Did you recently take on (or consider) a loan of 84 months or longer on a car purchase?
A reporter would like to speak with you about your experience; please reach out to PR@Edmunds.com by 7/22 for details.
A reporter would like to speak with you about your experience; please reach out to PR@Edmunds.com by 7/22 for details.
Options
Comments
Motor Trend $45k Luxury Car Comparison Test
March 2005 Issue
1. Infiniti M35 (Base, Non-Sport)
2. Acura RL
3. BMW 530i Sport 6MT
4. Cadillac STS V6
5. Audi A6 3.2 Quattro
6. Jaguar S-Type 3.0
M35 Performance:
0-60 MPH - 6.3 Seconds
1/4 Mile - 14.7 @ 92 MPH
60-0 - 118 ft
Slalom - 64.4 MPH
Skidpad - 0.86G
Someone posted a correction elsewhere, said the Audi was 4th and the STS 5th.
1st Place - Infiniti M35 (Base, Non-Sport)
2nd Place - Acura RL
3rd Place - BMW 530i Sport 6MT
4th Place - Audi A6 3.2 quattro
5th Place - Cadillac STS V6
6th Place - Jaguar S-Type 3.0
I am really surprised that the March issue of Motor Trend is out so eary. I just read the M45 review that they did in February.
M
By the way, anyone that has seen the M45 at the various auto shows, please note that these show cars are preproduction models and actual stock cars may differ a bit. I was playing with the DVD screen on Saturday when I realized the whole screen was a fake mock up. I am told that there should not be any major differences, but expect some.
I don't have the spoiler of the Infiniti-M, but it does not hurt to look at the Fuga's versions...
http://www.nissan.co.jp/OPTIONAL-PARTS/FUGA/car.html
Well, with the MotorTrend comparison, I am not surprised that the "little m(M35)" beat all those cars but it is nice to see that it beat the $71,500CDN Acura RL and it was the base M35 which retails for about $56,000CDN!
I rest my case about that RL being grossly over priced for the Canadian market. RL is a nice car but not $15,000CDN nicer.
The M45 should be something else! Can't wait for the tests on the M45! Not sure what cars they will put up against it. ANy ideas?
Have a great day;
Babs
Acura RL Comments:
"Several staffers preferred the RL's blend of luxury and performance, but others felt it lacks the visceral immediacy and tactile feedback to the steering, throttle, and brakes that are hallmarks of a true driver’s car. Second place but barely."
BMW 530i Sport 6MT Comments:
"Like all BMW sedans over the last three decades , the 530i leaves no doubt that it is a drivers car. It has great poise, finely balanced weight distribution, and a turbine smooth in line six, and it tied for first place in Motor trend's figure eight test."
"So why isn't the 530i the overall winner? We found the middle BMW polarizing, some editors enjoying its harder edges but many flummoxed by the unpredictability of its Active Steering, confused by obtuse iDrive functions, and repelled by its "flame-buoyant" styling. And all agreed that the third place 530i offers the least value for the money"
Infiniti M35 Comments:
"You'll find those qualities, and more, in the first place finisher, the Infiniti M35. Though not as powerful as the Acura RL, the M35 proved the quickest, thanks to lower weight and closer ratio gearing."
"No wonder the M35 smoked the competition in acceleration test and tied for first with the sport package equipped 530i in braking and the figure eight test."
"Superb weight balance and pinpoint steering make this sport sedan a willing partner on any road you care to choose."
"The Infiniti's front-midship layout provides near-perfect weight balance, and the chassis communicates texture and grain that makes the driving experience all the richer."
"Of course, the Infiniti's cabin is hushed and exquisitely trimmed in rich leather , real wood, and techno toys , but look, traffic just cleared. Time to put down the joystick and grip that steering wheel. When the road is yours, and yours alone you'll want to be behind the wheel of the Infiniti M35."
0-60 MPH Times
Infiniti M35 (Non-Sport) - 6.3
Acura RL - 6.7
BMW 530i Sport 6MT - 6.8
Cadillac STS V6 - 6.8
Audi A6 3.2 - 7.3
Jaguar S-Type 3.0 - 7.8
Everything potentialy gets better as future cars come along. The current 530i came in 3rd, plain and simple, no need for excuses. The E350 is not available yet here, and is not on sale. Are you sure BMW acquited itself very well, as usual? The E60 has not done that well in a USDM comparision test since its inception. The E39 and E46 always did well, AS USUAL, I agree. But, the past is history.
1. Is it worth another 10, 15 grands to get a M35 instead of G35?
and
2. Is it possible to get a M35 at below MSVP?
I suppose you would need to test drive both cars to decide(I've driven the g35), just thought it would be interesting to know what you think.
thanks
The STS hasn't beat anyone worth its salt yet. S type is an antique piece.
I can tell you that these are two completly different cars. I loved my G35, it was a first generation (2003), have driven it for 3 years. before I decided on the M35, i was leaning towards getting a 2005 G35. I like what they have done to the G35 in 2005, new interior and front end. I have of late found the G35 to be a bit small, for some reason the seat tracks are short and it would have been nice if I would have been able to move the seat back another inch or two. Perhaps the fact that I have been out shopping for cars and have decided to move up to the Mid luxury level from the entry level I am noticing the room that this segment has to offer.
I will be getting an M35 AWD, here in Canada the price difference between the G and the M is less than 10k, more like 8K so the move up for me is not so harsh.
All I can say is that they both fine cars and you have to decide where to draw the line. Also it depends if you plan to lease or buy. Keep in mind the M is a 2006 whereas the G is a 2005 so either way you gain some value with the M. If you plan to lease, the lease rates should be better on the M than the G and the price difference may not be as much as you think, given the better residual value on the 2006 M. If you buy and plan to flip this car after 3 - 4 years, one would think the resale on a 2006 would be better than on a 2005, this all depends on what the final verdict will be on the M once it is received by the public.
In any case, good luck with your choice and if you have any questions on the G I would be happy to help.
http://autos.msn.com/advice/article.aspx?contentid=4020223&sr- c=LP
But like you, I too find the interior of G35 a bit too small. M35 is really a better choice for me even if it can't perform/handle as well as G35. There's one post in the neighboring discussion speculates that there might be discounts for the M in the future b/c this segment is so competitive. I won't mind taking an advantage of it if that happens.
A few questions on the G. Does it keep you comfortable in a long trip say 3, 4 hours of driving and how's the noise level on the highway.
thanks
You will see first item is the news clipping- Toronto Star. Keep in mind that the savings noted over competition are in Canadian dollars.
"INFINTI SHOWS OTHERS HOW TO DO IT"
http://www.thestar.com/NASApp/cs/ContentServer?pagename=thestar/L- ayout/Article_Type1&c=Article&cid=1106825769524&call_- pageid=970599119419
a fully fully loaded M35X with the Entertainment Package, (5.1 Surround Sound system, 14 speakers, even in the seats, The Premium Package ( Nav, intelligent Cruise control, Lane departure warning,heated rear seats, IS STILL $3500.00 under the Acura RL. These option costs many thousands if added to the M35X.
I think the author realized all this and that is
why he only just made a broad reference that if you load an M35X up with every conceivable option that is available it still come out $3500.00 less than the Acura RL
Thanks for posting the correct link, I guess my knowledge of cars far exceeds my knowledge of computers.
Sorry for late reply. I have taken 10 hour trips in my G35 and can honestly say that with two people in the front, they were very comfortable trips, no driver fatigue..... Now ask my 15 year old son who is 6'+ to reply to your question and you will get a very different answer concerning his back seat experience. He prefers to fly (lol).
Noise wise, always prefer summer driving with all seasons compared to winter tires. Truthfully, never had a problem with noise level, except for the trips with you know who.
There is a link from a post above to an article in today's Toronto star. The reporter pretty well summed up your questions G35 or M35, take a look at it.
now that I think about it, I have not read one single negative comment about this car. Could it be?
All I know is, that if it was me, I would have cut out early with my clubs and hit the links in Scottsdale.
Another 2 weeks and you people will hear an unbiased, potential owners first drive experience of the highly recommended M35.
since yesterday despite having tried on different computers. If anyone else is having the same trouble you can gain access by doing a GOOGLE search for "Infinti M35" there is a link around 4 or 5 items down which will provide access to this thread without any problems.
Gabman
MODERATOR /ADMINISTRATOR
Find me at kirstie_h@edmunds.com - or send a private message by clicking on my name.
2015 Kia Soul, 2021 Subaru Forester (kirstie_h), 2024 GMC Sierra 1500 (mr. kirstie_h)
Review your vehicle
Sorry but I beg to differ. There is no problem accessing Edmunds home page, however I cannot get into FORUM, am only able to access via the GOOGLE link that I described. I think that you should look into this as you can see there is an absence of any new posts here except for mine.
Thanks, GABMAN
http://www.canadiandriver.com/articles/pw/06infiniti_m.htm
"Also available is a superb Studio Surround Sound Bose DVD audio system with digital 5.1-channel decoding and 14 speakers including two personal speakers mounted in the shoulders of each front seat. This system offers such an exceptional listening experience that it will be the subject of a future article."
This is like the 5th time that a review has highly praised the sound system. I'm definitely curious.
I am on: Windows XP pro, latest and greatest PTF's, newest version of Netscape (and IE, too). This site is so slow, I always assumed it was because it was so popular. Perhaps that is the reason. If you want to check out to see if it is the site or not, try going to www.google or www.usatoday or some site that YOU know is always (apparently) consisitent.
Edmunds is going through growing pains, or so it seems -- as long as I don't use IE, for the most part, things are fine (also, the spyware is reduced since everyone seems to target IE).
Back to the "M" or "G" or "RL" or cars, etc. -- already in progress.
Out of frustration at being unable to drive either the Chrysler 300C AWD or the Acura RL (although on my lunch hour today, I drove by the dealer and they seem to have an RL on display), my wife and I drove a 2005 Infiniti G35 AWD (with all the toys).
The sound system was the only "B" feature, and even it improved when we switched to Sirius demo channels (we did not bring along a CD, something we usually do). This was my first real experience with a non German car -- we were mighty impressed (then we found the price: $555 per month for 36 months MSRP $39,410, no money down.) My wife's $41,000 Audi @ 36 months [leased in 2002] is $710. I know, I know, that was then, this was now -- but the German cars still seem to be way out of line from the perspective of a lease.
If the Acura is anywhere near as impressive as the Infiniti G35x (which I fully expect it to be, and then some) and the MoPmt tracks -- WOW. The M35x ought to be a winner too!
The A6 is still coming in a a number beginning with an "8"!
Yeeow!!!
Lease on an M35 in USA will probably surprise you, cost here in Canada on a 48 month lease is in high $800.00, but hey this is Canada and everything costs more here.
Given that the M35 is a 2006 and residuals should be around 58%, I think that you may find that you can get into an M35 for not much more than the G35X. I just heard that our cars may be coming in early as soon as this week. will keep you posted once I test drive.
From a $$ perspective the M35 will kill, the Audi A6, here the diff is over $300.00/ mo on a lease with not as much equipment on the A6.
As far as the drive goes, have to wait to get behind the wheel.
Netscape is a dead browser. For those sick of IE, I would suggest the Firefox browser, (www.getfirefox.com) which is what Netscape has become. Its MUCH better than Netscape ever was. There is also another alternative, Opera.
Thanks.