By accessing this website, you acknowledge that Edmunds and its third party business partners may use cookies, pixels, and similar technologies to collect information about you and your interactions with the website as described in our
Privacy Statement, and you agree that your use of the website is subject to our
Visitor Agreement.
Comments
Steve
Host
Vans, SUVs, and Aftermarket & Accessories message boards
FYI, HID Xenon headlamp retrofits are illegal. There are plenty of places online that sell the kits, but if you look at the disclaimers, all of them state that the kits are only for show car use. The reason being that HID bulbs require special lenses, reflectors. Lenses and reflectors designed for halogen bulbs won't really do the job and will cause more glare towards other drivers, as well as yourself. What you may want to consider though, is 3rd party auxilary HID Xenon driving/fog lamps.
Good luck...
Drew
Host
Vans, SUVs, and Aftermarket and Accessories message boards
Four questions:
1. Has anyone else experienced this removal of the ABS option from their ES or LX-sport package?
2. Is it only a Canadian manufacturing issue and specific to Mazda (i.e. and not to the Ford Escape)?
3. How important do you feel ABS to be in an SUV?
4. Is the $650 (Cdn) a reasonable reduction and how can I specifically assess if this is the right amount being suggested by [Mazda]?
Welcome back to the states.
I, too, am searching Denver for a Tribute.
It seems a few Silver LX's are the only thing available and dealers are not overeager to part with them (even at MSRP).
I drove an Escape at Burt Ford on Arapahoe. It is listing its Escapes at MSRP as a starting point, so perhaps they will deal a bit. I'm not really sure tho - I really don't like the Escape styling enough to pay a premium.
Please, please update here if you hit a Trib gold mine anywhere in the Rockies, and I will do the same!
It's funny you should ask the question about the value of ABS in an SUV today.
I live about 80km north of you and we had a snowstorm last night. I took out the Tribute to see how it would perform. I tried mashing the brakes hard and holding my foot down, and then I tried threshold braking ( apply the brakes just at the verge of locking up). Each time I stopped in less distance by using threshold braking. But that is what you would expect by having the brakes applied constantly rather than on and off.
It is true that with ABS brakes you can still steer the vehicle with the brakes fully applied, but only at slower speeds and with some grip of the road. Last night when I stomped on the brakes to activate ABS at 30KMH (19 MPH) I could not get the Trib to turn more than 30 degrees into a 90 degree corner So instead of sailing past the intersection I was able to turn enough to go up and over the curb. (NOTE:Do not try this at home, I am a trained professional ;-}.
The Tribute brakes are amongst the best I have had, but that is in their basic design, not because they have ABS. I only got ABS because I wanted the Moon Roof and 6 CD stereo. If I was in your position I think I would order the vehicle without ABS.
Just a word of warning though, with all the marketing hype, you may not be able to get the same resale value as with an ABS equipped vehicle.
Anyone can claim to be a professinal driver. Are you the one who delivered those cold pizza last week?
http://www.theautochannel.com/media/netshow/misc/stomp-stay-steer.asx
http://www.theautochannel.com/media/netshow/abs/abs_56k.asx
ABS requires what Bosch calls GMA (Gier Moment Anstiegsverzögerung; yaw moment increase delay), so that the vehicle won't spin (as seen in the above video clips) if left and right wheels are braked hard on mu-split surfaces, for example both left wheels on asphalt and both right wheels on a snow covered shoulder. GMA delays the brake pressure increase on the wheels with higher traction by a fraction of a second, so that the driver can respond to a braking-induced turning/yawing motion. GMA is turned off in curves when the lateral acceleration exeeds about 0.4 g, since it tends to cause over-steering. This is why I think that our Canadian participant/owner-to-be could really benefit from ABS, especially in the fall and winter months.
ABS' major contribution is the lateral adhesion which allows steering during braking and, depending on the road surface, may decrease the stopping distance as well. WRT threshold braking, that's exactly what ABS does. It applies as much braking power as possible without locking the wheels. Obviously it can do this much quicker than a human can.
ABS systems do not necessarily exploit all available traction. In 2 channel systems only the wheel speed at one front wheel is sensed which can lead to lockup or underbraking of the other front wheel (e.g. Honda ALB). In 3 channel systems and some 4 channel systems the rear wheels are low-value-tied, and the modulation is based on the wheel with the lower adhesion. Only the very best ABS systems (i.e. MB's/BMW's systems) have four wheel sensors/four channels and can use all adhesion at each wheel. I believe the Escape/Tribute uses 3 sensor ABS.
Drew
Host
Vans, SUVs, and Aftermarket and Accessories message boards
Unfortunately I was unable to view the ASX video clips. I am quite interested and I will attempt to locate a suitable viewer.
I feel that in snow conditions threshold braking is the fastest. And of course threshold braking can be performed in a car with or without ABS. With all due respect I have to disagree that ABS performs threshold braking by applying maximum pressure without locking the wheels. In fact the driver applies the pressure with his foot and if it is sufficient to lock the wheel, ABS releases the pressure momentarily and allows the wheel to rotate once again before re-applying the pressure to start the cycle over again.
The point I was trying to make with my story about sliding into the curb, is that the ABS allowed me to steer somewhat during my panic stop but I was still going to fast for the tires to grip and complete the turn. If I had used threshold braking I may have reduced my speed quicker and maybe sufficienly enough that the tires would have had a better chance of gripping during the turn.
Some studies have also shown that a locked wheel produces a ramp of built up snow or gravel in front of the tire which further reduces speed.
I have always agreed that ABS does allow better control in a panic stop, but threshold braking allows quicker stops. Since threshold braking can be done on any vehicle, then I guess the logical conclusion would be that an ABS equipped vehicle is the best all round choice. Except.... when there is no place to turn in a panic stop. In that case then I would prefer just to lock up the tires and shave off as much speed as possible before the inevitable crash.
I had rear ABS only on my last van ( with a single sensor in the differential), and panic stops in the rain were very scary. The rear wheels would lock momentarily and then the pressure would be released and the front wheels where left to do all the braking. Stopping distances were about 3 times longer than if I was prepared for the stop and performed threshold braking. Anyone who drove that vehicle soon lost respect for ABS.
My conclusion, both types have their merits. There is not a clear winner and I would buy a vehicle for it's other features without regard to it's braking type.
Rick
can anyone confirm the 'cabin and road noise' on the tribute ?
also in a consumer report 3/2001, they complained about uncomfortable front seats. how are they really?
otherwise, it looks good.
The Main requirement for any SUV we tested was for sleeping room in the back (The Santa Fe and Forester Not flat enough, the Rav 4 and CRV were too short but the Tribute was just right).
1jimv1, I have some suggestions:
If you remove the rear head rests, insert a metal rod in each hole then attach them to the to the plywood extenders, feet would not have to be added.Your Extenders could be padded with dense foam rubber, wrapped in fabric and stapled on the other side ( this will raise it to the required height or higher for a pillow). They can be removed like headrests and require less storage space.
The space below the extenders can be filled with camping equiptment, tools, laundry etc.
We plan to use a camping mat as space is i big concern.
The V6 is ideal for cooking Foil wrapped corn on the cob----1/2 hour @ 60 mph.
Any other suggestions will be greatly appreciated.
As we drove on the lot, they were just pulling the EXACT one out that we wanted as we pulled up. (Talk about perfect timing.) It was the exact one I had built on-line earlier in the week--color and everything (minus 4WD). Since it was the one we wanted we decided since we live in Texas we could forgo the 4WD. (My wife and I are both from the north and thought we needed it but found it is next to impossible to get down here in Dallas-Fort Worth.)
While we were doing paper work, the saleswoman had to put a sold sign on the vehicle and shoo shoppers and other sales people away.
Love our loaded White Tribute ES. It is beautiful.
Rick
"ABS releases the pressure momentarily and allows the wheel to rotate once again before re-applying the pressure to start the cycle over again."
I have to disagree with the above. The braking-force coefficient and braking effectiveness are highest with the tire at the optimal brake slip. The controller modulates the brake pressure to keep the wheel in the optimal zone. A locked wheel's coefficient is about 10% lower than optimum, depending on the surface. Even more important is the lateral, or sideways, force coefficient, since it decreases to only about 10% of its full value when the wheel locks.
"Some studies have also shown that a locked wheel produces a ramp of built up snow or gravel in front of the tire which further reduces speed."
I definitely agree with the part about the gravel. However, not the snow. My SUV has a special ABS algorithm that allows the front wheels to activate cyclically on loose surfaces. The owner's manual cautions against using it on snow, but I wanted to try it anyway (in a large and empty snow covered parking lot). The end result was that I slid about twice as far in the 5" of snow with locked front wheels, vs. with ABS modulating.
" Except.... when there is no place to turn in a panic stop. In that case then I would prefer just to lock up the tires and shave off as much speed as possible before the inevitable crash."
As mentioned above, a locked wheel's co-efficient is actually less than a wheel on the verge of locking (optimum brake slip). If you lock the wheels, your stopping distances could actually be longer (especially on wet surfaces). A large part also depends on they type of ABS that the vehicle is fitted with. The 4 sensor/4 channel ABS with Brake Assist (applies full brake boost far faster and firmer than a human) is, of course, the most sophisiticated. But, we take what we can get.
"I had rear ABS only on my last van ( with a single sensor in the differential), and panic stops in the rain were very scary. The rear wheels would lock momentarily and then the pressure would be released and the front wheels where left to do all the braking."
FYI, if you don't already know, rear ABS is a mechanical system. No computer controls as with 4 wheel ABS. This is why you felt what you did.
Hope you get to see the video clips! The part with the skidding is most amusing. That alone would be enough incentive for most people.
Drew
Host
Vans, SUVs, and Aftermarket and Accessories message boards
http://www.xmission.com/~gargoyle/noise/noise.html
As far as the seats go, CR tested an LX with the manual driver's seat. Mine is an ES with the 6-way power seat, and the drivers in our family have no problem getting that into comfortable positions. I seem to remember reading another review that strongly suggested getting the power seat. The LX has a seat height adjustment (I think it's manual, but I'm not sure), which might help somewhat over the straight fore/aft adjustment in the DX, but I also need to use the power tilt adjustment on the lower cushion to get mine just the way I want it.
Overall, we have been extremely impressed with our Tribute. Granted, it's still new, but the build quality, handling, acceleration, occupant space, etc., are outstanding. After looking at a number of other makes priced anywhere from the low to upper thirties, I think that with its features, the Tribute is a bargain for the price, even at MSRP. A lot of other people must, also, which is probably one reason they're so hard to get at the moment.
The dealer said nothing about Not coming through with the ABS package so I will assume It will until told othewise, but from what I read in other messages, not having ABS is no real problem.
As far as price, I too paid close to sticker (only about $300 less) but I priced the car at carsdirect.com and they wanted almost $500 over sticker so I'll take it. Also considering the other suv's I looked at would have been 3-4 thousand more, the tribute is a bargain.
I also considered: Nissan Pathfinder LE, Toyota Highlander, and Subaru outback LL Bean.
has anyone purchased a tribute in jewel green? the color on the internet looks lighter than the swatch the dealer showed me. Is it a real dark green? or lighter one?
thanks
Thank you for the feedback on the ABS performance. I am concerned that you cannot get ABS on any models of the 2001 Tribute anymore. I want the ABS option, but cannot get it! Is this only in Canada, eh?
Drew
Host
Vans, SUVs, and Aftermarket and Accessories message boards
2) Does anyone know if the Mazda perimeter alarm can be added by the dealer? I'm hoping that the basic wiring harness is already in place from the factory, and that this can easily be added or plugged in, rather than going the custom route on an alarm system.
3) Has anyone purchased the front end mask for their Tribute? I like to use these when I go out on the road, but I've had bad experiences with a few cheaper brands of masks scratching the paint. Colgan masks have worked well -- they have a soft fleece backing and edge bindings made out of the same material -- if the Mazda masks are similar in construction, I might go for one of those.
Thanks.
2)The perimeter alarm is available at the dealer(p/n 0000-8F-G01). Not sure about the direct plug in, check with your dealer.
3) The Mazda bra(p/n 0000-8G-G01) is not made by Colgan, but all the ones I have seen have a soft backing.
Seriously? I know that the concept of a Dealer ... well, misrepresenting himself is not a foreign concept ... but I have effectively agreed to pay MSRP (with a few dealer-added toys). He has ordered the Tribute from Mazda, with a 3 month delivery horizon and should have no real motivation to "special order" an ES without ABS. He claims he recieved a letter from Mazda Canada in late January ...
Nevertheless, I will take your advice and call Mazda directly. Thank you. As an aside, does $650 Cdn seem like a reasonable reduction for no ABS system?
Cheers!
CarNeophite
being undecided made me lost the 4x4 with ABS version, so i'm getting the 4x2 with ABS. it doesn't snow that much here in Long Island NY so i think i could live without the extra 200 lbs $1200 4x4 option.
having ABS i believe is better than having a 4x4. of course having both is best.
i'll keep you guys posted on my findings of the tribute.
Purchasing a Tribute at the moment seems to be a hit or miss affair and I am not much of a gambler.
this is the best rate i've found so far and application was very easy. i just hope their service is as good too.
as far as the reported problems with the tribute, they've been fixed, but as anything that is mass produced, there will be individual issues. just hope they will be minor. heck, even the LX400 when first introduced had a recall! center brake light melting the plastic!
also, does the bug deflector add more wind noise or change the aerodynamics/handling in any way?
thanks.
I'd go slow on the Ziebart soundproofing -- drive the vehicle awhile before you decide. If you read the conclusions in that article, the sound reductions were really minimal, and the author sounded like he was trying to rationalize the $230 he just spent by indicating that the car was now more solid, and had better road feel. If that makes him feel better, great, but I don't think you can spray those qualities on -- they have to be built in. According to the data in the Car & Driver article, the Tribute was generally within 1 or 2 dBA of the other vehicles anyway, even at 70 mph -- which is insignificant. Ziebart is just trying to come up with another marketing angle now that modern cars no longer require their rustproofing product. For what it's worth, Consumer Reports recommends against sealants.
As far as the bug deflector, I'd go with the Mazda product if you really want one. My guess is it will be a better installation and fit. Personally, I don't like them -- the one I tried (on a previous car) vibrated at high speeds and disturbed the airflow over the hood, affecting the spray pattern from the windshield washers and causing the wipers to lift from the glass.
I've been driving it fairly hard (much to my parents' dismay) so I was thinking maybe this had something to do with the bad mileage. I'm definitely not racing or revving it up very much, just driving relatively agressively -- and mostly legally. Hopefully you all know what I mean
Any ideas? Is 16 MPG normal? Will it get better by itself? Would driving like Gramps help any?
Thanks in advance
Nice firm fit, easy to install , no drilling required.
Thanks a lot.
Esmeraldo
Our car buying experience was a good one--we have used the same Mazda dealership for previous purchases and my 92 Protege is still going strong and being passed to our son. We got about $900 down from MSRP--there were about 40 available but mostly DX models. Many of the LX and ES models coming in are already spoken for but I had to have a Sunburst Red LX or ES. When I went to pick up our tags, pulled in behind another Tribute doing the same and we had to tell people these had already been sold. I've always just considered a car transportation until now--love my Tribute!
Personally I have given up on the Tribute, the problems reported (especially the transmission failures, engine stalling, fuel smell) on the Yahoo Tribute/Escape Owners Club and Edmunds Mazda Tribute/Ford Escape forums are beyond the norm for first year vehicles. I was going to purchase one last September but decided to wait and see what problems would crop up, sure glad I refrained myself.
Good luck on your decision.
Still, I'd find it hard to demean anyone who decided on a RAV4, Forester or Santa Fe instead of a Tribute or Escape.
I might find fault with someone who chose an Xterra, CRV, Cherokee, Sportage, Grand Vitara or Tracker instead of an Escape or Tribute, though. In those cases, it would seem to be better to take a chance on the Trib than have to suffer through life with one of those.
You may feel rather dumb after driving to the dealership to program the new key because it's so simple, but I'd much rather be safe than sorry, particularly given the headaches you would have to endure should something go wrong and you lock up your vehicle's security system (which, apparently, is quite possible).