Edmunds dealer partner, Bayway Leasing, is now offering transparent lease deals via these forums. Click here to see May lease deals!
Options
Popular New Cars
Popular Used Sedans
Popular Used SUVs
Popular Used Pickup Trucks
Popular Used Hatchbacks
Popular Used Minivans
Popular Used Coupes
Popular Used Wagons
Comments
To me, buying on the internet means that everything was done via the computer. Golic posted
"...I obviously do go to a dealer to do test drive, kick tires etc... and even engage the salesman a shot at my business.."
This sounds like a regular sale to me, just because the person initiated contact via the internet is no different than taking a phone call from a customer and he comes in and buys a car. Does that mean he purchased the car over the phone??
rich
I guess a large number of people feel that the Internet is simply an electronic brochure, and
certainly it can be so much more than that...
Car_man
Host
Smart Shoppers / FWI Message Boards
I too purchased a vehicle in 1996 and had a great experience using the internet and ABT.
Fast forward to 2002 and using the plethora of auto websites and buying services, got me nowhere.
All of the "internet depts" at the dealers would never email a price quote back, they just wanted me to come on down and talk to them about it. No thanks. That is why I am using email, so i do not have to just come on down. If I wanted to just come on down, I would have just come on down.
A number of buying services let me configure cars for a price quote that were not available anywhere in the country.
I did experience some dealers that were responsive and tried to help me as best they could. These dealers seemed very professional and seemed like they had a more dedicated internet dept.
It would be interesting to have an article with interviews with the salesmen and managers and buyers from the most successful internet dealerships to see what they think works and doesn't for the buyer and the dealer.
The majority of the internet departments went from "The" way to buy a car, both for the lack of drama, at a great price to "The" way to shop your dealership against every other dealership in 200 miles.
This is why nobody quotes prices up front anymore, and this is why you find many dealerships cursing the "d**n internet"
It used to be a much better transaction from both sides of the desk, but, as they say, the game has changed.
The advent of inexpensive computers and cheap internet access has watered down the gene pool of buyers (and sellers). Its no longer (always) the cool/ chic/ hassle free way of buying a car. You now have a grinder with a computer in his hands, and you also have old school dealers using computers to play the same old (old school)games.
Those of us who are the best of the best at this game are having to wade through the pool to get to the legitimate buyers, as the "serious" buyers have to wade through the pool of sellers. We could use a *lot* of chlorine here.
Ed
: )
Mackabee
I cannot imagine walking into a House that is selling for $xxx,xxx.00,
and asking the seller "What is your bottom line price?" Not only preposturous, but rude...and very ineffective. Same here.
I seldom give prices...only the store's advertised Sale Prices from the paper... But I happily entertain offers...and either I can accommodate or I cannot.
Every Dealer wants the number that is on the Window, and every customer wants Invoice; somewhere in between is the common ground that makes everybody happy...
As Ed has pointed out this process is starting a
counter clockwise spiral...when the economy turns around; so will this. And, quite
frankly, what I miss the most is a customer base
that is polite and friendly...These folks are now
the exception and not the rule...Sad, very sad.
When I shopped for my car in 2001 I had my Edmunds and CR info. and emailed about 3 dealers for each make I was looking at. Never played them against each other, but right out of the box one guy gave price that was under TMV.
I emailed back and made appointment, took car for a test drive and spent about 2 hrs (1 wtg and w/ F&I) and I was done.
IMHO I think that is how the internet should work.
You said "The advent of inexpensive computers and cheap internet access has watered down the gene pool of buyers (and sellers)."
While I agree that there are probably a lot more people with internet access today than 5 years ago, are they necessarily worse buyers and sellers? I would think that they were at least intelligent enough to A)buy a computer, B)figure out the invoice and MSRP info, C)get in touch with your dealership electronically. Of course this is no excuse for them being rude.
I think what dealers are more PO'd about is that more and more people "know" about invoice pricing and incentives, etc and want a rock bottom price on cars. Also they can go on message boards like edmunds and find out what others are paying.
The old school of car selling was to get the buyer in the car and let the newness sell them. Keep them at your dealership and a sale is more likely. Unfortunately you cannot do that with the internet. There is no hook or emotion, that is what buyers like about it, and old school dealers hate.
Golic hit the nail on the head. He did not have to make an offer. A dealer took a chance and threw out his best price. Like golic said, it was easy to see who was the better dealer and he got the business and everyone saved a lot of time and hassle. Even the dealers that did not get the business did not have to waste time with golic at their lot dickering over price. I agree with him, that is how internet car buying should work.
Dealers need to understand:
A)The internet and the info it provides is not going away.
B)It is only going to get bigger and more and more future buyers will have computers and this info.
C)Dealers need to adapt to use this technology effectively, instead of being afraid of it just like the music industry fears MP3's and cd burners.
Dealers may find it harder to sell at MSRP, but what are they going to do when every buyer that walks through the door, or inbox wants a car at invoice?
They get to the local screamer ad dealer and the game begins. "Ok, who wants to sell a car today." the salesmen all run...
Finally, a green pea takes the customer for a test drive. They inhale some of that new car smell, the customer gets excited, all is great. "Lets talk some numbers" the salesman says. They sit down, break out the 4 square sheet, and lo and behold, the customer realizes when they are all through playing games that they're $2000 apart (realistic figure). Now, the salesman gets handed an email from the other dealership, "this can't be right, let me get the manager" blah blah blah. The manager comes over, big fake smile and all, looks at the figures, "what's it going to take for us to earn your business?" The customer wants $500-1000 less than the internet offer. "Sorry, that isn't a legitimate offer, they won't honor that, blah blah blah." Never mind that the offer may indeed be a couple of hundred into the holdback already from the internet guy.
At this point, the customer will A) continue to fall for the dealer's BS line and eventually get the car for the 1st guy's offer, or he will storm out and continue looking elsewhere or he will regain his senses and stick with the internet guy.
As I see it, the floor people have the advantage. They sell cars every day. The customer buys once every 4-5 years on average. The salesmen will TO to a manager who is even more convincing. Eventually, 99% of the customers will give up (and sign up), as we have seen many times here.
The honest internet guy (and again, this doesn't mean everyone) just lost a sale for doing his job. He did all the work exactly like the customer wanted, and someone else got the sale.
The dealer group that I work for has 7 stores. One of them is consistently the #1 seller of its make in the state. Everything about the process there is 100% old-school. They even deleted the invoice pricing from the salesman's computer so even the salesman doesn't know the invoice cost of the car. Lot dropping will cost you your job, everyone meets the manager. ADM stickers on everything.
Sounds great, right?
Our internet dept. basically got to the point that we wouldn't sell for this store. Nobody wanted to have to drive down there and deal with the atmosphere. We quit selling. Eventually, when the managers got their heads together, they put two of "their" floor guys in front of computers, and they're selling about 25 cars a month via their "internet" dept.
Some days it doesn't pay to get out of bed.
This isn't to say that it is all bad, because it isn't. However, I'd say now that the ratio of online "idiots" to realistic buyers is probably about 20:1. The 1 is a real gem, and gets the royal treatment (I had one Sat.) but they are so rare that the salesman's perception of you is going to be jaded by the time they eventually find you.
That's my perception of reality, anyway, I could be wrong.
Ed (still looking for that book deal
I have never pursued "invoice" pricing because I understand this. And most consumers understand this when they go to Sears, etc...
Correct me if I am wrong, but dealers cost and overhead is not the invoice.
But, I am right to suggest that Dealers either created or contributed to this stigma buy using the "here is our invoice on the car" tactic. Consumers, right or wrong, believe invoice is the "cost" of the vehicle.
I don't know how incentives, holdbacks and allocations work. (But I am a CPA and willing to learn if I can persuade any of you to convince your owner to change firms**cheap plug). But until Dealers find a way to educate consumers on true cost this rationalization will always exist.
Perhaps that is what the no-haggles (saturn, carmax, etc) are trying to do and Edmund contributes by offering TMV.
But I agree with masspector, the intenet is not going away and dealers should look for ways to use it to their advantage, ie email lists, send service coupons out to those provide email referrals, etc...
I have no problem with a consumer who thinks they are an expert in car buying...but they better be an expert in reality too. I can't tell you how many people really think that anything over invoice is NET profit. Santa clause and the easter bunny pay the overhead expenses. lol
It just drives some used car buyers nuts when they can't find out what we paid for the used car they are thinking about buying!
If the money is in the service, used car, and F&I departments, then dump the new car operation and start bailing money, right?
Shall I look?
brentwoodvolvo "Why do people want to buy cars for cost?" Mar 23, 2002 4:08pm
TB
So if we take away our feeder source of revenue, (new cars) and give that stream to another source like factory direct (which has been a proven failure) our most profitable departments will not have a direct link to the customer....Remember, nothing lends credability to a used car department and service department like a new car franchise.
On top of that, due the the huge failures of manufacturer selling and internet selling...what is a better way of doing things???
I do understand the concept of a loss leader.
I too, don't know of a better way to sell the cars. Besides, I buy cars, I'm not in the business of selling them.
I just derive some sort of perverse pleasure from pointing out such ironies.
TB
Having a hard time serving my customers today, their problems are too vague for the solutions I have, LOL.
Bill...ARE YOU OUT THERE? Anywhere...?
My question is this:
How do you "know" they are shopping the price to someone else? Do they come back and tell you that?
If I got a price from you and then got a lower price from another dealer I would probably go with the lower price dealer and you would never hear from me again. But there could be many reasons why I did not contact you again. Maybe I decided not to buy a car at this time, our I bought another brand.
I do not see the difference in email quotes or in person quotes. I always get the salesman to put a price quote in writing (usually on their business card) and then I have proof that the quote is real, if I decide to shop with another dealer. I would think that email would save everyone time.
Also, if customers are shopping your email price quote, wouldn't you on average get a fair number of shoppers shopping other email price quotes to your dealership that you could get business from?
Thanks.
If the customer replies back or initially with the detailed info, a discounted price will be offered...
Our number will rarely be the lowest but we won't be the highest either. Our sales abilties, dealership reputation and inventory will sway the customer our way...so I dont care if they shop.
is to do the Homework, Research, etc. There is MSRP and Invoice pricing Everywhere on the Internet. Determine exactly how they want their car configured, and what they deem to be an acceptable *Target Price* that they would pay for the car.
Contact the Dealership that would be the most convenient, or that they have heard good things about, and where they would like to do busines.
Then contact that Dealership with all of the above.
This is the traditional, accepted procedure for any type of negotiation...knowing a Retail/Asking price and making a counter offer...
By asking for an email quote or bottom line price the Customer is typically asking to be *LowBalled* only to discover that the price will
not be honored, or worse...paying substantially more than they really should for financing, or an
Extended Warranty, if they elect to get one, or buying *Gap* Insurance when it is already included in the contract.
I have always looked at the Internet Buying Experience as the one, single way for the Automobile Dealer to raise the bar, and make the car buying experience a pleasurable one...Fun, easy, quick, and devoid of the typical crap.
By succumbing to the temptations to get something for nothing, or at least for as little as humanly possible, the other door is opened, again...deceit, lies, and not much fun at all.
If I did my research and had a real target price of $20,000 OTD should I offer $18,500 as my first offer assuming that the dealer will counteroffer with a much higher number? Then we could trade offers and get closer to the real $20,000.
I would think if I made my first offer as my real target price, that the dealer would think that they could raise me.
If you submit a realistic offer, I wouldn't try to bump you. Even if you submitted a lowball offer, I'd counter with the bottom line that I could do. Its getting to the customer that actually wants to buy something (from me) that is the hardest part of the job.
Ed
It seems that the dealers that try to do the right thing by giving a quote get beat up by the other dealers that do not. It is ashame that it is this way, because the internet really could make the process better for buyer and seller.
: )
Mackabee
Quite frankly, this is fine if you are actually at the Dealership and prepared to drive home in the car of your choice or one that they try to get you into instead...;)
My vision of the Internet is one where the customer pays a price that they are comfortable with and where the buying experience itself is
important.
If you have accurate Invoice numbers, and that
obviously is important...checking a couple of different sources is a good idea...Edmund's, for
example continues to leave out Port Prep & FloorPlan Interest Reserve($167.00)for both on Volkswagen Invoices. And you know what MSRP is...
always accurate; then a Target price would lie somewhere in between. *IntelliChoice* has used this "Target Price" concept for years.
I found this very frustrating with the highlander. Toyota.com and carsdirect.com let me configure the car I wanted, but when I checked with dealers, nothing like that was available. All I could do was order it.
: )
Mackabee
I wanted a 2wd v6 limited with jbl premium stereo with cd changer, leather pkg, and side airbags only. I did not want a sunroof, or the towing prep pkg.
I think the side airbags was the first problem. All the dealers could locate with that option were fully loaded. Next, they had a hard time finding one with no sunroof. The final nail in the coffin was that all highlanders had the towing prep pkg installed at the factory, no exceptions, except on a dealer order. But if you check the website and edmunds, it lists that as a seperate stand alone option.
What is ironic is that what I ended up getting has a sunroof. Can't get away from them.
: )
Mackabee
: )
Mackabee
; )
Mackabee
BTW- can any of you in the business tell me two things...what % of buyers come in informed? and what % of people negotiate only on down payment and monthly payment. Just out of curiousity
(1) Quote everyone an out the door price.
(2) Follow up.
You will get some deals you wouldn't get by making it easy and you will lose some deals because someone will better your price by a few dollars. Most people are not PRICE SHOPPERS alone, price is usually in the top 4 or 5 but the only deciding factor. You should follow the 10/80/10 rule
10% you never have a chance to sale a car
80% use the internet to make a simple painless transaction (these are the people you concentrate on)
10% will say I'll be right down and pick it up now.
Before you say I don't know what I am talking about I do realize that you are only going to close about 10% of the internet leads and that 90% are time consuming and will end up nowhere. The internet is here to stay and it will constantly be changing and the best way to be successful at it is to be different. If no one can get a price over the internet I would advertise that not only will I give you the price but will also show you the invoice and whatever you need to see to make a well informed decison on your next car.
...off soap box now...
But I still need to test drive the various cars I am interested in and that usually involves the floor salesfolk. This then puts me in the Inconsiderate Buyer category because I am using their time and they will never get a real shot at selling me.
I want to figure out what car I want before I ask the Internet department for their price. It just seems awkward to me to arrange a price and a test drive from the internet department when I might not actually like the car or more likely, the car I want won't be in the local dealer inventory.
the Internet Manager about a Test Drive; he or she probably, no certainly, will be happy to accommodate...I know I always am...I cannot speak
for any other ISMs out there, but of the 20+ Sales Staff in our store, I am the go to guy about product knowledge & availability because of
my constant use of the net and because I order the cars.
If the car is not your cup of tea; then that is
the way it goes...And remember EVERYONE that you come in contact with at a Dealership that is involved with Sales is on Commission...Only exception would be the Sales Secretary at the
Reception Desk...Even the Managers...Bonus aka Commission.
So, don't give it another thought...Contact the ISM, explain what you would like to do, and be prepared for a great Drive...
Happy Thanksgiving!!!!
: )
Mackabee
I know what the marketing people say, but they're not visiting the same planet Earth that the rest of us live on.
Ed
Ed
I delivered a New Beetle last night to a family that was totally unaware of half the features on the car. They got a New Beetle 4 months ago and it got totalled in a Rear Ender and this was the
replacement. The first one had only 2800 miles on it.
They had received a terrible delivery on the first Beetle, got a great price, but a terrible
Lease Factor...Today they have a better equipped
New Beetle, spending $35.00 less on their
payment, and with a total of $177.00 out of pocket. That is REAL VALUE...And they have an advocate if they need one...
Is that not what people really want? Value and Service?
The key word here is hope. It seems lately there is nothing sophisticated about the people walking through the door. haha
You will still have folks that offer $200 over invoice on a loaded up G35 (with a straight face) offer $500 over invoice on a new "E" class Benz because the say "I know your cost.! - So here's my offer or I'm going down the street" ..
What the consumers forget is, most dealers know what their product is worth and what they selling for in Maryland or in Missouri, but buyers try to use this as some kind of "negotiation tool" against the dealer .. actually it works against the potential buyer.
I just had a 350Z, my golf partner was in LOVE with it, now he knew what I paid for it, he was with me the day I bought it .. He offered me $500 over what I paid for it, he was greatly insulated when I politely refused his offer ..
In his viewpoint, I could always get more and I should be happy with what was offered too me. I had to remind him, that it was going to be sold to a dealer in Arizona, for a lot more than his $500 offer - and my job is not trying to replace "hard too gets" with my time, but my job is finding the "hard too gets" for a profit ... we haven't played golf together now, in over 2 wks, he's upset.
Sorry, but I have never asked him to reduce his prices at his golf store for his products, and I know I have over paid more than once, but it's his business and I do understand business and if I wasn't happy, I could have gone down the street or online.
Terry.
Car_man
Host
Smart Shoppers / FWI Message Boards
: )
Mackabee