Subaru Crew Problems & Solutions

1160161163165166385

Comments

  • sueozsueoz Member Posts: 2
    Thanks for the replies on my transmission problems. It has given me a few things to think about and a few questions to ask. They are putting in a brand new transmission, quoted me $3,800. Subaru is paying all but $1,000. I'm gathering from people I've talked to that getting a rebuilt one might cost me close to that. If I was paying for the whole thing it would be worth it. Still very disappointed. Love the outback, but have had many other cars and have never had transmission problems under 100,000 miles. I guess I'm unrealistic! Anyhow, thanks for the feedback.
  • mrk610mrk610 Member Posts: 378
    I did my 6 month tire rotation clean and wax front and back of each rim deal yeasterday.
    Boy if we are going to have such harsh winters here like we had this winter then I guess I'm going to have to buy a set of winter rims/tires.
    My wheels took a beating this winter . But while cleaning my rims I found that soft scrub is great for getting the inside of the rims spotless.I also noticed that its time for front brakes .I feel it is a little soon to need front brakes . I have 24k miles on the outback now .I'm thinking that I may try to do the job myself .
      

    mike k
  • jimbob17jimbob17 Member Posts: 77
    What is valet mode. I see the same symptoms but I never had a valet, at least in this life. What does it do? Is there any benefit to it?
  • dchengdcheng Member Posts: 4
    Hello. I have a 98 Legacy GT wagon. In the past couple months I've had getting the ignition key into the Off position so I could remove it. I'd have to do some pushing and pulling, but eventually it would click into Off. Car ran fine otherwise.

    Today, while running errands, I put the key in and started, but there was a lot of resistance when I turned it clockwise to Start, and the key didn't kick back from the Start position. The engine starts but when I depress the clutch pedal there is the whirring sound of the starter going with the engine running.

    When I turn the key counter-clockwise, it moves easily into the accessories position but now it won't move into the Off position at all no matter what I do. Of course, the engine is off.

    I've tried jiggling the steering wheel but it's locked tight. My wheels are straight.

    Of course this had to happen on a Sat night at 5:30 pm and all the shops closing up.

    I'm getting it towed to the dealership, but does anyone have any folk remedies that I could try tomorrow? Would disconnecting the battery help in this case, and could I do that safely with the key in the accessory position? Or is major surgery required - ignition core?

    Thanks!
    David

    David
  • subearusubearu Member Posts: 3,613
    sounds like your key cylinder is shot. Nothing major, but it still is a pain. Your dealer should be able to take care of it for you.

    I doubt there is any home remedy you can try to fix this yourself. If you have a garage, you can safely leave the car in 'accessory' position with all accessories off to avoid draining the battery. Otherwise, there probably is an ignition fuse you can pull, but I'd rather not have you worry about that. You can safely pull the negative battery cable as well, but you'll lose radio presets, as well as making the ECU forget it's learned habits from you.

    Do you have an extended warranty? It looks like yours may be out of factory warranty at this point. Not sure how much a new key cylinder runs.

    Be careful if you do get it towed. Flatbed it only!!!

    -Brian
  • subearusubearu Member Posts: 3,613
    Did the Subie today, MPV tomorrow. The winter here wasn't as harsh for us. The wheels cleaned up very easily. Rewaxed 'em, rotated front->back, and corrected the tire pressures to 32 all around.

    Also noticed that the OEM Firestones are wearing rather evenly. However, I doubt they'll make it through another winter, as the wear bar indicators are not showing yet, but are getting closer. Will probably have to spring for tires in the fall.

    Mike - what kind of wax are you using on your rims? I used Turtle Wax Finish 2000 and it seems to hold up very well on the rims.

    -Brian
  • masanmasan Member Posts: 77
    The seatback in my '03 Forester creaks when I first lean up against it getting in and out of the car. It's kind of annoying. Is this unusual?
  • jaw49jaw49 Member Posts: 1
    I agree with cpcp. I was told today that the howling noise in my '98 Forester is due to faulty wheel bearings and need to be replaced for a ridiculous cost of $600. Wheel bearings should last for 50,000 miles !!

    #7 of 1112 Wheel Bearing Problem by cpcp Jun 20, 2002 (11:49 am)
    99' Forester 41,500 miles, straight hiway miles(no off-road). Front wheel bearing has to be replaced. I'm the third forester owner in a facility off 200 people that this has happened to (all between 40,000 and 50,000 miles). Calling various dealers in North East show that this problem is very common (left rear replaced most often)and expensive. Some dealerships do not put Forester bearings back on the rear---they use Legacy bearings which they feel are more robust. Front Legacy bearings are unfortunately not compatible. Some of the Parts Department people feel it is a seal problem. In any event this is a Subaru problem and should not be a Customer problem. Bearings should not fail this early (if ever). There is either a supplier problem (bad parts), a design problem, or an installation problem. In any event it is wide spread. This cost should not be passed on to the Customer. The cost should be adsorbed by Subaru.
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    Leave the key in the ignition, and use keyless to get in. ;-)

    Time to wash all the pollen off our cars, too!

    -juice
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    None of our seats creak (2 Subies in our fleet). I'd try some lithium grease on the tracks.

    Subaru went with a different bearing design for the 2003 Forester. For earlier models, indeed, get the part numbers from a Legacy.

    Also, try a wholesaler to buy the parts, they are usually a lot less. Try parts@libertysubaru.com or subaruparts.com for those. Then have a local, trusted mechanic install it. I bet you spend half.

    FWIW, the front wheel bearing for our 626 cost $820 or so, IIRC. $600 is relatively cheap for a dealer repair, at least per my experience.

    -juice
  • idahodougidahodoug Member Posts: 537
    Those prices are insane - absolutely off the scale. I paid $55 ea. for factory wheel bearings for my LandCruiser. Yes, you have to know your way around a car to pound out old races and pound in new ones, but I don't think it took me 3 hours for both fronts. Wheel bearing replacement takes:

    Removal of wheel
    Unbolt and move aside brake caliper
    A few nuts holding brake rotor/bearing on
    Pound out old race with hammer and drift
    Clean.
    Pound in new race
    Pack new bearing with grease.
    Reassemble.

    That price seems tantamount to something technical like a valve job, clutch replacement, or the like.

    IdahoDoug
  • n8wvin8wvi Member Posts: 43
    In our '02 VDC, the keyless has no affect if there is a key in the ignition. This is a safety 'feature' I believe.
  • masanmasan Member Posts: 77
    re: None of our seats creak (2 Subies in our fleet). I'd try some lithium grease on the tracks.

    It's not the track. It's the back of the seat, inside the material.
  • mrk610mrk610 Member Posts: 378
    I use Turtle wax Emerald series liquid . Very easy on very easy off and no powdery wax residue.
    I use vinylex on the interior and out side rubber. and I use turtle wax tire wax on the tires .
    So is it normal to have to get new front pads at 24k miles . It seems a little soon to me .

    Mike k
  • c_hunterc_hunter Member Posts: 4,487
    24K is too soon under normal conditions, so is there any "abnormal" reason why they would have worn out so early? I have about 22000 miles on my Outback, and the brakes have a long way to go (this is an auto by the way, which chews through brakes faster than manuals). My parents have my old 2000 Outback with over 40000 miles on the original brakes (5-spd).

    Craig
  • lfdallfdal Member Posts: 679
    Long time Subaru owners feel free to chime in after they read this and tell me I don't have a problem.

    Yesterday I made a round trip of about 240 miles in my 03 Forester. On the way out I ran with the cruise control on for a good part of the way and set to about 70 mph. The tach was mostly around 3000 rpm.

    On the way back, I ran the car somewhat harder - prolonged stints at 80 mph and up a couple of very long grades that had the engine at about 5000 rpm (no more than that) for several minutes at a time.

    I checked the oil this morning (I had last checked it Thursday - same parking spot, same incline etc...., so the bias angle on the dip stick was the same) and found I burned a pint of oil. Seems like a lot to me..... I'm 2000 miles into this oil change and thus far the car has never burned any oil - the engine has 8200 miles on it.

    BTW, while it was sucking down the oil it did give me mileage of 25.5 to the gallon.

    Is this oil consumption normal when the engine is pushed like this?

    Thanks for any comments.

    Larry
  • blaneblane Member Posts: 2,017
    lfdal:

    It may not be worth asking, but... when you checked your oil level after your trip, did you wait a couple of minutes for the oil to drain back into the sump? If not, you would have gotten a false low-oil reading.
  • kenskens Member Posts: 5,869
    Larry,

    On one hand, 1/2 quart per 2000 miles isn't something to be alarmed about but on the other, it is kind of unusual for a new engine.

    Spirited driving can sometimes increase oil consumption a bit, FWIW.

    Keep an eye on the oil level and see if it is a recurring thing. The best course of action given the newness of the engine would be to have the dealer document it and take a look.

    Ken
  • lfdallfdal Member Posts: 679
    blane - Actually, I checked it the next morning.....

    Ken - Its not 1/2 quart per 2k that worries me. It's the 1/2 quart per 240 miles that makes me wonder.

    Larry
  • paisanpaisan Member Posts: 21,181
    that is fairly normal IMHO for brakes to go. My dad's Legacy L burns through them ever 10-15K miles.

    -mike
  • armtdmarmtdm Member Posts: 2,057
    2201 Lengend Wagon that I just noticed has a loud piston slap or valves for the first few minutes every morning when the engine is cold. Is this common? Dealer says this is common but do I trust the dealer?
  • lucien2lucien2 Member Posts: 2,984
    what are kidding me?The OB has seen 4 track days and the GT has at least a dozen autocrosses on it. both cars are on their second set of pads. The OB with 54K and the GT with 64K
  • stevekstevek Member Posts: 362
    my GT had 65K when I put in new pads and it still had maybe 5-8K left on them I just did not want to take the chance of runining the rotors
  • paisanpaisan Member Posts: 21,181
    The Legacy L just has smaller pads, also don't forget we live in bumper to bumper traffic, there will be a significant difference between highway milage and bumper to bumper east coast urban traffic.

    -mike
  • psgpsg Member Posts: 72
    What torque for the rear differential plugs? I changed the gear oil in both diffs over the weekend in my 1995 Legacy L. Thanks for the jack on the end of the breaker bar suggestion for getting the rear plugs out (I think I read that here). No way I could of gotten them out any other way. I put them back in at 30 ftlbs.

    Phil
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    Doug: good info, thanks. Could a live axle Land Cruiser be simpler than an indy Subie suspension, though? I'm curious.

    masan: you must have two layers of foam padding rubbing against each other. One idea would be to insert a sheet of wax paper inbetween them. I saw a WRX at the NY Auto Show, someone had undone the bottom of the front passenger seat. I had zippers that went up the sides, so doing that would be easy on a WRX. Not sure about your Subie though.

    I think most manufacturers' rule of thumb is one quart per 1000 miles is the max "normal" consumption. 240 miles is short for that kind of consumption IMO.

    Crawl under the car. Look at the oil filter, the gaskets, the bottom area near the front seals. Do you see any signs of a leak?

    Tom: please clarify, is it a 2001 Legacy? That's a Phase II engine, I didn't think they were succeptible to piston slap.

    -juice
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    Also, paisan, doesn't your family buy autos? You have that constant crawl at idle that the brakes fight, plus no engine braking.

    Jack on a breaker bar, wow that was tight. I'll do mine at 60k so thanks for sharing the experience.

    -juice
  • ken_from_njken_from_nj Member Posts: 105
    no creak in the seat for my 03 forester.
  • kenskens Member Posts: 5,869
    Larry: Sorry, must have read your post wrong. I thought it was 2000 miles. Yes, 240 miles is certainly unusual!

    Tom: Can you describe the noise a little more in detail (characteristics, how long it lasts, etc.)? Like juice wrote, Phase II engines are less prone to piston slap, although I don't think any vehicle is 100% free from it ever happening. Some Impreza owners had a loose timing belt tensioner that was causing a slap noise too.

    Ken
  • paisanpaisan Member Posts: 21,181
    all ATs for us, can't really have an MT in the city.

    -mike
  • nygregnygreg Member Posts: 1,936
    I have the morning "knock". Goes away about 1-2 minutes after the coolant reaches operating temp. Going to 10W-30 (mobil 1) seems to have reduced it slightly.

    Greg
  • andrewf2andrewf2 Member Posts: 4
    Hi, I have a 2002 Subaru Outback,manual transmission with about 11,000 miles on it.

    Every since I got the car, about 14 months ago now, it often does a small backfire or pop, sometimes quite loud, usually as I let out the clutch after shifting, or if I've been coasting (in gear) then hit the gas.

    I reported it to my dealer, and originally they said that it was just the engine breaking it, then after taking it in for my 7000 Mile service, and I still complained, they said this is normal for manual Subarus. After taking it in for my most recent service, they said that Subaru had a computer mod that was supposed to help the problem, but so far was only available on the forester/impreza.

    Although I realise this problem is not critical, this is my first new car, and I'm finding very annoying. Especially now that the weathers getting nicer, and I like to drive with the window down.

    I was just wondering if anyone else has had similar problems (seeing as my dealer says it is common), and if they where able to resolve them.

    Thanks

    Andrew
  • armtdmarmtdm Member Posts: 2,057
    As NYGREG stated, goes away after 1-2 minutes. A 2001 Legacy.

    Could try the oil route.
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    For that backfire, I'd try to reset the ECU. It may be running too lean or too rich.

    Disconnect the negative battery terminal. Then step on the brake pedal until the brake light fades out, killing residual power. Reconnect the battery, start her up until idle.

    She'll run a little rich until the ECU leans it out again, hopefully sans back fire. Worth a try.

    -juice
  • subearusubearu Member Posts: 3,613
    on my '00 Outback. Goes away within a few minutes of driving. Mobil-1 here as well.

    -Brian
  • andrewf2andrewf2 Member Posts: 4
    Thanks Juice, I'll give that a try tonight.

    Disconnecting the battery won't cause the security system to "forget" my keyless entry remotes? I assume the information is stored in some sort of non-volatile memory.

    Andrew
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    I don't have an alarm, but my keyless did still work. The flashers were blinking, but a quick lock/unlock pattern made it happy. YMMV.

    -juice
  • kenskens Member Posts: 5,869
    Andrew,

    The alarm system stores your keyless remote codes in some form of non-volatile memory and won't be affected by a battery disconnect.

    However, the alarm goes off by default when you reconnect that battery so have the keyfob ready in your hand. I stuff a towel in the alarm horn to retain my hearing.

    Ken
  • jfljfl Member Posts: 1,398
    Phil, you're welcome. (That was my suggestion as it took all the tricks I knew to remove the rear diffy plugs.) You are spot on for the torque. 32.5 +/- 2.9 ft-lb.

    Jim
  • I need a little advice on a price-versus-benefit dilemma I'm in. The vehicle is a 2000 Subaru Legacy GT Limited sedan with manual tranny. The mileage is at 29,500, and I priced out the 30,000-mile service with my local dealerships. One of the shops had two service plans:
    1. Gold - Perform everything recommended in the service manual; fluids are drained and replaced. Priced at $346 with tax.
    2. Platinum - Perform everything recommended in the service manual; fluids are FLUSHED and replaced. Priced at $600 with tax.

    What do you think? Is the added benefit of flushing the coolant, tranny, diffys, and transfer case worth the extra $254? I like the thought of completely replacing the fluid through a flush, but that's a pretty steep price.

    BTW, I mentioned that my clutch was chattering, and the service advisor said they would take care of it under warranty no problem.

    -Ty
  • locke2clocke2c Member Posts: 5,038
    no, it's not worth the premium for the flush. nothing benefits from that except an automatic transmission (which you don't have) and a radiator (which is pretty fresh at 30k).

    -Colin
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    Wait until 60k. My guess is it would be unnecessary.

    -juice
  • jfljfl Member Posts: 1,398
    I agree w/ Colin. Skip the flush.
  • jim259jim259 Member Posts: 3
    After 6500 miles on my '03 XS, the reverse lights would not come on. I brought the car to a dealer, and the warranty covered a bad switch in the transmission. Supposedly, a gasket on the tranmission allowed water in, which corroded the switch. I was wondering if you think this had anything to do with the parking rod recall, which was performed 4-5 months ago?

    Someone had made a comment about not going ahead with the parking rod recall because they didn't someone taking apart their brand new transmission.
  • hondafriekhondafriek Member Posts: 2,984
    My 2 cents skip the flush, like Colin suggested,a full flush is only necessary with an automatic, with a manual tranny it is just drain and refill, the extra $254 is just pure gravy for the dealer.

      Cheers Pat.
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    The recall was early on, so if anything does come up as a result of the service, it would be covered. That plus they cover any repair for 1 year or 12k miles.

    I wouldn't worry about it, I'd do the recall. Think of it this way - you get fresh ATF free in the deal.

    -juice
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    I did the tranny and the rear diffy on my Miata.

    Took 4 quarts for the tranny, IIRC, so even with synthetic gear oil that was $28 plus maybe an hour of my labor.

    For the diffy, it was one quart, or $7, plus 20 minutes labor. I did also buy an oil pump for under $10, but I've used it on other cars too.

    -juice
  • hondafriekhondafriek Member Posts: 2,984
    The laughable thing to me is the choice of language between the two services.

    In the gold all fluids are drained and replaced.

    In the platinum all fluids are flushed (BS.) the only fluid that would be flushed would be an Auto tranny,so basically the dealer is laughing all the way to the bank when anyone opts for the platinum even those with an auto tranny.

     The extra cost to the dealer is the extra amount of tranny fluid for the full flush, and that hardly costs the dealer anywhere close to $254.

      Cheers Pat.
  • locke2clocke2c Member Posts: 5,038
    ah... well actually I've definitely flushed a radiator or two in my time.

    ;-)

    -Colin
  • jfljfl Member Posts: 1,398
    The 60k maintenance really wasn't that much work. I printed juice's list, ordered the parts, and did it piecemeal over a month or two. Other than removing the diffy plugs, it was all pretty straight forward.

    I can't believe I had the dealer do the 30k maintenance...back when I was unemployed! (It does help to be mentally prepared when you work on a car and I probably wasn't then.)

    Jim
Sign In or Register to comment.

Your Privacy

By accessing this website, you acknowledge that Edmunds and its third party business partners may use cookies, pixels, and similar technologies to collect information about you and your interactions with the website as described in our Privacy Statement, and you agree that your use of the website is subject to our Visitor Agreement.