Did you recently take on (or consider) a loan of 84 months or longer on a car purchase?
A reporter would like to speak with you about your experience; please reach out to PR@Edmunds.com by 7/25 for details.
Options

Oldsmobile Intrigue

11516182021238

Comments

  • 14151415 Member Posts: 249
    dindak::::::Does the door panel flex on the Alero in window operation. I had a two door for a couple of days and the interior panel was rigid so I am curious about the 4dr..

    white6::::::Good Cuda story!! I know nothing about the Aquatread tire but 80k warranty for a $100 tire sounds great. One thing about the second of tires is that the tight suspension is somewhat gone and the whole front end is becoming sloppier so will a high priced tire really be of any benefit. The LS tire wears like a speed rated tire--hoping to get 40k miles..Another decision coming up..What service bulletin covers the alternator replacement???? My dealer is getting a little plexed with me and my second Intrigue. I am getting a little plexed with the car.

    ketch::::::When GM made the decision to take the new Cutlass away from Olds after the 98 model that spelled the end of the line..The new Aurora was too far along to kill for it would never generate enough volume to save the division. GM literally put Olds out business by slowly cutting their product lines and blaming it on low sales. They had nothing to sell. If GM announced that Aurora was going to Cadillac it would be a surprise but it may be the only out available because of the engine..

    The 300 and Chrysler may be extinct unless they get their act together; its rumored that Honda might buy them..The Germans marched over and took all their cash after the merger and went on a shopping spree. Penske unloaded Detroit Diesel at a giveaway price to the Germans and cost me a few bucks..

    The 300 is selling at a nice discount during these difficult times and the Dodge Intrepid R/T can be had in the low 20s. The question I have about R/T edition is whether the suspension has been tweaked or did they add 17" wheels plus the 3.5 detuned V-6 and hype sport qualities??? I didn't see anything about the suspension mentioned in their brochure..The heavy setup is good for 100K without fail..

    bz4::::::No DTS since it is a Deville with stiff struts and bucket seats..I will get wifey a one yr old STS with less than 10k miles. After 3 new Cadillacs I have better ways to spend money foolishly, so the heavy metal will be bought used but not abused..

    The Detroit Auto show opens tonight with a black-tie bash @ $300/head and tomorrow it is open to the public for $10.00/head--seniors and kids discounted.

    Olds has space at the show; could be the final prayer service...or maybe they will drag out the OSVs to tease the diehards. I imagine that attendance will be off this year due to the downturn in sales and the lack of factory overtime will dampen the lust for a new car.. There is some bigtime trouble ahead..this soft landing bullcrap is a joke. When the Big Three sputter its night-night time in the Motor City.

    I see where Toyota is increasing production this qtr by 3%. I also read where "we are still begging the Japanese to allow us to sell our autos on their mainland without their restrictions." Isn't FREE TRADE great!!!!!
  • etharmonetharmon Member Posts: 399
    I live in Nascar country(TN) and still don't see thay many Monte Carlos. I haven't really warmed up to the MC's styling yet. I'd take a Grand Prix coupe over it anyday. I'm just curious if anyone knows how many V6 Accords and Camrys were sold last year? I know the bulk of those models sell in 4 cylinder trim so I'd be curious to see how many V6 models they sold.

    1415, you really should consider the new Devilles. Even in base form, the suspension is a much better design than the older ones. Too bad the Japanese don't have a free trade policy like we do. Hey, what do you think the economy is going to do? You think it's going to tank soon? I'm looking forward to next Saturday, the "you know what" party will FINALLY be out of the White House. What do you guys think, will Bush's new presidential limo be a Caddy or a Lincoln? I'd like to see it be a Caddy based on the new Deville, but since Clinton's was a Caddy and they often alternate, it may be a Lincoln.
  • b4zb4z Member Posts: 3,372
    Don't have the breakdown for V6 vs. 4 banger, but i can give you the totals.
    Camry 1999=448,162/2000=422,961
    Accord 1999=404,192/2000=404,515
    Interestingly the Camry sold about 6,800 more cars in Dec. than the year before.
    Accord sold about 2,400 cars in Dec. than the year before.
    This does not bode well for the domestics, the Asians are taking market share little by little.
    I think it was Lee Iaccoca who said, "Lead follow
    or get out of the way".
    I think GM is trying their best to get out of the way.
  • b4zb4z Member Posts: 3,372
    Just saw the Jan. 16 issue of AWI at the newstand.
    They gave a glowing review of the 2001 Intrigue.
    The car they tested was a GL with chrome wheels and PCS. The PCS badge was clearly visible below the Oldsmobile badge on the trunk, but the car did not have the rear spoiler! I have done a lot of research and the spoiler is standard with PCS.
    And there doesn't seem to be a way to delete it.
    How did AWI get that car optioned like that?
  • b4zb4z Member Posts: 3,372
    I must not have done enough research.
    You can get PCS without the spoiler i n the GL.
    If you get the GLS the spoiler comes with it.
  • 14151415 Member Posts: 249
    etharmon::::::I spent a weekend last fall with a 2000 Deville and abused it for 500 miles or so; compliments of my local Cad dealer. Nice car, handled better and flew like the wind; but the downside is not really any special item that says luxury or quality..Equipped like my 96 it has to sticker around 44k; now that for the entry level one. At 80 the hood flaps in the breeze and at 90 you get the feeling that it might just leave the car. Raise the hood and discover what a thin piece of metal it is and the plastic grill is about a $5.00 item....I pass on the Deville...

    For our younger readers and everyone's eagerness to learn about today's world and how come the Asians are eating our lunch; I would recommend a trip to the library for a book titled; "Agents of Influence" by Pat Choate, best seller in 1990. It explains how Japan manipulated America's political and economic system with their brand of corruption which still is rampant today.

    Yes!!!I am old enough to remember Frigidaire, Harrison, Airtemp, and Dec 7, 1941....Nippondenso the large Japanese outfit has a plant in the cornfields of Micigan called Michigan Automotive Compressor which cranks out a/c compressors for the transplants and Chrysler..

    Yes, we have a new occupant for the palace, and the family leaving is just moving down the street
    so we will be hearing his thoughts daily..The young Ford Chairman leans a left and maybe that was to keep the trial lawyers away from Dearborn. however dubya is usually seen in a Chevy SUV, so maybe GM will rule the fleet.

    I am leaving CHAD COUNTY, Florida on 1/29 and sending the furniture to storage. Both Marion and Sarastoa counties supported the case in Nov; so either one is a safe haven.

    I was wrong on the entry fee for the opening night bash of the Detroit Auto Show; it's $350/a head instead of the $300 of last year.

    Got alot of chores to do around the house because its off to Fla next Friday to start the move. This sudden decision to depart from CHAD county is cutting two months of my wife's away time out--sad. She hasn't driven in snow for 11 1/2 yrs...should buy her a tank...

    Will catch the board later...Ernie Els is playing great golf and must watch tonight for he needs to increase his lead so he can coast Sunday. Tiger can work on his concession speech..
  • ickesickes Member Posts: 82
    Given how poorly the Intrigue is selling, even when propped up by $2000 rebates, zero interest financing for 60 mo. or the $0-0%-$0 plan you've got to wonder if GM will even bother with a 2002 model.

    I know Harlan said that he was working on interior details for 2002, but really, couldn't they use the capacity at KC for GPs or even just layoff some workers with the anticipated market slow downs?

    Of course, these employee cutbacks are a joke. Anybody who knows how GM runs internally must wonder how they make a dime. According to my father in law, GM will pay employees $60K to transfer. They also just offered early retirement to employees in some car plants that if your 55 or over, they'd credit your pention has having worked until 60 to encourage workers to hang it up. Unfortuneatly for my father-in-law, no such program at the plant he works at because they still run three full shifts and no layoffs are anticipated.
  • ickesickes Member Posts: 82
    I jsut read that the 3.5l dropped off of Ward's "ten best" engines list. A reviewer commented that it is the Atlanta Braves of engines; has all the expensive pieces, but just couldn't win the big one. Kind of sums it up for the Intrigue and Olds in general, don't you think?
  • dindakdindak Member Posts: 6,632
    yurakm: Base Intrigue GX is cheaper than a base Impala LS (I'm comparing cars with similar engines). I know you can get an Impala for less (with the 3.4L), but what I am trying to convey is that if they are evenly eqiuped, Impala is no cheaper.

    1415: No flex that I can remember. It's winter so the window only opened once at the BK drive through. ;-) Alero is nice, just lacks the overall refinement of Intrigue. I think the fit and finish on Alero is better though.

    etharmon: Interesting. The Monte Carlo is growing on me, especially with the 2001 spoiler update which looks better. Saw a black one today. Still prefer a GP or and Intrigue though.

    ickes: I predict Intrigue will die after 2002. Grand Prix production is moving for the new 2003 model to Oshawa ON and I suspect that will be when Kansas is converted for a new line of cars or trucks.
  • 14151415 Member Posts: 249
    Was at Barnes and Noble this pm and picked up the lastest Auto News which showed Intrigues Dec sales at 4200; Aurora was at 3700 units.. Look for some more rebates because that volume isn't going to fly. Sourcing contracts for the major components is normally a five year life so 02 would be termination..

    The next rebate to be tied to the Olds line is an old Buick favorite----AARP membership discount..I do automotive parts; but I don't get involved with a supplier discount program for various reasons.

    Right now I am dickering with two Fla moving companies on pricing; I find that they a slippery people, rating worst than a used car salesperson or a stockbroker.

    Is the 3.4L a 2 or 4 valve setup; seems like it is the old 2 valve deal???

    I didn't buy the Automotive News for it is rather mundane stuff; and my Canadian source keeps me informed of the SUV happenings. At my stage in life the greatest thing the Automotive world can do is pay their damn invoices on time for any slow as stated earlier is an excuse to skip a few days. I had two meetings with a large stamping supplier whom I supply with a component and they are starting to play the game.

    Gotta hit the kitchen now!!!!! The main course will be Salmon (broiled) brown rice, green beans, and a salad. Dessert will be yogurt and 2 super martinis before the meal...
  • b4zb4z Member Posts: 3,372
    If the 2001 quits selling. Will there even be a 2002? The Kansas City plant is on hiatus now because of slow sales. Harlanc said all of the changes have been made and contracts signed, but if the car is selling at a loss, why bother. My dealer has the same cars sitting on his lot since October. I know he won't order anymore this year anyway.
    He has a pretty blue intrigue
    that has no options. It doesn't even have leather steering wheel, cd player, and power seat.
    He is going to eat that car. It will probably be sitting there next fall.
  • vcjumpervcjumper Member Posts: 1,110
    I don't know why GM would bother, doesn't make sense building a car that won't sell enough to come close to breaking even on. Maybe just to keep the vultures from talking about Olds death so people will still buy Aleros (Anyone have the sales figures for Aleros?) which is probably the only Olds car that sells enough for GM to break even on.

    That stripper Intrigue on the lot could probably be had dirt cheap and made nice with a katzkin interior job and aftermarket stereo.
  • redly_oneredly_one Member Posts: 122
    I recently visited an Oldsmobile/Chevrolet Dealership in Central Indiana. I started talking to a sales person about what product line they will carry when Olds finally folds. He wasn't sure, but he did state that it was his understanding that the Alero was going to somehow be merged into the chevrolet lineup (in the already compact segment??? Maybe after the Cavalier is axed they will morph it with the Malibu?) and ...gasp...the Aurora. I personally cannot see the Aurora in the chevy lineup, but it is GM (assume bad descisions).
    In fact, yes, I can see the Aurora in the Chevy lineup. I bet they'll even cut the 4.0 and the 3.5 and sell it with the 3.4 standard (sarcasm).

    So, has anyone else heard of any similar news? (no opinions, thank you). It would be interesting.

    Oh yeah, before I forget, an Intrigue with no options....(post 860) now that would be a chevy candidate!
  • dwgdwg Member Posts: 43
    Hey guys. Maybe you can help me with this. In the last two weeks, I've noticed a feedback through the steering wheel that I've never encountered before. It happens at highway speeds and at slow speed applying the brakes. The steering wheel doesn't vibrate but I definitely get feedback through the wheel while I'm driving.

    I could be paranoid or simply expressing my anger at GM for killing Olds, but this is starting to bother me. As mentioned before, its a 2000 with PCS (build date around 11/99).

    Your thoughts will be appreciated. I take it to my dealer (under new ownership) next week.

    dwg

    P.S. Watch the Martinis 1415.
  • 14151415 Member Posts: 249
    dwg:::::::when braking the steering wheel pulsates with a side to side motion; probably means the brakes(my favorite parts)rotors are getting alittle wavey or warped. It's a common to the Intrigue, and your trusty dealer will probably fix it under warranty terms. No sweat; I have mine done every third oil change.

    We are stuck with these oddballs and will have to make the best of it. Maybe the auto thieves will put them on their hot list due to lack of low priced parts available thru the regular dealer network. The downside is that our insurance company has the car undervalued in relation to its original pricing!!!!

    Ernie Els really came apart on the back nine today.
  • etharmonetharmon Member Posts: 399
    Probably frustration with GM's lame decision to drop Olds. Again, when I look at the Intrigue and Aurora and then the Grand Prix and Bonneville, I just have to wonder what they were thinking. What type of feedback are you feeling? A vibration, changes in steering effort, pulling to one side??? A vibration or just a slight pulsation would indicate brake rotors are warping. A pull may indicate that one brake caliper is grabing harder than another or that the front end is out of alignment.

    As for Olds and 2002, my bet is the Intrigue and the rest of the models will return for 2002. That will probably be the last year for the Intrigue and Silhouette while the Aurora, Bravada, and Alero carry on for another year or so before the entire brand in completely phased out. From what I hear, the W-bodies and minivans are being replaced for 2003, so this would make sense to drop those two models after 2002. Well, as much sense as one can make as the entire decision to drops Olds was rather foolish. After a week with his new Intrigue, my co-worker is still very much impressed with his new car. As for Chevy getting the Alero and Aurora, I can see them getting the Alero as it would slot very nicely in there above the Cavalier(too costly to replace the Cav) and would be a sportier compliment to the Malubu. The Aurora does not fit the brand as well though. Buick or Cadillac would be a better place for the Aurora.

    1415, I could go for a Martini about right now. If it wasn't so cold outside, I'd get in the Intrigue and drive down to this neat little club thats close to me and have a few. Maybe meet some ladies while I'm there:) Anyway, I agree with you on the Japanese. Sure they have a good product, but so does Olds. As my co-worker(the new Intrigue owner) says, "why would someone spend more money and get less car?" Less power, less sophistication, less style, and fewer features than the Intrigue has. And in his case, less warranty and higher interest rates? I don't think the 60 months at 0.9% is still available(at least not right now) but even the 60 months at 3.9% which is on right now is better than your typical car loan. And the 5 year 60,000 mile warranty is a big advanatge. To buy an extended warranty like that would probably be $1000 or more(bumper to bumper with no deductable). Call me a Republican, but I like to get the most out of my money and not just blow my hard earned $$. And find me a midsize sedan under 30K that has a stability control system.
  • yurakmyurakm Member Posts: 1,345
    I agree with you. The Intrigue GX without any option is a somewhat less expensive than Impala LS, also without any option. All W-body cars are priced about the same, after accounting for optional equipment etc. At least before rebates.

    Though, there is no such a thing as "a base Impala LS". LS means luxury, not base. The same with Intrigue: even the cheapest GX is too expensive to many people.

    Not only it is possible to buy a Chevy Impala (and MC) for less than $20k, but a lot of people are really doing this. Plus the fleet sales: rental cars, etc.

    The same is true with Pontiac GP SE, Buick Century. Only Oldsmobile did not offer a W-body car in the price segment. Alero is too small for a lot of mainstream customers.

    We do not know about the other makes, but with Buick it is absolutely clear: two "cheap" Century are sold for every "expensive" Regal. Extrapolating, we can assume that 2/3 Impala bought are the base ones, as well as 2/3 of GP are GP SE.

    On the other hand, Oldsmobile pursued only "the most rich" 1/3 of the potential customer base, and this turned to be not efficient.
  • yurakmyurakm Member Posts: 1,345
    I found that new car dealers very often have one bare car of almost every model, just to advertise the low price in local newspapers.

    People go to the dealership to look on the car, take a drive, than are buying a loaded copy. There is a special wording for such a trick. Bait and switch or something in this kind.

    Sometimes the bare thing is silly, nobody hope to sell them in reasonable quantity. E.g. the bare Malibu have no power mirrors, nor defroster for the rear window. Though, have air condition and tachometer.

    Expect the bait cars to sitting till end of year, then being disposed at substantial loss. Do not sympathize with dealer, this is deliberate.
  • b4zb4z Member Posts: 3,372
    Remember when all of the GM divisions had a "performance" version of their family cars. These cars brought people into the showrooms and they often decided for whatever reason(payments or
    insurance) that the sportier version would not fit in their budget or lifestyle. So they bought the more sedate version, but at least they bought something.
    GM doesn't have anything that can build traffic now. I understand that LS-1 Impala V8 was killed.
    OSV will never happen, The performance cavalier and malibu versions have never shown up.
    Etc. etc. the list goes on, Gm has been so conservative in the last ten years i am surprised that they are on anyone's shortlist.
    The only thing that my olds dealer has to offer is stripper intrigue with a big $21,999 written across the windshield. That will build a lot of traffic,yeah right.
    I blame it on the Proctor and Gamble soap guy, and all the complacent executives drawing the big salary.
    Just finished reading "the fall of the Packard Motor Company" and i am starting to see some parallels. Maybe in another twenty years GM will cease to exist.
  • b4zb4z Member Posts: 3,372
    Alero sales 1999=118,907
    Alero sales 2000=122,722
    Alero sales Dec. 1999=8,787
    Alero sales Dec. 2000=8,199

    It appears to be selling pretty well.
    The alero is badged as a chevrolet in europe.
    Data is from www.autosite.com
  • b4zb4z Member Posts: 3,372
    A 2001 or 2002(?) is an option for me when i buy my next car. I am debating whether to wait to see if the 2002 changes are worthwhile and if there will in fact be a 2002. Whichever year i get it will definitely have PCS without the spoiler.

    The last couple of days i have been in the Sabaru Impreza WRX site. The specs on this car are incredible. 3085 lbs. 227 hp AWD 0-60 in 6.1 secs.
    for $24,000. I am definitely interested. It appears to be a little small, but i could have some serious fun in that car. Reliving the sliding sideways around corners days of my misspent youth would be a blast.
  • vcjumpervcjumper Member Posts: 1,110
    Has amazing performance numbers, and that AWD makes it a steal at that price. I just wish it was styled a little more conventionally like the Legacy, I would take a huge hit on the Intrigue trade in, it would be worth it.
  • 14151415 Member Posts: 249
    One of the problems is that an Olds dealer is not a car buff for after selling 88s for years they lost touch with the mainstream buyer. They have no clue about DOHC V-6s and could care less. Apparently some of them still haven't heard about the 5/60. Case in point Drummy Olds--advertising Aleros and Intrigues:::good size inventory 60 Aleros and 20 Intrigues...pricing on a Intrigue MSRP 23,595-$18,444 non-GM emp. Not a word in the large ad about 5/60..no mention of a V-6 either..

    The dealer is 4 miles from the house and I was having the 98 lemon GLS serviced there until I got peeved..Their service area floor is a skating rink of oil & dirt and the protective paper mat after the end of the service fix was oil soaked.

    300Ms are beig priced out at 25,500, stripped 4 cyl Camrys are sale priced at 16,999 or 199/mo on a 4yr lease..

    How about a 2001 Prowler for 46,225?

    No Camaros or Firebirds shown in the new car ad section; quess it is not a winter car or they don't feel like wasting money advertising since they are fallen angels..

    Well it appears that the Giants will clobber the Vikings this afternoon..

    Went ouside to see if I could break up the icedams on the roof for the water is about to affect some interior walls. The area around the valleys is bad and the gutters never the valleys are iced a foot high..Just love global warming!!!

    I fell on by backside so I just called the fellow who does the snow plowing and lawn mowing to see if that thief would be interested in earning 200 to clear some snow..
  • dwgdwg Member Posts: 43
    I think my last post was a little misleading. I do notice the feedback while braking (it's probably most pronounced at that point), but I also notice it traveling at street/highway speeds -- over bumps or over expansion joints. It does feel a bit like pulsation. The steering wheel is rock solid -- no looseness -- but you can just feel something through the steering wheel.

    Ron Zarrella was interviewed by Business Week this week. He assures the interviewer that Buick and GMC are not the next on the chopping block. I don't know about GMC, but Buick has a niche already (albeit one that is aging). They'll have to attract younger buyers without alienating the AARP crowd like my folks. Perhaps GM can revive the Buick name plate the way Chrysler was revived in the '90s. Speaking of Chrysler, the Sunday Financial Times of London reports that Deutsche Bank and the Kuwaiti Government (DC's largest shareholders) have basically given Schrempp 6 months to show a realistic turn around plan. There is talk of a break-up if things don't turn around quickly. GM, Ford and Honda were all mentioned as potential suitors for parts of DC. Interesting stuff.

    Giants and Ravens in the Super Bowl.
    Giants: 16 - 10. Then PGA and College BBall seasons begin in earnest.

    dwg
  • dindakdindak Member Posts: 6,632
    yurakm: Ya, similar eqiuped Grand Prix and Regal are about the same as Intrigue GX. Why buy a Chevy when you can have an Oldsmobile I always say. Intrigue looks better inside and is more sophisticated. For many though, a base Impala is all they want.

    1415: 3.4L is a 2 valve set up.

    bz4: A friend of mine works at the Oshawa plant (home of the other W-bodies) and he said the plan being talked about is that 2002 will be the end. That being said, production may wrap up early for 2002 models if sales continue to fall. All 2003 w-bodies will be made in Oshawa when Grand Prix production is moved.

    RE: Oldsmobile models. Alero will likely replace Malibu in 2003. Malibu is a dude and Alero would serve well as a Chev. Intrigue technology will likely be transposed to the next Buick mid-size. Aurora will likely go to Buick as it doesn't fit Cadillac at all.
  • etharmonetharmon Member Posts: 399
    Chrysler does look to be in trouble and although I don't like their product as much as I do GM's, it will be a sad day if they go the way that Olds has gone. Chrysler Corporation should have known better than to get involved with the Germans. The called it a merger, but if you look, nearly all of the former Chrysler Corporation execs are gone. The sad thing is, Chrysler like Olds has their best product in years currently available(and Chrysler has a decent ad campaign) yet their cars are not selling.
  • yurakmyurakm Member Posts: 1,345
    I rented Pontiac GA (practically the same thing as Alero) while my Malibu was in body shop, and can compare the two cars.

    The main advantage of the GA/Alero is its 3.4l V-6. It have much better torque than the 3.1l engine in Malibu.

    On the other hand, the rear seats of GA are cramped. Substantially less legroom, plus the low roof makes hard to get in/out. OK for occasional drive, but a pain for the regular use.

    Our son was only 8 then, but it was still inconvenient to drive him around in GA. With two kids, or with older / bigger kids, or with an infant / toddler in a safety seat it would be even worse.

    I would recommend Alero to a single person or childless couple, but it is not a good family sedan. For a family with one-two kids Malibu is much better car. With three or more kids you need a minivan...

    Other differences are less important, imho.
  • dindakdindak Member Posts: 6,632
    Perhaps the Malibu has more rear space, but the car is still a dud. I suspect the Alero will be re-designed and let loose on Chevy show rooms. If not, I really hope the redesigned Malibu is a more exciting car.
  • 14151415 Member Posts: 249
    Got bored on Sunday night and ran the figures up for a 4.0 versus the Deville..The 4.0 can be purchased for about $12,000 less than the Caddy.

    The Caddy pricing does not include the PCS feature that comes std on the 4.0..The 4.0 auto
    is the same one as used in the Caddy(4T80E).

    The pricing is based on all the sweetheart deals on the table at Olds and no deals at Caddy except both based on dealer cost.

    With sales tax included and all the options on the 4.0; should be able to do $31,500.
  • teoteo Member Posts: 2,508
    The Impala's biggest sale point is safety. To many family sedan buyers in this segment, this is a very powerful reason to get one, aside from the fact that you can get a decently equipped base model for way under $20K (3400 V-6, Power everything, six seating capacity, nice stereo, etc).

    The Impala is the only W-body car that already meets year 2003 Government safety requirements and also the only one that has scored the highest in crash tests (5 Stars front and 4 stars side without the side airbags!). At the Insurance Institute for Highway safety offset tests, the Impala also scored higher than its other W-body peers. The Regal and Grand Prix models all meet 1997 Government safety requirements, hence they have scored lower in all the safety tests (4 Stars front and 3 stars side). The Olds Intrigue is the only W-body car that has the lowest side crash test results...only 2 stars! I can't understand why the 'more expensive and sophisticated' Intrigue has the worst safety results of all W-body cars? Less sheetmetal perhaps? This is another 'Nail' in the Intrigue's standing in safety crashworthiness issues.

    Safety sells, and it is a paramount factor for most buyers in the family sedan market.

    This also translates in lower insurance premiums....my yearly premium on my Impala is a joke versus the Intrigue.

    I don't want to 'trash' the Intrigue because otherwise I believe it is a very nice car, but I find unacceptable the poor safety and protection this car offers vs the lowest priced and less sophisticated variants of the W-body family.
  • dindakdindak Member Posts: 6,632
    I can't argue with safety. If that is you primary concern Impala is the choice. While I don't ignore safety, I feel the Intrigue is safer than any car made 5-10 years ago and aside from that one weakness is well rated. The insurance premium difference from my company was C$112, not enough to make me go Impala. There is nothing wrong with the Impala, I just don't find it as attractive or fun to drive as the Intrigue.
  • yurakmyurakm Member Posts: 1,345
    Your answers make me believe that you either have no kids, or they are usually driven in the other family vehicle.

    When you have to drive even one kid, it turns rather important how fast and easy he gets into / out of the car. Daily drive to school and back, several times a week to after school activities, and rather often to their friends, to dentist, doctor etc. Plus the American law practically require to take kids with you when you are shopping, to buying groceries etc. I believe, the same with Canadian law, and probably with other laws of Anglo-Saxon descent.

    The ease of getting to the rear seats is even more important with securing the safety seats - if you have smaller children.

    With the short trips, the rear space is not important. But it is paramount for kids comfort at longer trips.

    The rear space is especially important with teenagers, who often are higher than their parents. Given the new car, in average, will be replaced only 8 year later, it is reasonable though to forecast the needs even when the kids are just went to school, or even earlier.

    And, of course, with kids you always care about their safety. This is instinctive.
  • 14151415 Member Posts: 249
    teo:::::the Impala has always been associated with good value and I guess the latest models have a high safety rating. My insurance premiun for the Intrigue never varied from the previous car and it is insured for business which I believe the cost is $600/yr. My driving record and age factor also determine the rate. No tickets in the USA,and the other people are mum.

    In my past lives I have owned 5 Impalas all V-8s,2 Biscaynes, and 1 BelAir. The neatest one was the 60 yellow conv. w/348 ci V-8, bought new and the first day of ownership the fuel pump sprang a leak. My first car to drive on the highway was a 48 Chev Fleetmaster 4dr with vacuum shift. Built like a tank, rolled it the first year and father put it in the repair shop for 6 mos.; and then I got into a 50 Ford Crestliner V-8 shift w/overdrive.

    Airbags, seatbelts, and the additional safety items associated with the overall govt mandated equip on a car today is awesome..In the old days before the current safety edicts, and other regulations they had more flexibility in building cars and did some radical year to year changes. Those good old days are gone because nothing is really changed over a 5 yr period due to required testing needed to change and implement a feature. The public asked for it and the car gets more expensive and blander::::::engines stay the same horsepower, no annual hp increase, dull face lift that nobody notices..

    Enjoy the Impala because the car is a well thought out reliable mode of going from A to B. Good trade in value...My Safety requirements hinge around the handling aspect of the driving cycle to avoid the collision. The govt has never made any headway on improving brakes other than the ABS feature.

    Everybody spends so much time trying to make a car crash proof our level of product performance suffers. The public insists on an idiot-proof car to offset the effects of bad driving.. tough task.
  • dindakdindak Member Posts: 6,632
    "Your answers make me believe that you either have no kids, or they are usually driven in the other family vehicle".

    Wrong on both counts. I have a 2 month old daughter and the Intrigue is the vehicle she travels in most often. While I don't discount your concern for safety, I have to agree with 1415 that there is more to safety than crash tests. I am confident when driving the Intrigue and I can't say that about most cars I have driven in this price range. I am very concerned about the well being of my baby and I am also satisfied that my Intrigue will protect her just fine if I can't steer clear of an accident.
  • ketchketch Member Posts: 217
    Reason Intrigue does worse in the safety rating as compared to other w-bodies?
    Because the way the tests are done by the govt. are not proven to be reproducable, and
    are flawed enough to make any ratings hard to take at face value. Those who do can
    expect to be mislead. Experts agree on this, and recent 'rollover tests" again prove the futility of NHTSA. As 1415 said "My Safety requirements hinge around the handling aspect of the driving cycle to avoid the collision", and so this is why such cars as the Intrigue are in fact perhaps safer in the real world. I have two kids, and this was a serious benefit when buying.
  • teoteo Member Posts: 2,508
    Buddy, I didn't quoted that...I believe it was Yurakm ;-)

    Peace
  • slopedirkslopedirk Member Posts: 46
    My 13yr old Shadow ES turbo 5 speed is showing its age, and I've driven a variety of cars. Its coming down to the Honda Accord v6 ex (my wife likes Hondas) which is slowish, lacks torque and doesn't really handle great. It does have quality, great room for size and good price for loaded car. Misses - dual zone climate, pass seat doesn't do power tricks besides up and back, stereo sucks.

    Other finalists is the Maxima - ugly car but wow, what a drive. Smooth, quiet, handles like a dream, very neutral. Good resale, higher insurance, high cost.

    Also considering the Olds Intrigue GLS with PCS. Like interior a lot, engine revs like a import, nice and smooth, good power, good handling, comfortable seats with full power adjustment, lots of leg room. Misses - not as good handling as the Maxima based on my limited test drive, headroom with sunroof puts ceiling just skimming my head both front and back. Have to tilt seat back. Seats lack side bolsters like Maxima and other performance cars. Guess GM knows americans are big and fat. Too bad I'm not, and I slide around on the seat.

    Anyone have comments? I am looking at used for the Max and Olds, since I have seen what depreciation looks like -- and it becomes your friend as a used buyer. One problem is the tons of GX and literally NO GLS's and very few GL's in Houston area so far.

    Slope
  • dindakdindak Member Posts: 6,632
    teo : Sorry.. that one is for yurakm.

    slopedirk: Most of the GX models are likely former fleet or rental cars. I would look for a GL, 2000 or better. I have a GL with upgraded stereo/ wheel controls and spoiler. Best car I have ever had. The Maxima isn't bad, but it's not as nice to look at and requires premium fuel.
  • etharmonetharmon Member Posts: 399
    Unless you can get a killer deal, I'd look at new Intrigues. Also, see if some new 2000s are available. A co-worker of mine just purchased a new 2000 Intrigue GLS with PCS, sunroof, Bose sound system, and cd changer for 1% over invoice then got $1500 of that(wife had a 97 Cutlass) and financed it for 0.9&% for 5 years. Had he not taken the 0.9% financing, he would have gotten another $2500 off in discounts. My guess is that any remaining 2000s are going to be heavily discounted. I don't think the 0.9% for 5 years is still available, but they are now running 0.9% for 3 years, 2.9% for 4 years, and 3.9% for 5 years on 2001s and you should be able to get the car at a decent price(near invoice). And Olds is giving you a 5 year 60,000 mile full warranty on all new models sold. As for the cars you have narrowed it down to, I'd certainly say go with the Intrigue. I have a 98 Intrigue and have enjoyed it alot. My lease is up this summer and I am seriously considering a 2001 to replace it. Good luck with your decision. Personally, I'd at least get a GL if you get the Intrigue. My 98 is a base model(GX) and it lacks some features that I would certainly want on my next one.
  • etharmonetharmon Member Posts: 399
    I too wonder how the Intrigue scored so differently than the GP and Regal. I can see the Impala as some enhancements were done, but the Regal, GP, Century, and Intrigue are all about the same. The doors feel the same weight and sound the same when shut.
  • medic5medic5 Member Posts: 1
    I just purchased a 1998 Intrigue GL with 36000 mi., leather, dual temp. control and 60/40 split back seat. If you are looking at one without any one of these options, you are probably looking at a rental or fleet unit. I found many 2000 models with 14000 to 22000 miles, another dead giveaway. You won't find find many 99-00 GL or GLS models individually owned because the owner no doubt loves the car! I drove the Impala and the Buick Regal during my search, and the Intrigue gave me everything that they offered @ a better price. Be patient, wait for the Intrigue to come along, you'll be glad you did.
  • swagledswagled Member Posts: 195
    After driving my Intrigue for a month, I'm starting to think the reflection of the dashboard onto the windshield is annoying me just enough to want to cover it... It seems like in most lighting conditions, I can see the plastic "lip" between the two main dash pieces as a line, which runs right through where you're looking, when parking the car or drivng in slow city traffic.

    I'll concede that dash covers are an especially dorky looking device. (But I suppose that beats driving around with a black towel on the dashboard of a new Intrigue....) Anyone know a good fitting supplier?
  • vcjumpervcjumper Member Posts: 1,110
    What, you get daylight this time of year? Is that that thing that happens when I'm in my office staring at the computer screen?

    Did you treat your dash with an especially shiny protectant?
  • b4zb4z Member Posts: 3,372
    Tried to post last night but my msn dial up connection was so slow that i gave up.

    Closed on my little condo yesterday. This means
    that i will have to work harder to make that mortgage payment. So i can't hang out with you guys as much anymore. LOL.

    I am leasing a GX, I hope its not confused with the rental cars you guys were talking about.
    My GX has cd, power driver seat, leather wheel,console and shifter,keyless and airfilter.
    The only Intrigues i ever see for sale are former rental cars and off lease vehicles. You never see an intrigue for sale by a private party.
  • dindakdindak Member Posts: 6,632
    The only reason we say GXs are likely rentals is because they are, especially when a dealer has 10 of them standing in a row with 14-22K on them. Almost no one gives up a car after 1 or 2 years. I know not all GX's are rentals and I almost bought a GX until I realized my new wife at the time was ALWAYS cold and then I wanted dual-zone climate control. This is a must have for married guys!

    swagled : What color is your dash. I have dark gray and it's fine.
  • b4zb4z Member Posts: 3,372
    I would think that the intrigue would be quite a bit cheaper than a comparably equipped Maxima.
    The Maxima is a sweet car, but does not have an independent rear suspension. I have also heard of transmission problems with them. If you do buy the Max i would get an extended warranty.
  • b4zb4z Member Posts: 3,372
    If i do get another intrigue it will be a GL, because of the climate control, fogs and 60/40 rear seat.

    I am not sure if i will get leather. It can get to be 100 degrees in S.C.

    I wouldn't get the GLS due to the chrome wheels and the bundling of options.
  • b4zb4z Member Posts: 3,372
    With the new format, Edmund's has taken away our ability to jump to a specific post, or scroll through a bunch of posts.

    If you get stuck with only a couple of posts on the screen you can go back to the beginning of the discussion, then scroll to the end of the discussion and it will display the last 20 posts.

    Edmund's really needs to make this more user friendly.
  • b4zb4z Member Posts: 3,372
    No actual rollover tests were done. Data was compiled from accident reports. I don't put a whole lot of stock in anything that has the word government in front of it, as in "government tests."

    I also doubt that the impala would do significantly better than the intrigue in a real world test....i mean accident.
  • dindakdindak Member Posts: 6,632
    You can get the GLS with no chrome wheels. I'm not a leather fan, so I stayed with the GL. Fog lights look sharp and the pass through is very handy, especially with skis.
Sign In or Register to comment.