By accessing this website, you acknowledge that Edmunds and its third party business partners may use cookies, pixels, and similar technologies to collect information about you and your interactions with the website as described in our
Privacy Statement, and you agree that your use of the website is subject to our
Visitor Agreement.
Comments
How come this is the recommendation considering the fact that they typically drive at higher speeds (Autobahn), rev their engines higher and most of their trips are short? What does this say about the quality of engine oils sold in North America?
Consumer Reports consistently states that petroleum based oil can now go at least 5,000 miles between changes but it seems very few believe it. They prefer to keep believing an oil change is cheap insurance for a car so why not change every 3000. Don't seem to care that the oil and filter are also cheap and it may be part of the reason they recommend every 3000 miles.
They say it offers superior protection over the petroleum oils out there but obviously the 5W20 weight has them lowering their change intervals to the 7500. Their XL7500 series does not have the same additive package for longer usage and is intended more for the quick lube business.
Happy that I do not have to use 5W20 as yet!
Mark
Again, I am soooooo happy somebody has a synthetic 5W-20, BUT, once I am through my warranty period I will be using synthetic 5W-30.
http://www.lesezeichenverlag.de/versand/yaris.htm
(The Echo is called YARIS in Europe)
http://www.carija.de/pdf/Yaris_Datenblatt_032000.pdf (in German)
I have no reason to believe that my engine is excessively dirty-- just trying to figure out what to do with this extra dino oil.
Do you have any photos of the installation of Amsoil by-pass filters on your Echo?
What was the total cost and where exactly did you install it?
Which one of the by-pass filters do you use?
Any info you provide will be helpful as I intend to install this system my self.
One exception, though: I will not use Amsoil oil because I believe it is too expensive and it's easier for me to obtain Mobil 1 locally.
One more thing to consider: The recycling fees for used oil are higher in Germany.
*herzlichen Gruss aus Vancouver*
If you really want to clean it get a can of engine flush. Follow the instructions on the can.
Could this be right, to go 2 years or 15k miles before my first oil change?
He said if I want it done earlier it would be on my on nickle.
I'm wondering if BMW didn't recommend an oil change at 7k miles when they didn't include service with the cost of the car.
I'd simply do the oil change myself if it makes you feel better. I personally wouldn't be too concerned with the 15000 miles, but rather with going for two years without changing the oil.
What does your manual recommend?
My indicator has not gone on yet. But I'm assuming it's not very intelligent
and simply goes on at a certain odometer reading as opposed to sensing
oil contamination or degredation.
I will likely change the oil on my own. It just doesn't seem right to me to say that all scheduled maintenance is included and then all of a sudden change the rules to 15k miles being the first oil change. If BMW is not consistant, then they're either short changing owners now or were ripping people off in the past.
Danke Pulgo fuer alles was Sie geschrieben haben!
Mark
div2 is correct in stating that the service indicator is actually rather accurate on how hard the car is being driven.
(It's interesting to see that MB actually has a sensor that measures the dielectric constant of the oil to determine the degradation.)
The Bentley service manual for the Z states that it is expected to have an oil change intervals of > 7k miles, depending on when the service indicator demands it.
Or in short, you probably can just follow the service indicator, bring the car to the dealership, and you'll be just fine. And I can somewhat understand BMWs side when they only cover the indicated services.
However, if you want the warm, fuzzy feeling of being on the safe side, just change it earlier. (And don't reset the lights, just as div2 said.)
Here is the REAL technical information.
Mobil 1 is formulated with what are called Poly-alpha-olefins (PAO's). These molecules look like a zipper or the wire in a chain link fence, with a single unsaturated bond on the end (the 'alpha-olefin). These molecules are pretty good for use in lube oils because they hold their viscosity better with temperatures than 'conventional' lube oil molecules. They are not perfect however. they are not very good solvents for theadditives and combustion byproducts in an engine, so the detergent and dispersant additives have to be 'better' than in 'conventional' lube oils. Also, some co-solvent conventional base oil has to be included to keep the additives in solution.
A refining process developed a few years ago and first used by Shell Oil 'isomerizes' paraffin wax so that the isomerized molecules look and behave almost exactly like the PAO molecules- but without the terminal double bond.
These are very different approaches to making essentially the same 'synthetic' molecules. PAO's are made by connecting a whole bunch of ethylene molecules (the poly), while isomerization starts with natural molecule and rearranges it.
Now interestingly, petroleum waxes are often 'cracked' or split up into the samll ethylene molecules that are then polymerized back togetherinto PAO's.!!. Now which way do you think is more costly? Tearing up molecules and then glueing them back together, or rearranging ones nature has already made?
By the way, if petroleum wax, which is mostly straight chain or 'normal' paraffins did not freeze solid at such high temperatures (130F or so) it makes an outstanding lubricant base oil. 'Isomerizing' rearranges some of the 'normal' portion of the wax molecule into 'iso' paraffins-basically adding a few bends and pieces or wire to the main piece.
The Courts found that since neither of these molecules were 'natural' and both are 'synthetic', actually do look almost identical, and behave essentially the same in lube oil, that Castrol (and others) could call oils blended with either as "Synthetic."
This is a real victory for we consumer because it means that lower cost 'synthetics' are finally going to happen. These are better base oils for engines, but do cost more to make than 'conventional' ones.
O, yea? Does Castrol charge any less for its "synthetic"?
I would gladly sacrifice some fuel economy for a better lubricated engine. With the hot summertime temperatures 5W-30 couldn't hurt, right?
During my recent free oil change the technician put 5W20 weight in my car. After questioning, the tech told me that he followed Ford's directions .
It is doing a great job on my '91 Caprice (210k miles) and using only about 1/2 quart every 8k miles.
dpwestlake: Cost effective? Probably not. But if cost is the only reason why don't we all commute on bikes? Wouldn't that be cheaper and more cost effective? All of us fix up our cars, some buy expensive wheels, stereo equipment, etc. Others invest a little in good oil and filters and have cars that (hopefully) last a little bit longer.
For the $250 labor to install the bypass filter you could buy enough Mobil 1 to change the oil about 14 times!
Dave
Compared to whatever vehicle(s) you drive jimmah (and I) are saving hundreds of dollars per year, probably many thousands over the life of the car.
I accept that you drive any car you choose, even if that means contributing your bigger share of pollutants to our air. That's your prerrogative. I don't think it's appopriate to belittle other people's choice of car.
I also own a Chevrolet Caprice (bought new) and a Chevrolet K1500 (2 years old), but I use my Echo to drive to work daily and, believe me, it's a fun to drive little car. Just because you choose to drive something more expensive doesn't make your choice any better or worse, it's just your personal choice.
jimmah...I know this is still a matter of personel preference. But you'll have to tell me what the advantages of Amsoil over Mobil 1 are. I was a dealer once and I have used both products. I believe that Mobil 1' s documented testing program is more public than Amsoil's. I also believe that Amsoil is also a fine product.
I was simply questioning why one would install an elaborate filtration system to get 40K out of 4 qts of oil, although you've most likely increased the capacity to 5+ with the big filter.
If the answer is "Just for the hell of it." that's as valid to me as any other answer. people have questioned my sanity for restoring a TR7 and a V4 Saab.
If you're interested in experimenting how long you can get oil to last why don't you also install an oil cooler? It may prevent the oil from degrading from heat.
Another question: over 40K won't you end up changing the oil by just having to add oil now and then? All engines lose a bit of oil past the rings and valve seals. Don't you anticipate adding at least 4 qts over 40K?
Brucer2 - That is Castrol's basic response to the whole Syntec vs. Mobil 1 issue. It's not 100% BS but it IS spin. Just look at that bit about the consumer benefitting ... even though Castrol has not reduced their retail price at all!
As for European drain intervals, don't forget to factor politics into the equation. Europe imports a great deal of their petroleum and they may be encouraging people to get the most out of each quart of motor oil ... and disposal is another problem. Remember, it was the EPA that gave us 5W20 oil ...
--- Bror Jace
I believe the add on filters may detract from overall vehicle reliability by adding lots more pressure boundaries, fittings, hoses, etc. These things have not undergone the evaluation which the vehicle manufacturer put into each vehicle. They are somewhat of a one size fits all approach. Hoses can rub other parts, fittings can vibrate lose.
I am also dubious about your guesstimate for doubling engine life. Mobil has ran many 200,000 mile tests on many vehicles. Filters(standard-not even Pure-One calibre) are chananged at 7500 miles and oil (Mobil 1) AT 7500 OR 1500 MILES. Results are, that all wear parts come up to specs for new parts. I'm guessing the engine wears out or fails via other than oil related failures. Who knows?? Besides the super clean oil probably will not affect ring wear as there are abrasion products entering here constantly.
So for me it's a nice feel good concept that has more risks than benefits.
I sold the truck so I don't know how long it lasted.
Later,
Al
Mobil 1 Synthetic 15W-50
Mobil 1 Synthetic 0W-40 (only available to dealers)
Valvoline Synthetic 5W-30
Castrol Syntec 5W-50
Castrol Syntec 10W40
Castrol TXT Softec Plus 5W-30
Shell Helix Ultra 5W-30
Shell Helix Ultra 5W-40
I'm a dyed-in-the-wool Mobil 1 user like most people on this board. Is MB telling me that Mobil 1 OW-30, 5W-30, 10W-30 are not as good as the other brands listed in similar weights?
I live in Southern California, do alot of stop and go driving, many short trips of less than 10 miles, drive to Mammoth Lakes (snow country) via the desert in both winter and summer.
At 1200 miles I changed the mystery factory oil with Mobil 1 5W-30 and plan to continue oil changes at half the FSS schedule (approx. 5000 mile intervals). I can't get a straight answer from any of the half dozen dealers in my area on what oil weight would be appropriate. What Mobil 1 weight oil would be best?
I don't like second guessing MB, but 15W-50 seems to heavy and does not provide enough cold temp. protection, and 0W-40 is not available for do-it-your-selfers. Is 5W-30 or 10W-30 Mobil 1 a reasonable alternative? What's a guy to do?
Thanks in advance!
I would:
1. Call up Mercedes and get hold of their technical engineering department. It can be done if you are persistent. I would not necessarily do this step first. Find out why they are doing this- There's something fishy here.
2. Call up Mobil 1-800-ask-mobil. If you are not happy with the answer, ask the phone guy to transfer to Mobil technical engineering/research. I have done this.
3. In the meantime, if you have to change, I would go with the 10W-30(gives a bit more protection for the short trips/frequent starts.)
4. I wouldn't worry about the 5000 miles. Oil change interval doesn't appear to be the issue here. But if you do a lot of short drips, that's no big deal. You can also probably afford it. As i have said before when I was a working stiff, I learned a fair amount about oils. Syns can generally give adequate service one grade below(lower viscosity) recommended, both in the ISO (International Standards) grades and API/SAE grades.
5. Just another thought. I'm planning to go with Red Line 10W-30 on my next change. It's salty but then again-so are cars.
http://www.redlineoil.com/products.htm
Finally- The update by Mercedes is troubling- These things are sometimes done because of some unexpected condition they discovered. Keep this in mind for the future - you may have a legal case if the vehicle has oil related difficulties even after warranty. For warranty purposes and because of my last statement, I would have "proof" that I complied with their recommendations- if you get my drift.
Let me know via this board or email me on what you found. I'm curious.
Later,
Al
I want to use Amsoil - they also make an engine flush product - should I first flush the engine & then add the syn oil? If I do, how long should I go b4 the first change? Should I go the full 7,500 miles or do it sooner since it's the 1st time I'm using it after 25k miles of regular oil?
Any ideas or advice??
Thanks in advance.
:-)