Subaru Forester (up to 2005)

1177178180182183344

Comments

  • jbeckrjbeckr Member Posts: 21
    We have had our XS premium for four months now - just over 4k miles. It is a good car.

    Likes: great visibility, handles well, upgraded stereo sounds great when you play it at higher volumes, I like the looks of the car more and more, good reliability so far. I think the engine has plenty of power.

    Dislikes: gas mileage disappointing, upright windshield has a chip in it.
  • rshollandrsholland Member Posts: 19,788
    If that's true, then I'm certain it will be a Chicago. Both shows are about the same time.

    Bob
  • mritchymritchy Member Posts: 1
    I just purchased a 2002 Forester that was hit in the rear passenger quarter. The parts I need to find include the lift gate(red), rear bumper(silver), and quarter clip (or quarter panel and suspension). My question is this: is there a better (or alternate) way to find parts nationally than car-parts.com? Maybe a forum listing Foresters that are being parted out, or Forester "sightings" at local junk yards/auto recyclers? Any help would be appreciated.
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    Subaru has a 1% market share and they tend to last, so Subarus at junk yards are about as rare as vegetarians at a hot-dog eating contest.

    I go a couple of time per year with my brother-in-law to check it out. I've seen maybe one or two Loyales and I think one first generation Legacy, but that's it, and that's after going to 3 different "parts recyclers" several times.

    Try e-mailing parts@libertysubaru.com. If you get parts at wholesale they're very reasonable, a new OE bumper cover is something like $150, $125 for a taillight, etc.

    Can't wait to see the new Forester turbo. All I'm asking for is 200hp, but 220 or even 250 could make it a real screamer. Car & Driver just tested the new Infiniti FX45, and it has the best 0-60 of any current model (quicker than the ML AMG and X5 V8), at 6.3 seconds, and the Forester could beat that if it gets 250hp.

    A Cayenne turbo might be quicker but that's about it, and "Porsche SUV" is an oxymoron anyway.

    -juice
  • mckeownmckeown Member Posts: 165
    The biggest I have seen, and gotten parts from, to date is F&S Subaru in Roxbury Ct. (Just a few miles east of Danbury Ct. Their Web address is:
    http://www.fsautoparts.com/
  • retiredguyretiredguy Member Posts: 67
    First, thanks Kens.for the info on the auto trans..

    What type of driving do you do..and what are some examples of mpg..TIA
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    That's funny because my brother-in-law lives in CT. Guess we went to two different ones, in Bridgeport IIRC.

    -juice
  • kenskens Member Posts: 5,869
    That's great news that the Turbo Forester will be unveiled in Feb! That's a lot sooner than I had expected.

    I certainly hope it makes at least 200HP, preferably with the 2.5 engine. Now if Subaru offered it with a Cross Sport like package, I'd be stoked!

    Ken
  • kate5000kate5000 Member Posts: 1,271
    This is me rooting for at least 220 HP in the Turbo Forester

    <chanting continues>
    220! 230! 240! 250!...
  • tidestertidester Member Posts: 10,059
    <chanting continues>
    220! 230! 240! 250!...

    Powermonger! ;-)

    tidester, host
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    I'm not sure if a Cross Sports-like model would sell well here, it's lowered IIRC, and people already complain the Forester is too low.

    It wouldn't keep me away, but I bet sales overall would be better if it even had slightly bigger tires on 17" rims, with more clearance overall.

    -juice
  • rshollandrsholland Member Posts: 19,788
    I would rather see it a bit more off-road oriented, but that's just me. ;)

    Bob
  • inharmswayinharmsway Member Posts: 153
    Hi Guys. I have been a "lurker" on this forum for a long time, and your posts have helped me make up my mind to get a Forester. Then the turbo rumor started, and I thought we would wait for that, but now after reading that other countries(especially Australia with the 2.5L) get a dual range transmission, I wonder if Subaru will bring this to USA. Have anybody heard something about that?

    Niels
  • xccoachlouxccoachlou Member Posts: 245
    I spoke with a dealer and they did confirm that a price increase was coming in February. :(

    - Lou
  • kenskens Member Posts: 5,869
    Niels,

    I doubt that Subaru would bring the dual range tranny to the US, mainly due to price considerations. Also, the dual range tranny is available only with the manual transmission. 90% of Foresters sold in the US are with automatic transmissions.

    However, we asked for the Hill Holder clutch and we got it, so who knows?

    Ken
  • inharmswayinharmsway Member Posts: 153
    Ken
    I would get the manual transmission because I think it is more fun, and you have better control. Also we will tow a small folding trailer (Chalet), so the 2400# capacity is best. The low range would come in handy for this and also for driving on steep dirt roads, when I go train chasing. I read that a non turbo is better for offroad.
    Any comments.

    Niels
  • sfdriversfdriver Member Posts: 35
    I broke down and purchased a Forester X over the weekend, after finding out about the price increase. The dealer even showed me his computer printout of future orders, and his invoice prices for the X were indeed $300 higher. After some dickering, he agreed to $200 below current invoice and absolutely no lower. I'm was too tired (shopping the whole day, and it was past 8 already) to bargain further. After coming home, I begin to wonder if Subaru intends to raise the price by $300 and later offer a $500 incentive.
  • kajkokajko Member Posts: 70
    Niels, i think given Ken's observation about 90% AT's and the few people who would enjoy a more off-road Forester, we can keep dreaming...

    i figure Subaru is going in the USA for the more rally, auto-X looks/crowd since there are plenty of serious Jeep 4X4 clubs, unlike Australia.

    Speaking of Australia, i just spoke with Scorpion Automotive (in Qld) and they are still developing the springs for 2003MY. it turns out the suspension changed quite a bit, including different springs in the rear. I will have to wait a couple of months to get the taller springs and be content dressing it up with other "goodies". I put in the Sylvania SilverStar bulbs in the headlights (after a couple of weeks of reading messages and finding them for $15ea). I am not sure if they are much brighter, but i do enjoy the MUCH whiter light and think it's well worth the $30 for a pair. Another recent modification was replacing the "engine splash guard" with an aluminum plate.

    For pics, see http://www.imagestation.com/album/?id=4291027207. Sony disabled direct link... ;-(
     
    cheers

    oh, as far as chanting, i'll join kate <220><220><220><230>....does it mean better MPG?
  • xccoachlouxccoachlou Member Posts: 245
    Writing about the CR-V, DH says, "The CR-V is no bargain, but its asking price can be justified by its extensive standard equipment and numerous qualities.", and "It is quite reasonable for a vehicle in this category, covering 20 mpg of regular unleaded. This provides it with a cruising range of 300 miles."

    And then when we get to the Forester, in the same part of his review, he writes, "Price/Equipment: Compared to other vehicles with veritable off-road capabilities, the Forester is very expensive for what it really is, i.e., a nicely equipped all-wheel drive station wagon." and "The Forester average 20 mpg of regular unleaded with either transmission, expect to have to fill up every 280 miles or so."

    Doesn't the Forester have a 15.9 gallon fuel tank? 15.9 times 20 is 318 miles... ummm...
  • rochcomrochcom Member Posts: 247
    Where in Toronto is the auto show being held? If it stops snowing long enough, I might take a drive.
  • kenskens Member Posts: 5,869
    Niels,

    I agree that a manual tranny is more fun -- that's why my Forester is a 5-speed. :-)

    Turbos are not necessarily "bad" for off roading. Off roading applications typically call for low end torque. A properly tuned turbo engine can deliver good low end torque. If Subaru does offer the 2.5L turbo in the Forester, it will most likely be a low-boost version that spools up quickly.

    Ken
  • gened1gened1 Member Posts: 256
    How hard are the Sylvania Silverstar bulbs to install. Does the bulb take care of the high and low beam? Are the numbers the same as in the Subaru owners manual, and do you feel there is a need for a "stronger" wiring harness or can you just plug them in the socket the old ones came out of?
    Thanks for the info.
    Gene
  • cbmortoncbmorton Member Posts: 252
    The auto show in Toronto is held at the Metro Toronto Convention Centre and Skydome, right downtown. See http://www.autoshow.ca for more info.
  • hypovhypov Member Posts: 3,068
    xccoachlou Jan 27, 2003 10:55pm

    and the CR-V fuel capacity = 15.3gal.
    Interesting math. :)

    -Dave
  • rshollandrsholland Member Posts: 19,788
    Subaru used to offer it here, but several years back decided to drop that feature, much to my dismay.

    Bob
  • kajkokajko Member Posts: 70
    Gene,

    the bulbs are H4 = 9003 and they are pretty much the same as the OEM including Hi/Lo, no harness or modifications required. Strangely enough, Sylvania says that they are 65/72W but the bulb has the same 55/65W markings on the lip as the old one. ??!!

    in any case, mine is 2003, so might be a bit different: i removed the silencer box to have more room to work behind the RH headlight, on the LH, the battery makes it tight, but still doable. the hardest thing was to take the plug off of the bulb (1st thing to do). make sure you feel and squeeze the socket on both sides, don't just tug on it. There are arrows indicating that, but you really just need to feel the plastic through the rubber. Once you remove the plug, take off the rubber "skirt" and there is a metal retainer that holds the bulb in place. You need to squeeze it and tilt it back to free the bulb. The bulb goes in only one direction, with the tabs aligned in a triangle pointing up (similar to a mercedes sign). Most important thing is to not touch any of the bulbs as the dirt and oil from your hands can eventually crack the glass as it heats up.

    I didn't change the foglight bulbs, because i would rather find the Hella YellowStar bulbs. Anyone know if they are available as H3 ??
  • kate5000kate5000 Member Posts: 1,271
    He better does not get in my way. We bought husband's (now hated) Accord in 1997, largely due to super-duper reviewes of Mr. Heraud and other auto-reviewers. This was the time when Internet really became a source of autoinfo, so we decided to believe those professionals as opposed to our own test drives. BIG mistake. And yes, he is unfair, and that comparison of his review of CR-V and Forester clearly shows it.

    In fact, even entry-level Forester X is very well equipped for its class and trim, and very reasonably -- if not plain cheaply -- priced.
  • ducktapeguyducktapeguy Member Posts: 115
    Which skidplate is that? And how much was it?

    Oh wait, I just enlarged the picture, and I can see primitive racing stamped on it. Looks really nice
  • kenskens Member Posts: 5,869
    Gene,

    I use Philips Vision Plus bulbs in my Forester and absolutely love them. They are not the cheezy HID-look alike bulbs that have a blue coating the make the light look whiter, nor are they overwattage bulbs that can risk damage to your wiring harness. They simply are the best halogen bulb out there. The light output is noticeably brighter and whiter than standard halogens. The beam cutoff is very sharp and does a great job of illuminating the road and signs. Also, the Vision Plus bulbs last a lot longer than typical Xenon-filled halogens Hella Premiums.

    Unfortunately, you can't get these Stateside. I order mine from the below vendor -- they've been very quick and reliable.

    http://www.autolamps-online.com/halogen/visionplus1.htm

    Ken
  • oilwell99oilwell99 Member Posts: 1
    I have a 2001 Forester. It started making a noice about 1000 miles after an oil service. It has 24200 miles on it. Took it in to Subaru for check-up. Subaru informed me that there were no diff. fluid in the transmission!! Completely dry!!
    Is it likely the lube store drained the diff fluid?? If so, how could I have driven 1000 miles before this happened??? Or is this a Forester problem Subaru is trying to cover up??
    Have anyone else had this problem with their Subaru??
    Like to know asap!!
    Thank you for responding!!
    PS Love the car in general!!
  • paisanpaisan Member Posts: 21,181
    You probably could have driven 1000 miles w/o diffy fluid. It wouldn't suprise me. Subies are that good.

    I'd look at the shop that did the change for the problem...

    -mike
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    I find it a little surprising that only the auto gets an oil cooler, yet the manual is rated to tow 400 lbs more. Also, the auto tranny is generally considered more robust.

    The 5 speed is quicker and more fun, plus more efficient to boot (never mind EPA figures, ask around).

    But pick your tranny preference and don't look back.

    kajko: LOVE the skid plate! Solid!

    Did you get the replacement springs yet?

    Lou: reviewers aren't consistent. I do sometimes wish for a bigger gas tank, but range in the CR-V is even less than in the Forester. My wife's Legacy has 1 gallon more than my Forester, and it comes in handy.

    John: yes, fly-by-night oil change shops have been known to drain the wrong fluid when changing the oil. The trans fluid drain plug is readily visible, while the oil pan's plug is hidden behind the plastic cover.

    That it went 1000 miles shows how tight tolerances are in a Japanese-designed drivetrain. It went that far without any lubrication? Wow.

    -juice
  • beanboybeanboy Member Posts: 442
    Change my own oil. Doesn't matter how cold it is. I've heard too many horror stories over the years.

    Oilwell99, where to begin? Know any good lawyers first off? If the oil change place drained the tranny by mistake, I would hope they would have noticed the problem when they tried to cram new oil in an already filled engine. Then again, stranger things have happened.

    After a 1000 miles it might be tough to tell that the oil wasn't changed when it should have been, one reason I always tell people who do take their cars in for oil changes to always check the level afterwards, and in doing so, the condition of the oil.

    -B
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    Good point, beanboy. If the didn't drain the engine oil, and then overfilled that by 5 quarts, you're left with two problems.

    If you do get an oil change at a dealer, mark the old oil filter with a grease pencil, then you can assure they put in a new one. Also check the oil level then, and every time you fill up the gas tank.

    -juice
  • gened1gened1 Member Posts: 256
    Thanks for the info. I am thinking of replacing my lights and needed the info you provided.
    Gene
  • ducktapeguyducktapeguy Member Posts: 115
    After an oil change, ALWAYS check the fluids. Most of those guys working there don't know what they're doing, so it is very likely, I would almost say definitely, they drained the wrong one. I would also recommend to change the oil yourself, but I'm lazy and sometimes I usually take it to one of those quik lube places too. but I always look at them when they're draining it to make sure they don't make a mistake, and i always check all the fluids as soon as they're done. I've had some bad experiences, but if you keep your eye on them, it's not so bad. I've thought of putting a big sticker or painting "OIL" on the skid plate with an arrow, or getting some sort of cover for the transmission and diffy bolt so they can't just unscrew it, just haven't gotten around to it.
  • taft4taft4 Member Posts: 57
    If your dealer is handy, why not let them do all the servicing, including the oil changes? My dealer charges $19.95 for a filter and oil change and I tell the service writer I come there because they have my record in their computer and if my car is serviced wrong and a problem develops, I know who to blame. They are careful and efficient in their work.
  • c_hunterc_hunter Member Posts: 4,487
    I would never go to a place like Jiffy Lube, Pep Boys, Sears, etc... for oil changes. I know at least 5-6 people that have gotten royally screwed that way. Most recent is my wife -- she took her 626 (traded in for a Forester last August) to a Pennzoil shop for an oil change. Next day, the car reeked of burnt oil and smoked. Overnight, oil would collect on the ground. I reached under for the filter, and it was barely on -- not even hand tight. Of course, the morons made up some excuse.... At least she got her money back.

    The only good part was that this became one of those rare cases where my "I told you so" gained some minor credibility with my wife. Of course, the Forester gets all it's oil changes done in my garage.

    I remember when I first started reading Edmunds back in 2000, some poor soul wrote in that Montgomery Ward had drained his new Outback's transmission dry and then overfilled the engine with oil. Totally destroyed the transmission, and would make me have serious doubts about the long term dependability of the engine (overfilling is a sure way to blow seals, gaskets, etc...). As different as auto transmission fluid and oil look, feel, and smell, you'd think this kind of mistake would be caught. Tells you how cluless and careless most of these shops are.

    Craig
  • merrill3merrill3 Member Posts: 6
    I am considering buying a new Forester X, automatic. When test driving it tonight, I thought it seemed as if the brakes locked up very easily. I was going about 35 downhill on dry pavement and hit the brakes (hard), and they locked up, and the anti-lock kicked in. Of course, it is good that the anti-lock worked, but I don't think they should have locked up at that speed - other cars haven't along that same road at the same speed - I drove a couple that same night. It happened a few other times also on a flat stretch. Also, when I braked on a curve, it seemed to skid and zig-zag a bit (more when turning to the right, I think).
    Any thoughts?
    Thanks! Overall, I love the car and otherwise it handles great. Just trying to convince myself to stay with the base model and not break my budget for that great sunroof!
  • zigzag7239zigzag7239 Member Posts: 40
    I once had the oil on a '79 Volvo changed on the road, at a service station. Thought it would be a good idea since I had started on a cross-country trip and hadn't had time for the dealer to do it. They assured me that they had the right filter. Half-way across the desert I figure out that they used the wrong size filter and that it was mis-threaded. Morons (shoulda listened to my old man who always said that you should never have a car serviced on the road unless necessary).

    Another time I was at a quick-lube place and told them DO NOT touch the air filter (I knew it was clean and that it was very hard to reassemble the housing anyway). So the first thing one of the guys does (I can see him through the hood opening but he doesn't know it) is unclip the air filter housing and wipe an oily rag across the filter as he removes it. He walks up to me and tells me I need a new air filter, and I read him the riot act and end up with a free oil change (at least they got that part right). Of course, I had to spend 15 minutes reassembling the air filter housing because he was so clueless. I could've complained to the State Attorney General but it wasn't worth my time. Complete idiots who can't be trusted to walk a dog.

    Dealerships aren't much better but at least you know they're familiar with the cars and have the right parts.
  • zigzag7239zigzag7239 Member Posts: 40
    db - It looks to me as though Foresters are going for invoice or below. One indicator is fitzmall.com, which shows both inventory and discount pricing. Also, I think I saw in Automotive News that there's a large dealer incentive on the cars - I can't remember exactly but my memory tells me that it was over $1000. So even at invoice the dealers are making a lot of money.
  • gvmelbrtygvmelbrty Member Posts: 64
    >posted by kens in Meet the Members:
    >
    >Has anyone seen this link?
    >
    >http://www.subaru-global.com/lineup/forester/interview/

    Kens, my favorite line from these interviews was:

    "While the Forester is a product for distribution in the marketplace, what is extravagant about the car is that no effort or cost was spared on areas that can't be seen."

    That's what I like about Subaru, attention to detail in the areas that can't be seen.

    Not that they didn't do the same for the areas that can be seen. The interview says the interior designers wanted to use a dimpled texture on the Forester's dash, but were concerned about the accumulation of dust in the dimples. So they experimented with various dimple designs and finally settled on one that had smoother dimple edges that collected less dust. That's detail.

    -tom
  • paisanpaisan Member Posts: 21,181
    I find it a little surprising that only the auto gets an oil cooler, yet the manual is rated to tow 400 lbs more. Also, the auto tranny is generally considered more robust.

    Juice the reason for no tranny fluid cooler on the manuals is that there is no pump to circulate the fluid through the cooler. You'd need both a pump and the cooler in order to accomplish cooling of the tranny fluid in an MT. In the AT you have a pump pumping ATF so it just pumps it through the cooler before it goes into the ATF.

    -mike
  • c_hunterc_hunter Member Posts: 4,487
    Two things come to mind: 1) something is wrong with the brakes or wheels (tire inflation?) on that particular Forester, and/or 2) the brakes are still green and need to be broken-in gently before doing hard braking. The skid/zig-zag problem you mention makes me think it's more #1. But seriously, you need to go real easy on the brakes of a new car.

    My wife has an 03 Forester XS, and the brakes are great. The way she drives, I would know by now if the brakes were prone to lockup! We took it up to CT for Christmas, which is a 10 hour drive through some nasty traffic. I had plenty of opportunities to test the brakes through DC and on the NJ Turnpike, when 75 MPH traffic would suddenly drop to 10 MPH, and everyone had to slam on the brakes. Pretty much non-eventful in the Forester (though I winced watching cars skidding and squirreling around behind me).

    I should add that we had three people in the car, loaded to the gills, and still got 26 MPG! I was really impressed, and love the car.

    Craig
  • dbenjamin1dbenjamin1 Member Posts: 12
    hi zig- thanks for the info. I'll check out fitzmall for details. Had heard about the price increase in Feb of approx 3-500, but maybe this could be a wash due to the holdback.
    Anyone have experience with dealers in RI- namely Bald Hill, Anchor and Liberty?
    Many thanks,
    db
  • tincup47tincup47 Member Posts: 1,508
    You can't see most because they are integrated into the radiator.
  • paisanpaisan Member Posts: 21,181
    tincup is correct. They are used for both cooling and heating up the ATF.

    -mike
  • nygregnygreg Member Posts: 1,936
    "We sweat the details you don't see". Do you get it?
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    Something's out of whack with that Forester you test drove, maybe the pressure in the tires is off or something. It shouldn't need ABS in those circumstances. Maybe ask if you can drive another one on the same path.

    mike: actually, I think it's an engine oil cooler that I'm talking about. Guess it has both, then. Aftermarket vendors even sell them and you can bolt them right onto a manual, as a matter of fact.

    -juice
  • debaladebala Member Posts: 1
    I have a concern I would like to get everyone's input on. I purchased a 2003 Forester in June of '02. It is a second family vehicle but more importantly it is the car I picked for my 18 year old newly licensed daughter. She is only 5'1" and weighs 95 pounds so I tried to find a car that gave her 12" of space from the steering wheel(air bag) and good visibility. The Forester gave her that and along with side airbags and all the other safety features I was sold. We all enjoyed driving it until this winter. I live in Maine and we have had one snow storm after another. The roads are constantly covered with some form of snow. I have experienced alot of sliding and slipping with my Forester. Along with that alot of what I think is called fishtailing when you make a slight turn and the back end sways back and forth. I am very concerned about this as my whole reason for buying the car was to protect my daughter as much as possible from these country roads. Even my Town & Country 4WD van seems to ride better. My brother has a FWD Saab and he says it sticks to the road like glue. Can anyone help me solve this problem. Thanks.
This discussion has been closed.

Your Privacy

By accessing this website, you acknowledge that Edmunds and its third party business partners may use cookies, pixels, and similar technologies to collect information about you and your interactions with the website as described in our Privacy Statement, and you agree that your use of the website is subject to our Visitor Agreement.