By accessing this website, you acknowledge that Edmunds and its third party business partners may use cookies, pixels, and similar technologies to collect information about you and your interactions with the website as described in our
Privacy Statement, and you agree that your use of the website is subject to our
Visitor Agreement.
Comments
Some of us who own Foresters (I have a 2000) have found that the car is set up to understeer, that is, to exhibit handling opposite of what you describe (to "push" through curves rather than to let the tail slide out) and have installed thicker rear sway bars to compensate. That actually will cause the car to become more tail-happy.
Another thing to check is your daughter's driving reactions when she encounters slippery conditions in curves. If she tries to overcompensate she may actually cause the rear end to slide out - it's not that hard to do.
Finally, even with the best snow tires and one of the best winter handling cars on the market, there are still some road conditions that will cause problems for any driver. All wheel drive can make a driver overconfident in situations where they otherwise would be more prudent.
In my opinion the snow tire route would be the best. In my travels in Maine and northern New England I always saw a lot of Subarus. I figured they were either considered throwaway cars or they had something going for them; that's one of the reasons I ended up in one.
Good luck,
Ed
My wife complained often about the slipping factor... until it actually did slide quite a bit on ice one time (not just the usual tiny slip) and she was able to regain control pretty quickly while someone else nearby lost complete control and went off the road. She came home and said "now I know what the AWD is for!"
'11 GMC Sierra 1500; '98 Alfa 156 2.0TS; '08 Maser QP; '67 Coronet R/T; '13 Fiat 500c; '20 S90 T6; '22 MB Sprinter 2500 4x4 diesel; '97 Suzuki R Wagon; '96 Opel Astra; '11 Mini Cooper S
It also takes some practice getting used to AWD dynamics -- each car is going to behave differently. I find that gently staying on the gas and keeping the steering wheel pointed in the direction I want to go when my Forester begins to slide is the best way to correct itself. The best thing to do is spend some time in a safe and empty parking lot and try some controlled slides.
Ken
I have an 03 Forester with the original issue geolanders. They have been great in the snow or the rain.
I should explain that I don't risk my car in the snow unless I have to get to or from work or its a good reason.
I am more afraid of the drivers of the urban assault vehicles who are not aware of their mortality.
When I bought the tires, the manager of the tire shop was talking with a customer about the fact that during the winter, they acquire many "take-offs," tires that come on new cars and customers decide to replace while they are still nearly new. His opinion was that msny people drive too fast in poor winter conditions and thus conclude that their slipping and sliding are the result of the tires, when it is actually the result of speed too fast for conditions. Drive down a major road after the first big snowstorm of the season and count how many SUVs and tractor-trailers you see stuck in snow drifts or in ditches.
In my commute, I notice that when I drive through the city and suburbs, people keep up their ususal hurry no matter what the conditions. But in the rural area I work in part of the time, people have the sense to slow down and allow more time for maneuvers like turns.
One possible solution to the sliding problem is to adjust tire pressures. Subaru recommends 3 pounds less in back than in front when carrying a light load. If you do what many Forester drivers do and set the pressures the same all around, the higher pressure in the back where there is less weight, will move its response toward oversteer. Keeping the recommended diferential should help, and it can be increased by adding more pressure to the front, if necessary. But, then if you carry a heavy load (rear passengers, luggage, etc.), you need to adjust the pressures higher in the rear to compensate.
Dedicated snow tires are also a possiblity, but you may not like the way they handle on dry pavement.
One big difference: when FWD slips and the front end starts plowing, it's very easy to correct before things get too messy. With AWD or RWD, once the tail gets loose and rotates, you have far less time to correct, thus, it's easier for the car to get out of control.
I'd say the trick is not to get to the point where you lose traction. All else held equal (ie, tires) this is where AWD has a considerable advantage over FWD.
Craig
I am hoping that Foresters get a seamist green or winestone red.
- lou
Thanks!
Also, as soon as many inexperienced drivers sense a slide coming on, they panic and decelerate. Unfortunately, if the wheels have no power going to them, they will slide even more (a similar thing happens in a powerboat - when you cut the throttle, you lose control of the steering). The smart driver knows that he/she needs to go into a slippery turn at a reasonably slow speed and keep power applied.
If you look at the brochures of the AWD manufacturers, you'll notice that they don't list AWD under the "Safety" features - it's usually under "Performance" or "Engineering". There's a reason for this: they know that while AWD can enhance traction, it does not magically prevent a car from fishtailing or sliding in turns on snow and ice, and in the wrong hands can do more harm than good. Unfortunately, too many people buy AWD under the impression that it has magic properties, and the manufacturers and dealers are in no hurry to discourage this thinking.
I'm reminded of the ABS brake phenomenon - people bought ABS thinking it would allow them to stop faster, when in fact it only allows them to stop straighter.
I hope I haven't misstated any scientific principles here, but I hope I've got the idea right. SLOW DOWN.
I admire many things about the 2003 Forester - especially the new dashboard design - and the interviews enhanced my appreciation. But I have some observations and am wondering what others think before I buy:
1) Considering the very refined styling of the new dash, I'm surprised at the fabric and color choices, which don't seem nearly as sophisticated. The base seat fabric isn't bad, but I'm not too sure about the XS fabric. And why are there fewer, rather than more, body color choices in the leather/premium model (can't get Forest Green, or Black/Beige)?
I also prefer the gray cladding, which makes the car look more substantial, to the painted cladding - years ago, you had to pay extra for the gray cladding. But I'll probably get leather so I'll live with it. Just an observation.
2) It seems to me that the cloth armrests on the doors are magnets for dirt and wear. Do owners find this to be the case? (Just wondering in case I get cloth)
3) With all the talk of attention to detail, I'm surprised that the center armrest (even with the optional riser) doesn't extend further forward. Does this bother anyone or do you adjust to it easily?
4) It appears that the automatic climate controls can't just be dialed-in, but have to be held in position or turned more than once in order to adjust (I'm referring to the mode and fan speed controls). Is this true, and does anyone find it bothersome? Is there an advantage to this that I'm missing? I like the layout and looks of the controls but this particular aspect seems un-ergonomic.
I realize that these might be nit-picks but since I noticed them, I wonder why the designers overlooked them and what owners think. Beyond these minor concerns, I'm a big fan of the car. Thanks in advance for any input.
Hope this helps someone.
Gene
Any bets on whether he even drove the car?
I would reiterate, however, that AWD is not magic. One still has to drive cautiously in adverse conditions.
Another 0.02.
One option I never thought I'd care for but would hate to do without now is the heated seats. I think they're great.
From full auto, the system will progressively go into manual as you override each setting. If you override all settings, the system will be in full manual mode. The in-between seems confusing to my wife, who usually ends up fighting with the system. Personally, I leave the system on full auto, and use the temp control to make it do what I want. Works for me.
Craig
Is anyone else having minor but pain in the neck problems? I love having the Roadside Assistance - they've been great, but I'm not thrilled that I've had to use it.
As for the snow driving, my recommendation is to get out in a snowy parking lot and practice, practice, practice.
Sure, snow tires help, but there is nothing like experiencing it for yourself.
Try to simulate several common conditions - test the ABS in a curved, quick stop. Sample drop-throttle oversteer, maybe in 2nd gear (make sure you have lots of room). Practice steering corrections in skids.
I don't mean to brag, but I can take a turn with all four wheels drifting in perfect control. You actually ADD throttle when you oversteer, so the AWD shifts power to the front and that steers you out of the skid. It's counterintuitive so you may need practice.
ABS can be surprising, too, because you expect to skid but don't, the vehicle may actually turn when you don't expect it to.
The Forester is relatively light and has a short wheelbase. The same characteristics that make it nimble, i.e. turn in quicker, make it succeptible to driver error in emergency manuevers.
I bet that parking lot lesson will teach a 16 year old driver more than any driver's Ed course ever did.
-juice
Thanks
-Frank P.
Glad you weren't injured. Good luck with the repairs and the aftermath.
Ed
Greg
disclaimer: I like gray cladding too!
Sorry to hear of the accident.
Glad that no one got hurt.
Don't think not braking would have helped.
The car in front probably braked hard and nose dived too; hence, raising its end.
-Dave
Bob
Twenty years is an eternity. Consider yourself an outlier in accident-free driving!
Keep us updated on your repairs.
Ken
Actually, I drove an X yesterday and found the beige weave to be quite nice - I like it better than velour. And it's not as chilly as leather, so seat heaters wouldn't be missed as much.
I could also get the XS, replace the Moquette with leather, and have the heated seats and auto-climate. I had a chance to operate the auto-climate controls and while the design isn't perfect, it would be easy to get used to, and the dials are a lot smoother than the manual controls.
I sorta prefer the single-CD player of the X to the 6-disc changer of the XS, simply because I don't need a cassette player and the single unit has a nice cubby-hole under it - just right for storing CDs or an iPod. I never really cared for changers anyway - I tend to play one CD at a time because my mood changes.
Which raises a question: will CDs fit in the console compartment? Or in the storage tray on the dash? (I usually carry them flat inside their booklets and leave the jewel cases at home - a lot easier and saves space).
Decisions, decisions . . .
We realy wish the radio came with an input jack for hooking up an iPod. I will probably invest in a cassette adapter or RF transmitter, though neither gives the best sound quality. But, it would be better than juggling CDs!
Craig
http://www.griffintechnology.com/products/itrip/
This is why I don't need a cassette player - at least I hope so.
Maybe this should be in the "help me choose" section, but I'm hoping the experienced and knowledgeable folks here will give me an honest and forthright opinion.
Driving a Lexus RX300 right now, but lease is up in May '03 - want to be a bit more pragmatic this time around and believe the Subaru is more want I need versus paying the "big bucks" vehicles like the Lexus command. It's been a great ride, but mortgage, tuition and retirement or looming large.
C'mon guys 'n gals - be honest - let's hear your true thoughts on the ups and downs of Subaru ownership - is it as good/great as I hear? Which model is the best for me?
The Forester is a great vehicle, and I can't say enough good things about it -- fun to drive, great gas mileage, handles amazingly well, and looks great in my opinion. So let me focus on the obvious issues in your case -- if you are used to a luxury vehicle like the RX300, the Forester may be a bit crude to you (even though it is fine by "regular" car standards). In addition, the back seat is tight, especially on legroom, which might be a problem if you need to stick older kids back there. Otherwise, I highly recommend this car, especially compared to the CRV and Escape twins. The CRV has a very spartan interior, is short on power, and drives/handles like a bus. The Tribute/Escape have questionable quality, Ford styling, and drive like an SUV.
I bought the LL Bean Outback and chose it over both the Acura MDX and Lexus RX-300. It is that good. Definitely can compete with the RX-300 for luxury feel, though it will be missing a few of the little touches you get with a Lexus. The LL Bean and all Outbacks have good rear seat room, and ride a little cushier than the Forester (but the Forester handles better). Outback still gets decent gas mileage (about 24 mpg in mixed driving). Outbacks start around $24K, and other Legacy models are even lower. I think they are all great values.
So, in one corner, you have the Forester -- fun to drive, handles great, a bit small, and a teeny bit on the crude side. In the other corner, you have the LL Bean Outback, which is very similar to your Lexus (perhaps more car like). In between, you have the various other Outback (4-cyl) models. The prices tend to overlap the same way. By the way, you can usually negotiate and get most any Subaru for around invoice price or less.
This is just a ramble based on my experience. I really think you need to test drive the various Outback and Forester models for yourself. You will know which one is for you! Both the Forester and Outback have very unique characters, I think the Forester a bit more so.
Good luck!
Craig
I need some help.
I'm trying to decide between a Forrester and an Impreza WRX Sport Wagon.
I have a baby on the way--I know the Forrester is probably more practical, but I like the Impreza Wagon better.
Any advice?
Thanks again for your help.
Bob
The only thing I don't like about the Forester interior is the Moquette fabric on the XS. I think both the leather and the base weave are better-looking and more suitable for this type of car. I don't think you would be "de-valuing" the Forester at all by getting leather - leather is a very durable and comfortable surface in addition to looking great.