2009 Subaru Forester

1424345474875

Comments

  • pharmd718pharmd718 Member Posts: 78
    I have a new mini cooper S with a 6 speed manual thats a blast to drive. However, when I drive into Mahnattan its a pain in the [non-permissible content removed]. Although I like to drive manual as well, the forester is not a sporty car and can't possibly handle as well and be as fun as my mini cooper S. Therefor I feel the automatic is a better option for the car. Especially when driving around manhattan.

    Additionaly it will be alot easier to sell then the MT model. Not everyone drives a stick.
  • sgloonsgloon Member Posts: 323
    "
    Additionaly it will be alot easier to sell then the MT model. Not everyone drives a stick."

    And not everyone wants an automatic. It is all about personal preference.
  • pharmd718pharmd718 Member Posts: 78
    for every person that prefers a manual SUV you will have 30 who will insist on an automatic.
    However, If you had a manual 911 you will have an easier time selling that over an automatic 911.
  • kurtamaxxxguykurtamaxxxguy Member Posts: 1,798
    Up thru '08 the XT had a manual transmission option.
    Subaru apparently sold very few of those, and dropped the option for '09.

    ....and frankly, if one wants a sports car from Subaru, why not get the '09 WRX or STI ? They're aimed at the track / rally loving enthusiast.
  • bpraxisbpraxis Member Posts: 292
    Thankyou everyone for your very insightful articulate and well reasoned feedback. I also enjoyed your personal experience and sharing your driving passion regarding the manual.

    Today I test drove the manual and the gas milage was amazing at approximately 31 MPG. Wow.

    The Turbo was a blast to drive and seems to ride much better with the 17 inch tires. Gas milage was about 22 MPG and I was very enthusiastic in my driving style.

    There are no silver or red tubos within 500 miles so I will probably go with the manual premium model for an MSRP of $25,100 minus the discount of course. I want to buy the Spark Silver or the Red Pearl. I am not a fan of dark colors for Boise Idaho given the dust here.

    Thankyou again for your feedback and I wish you the best with your Forrester.

    Brandon
  • board_jayboard_jay Member Posts: 22
    I asked Subaru why the difference in towing for US vs UK for the same vehicle and this is what they said. I was surprised that they came right out and said it was regulatory, but makes me feel better that I should be able to tow 2900lbs 3mi roundtrip a dozen times per year. I omitted the name of the Subaru contact person.

    ********************************************************************************- ***

    Thank you for taking the time to contact Subaru of America. The trailer towing capacity of your 2009 Forester is 2,400 lbs with trailer brakes.

    Frequently, the differences in trailer towing capacity between our vehicles and Subaru vehicles offered in other countries, such as our Forester models and the UK Forester models, relates to the different regulatory bodies of the countries where vehicles are driven. In the U. S., there are body rigidity standards that relate to towing capacity that are stricter than some (most) other countries. So, the 'rules' are different for towing. Also, Subaru of America wants all of its vehicles to maintain Passenger Car Safety Standards, including the Forester and Outback model lines. Therefore, we need to have them viewed under the body rigidity standards established by the department of transportation for passenger cars.

    I am making the assumption that you would like a higher trailer towing capacity for our Forester models. We will forward your messge to our Product Planning Department for their review and future consideration. We hope to continually improve our products and appreciate your message.

    Thank you for the opportunity to be of assistance. If you need any future assistance, please feel free to contact us again.

    Best wishes,
    xxxxxxxxxx
    Subaru of America, Inc.
    Customer/Dealer Services Dept.
    ********************************************************************************- *********
  • rshollandrsholland Member Posts: 19,788
    I've heard that engine/transmission cooling is also part of that equation, or so I've been told by people who work for SOA.

    Bob
  • farnorth3farnorth3 Member Posts: 5
    I have been using the above tire on my 2003 Forester for the past three years.Just now on to my second set.The difference is quite amazing,For me it is used on trail heads/high altitude lakes,including gravel forest access roads as well as routine city /highway use..When I first put them on there was a clear new handling/ride characteristic.Both firmer and more controllable..In winter/wet conditions it out performed the g800 s by a wide margin.It passes as both a Highway tire (relatively quiet and good tracking) as well as a winter tire replacement.Truly a realworld all season radial.It should be noted the second set has a new tread pattern for longer tread life.They certainly enhance the superior allwheel drive capability of the Forester.
  • board_jayboard_jay Member Posts: 22
    Could be, but I have a manual so shouldn't be any cooling issues especially for 3mi round trip. Biggest issue will be pulling the boat out of the water up the ramp and figuring out the tricky 1st gear with 3K behind me.
  • farnorth3farnorth3 Member Posts: 5
    My son just returned from Heathrow airport (London) and saw both a 2009 Legacy and a 2009 Forester ,both with turbo diesels/standard 5 speeds at the car park.Does anyone have any info on when these Euro models will be available here? It was indicated they averaged 48/55 mpg with the flat four diesel.
  • rshollandrsholland Member Posts: 19,788
    Unlike the Legacy/Outback diesel, the Forester diesel (and Impreza diesel which is coming around the first of the year) have a 6-speed manual, not a 5-speed manual.

    No word yet as to when we will get them.
  • saedavesaedave Member Posts: 694
    Euro models will be available here? It was indicated they averaged 48/55 mpg with the flat four diesel.

    No doubt imperial gallons for that rating. For the U.S., the numbers would be significantly lower.
  • robm2robm2 Member Posts: 53
    48/55 Imperial Gallon
    = 40/46 US Gallon
    = 6/5 L/100 km
  • kurtamaxxxguykurtamaxxxguy Member Posts: 1,798
    The Truth about Cars website reviewed the XT and complained about its heigth, the turbo bulge, 4 speed trans, tippiness, etc. They liked the back seat, though.
  • orcorc Member Posts: 39
    complained about its height, the turbo bulge, 4 speed trans, tippiness, etc....

    Unless they are comparing the Forester with a high dollar Porsche Cayenne I don't understand the criticism in those areas.
  • kurtamaxxxguykurtamaxxxguy Member Posts: 1,798
    Perhaps the TTAC reviewer was driving some Hooligan special or track oriented car first, then took the Forester out for a spin?

    The same senario's been posted today (8/25/08) in the Edmunds Straightline "daily driver" blog (somebody who had previously hated a Buick Enclave because it was "mushy" when compared to an Evolution, has changed its tune and appreciates the Enclave for what it is).

    It took me at least 10 test drives in different cars, and driving Forester XT twice, before I made up my mind.
  • farnorth3farnorth3 Member Posts: 5
    Thanks for the info.I since checked the Subaru(U.K.) web page .It showed the 2009 Forester Diesel with a manual 6 speed as you indicated.It also indicated a Tow Capacity of 4,400 # (It must be an error ????) Your fuel mileage was right on the mark (46 mpg U.S.)
  • rshollandrsholland Member Posts: 19,788
    The UK tow rating is not a mistake. Subarus around the world are all rated much higher for towing than here in the U.S. This has been the case for years.

    Bob
  • paisanpaisan Member Posts: 21,181
    Not just subies.

    Also don't forget that when they do the ratings, it's based on local driving conditions.

    I'm fairly sure that in the UK, they don't have nearly as many super-highways with tractor trailers doing 80+mph, steep grades like we have here, etc. etc.

    From someone who tows often, unless you are very experienced in towing, one should tow about 75-85% of the max to leave a margin of error.

    -mike
    Motorsports and Modifications Host
  • orcorc Member Posts: 39
    Very true. Americans are towing fanatics with campers, 5th wheels, boats, U-Hauls and I even pull a small trailer behind my motorcycle. As you say... we have long distances to cover, (especially in the west) steep mountain passes, long grades and thousands of miles Interstate. There are plenty of safety reasons to keep towing weights well below the absolute maximum the system can tolerate. I'll also agree about the experience factor. Far too many folks tow improperly and become a potential hazard on the road. JMO.
  • redherring1redherring1 Member Posts: 66
    I think the reviewer on TTAC is an idiot--she says she's not reviewing the XT as a sports car, but then says she likes "speed, handling and the fun factor", which is why she trashes the XT while ignoring all of its practical attributes. Aside from my disagreement with her about the performance of the XT, I would submit that it's ludicrous to review an SUV based on performance alone--what does the "U" stand for? She defends the RDX cargo capability by saying that it has only "marginally less cargo space" than the Forester because it's only 2 cubic feet smaller. As all the rest of us seem to know, measured space doesn't translate into usable space.

    What makes the XT work so well is the sum of its parts--it's a great balance of performance and utility. Ignoring one of these completely while unfairly minimizing the other makes it easy to write a bad review, but it's worthless to the reader.
  • aldo6aldo6 Member Posts: 1
    I do have the rattle towards the end of the sunroof (I just bought my Forester 2009). The dealer said they adjusted the rails, but it is the same as before. Is this a common problem? any suggestion? Am dissapointed, the car just doesn't feel new.

    many thanks
  • pharmd718pharmd718 Member Posts: 78
    Rattles around the sunroof area seem to be a common problem with the forester. Previous posts complained of the same thing. I believe someone found a solution and posted it on a previous post in this blog.

    I have not picked up my new X-limited yet (just got a call from the dealer that it has arrived ....2 months after placing the order). One of the first thing ill do is keep an ear out for the rattles.
  • kurtamaxxxguykurtamaxxxguy Member Posts: 1,798
    My guess is the XT-Bashing TTAC editor is from go-cart school of driving style and wants to feel connected to the road. The Lotus Elise, Dodge Viper and any number of harsh riding but flat cornering vehicles should fill that bill.

    Then again, do you really _want_ to be connected to the road when crappy road quality and a bunch of potholes/expansion heaves start pounding your car?
  • kurtamaxxxguykurtamaxxxguy Member Posts: 1,798
    Perhaps some Subaru posters here that talk to factory folk can help with this one?

    I've identified this formerly called "steering columm" buzz as something else.

    It is a low pitched buzz that you can hear when turning vehicle left or right, and the HVAC fan is running. Turn off the fan and the noise vanishes.
    However, two unusual aspects of the noise is:
    It changes density/frequencey, but __not__ its timber or pitch, as the HVAC fan is sped up or slowed down.

    Another way to think of it is something striking a tiny gong. The gong never changes pitch, but the striking frequencey increases as the fan speed goes up.

    My guess is it's a switching power supply feeding power to the blower motor. As the fan speed is increased, the power pulses to the fan (each pulse the same pitch) are spaced closer together to increase power to fan, and also increase the density of the buzzing.

    If it were something hitting the fan blades, or a motor bearing issue, the pitch would change as a function of the rotational speed of the fan motor.
    Comments? :confuse:
  • phdhuskyphdhusky Member Posts: 116
    Yeah I have these rattles also around the sunroof i figure it is loose wiring or something else. Not really adament about getting them fixed as they don't bother me and I don't want the dealer causing more harm then good.
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    Ignore them. They just have something against Subaru.

    They wrote a very tasteless review of the 2006 Subaru Tribeca, and Subaru responded by banning them from its press fleet.

    Subaru was not alone, BMW also banned them from their press fleet vehicles, in reponse to the same review (good for them).

    I'm sure they simply have it out for Subaru.

    Freedome of speech is one thing, but being downright offensive to the point where even other manufacturers have to ban you from testing their products is quite another.
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    Let's see, what else did I miss?

    JC: congrats.

    That photo with the gold Forester looks good. Tinting the windows really does wonders for the overall look.

    Kurt: glad to hear you validated your decision when it came to Forester vs. Outback.

    MT vs AT: its the age-old argument. Get what fits your needs. You won't ever convince a MT fan to go auto. Meanwhile, if you commute in heavy traffic and/or have a lot going on in the car (think kids in the back), that auto really comes in handy.

    Both are able to break 30mpg, so can't complain about that. The MT defaults to a more even 50/50 split, but the auto AWD can be proactive while the viscous coupling reacts quickly. The MT is quicker, but not by much. I think I'd rather have an AT for towing up a wet boat ramp - no clutch slip.

    Let your needs decide for you. If you want something fun for light traffic and would rather pay less up front: manual. If you have a heavy commute and are constantly distracted by kids in the car, plus you have concerns about the number of buyers for the car when you sell it (93% of americans search for automatics), get the auto.

    My 1998 model was a manual. It was the right choice for me at the time, I had no kids, and fun was a priority.

    For 2009 we chose an automatic. The wife commutes in DC beltway traffic, so her left knee can take a break. At other times she's car pooling with 3 kids all over the place, and has enough on her mind, so she'd rather not worry about a 3rd pedal.

    I think it was also the right choice for us at this time.
  • kurtamaxxxguykurtamaxxxguy Member Posts: 1,798
    I read TTAC Subie reviews and while Tribeca's was blunt and offensive, other reviews were not all bad.
    What seems clear is dem folks desire Go-Kart handling and ride quality. However, there was grudging admiration for Subie's composure on rough roads.
  • michael59327michael59327 Member Posts: 1
    09 Forester. I sometimes get a blue (not red) engine temperature light when the car starts. The manual's explained the light means the engine is not heated-up. But what does this mean? I am not to drive until the light goes off (a long wait)? Or am I to drive, but slowly? Or, is the cold engine light an unusual sight in summer (so I should have it checked out)?
    thanks
  • kurtamaxxxguykurtamaxxxguy Member Posts: 1,798
    From what I have read "blue light" means don't push the engine too hard.
    No full throttle acceleration, no jackrabbit starts, no continuous revving over 4000 rpm, etc.

    For my area, On hot days (90 degrees or so), the "cold" engine light stays on for a very short time (about 1 - 2 minutes). For 50 degree days it takes about 3 - 5 minutes.

    Once engine is warmed up, the light goes out, and the fun can begin.
  • pharmd718pharmd718 Member Posts: 78
    I finaly got the message from the dealer that my car has arrived. One week before it arrived I told him that I wanted the factory subwoofer added and he said it would not be a problem.

    Today I went to make payment for the car. However, when I looked at the invoice, the subwoofer was not listed. I asked the dealer if it was installed and he said that it was and they forgot to add the amount to the invoice. they added a charge of $209.

    What I want to know is if there is a way that I can make sure that a subwoofer has been installed. I understand it goes under the drivers seat....but is it visible if I move the seat back? The car was parked in a small tight space and I could not open the door to look inside.

    I just want to make sure that they indeed installed the subwoofer.

    Thanks
  • slazengerslazenger Member Posts: 99
    Yes, it is visible under the driver's seat. If it was installed at the port, it should be listed on the window sticker. If your dealer installed it, make sure that they put it as a separate item on the sales receipt.

    If it is not on the window sticker, I highly doubt that your dealer installed it and forgot to include it in the car price.
  • paisanpaisan Member Posts: 21,181
    Very true. Americans are towing fanatics with campers, 5th wheels, boats, U-Hauls and I even pull a small trailer behind my motorcycle. As you say... we have long distances to cover, (especially in the west) steep mountain passes, long grades and thousands of miles Interstate. There are plenty of safety reasons to keep towing weights well below the absolute maximum the system can tolerate. I'll also agree about the experience factor. Far too many folks tow improperly and become a potential hazard on the road. JMO.

    Yeah you are talking to someone who tows a Go-Fast Boat behind my Armada and push the envelope in terms of the rated capacity. I couldn't imagine someone who hasn't been towing for years towing at the limit. I even white-knuckle it sometimes when a rig passes or I have to pass a rig.

    Also as you said we drive 1000s of miles at a clip. Fatigue factor is also an issue. If you are in the UK, you probably won't be towing at 80mph for 800-1000 miles at a clip.

    -mike
    Motorsports and Modifications Host
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    Valid point, I bet our average driving distance is more than double theirs.
  • sylviecatsylviecat Member Posts: 10
    Hi All, I'm thrilled to announce that my Newport Blue Ltd was delivered to me today. Couldn't get one before moving to Maine from NJ, a dealer in NH could get me the color/trim level I wanted the quickest). It is beautiful, wonderful, fun to drive and I am very, very happy. :) I thank all on here whose advice and comments helped me know this was the car for me. However, one glitch: if you go to Subaru.com, and look at the Forester, and then the Interior photos, it looks as though the pedals are metal (aluminum?) with holes, which I really thought was cool, and hoped to have (they look different from the optional STIs which appear to have red, as well as silvery metal). The pedals on my car are just regular old pedals (a minor, but slightly let down :( ). What do other Ltd owners have in the way of pedals?Thanks, Sylviecat
  • red927red927 Member Posts: 118
    The XT model gets aluminum look pedals as standard equipment. I happen to think that the regular old pedals on my Limited are fine.

    Phil
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    Congrats, we have the exact same model, same color even!

    Rubber pedals may not be flashy but they are better - less slippery. Imagine wet soles on metal pedals.

    I think you can get them as an accessory from the SPT parts catalog if you really like them.
  • red927red927 Member Posts: 118
    Has anybody had any problems with the sound from the rear speakers when in enhanced Surround Sound mode (Limited model w/6 disc changer)? When I picked up the car I noticed that I wasn't getting any sound from the rear speakers. I called the dealer and they spoke to Subaru and was told that this is normal when in the enhanced surround sound mode. The speakers also cut out when the surround sound was turned off so they offered to change the radio.

    I had the radio replaced today and I feel that the problem is still there. Subaru says that the sound from the rear speakers is muffled when in this mode and sometimes the rear speakers are very soft.. That doesn't sound right. Surround sound means that the sound should be coming from all around, not just the front. Also, in order to get decent sound from the rear speakers you either have to turn the volume up to 28 or higher or turn off the surround sound.

    Any help I can get will be appreciated.

    Phil
  • pharmd718pharmd718 Member Posts: 78
    I just got mine yesterday after waiting for 2 months. Its dark gray in color. You are right about the sports pedals at the subaru site and I did not even notice when I got into my X-limited yesterday. Ill find out as soon as I get into the car after work. I also got one master key and one valet key. I thought I would get 2 master keys?! I just sent my dealer an email to find out if thats the case.

    The ride home for me was not comfortable at all. The head rest was at an awkward angle and pushing my head forward. I was sitting in a learched position. When I got home I took out the manual and saw that the head rest needed to be elevated. The middle of the head rest should be aligned with your ears. Once I did that and played a bit with the 10 way power seat...it was perfect.
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    I'm ashamed to say I haven't even tried that out yet on the stereo. Of course it is my wife's car, and I try to drive it whenever I'm in it!
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    Congrats and welcome to the (rapidly growing) club.
  • mwasnidgemwasnidge Member Posts: 28
    Picked my '09 up from the dealership Monday! Here's what I got:

    Spark Silver Metallic (really wanted Satin White Pearl, but hated the light gray interior), Automatic, Premium Package with the following-

    All Weather Package
    Aero Crossbars
    Body Side Molding
    Wheel Arch Molding
    Splash Guards
    Rear Bumper Cover
    Fog Lights
    Puddle Lights
    Auto dimming Mirror w/ Compass
    Cargo Tray
    Luggage Compartment Cover
    Dual Tailpipe Cover
    Tweeter Kit
    Ipod/phone Console Tray
    All Weather Mats

    My price: $24,556 + $120 service fee, tax, title and license

    I really, really like it so far. I have gotten quite a few double take glances, and I must say, I feel pretty cool and unique driving it around Northeast Wisconsin!

    Couple of minor gripes: Lack of lower back/lumbar support. Passenger seat is ridiculously low (I don't care, but wife probably will). Square cupholders--what were they thinking? All well documented problems on this forum and not enough to put me off buying one. One other thing is the blue engine light that comes on when you start it up...i'm apprehensive to drive until that light goes out--I believe that has been addressed in a thread on here also.

    One thing I really like and would recommend as a cheap mod is puddle lights! They look really cool at dusk! What are some other things people have done mod-wise or added as an option that they like?

    Overall, very impressed and has so far lived up to its hype.
  • kurtamaxxxguykurtamaxxxguy Member Posts: 1,798
    blue light = cold engine. Simply drive it moderately until it disappears.
    Also keep in mind Subaru recomends a 1000 mile break-in; your owners manual will outline the details.
  • mwasnidgemwasnidge Member Posts: 28
    Kurt,

    Thanks. Yeah, I think it was your post that I read on it previously. Is it on all '09 Foresters or just random, do you know?
  • kurtamaxxxguykurtamaxxxguy Member Posts: 1,798
    the "cold" light is on all '09's, from what I have read and have been told. It replaces the temperature gauge on the '08's.
  • bbthomasbbthomas Member Posts: 24
    I noticed this too. I sat in the back seat to make sure I was hearing it correctly and found that even with SRS off the rear speakers were not very audible. I adjusted the fader (~5 towards the rear) and it seems much better.

    BBT
  • mwasnidgemwasnidge Member Posts: 28
    Yeah, I suppose it is just the same as having a gauge on cold before it heats up.
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    A man walks in a bar and says, "I'll have a Premium with everything". ;)

    Congrats.
  • pyewackettpyewackett Member Posts: 11
    My husband and I are thrilled with the '09 2.5x Limited we bought/drove home yesterday. It's the Camellia red pearl with black interior. Our bells/whistles include the Utility package, Pop Equip Group 3 (nets & spotlight), luggage cover, bumper corner moldings, trailer hitch (for bike carrier) and the iPod interface.

    Since this is our first new car since 1994, we're still getting used to all the wonderful features. But one feature is making me a bit paranoid: The red security indicator light flashes about every 3 seconds ALL THE TIME! Whether we're in the car or not. Whether it's locked or not. Whether we open/close the door with the key or remote.

    It's making me nervous. Is it supposed to flash 24/7? Won't it wear on the battery? Or does it have its own battery, like a computer's clock?

    I read the manual which explained why it was flashing. But it didn't indicate how we could turn this off, which makes sense when the car's in our garage for any length of time. It's just so weird that this thing incessantly flashes. But it's also weird that our last new car purchase was in 1994, so maybe our learning curve just needs to ramp up.

    TIA for any advice/info.

    - pye

    [edited for typo, just 'cuz]
Sign In or Register to comment.

Your Privacy

By accessing this website, you acknowledge that Edmunds and its third party business partners may use cookies, pixels, and similar technologies to collect information about you and your interactions with the website as described in our Privacy Statement, and you agree that your use of the website is subject to our Visitor Agreement.