipo
  • brave1heartbrave1heart Member Posts: 2,698
    Very much true! You'd have to pay attention all the time on the street and even on the track. I've seen some nasty curbs and dropoffs on a few tracks... That said, there are only two ways to reduce load transfer and center of gravity is one of them (the other one is wheelbase). It's always a tradeoff. The H&R sport springs lower the front a bit too much even for my taste but the handling is absolutely amazing.
  • tcn2ktcn2k Member Posts: 277
    Guys, help. I hav a 325i 2001 and I haven't driven it for 6 months. The car is basically dead. I tried charging the battery tonight by hooking up my jeep to it and let it sit there for about 20 mins. I then attempt to start the bimmer but nothing happen. It won't turn. It just makes a bunch of clicking sound and lights flashing but the starter would not even turn. Any suggestions?
  • blackiblacki Member Posts: 6
    You might try pulling your battery out and charging it on a good charger for at least an hour,maybe two, then see if it holds the charge. Also you should clean the battery posts and clamps; they always corrode and wont allow sufficient current to pass when a vehicle sits too long out of service. I'd try that first (cleaning) before anything else, then a good charge.

    Batteries often just go bad after an extended period of non-use because of the oxidation that takes place on the lead plates unless you use a battery tenderto keep them properly charged during extrended periods of non-use. You could try a battery from your other vehicle and see if your 325 will start, if the size and terminals are similar.

    Hope this helps.
  • div2div2 Member Posts: 2,580
    Is your independant BMW tech located anywhere near northwest Arkansas? If so, name pleeease.

    If you haven't done so already, you need to join the BMW Car Club of America. That will allow you to find out what shops are used by other members in your area. Most shops offer a 10-20% club discount on parts and/or labor.
  • ventureventure Member Posts: 3,173
    There was some discussion earlier about wheels seizing to the hubs. (I think some said it couldn't happen)

    I changed from winter tires to summer tires today.

    I took the bolts out of one of the back wheels and it didn't budge. It was like the bolts were still in there.

    I kicked it gently one time with no change. Two more successively harder kicks and it finally broke free. The other back wheel only took two kicks to break free, but I kicked it harder.

    The fronts were not nearly as bad - in fact one of them dropped right off.

    I noticed that on the back wheels there was much more "gunk" between the wheel and the hubs and one actually had water between them. I checked the torque on a few of the bolts just for giggles before beginning and the ones I checked were OK.

    We also discussed applying a lubricant of some type when mounting. I used white lithium grease in a spray can last fall but, obviously, not enough. I remember spraying just a little on each wheel before mounting - this time I sprayed quite a bit.

    Also - if you decide to use a spray, spray it on the wheel and not on the hub. You will surely get grease on the rotor. Ask me how I know that!

    2025 Forester Limited, 2024 Subaru Legacy Sport

  • abfischabfisch Member Posts: 591
    I am about 6 months ahead of you only. I have a 02 Avalon that I use as my daily driver. I suspension tuned it abit but it is still a Toyota. I recently bought a 325ci SP 2004. I am just starting to run it now as the weather has gotten good, so I can only tell you a little. I do garage all my cars, heated, including my wife's so I should preface it with that. My Avalon, with TokicoHP shocks and Energy Suspension bushings, is more useful and still the rock. It goes through snow better, can pull a trailer, and is more comfortable with the bench seat. We went to the track the other day and took the BMW. It was rock solid, tight, and took off right away. Fun, very fun. My wife stated that she wants to take the Avalon on trips not the BMW cause the ride is better and is more comfortable. I just smiled.

    abfisch
  • brave1heartbrave1heart Member Posts: 2,698
    It happens with my wheels too, mostly the drive wheels. I use a drill with a rotating wire brush to polish the hubs and inside the rims, then apply anti-seize compound to the hubs. Make sure you do not spray anything that might get on the rotors! I apply the anti-seize with my fingers so I can spread it evenly on a very thin layer. Even with all this, the drive wheels need a few good kicks to come off.
  • maulanamaulana Member Posts: 55
    dear Clack,
    That is very helpful.Thank you so very much for this.

    It sure helps to have the experience of real world drivers who have driven both cars.

    My gratitude.
  • gordonwdgordonwd Member Posts: 337
    I had to drive into work early in the dark this Tuesday, so when I was backing out of the garage I immediately noticed that the right rear reading light was on. I had to get out of the car and run around to turn it off. Now the only possible way that could have been turned on was on Saturday when I was doing my "Spring detailing" and had climbed in and out of the back seat a couple of times to clean the rear window, vacuum the seats & shelf, etc. I must have bumped the switch at that time.

    I drove around later that day, no driving on Sunday, and then put a couple hundred miles on it on Monday without noticing that it was on. Of course, we were having unusually clear, sunny weather, and I must just not have seen it.

    So was this light actually on all that time from Saturday to Tuesday? Or do those lights eventually time out and turn themselves off when the car is parked with the ignition off ('04 325i)?
  • div2div2 Member Posts: 2,580
    The either the body computer or the LKM puts the car "to sleep" @15 minutes after the key is removed, so the reading light was off. Back in 12/95 I remember going down to the garage and finding that I had left the driver's door open on brand new Club Sport. I hadn't driven it for several days so I was certain that the battery was dead. It fired right up-of course...
  • shospazshospaz Member Posts: 2
    I'm thinking of buying a used '02-'05 330i or 325i sedan. Can you fit 3 sets of clubs in the trunk? Small carry bags? How about with one of the rear seats folded down? Any golfers out there w/ the info?

    Thanks!
  • JingleJillJingleJill Member Posts: 120
    I'm not sure about 3 sets of clubs, but I highly suggest finding a car with the fold down seats...

    Stacy
  • erickplerickpl Member Posts: 2,735
    I easily fit 2 bags of clubs in my 325xi (2002). I think a 3rd would fit, but it may be tight. May depend on how long the clubs are. :)

    Fold down seats ARE nice to have though and you could fit three sets in the long way w/o too much trouble if you have them.

    -Paul
  • gordonwdgordonwd Member Posts: 337
    Fold down seats ARE nice to have though and you could fit three sets in the long way w/o too much trouble if you have them.

    Plus the fold-down seats also have a built-in ski bag that makes it super-easy to carry your skis (including long cross-country skis) without having to actually fold the seats down. A pretty cool feature, IMO.
  • tcn2ktcn2k Member Posts: 277
    Guys,
    I have a '01 325i and the passenger window is making clunk noises when you roll the window down. Does anyone know what the problem maybe? Does it need lubrication? New window regulator? Is it pretty easy to fix myself, meaning pulling off the front door panel etc?

    thanks!
  • webby1webby1 Member Posts: 209
    I have 2004 330i and it is a problem just to get one set in. I take the driver/drivers out of the bag and then there is no problem. Drivers fit OK in the trunk but not when in the bag. If you do that then you can fit 3 bags.
    It is a pain in the [non-permissible content removed] but a small price to pay.
    Regards,
    Webby
  • erickplerickpl Member Posts: 2,735
    Sounds like the window regulator to me.

    -Paul
  • kgakga Member Posts: 23
    It’s definitely window regulator. You can fix it yourself easily. BMW service charges $100-$200 for this kind of job. If your car has side airbags, you have to disconnect battery first.
  • dennydenny Member Posts: 17
    Is there a valid reason why BMW brake fluid should be changed every two years, or is it mostly service dept profit. I've never changed brake fluid on any car regardless of time or mileage with no apparent problem.
  • div2div2 Member Posts: 2,580
    Is there a valid reason why BMW brake fluid should be changed every two years?

    Yes. Brake fluid is hygroscopic, which means that it absorbs water. Over a period of time water will migrate through various brake system components, and this absorbed moisture lowers the boiling point of the brake fluid and can cause damage to components such as the ABS pump. Boiling the fluid is not good. BMW specs DOT4 only, so I recommend Castrol LMA or ATE Super Blue Racing fluid. Those of us who drive our BMWs as God and Munich intended-on road AND track-change the fluid every six months or so. Having the brake pedal go to the floor at 130 mph when you are approaching an 80 mph corner will ruin your whole day.
  • erickplerickpl Member Posts: 2,735
    Does it make sense to change it more frequently in humid areas? In soCal, 10% humidity is high, but in Alabama, 10% humidity would be a Godsend. :)

    I just wonder how that would affect the brake fluid. With it being a closed system, how does moisture get into it?

    I'm really curious about this.

    -Paul
  • gordonwdgordonwd Member Posts: 337
    Out of interest, I'd like to know if there is any other manufacturer that recommends changing the brake fluid. My brother has a 10-year-old Civic with over 250k miles with the original fluid (not comparing a Civic with a Bimmer, but just showing you where I'm coming from).

    It was the same with motorcycles -- BMW is the only brand I'm aware of that wants to change brake fluid, especially that often. When I owned one I did do this service, figuring that on a bike the whole braking system is more exposed to the weather, but I always wondered how necessary it really was.

    And I've been driving cars and motorcycles (including in competition) for 40+ years without a hydraulic brake failure so far (knock on wood!).
  • armandarmand Member Posts: 178
    I know that Audi and Acura recommend changing brake fluid = probably other too. It does make sense and isn't that expensive.
  • div2div2 Member Posts: 2,580
    Does it make sense to change it more frequently in humid areas? In soCal, 10% humidity is high, but in Alabama, 10% humidity would be a Godsend.

    If your car isn't seeing any track use I'd change it per BMW's recommendations. Track rats should change the fluid every six months.

    I just wonder how that would affect the brake fluid. With it being a closed system, how does moisture get into it?

    It just does; note that quality brake fluids list their Dry and Wet boiling points.
  • div2div2 Member Posts: 2,580
    It was the same with motorcycles -- BMW is the only brand I'm aware of that wants to change brake fluid, especially that often.

    The maintenance chart for my 1996 Triumph Speed Triple not only demands a brake fluid change every two years, it also calls for replacing all brake/clutch hoses as well as rebuilding the brake master cylinder/calipers and the clutch master/slave cylinders every four years. And it's not that fast of a bike; it will barely nudge 130 with a strong tail wind...
  • bdr127bdr127 Member Posts: 950
    Out of interest, I'd like to know if there is any other manufacturer that recommends changing the brake fluid. My brother has a 10-year-old Civic with over 250k miles with the original fluid (not comparing a Civic with a Bimmer, but just showing you where I'm coming from).

    FWIW, I can't imagine BMW recommending brake fluid flush every 30k or so if it didn't need it.... After all, with their free maintenance program, BMW is the one that's paying for it! ;)
  • tcn2ktcn2k Member Posts: 277
    Guys, it's not the regulator. It was just a broken piece of plastic that sits on the window guide. Lots of cars has this problem. Check out the e46fanatics.com forum under DIY and do a search for window regulator. I fixed it this evening with plastic ties as recommended and works great now. Save myself lots of $$...
  • shospazshospaz Member Posts: 2
    Went by the dealer and was able to fit 3 sets, (2 reg. bags, + 1 carry bag) in the trunk, with woods taken out of one bag. Test drove the 325 & 330 sedans. I now own a 2003 330i & love it. Awesome machine. Thanks for the help! :shades:
  • kominskykominsky Member Posts: 850
    "The maintenance chart for my 1996 Triumph Speed Triple not only demands a brake fluid change every two years"

    My '95 Honda VFR called for a change every two years also, I believe. I changed it about once a year, when putting on new rubber.
  • webby1webby1 Member Posts: 209
    Congrats !!!!!!.....the more you drive it the more you will love it.
    All the best.
    Webby
  • div2div2 Member Posts: 2,580
    I have an opportunity to pick up a clean 2001 330Xi MT(with @83K) at a very good price. I know that the E46 has proven to be very durable, but I'm wondering if there are any specific Xi problems I should be aware of. Thanks!
  • speeds2muchspeeds2much Member Posts: 164
    Bought my 2005 330ci last July, and it's been an awesome car outside of a few problems (e.g., a communications chip, one bad injector) that were quickly fixed at the dealer's. I've noticed the car continued to break in up to 10K miles, and now it's a blast.

    Anyway, there has been one nagging problem, but apparently it's too subtle for my dealer to pinpoint and correct, so I hope someone here can offer some suggestions. There are creaking noises coming from the right-rear passenger area of the car. The noise is best described as a dry creaking sound, although sometimes it sounds like velcro ripping. It only happens when there's some body flex on the right side of the car, not when I go over normal bumps that affect the whole car the same way. Each time I've had it at the dealer's, I've asked them to fix it. They said the rear 3/4 window needed lubricant and was very dry, and that helped slightly. They also said there was a piece of trim loose in the trunk, and that seemed to help a little. Sometimes I think the sounds are coming from the arm rests, and I've noticed the driver's arm rest makes a similar sound if I really lean on it. Most of the time, the car's tight and quiet, but that also makes the sudden creaking extra annoying.

    Since I bought the coupe because I wanted a quiet, tight and fast car, the creak is spoiling what would otherwise be a dream ride. It even makes me think about trading in the car as soon as the business lease is up, which is a waste and shame. I'd much rather fix the problem and keep the car longer. Does anyone out there have any suggestions?
  • nyccarguynyccarguy Member Posts: 17,556
    You're asking us? You're one of the BMW experts here...lol!

    Seriously though, I can't recall reading about any problems with the '01 Xi E46. I know erickpl had a 325xi and put similar mileage on it.

    2001 Prelude Type SH, 2022 Highlander XLE AWD, 2025 Camry SE AWD

  • div2div2 Member Posts: 2,580
    Well, the Xi was never on my short list of must-have cars, and as a result I never paid much attention whenever they've been discussed. That said, this one is really clean and relatively inexpensive(probably because of the manual tranny). I also love the color-Electric Red with a Natur(tan)interior. I'd use it as my commuter so I'd like to get another 80K-100K out of it. I know the RWD E46 will do it but I want to make sure that I won't have to eat a transfer case or some such...
  • erickplerickpl Member Posts: 2,735
    The older technology Xi's, like that in the E46, never has been an issue. My 325xi went well in excess of 90,000k without a hiccup in the transmission at all, and that includes drives up/down mountain roads. I was NOT easy on that car.

    -Paul
  • kominskykominsky Member Posts: 850
    Try folding down the rear seats and then putting them back up being sure they snap in properly. I'm not sure if this will fix your problem, but I had a creak/squeak coming from the right rear of my car for ~six months. Like your problem, it only seemed to happen when the right side of the car was on rougher pavement than the left. It suddenly went away last week.

    The only thing I can think of is that I never use the fold -down rear seat except when transporting rifles to and from the range/field. The second-last time I had them in would have been in fall and then not again until my son and I went to the range a couple of weekends ago. So if I had to guess, the seat was never properly latched in between those two times.
  • jim1395jim1395 Member Posts: 34
    it might be the felt trim on the window frames on all the doors. it sounds exactly like the problem i've had with my 325i. i have to clean and lubricate the felt seal every 6 months or so. you can do a search on e46fanatics.com and come up with detailed pics and solution. sorry in advance if i wasn't suppose to list any other web sites. hope it helps.
  • nyccarguynyccarguy Member Posts: 17,556
    Not that I'm looking to actually buy one (or any car for that matter right now), but some asking prices on really nice, low mileage E36 M3s are sky high. There are still quite a few '98 & '99s out there for sale with asking prices in the low $20K range. I know it is a BMW (good resale value) and an M car (even better resale value), but we're still talking about a 7 or 8 year old car regardless of condition and mileage.

    2001 Prelude Type SH, 2022 Highlander XLE AWD, 2025 Camry SE AWD

  • nyccarguynyccarguy Member Posts: 17,556
    I never figured you as an Xi guy, but if the price is right...

    2001 Prelude Type SH, 2022 Highlander XLE AWD, 2025 Camry SE AWD

  • speeds2muchspeeds2much Member Posts: 164
    Thanks kominsky, I think you nailed it. The seat looked snapped in, but upon inspection I found it was not. I really slammed it hard and it seems tight now. Looking back, I remember this problem appearing right after I first folded down the 60/40 rear seat. I subsequently tried to close it, but the creak continued...apparently I'd never slammed it shut hard enough. Owning a BMW does not mean everything snaps shut with a solid click, apparently.

    But jim1395, I'm going to do what you suggested, because I think it's a secondary problem. Thanks for your input.
Sign In or Register to comment.

Your Privacy

By accessing this website, you acknowledge that Edmunds and its third party business partners may use cookies, pixels, and similar technologies to collect information about you and your interactions with the website as described in our Privacy Statement, and you agree that your use of the website is subject to our Visitor Agreement.