Subaru Crew - Dealers & Pricing

1246738

Comments

  • warpathwarpath Member Posts: 4
    Mike,

    I haven't checked out CarBargains yet but it's something I may consider. I did see your rave review. I'm just a little hesitant at dropping $165 on the service if they can't get me at least that much better than what I already have heard.

    Tev
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    Tev: I think your price quote is already very competitive. Instead of working down the price, I'd try to find a dealer to match that price that has your model/color in stock.

    All the autos seem to be right around $24k, so you can show yours and Fitzgerald's price quotes and ask anyone to match it.

    That can be a pain, but call around and see what you can find. Check the Wasington Post and the Washington Times. The latter has a very good automotive section, and it appears today (Friday).

    Good luck. I'm jealous of that awesome roof!

    -juice
  • miksmimiksmi Member Posts: 1,246
    Tev: Indeed, CarBargains doesn't fit everyone. You're definitely paying for the convenience factor, and sounds like you've done most of the legwork. As another price reference, you can configure your Forester on CarOrder.com and find out what other dealers are offering (and save your "invoice" in a virtual garage for later perusal). Price fluctuates wildly depending on the time of year; it's a new service.

    You're responding quickly; you must be in IT or have a fat pipe to the 'net ;)

    ..Mike

    ..Mike

  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    Speaking of fat pipes, who do you have to kill to get a DSL line at home? We've been waiting since February!

    Maybe then I won't only post on weekdays.

    Hmm, it's a conspiracy! One of you guys is tired of me ranting! Well, I don't rant, you here, I...

    Never mind.

    -juice
  • warpathwarpath Member Posts: 4
    I'm not in IT and I have to wait another two weeks before my DSL will be activated. In the mean time, I got off work early (Government...it's the best) and have nothign better to do int his glorious weather than check the posts!! :(
  • miksmimiksmi Member Posts: 1,246
    who do you have to kill to get a DSL line at home

    Can you say telopoly? [telephone monopoly]

    Bell Atlantic owns the local loop (a twisted pair of copper wires from the central office to your home/business, the famous "last mile"). Therefore, all DSL providers (Covad, NorthPoint, etc.) rely on BA to make the last connection. The Washington Post had an article about BA's non-performance. On any given day, the "BAh" completes a whopping 20% of Covad's installation work orders. BAh is the BAhttleneck.

    Do you want me to tell you how I really feel about Bell Atlantic?

    ..Mike

    ..Mike

  • subardriversubardriver Member Posts: 1
    Oregonman,
    Sorry it has taken me so long to get back to you-- have been out of town. Yes, they will take your check. Be SURE to take the ad with you if you plan on buying an ad car. They probably wouldn't come up with one on their own. The ad also will list the stock numbers of the cars. erics6 is right on. If you plan on financing, I believe it's best to be pre-approved before you arrive to buy-- it will save lots of time. Unfortunately, we asked what they might give us on trade for our older Subaru, even though we already had a buyer. Big mistake. That took a lot of extra time. The so-called "sales manager" offered us practically nothing (not unexpected) and followed that up with the statement that they since they weren't making anything on the car, we owed them the trade so they could make something on the deal. Hey, pal I didn't write the ad! So, as erics6 said, don't trade if you can help it, have a check ready (and/or pre-approved financing) and whatever you do, don't add any other options- you won't like the prices they will quote you. Take the car as it is equipped and drive it away. Let us know how it ends up for you. I never could find a better deal, on-line or off.
    Steve
  • jwilson1jwilson1 Member Posts: 956
    Yikes. My wife just found out that her company is moving and she'll now have a 45 mile commute over hill & dale in Massachusetts. I'm thinking I should get rid of her fwd & look for a new Legacy GT or Ltd.

    My question regards timing. Here in the NE, I'm wondering if now is a wonderful time for price -- i.e., entering summer and people aren't thinking of AWD. Or if I would do better to wait for the '01 to come out and try to pick up a left over then. In which case, when will the '01s hit market?

    I didi a search on this so I'm sorry to ask if it's been hashed out -- if so, apologies ... and can you refer me to where I might look for the discussion? Thanks.

    Take care.
    Joe W.
  • yellowbikedonyellowbikedon Member Posts: 228
    Joe,

    The information I've gotten indicates the six cylinder '01 Outbacks are due to arrive at dealers around October. Production at the SIA facility in Indiana begins in September. I have no information regarding the current 4 cylinder engine models (Legacy and GT) but think new '01 production will definitely begin with the H6 powered L.L. Bean and VDC models.

    As a generality, good deals can be had at introduction time for left overs. Yet, one has to take into account the depreciation of a one year old car versus a "new" car. If you have a good relationship with your local dealer and have the cost data necessary to arrive at a fair deal, you probably should be open with the dealership and let them present ideas and figures to you. I have generally found the savings to be gained by buying a one year old car is minor, unless there are dealer incentives. When the 2001 Forester went on sale, Subaru offered excellent financing and service arrangements. In today's world, many dealers know prospective buyers are well armed with costs and facts before they shop and therefore, it is not unusual to find cooperation and yes, good information!

    Hope this bit helps.

    Don
  • oregonmanoregonman Member Posts: 60
    Thanks all for the info about the Forester pricing and the info about Oregon dealers. With the help of this info, I bought a 2001 Forester L automatic with FP2, rear dust deflector and tweeter for 19100 cash.
  • rshollandrsholland Member Posts: 19,788
    are also often found at the end of the month, as the dealers like to clean out inventory. Future dealer allocation is often dependent by how many vehicles they have left at the end of the month. Fewer unsold vehicles is better for them.

    Bob
  • bencelbencel Member Posts: 3
    Well, I bought a Forester S from Subaru of Manchester, NH.
    Nashua said they wouldn't come down from 22900.
    On Tuesday, 16 May, I emailed Manchester, saying
    "Sell me the car I want for 22050, and I'll buy it today",
    which wasn't altogether practical, since it was
    after 6PM. But I did buy it on Sat, after
    getting truly expeditious loan service from DCU
    (Digital Fed. Cred. Union).

    Pricing: Base invoice 20776
    Dest. charge 495
    Auto. trans 719
    Advertising 200
    Gimme some of
    the holdback (187)
    ------
    22003
    What the hey,
    offer them 22050

    That "advertising" is probably bogus, but that's
    what Intellichoice says. And I ought to have
    squeezed the holdback more. As usual, I paid
    too much (though the car has keyless entry, which
    I think is an extra-cost item).

    The car drives nicely, though from a stop, it
    tends to lag, then lunge, as if being pulled by
    a rubber band -- a bit unsettling for someone
    accustomed to the tight response of a Saab.
    Is it supposed to do that?

    Regards.
  • donald78donald78 Member Posts: 3
    have anyone seen the 2001 impreza? and where? please post http if you seen it on the net.
    i haven't seen it yet, i hope it 'not' that good looking because i'm planning to buy the 2000.
  • bat1161bat1161 Member Posts: 1,784
    I've been following the subaru discussions for a while. This weekend finally got out and test drove the Legacy sedan(so-so), Outback wagon (I like, the wife doesn't) and the Forester (We are both in love).
    My question is this: Dealer offered me a new 2001 Forester L, manual transmission and luggage cover for 19800. I live in the NYC area. IS this a good price? The vehicle won't be in till mid June. I don't know whether I should go for it or shop around some more. Any and all advice would be greatly appreciated.
    Thanks.
  • skipdskipd Member Posts: 97
    Check the pricing with Edmunds and Kelley Blue Book. You can get the invoice pricing from both of these sources.

    Once you are armed with the invoice prices, I would go to the Subaru of America Website, http://www.subaru.com/ and perform a dealer search in your area. Email all of the dealers in the area and ask them to respond with their best price on the Forester with the options you want. I did the very same thing and was offered a price of invoice by several dealers up front for a 2001 Forester L. So, I would shoot for invoice on the Forester you want.

    Hope this helps.....if you have more specific questions, feel free to ask

    Skip
  • fayesfayes Member Posts: 12
    When test driving a 2000 Forester S (the dealer's only 2001 was on the showroom floor), I also felt that there was a "rubber band" lunge when starting. I found that I could get going more smoothly if I started with a very light, gradual touch on the accelerator. This was quite different from my Saab, which wants quite a bit of gas while I'm letting out the clutch. I thought this was just my difficulty in adjusting from a manual to an automatic. Maybe this is common, and just something to get used to? I haven't had a chance to go back for another test drive to see if all the Foresters drive this way, now that my local dealer has more 2001's in stock.

    I'm eager to get on with buying a Forester - just waiting for parts to complete a minor repair on the Saab before I trade it off. I hope the Forester is more reliable, or at least parts are more available! No flames from Saab owners, please :)

    Faye
  • francophilefrancophile Member Posts: 667
    The '00 Subarus I have driven have a rubberiness to the drivetrain. Coupled with the low end torque of the new 2.5L engine and the quick throttle tip-in of my Legacy, and starting out smoothly is an exercise in driving skill.

    Don't let that one detail deter you from buying the car however; Subarus are excellent vehicles.

    Regards,
    WDB
  • mcj13mcj13 Member Posts: 85
    I looked at the above one-owner vehicle with all maintenance records from day one, all work done by Subaru dealer. The body and interior is in very good condition. The owner had the timing belt changed at about 140 Miles and had recent trouble with the brakes and a pump. Other than that the records look like routine maintenance.

    Naturally, I'm concerned about the high mileage and wonder if everything's about to fail. I'll go insane if I don't get a car that's trouble free for at least a few years.

    I drove a 2000 Legacy yesterday and was very impressed, it's a huge improvement over the 94, but I can't afford it. I've also driven a 97 Legacy but can't compare it to the others from memory.

    Any comments on this 94 Legacy L or comparisons with the next model years?
  • jwilson1jwilson1 Member Posts: 956
    as I know the Subaru is a notoriously reliable ride, but we'll all be worried about your sanity, mcj13 and I'd caution some common sense in this case.

    If you really mean that you want NO trouble for "at least a few years," you are asking an awful lot of even a good, reliable car @ 150k. Assuming you drive about 15k/yr, and a "few" years means three, I'd be looking for something between 50 and 75k ... that way, by the time you get to 3 years out (and 100 to 125k miles), you'd know whether to trust the car for more or not based on how it's wearing.

    Just an idea. Hope it helps.

    Take care.
    Joe W>
  • mcj13mcj13 Member Posts: 85
    I would expect to have to put some money into any used car I buy, so I don't mean NO trouble, but free of continuous problems or persistent problems that defy all repair efforts and tight wallets.

    I hear you just the same, thanks

    Mary
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    Joe W: Check if the recently rumored $500 dealer incentive applies in your area. Rebates may hit $1000, but then again they could disappear entirely. If you can get the $500 off now, it may be worth it.

    As for advertising and processing fees, just compare apples to apples. I'd add it on the the dealer margin, because that's what it is essentially. It seems ludicrous for them to ask you to pay for commercial interruptions, no?

    2001 Imprezza buzz:

    http://www.egr.unlv.edu/~simon/2.5RS/edit/spy.html

    Mark: $19.8 sounds a little high. I'd at least get other quotes.

    Mary: the Brighton wagon invoices for 17353, plus 495 freight is still under $18k. That plus there may be a regional $500 incentive, so it's worth a look. Personally, I'd spring for the L at just $700 or so more.

    Even if you have to finance it for 5 years, it'll be under a powertrain warranty the entire time (5/60k is longer than Honda, Toyota, Mazda, etc.). Plus, you'll likely get those trouble-free years you long for.

    -juice
  • texsubarutexsubaru Member Posts: 242
    I also theorize that some of that feel (which I've experienced, too, though I don't really even notice much anymore) might be power shifting to the back wheels upon hard accelerating and then evening up between the front and back wheels.
  • francophilefrancophile Member Posts: 667
    I agree with the poster who said that to expect no trouble from a car with that many miles is unwise. A funny thing happens to all those moving parts over the years; they wear. Some of them eventually break, or wear to the point of needing replacement. It just happens. However with a Subaru you can reasonably expect to have fewer problems than with most other cars of a similar age/mileage.

    Here are the things I'd look hard at:
    - Number of owners. Fewer=better.
    - Service records. An owner who gets the routine services done is the next owner's best friend. My last car had a previous owner who changed the oil twice as often as recommended - what a pal.
    - Major drivetrain. Have a knowledgeable individual inspect the engine, front/rear/center diffs, driveshafts, CV joints and trans for signs of impending doom. Keep in mind that finding no signs is not a guarantee. Nevertheless, spending a bit of money here might keep you from spending a whole lot a month from now. Take special note of the CV boots on the front driveshafts; Subies are famous for ripping holes in them which then means a costly replacement job.

    On a more meta level you may want to sit down with *all* of your car finances some day. I did this a few years ago and was struck by the fact that the combination of repair costs and lost vehicle time was just about the same as a car payment for a new(er) vehicle would be. The key factor for me was placing a value on reliable, always-available transport vs. begging rides and renting cars when mine was in the shop.

    Good luck,
    WDB
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    Do I sense a few Peugoet stories?

    ;)

    -juice
  • jwilson1jwilson1 Member Posts: 956
    Thanks, juice. The regional rebate is sure worth checking into. I appreciate the feedback about purchase timing from you and all the others. It sounds like: "stay on top of it."

    Take care.
    Joe W.
  • mcj13mcj13 Member Posts: 85
    The thing that impressed me about the 94 Legacy L was the maintenance records from day 1, and it is a 1 owner car, the maintenance was all done by the Subaru dealer and I can call the original owner. It also seems likely that all those miles on a not so old vehicle with a clean body are highway miles.

    The asking price of 4900 is well within my budget. I could go higher say up to 10,000 maybe 12,000 for the right car, but with new I'm afraid I'd be in over my head as I'm looking to move, change jobs, etc.

    I hope to get out today to drive a 95-99 Legacy. The 00 Legacy that I drove was such an improvement over the 94, I'm wondering if the 95-99 is at least a happy medium improvement or if it's basically the same ride as the 94.

    WDB: Thanks so much for the tips on things to look for. Whatever I buy I want to check it out as thoroughly as I possible.

    Mary
  • gearhead4gearhead4 Member Posts: 122
    Mary,

    Good luck on your search. Here are soe things to consider:

    Subaru sold a lot of 2 wheel drive Legacys during the mid 90's. They look identical except for the little AWD badge on the back. They had the same engine and are still good cars, but the price should be much lower.

    In 99, Subaru offered a 30th Anniversary package that added a lot of value for not alot of cash (alloys, moonroof, height adjustable seat, etc). In 99 the 2.2 litre boxer engine received a 5 HP increase (to 142 HP).

    Aside fron these points, the Legacy didn't change musch from 1994 to 1999.

    The 2000 Legacy is substantially changed. There is still a strong family resemblence, but the engine is more powerful, the body reinforced, suspension revised, etc. I was so impressed, I sold my 99 Legacy with only 1000 miles, and bought the 2000 model. The only regret I have is that I should have given my wife the 99 and traded in her Dog -I mean Dodge.

    -gearhead4
  • dinaldinal Member Posts: 7
    Hi, all.

    'Ling time lurker, first time poster!'

    I've been shopping for months for a replacement for my sturdy but aging '86 Toyota Tercel 4WD wagon. I've been shopping and test driving a lot, including the Audi A4 Avant wagon, the Passat wagon, and the Volvo V40. As a driver I enjoyed the Audi the most, but the Forester is probably going to be my choice because it seems to represent the best value among all these cars. It's not as exciting or as beautifully styled or finished as the Audi. However I feel a lot more confidence in the Subaru's long-term reliabilty and cost of ownership and as you can tell, I tend to keep my cars.

    I've been intrigued by the many stories I've seen posted on Edmunds and elsewhere about shopping via the many web-based services. I have priced out the Forester and several other cars, notably the Audi A4 Avant wagon, many times on Carorder and other services, and I have consistently found that I've gotten HIGHER prices from web-based services than I could get from a local dealer.

    This is probably at least partially a regional thing. I'm in the Midwest (Chicago) and perhaps these services don't have good dealer connections in this area. In fact Carorder's website now shows me a notice that starting June 1, they will not be doing business in this region for 'a period of time.'

    Well, no wonder. Carorder's prices can vary wildly, but I've found them to be high, sometimes amazingly so. For example, I recently priced out a Forester S and the Carorder price had the options at invoice price, but the car itself at MSRP and a whopping $1295 delivery charge! That's right, $800 extra...though their list showed this as being the invoice amount. Carorders' prices get even worse with cars like the Audi and Passat...often ABOVE MSRP. I can negotiate better deals than this even on the Audi!

    I've seen here recently that some folks have gotten cars through Carorder at below invoice...are they definitely talking INVOICE and not STICKER?

    Greenlight.com at one point seemed to have good prices, however about two months ago their website and their pricing changed dramatically. I have lately gotten lousy prices from them, well above invoice and approaching MSRP. Oddly for a business which claims to be 'changing the way people buy cars, their own invoice includes (sometimes) various tacked-on dealer charges.

    Carsdirect.com has a straightforward website, but the best price I've found on a loaded Forester S through them is about $1000 over invoice...about 4.5% markup. On an Audi or VW, makes which have no dealer holdback, maybe that's reasonable. On a Subaru, I don't think so.

    I have had even worse luck with: Autobytel (no contact at all from 'exclusive dealer') DigitalCars (wanted me to contact dealer, then they would negotiate for me...sure) and Stoneage.com (passed my info to Carorder...which never contacted me.)

    Driveoff.com I like the best of these services, as they quote you a range of prices from specific dealers in your area. (They don't tell you the dealers' names, but their distances from you in miles. With a list of area dealers you can usually tell who is being referred to.) Driveoff's website usually has a pretty complete list of options, and they show you the invoice and MSRP of your package, then what their dealers would sell it for. Their prices for Foresters have been fairly good, down to about $700 over invoice for a 2001 Forester S. I think I'd been getting better prices on 2000s--the 2001s may come down. However, a car with the Premium Package was only available from dealers a few hundred miles from me at $1200+ over invoice.

    Now for the good news. Last winter I went into the closest dealer to me, MidCity Subaru in Chicago. I was interested in a used '98 'S' they had. I decided not to buy that car. However the salesman, Skip Bauer, said that that I could order a new 2000 Forester for a price better than any of the net offers. At that point I was still shopping so I didn't buy a car. Last night I was in there again, just because I was passing by and was curious to see an 'S' with premium package. Not only was that slightly-over-invoice price still good for a 2001, but he would even go lower because of it being the last day of the month. And this even included the Forester 'S+' as they're calling the car with the premium package. This is WITHOUT my even having to bargain down.

    (Before posting this I called and asked Skip if it would be okay to post his name and this info in a public forum. He said sure but asked me to not tell the exact price he quoted me, as prices vary depending on inventory, etc. So I've respected that. But it was a modest amount over invoice.)

    Well, I work freelance and have strict rules about my cash flow...so I didn't buy a car last night. However when I am ready to buy, where do you think I am likely to go?



    Best wishes,


    Alan
  • dinaldinal Member Posts: 7
    Should obviously have been 'Long time lurker, first time poster.'
    I tried using the spellcheck and it wanted me to correct every proper name including Subaru, so I gave up.

    BTW I should probably have mentioned that I have no tie to anything mentioned in my post, even MidCity Subaru. I am not even a satisfied customer (yet).

    Alan
  • mcj13mcj13 Member Posts: 85
    I'm glad you didn't trade in your dog, but I feel for your wife with the dodge. Thanks for your comments.

    Any comments anyone about various model years for the Legacy GT?

    Mary
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    Mary - the 95-99 models probably are about at the midpoint you mentioned.

    In 95 the Outback came out, but I think the 2.2l was the only engine.

    In 96 the 2.5l came out, but it required premium fuel. At least keep this in mind.

    The 97s dropped the premium requirement, and could run fine on regular gas.

    But the condition and service will matter the most. Happy hunting.

    -juice
  • dinaldinal Member Posts: 7
    Thanks for the heads-up, Dan.

    Actually I HAVE been to Liberty City, as I was working on a movie up in Libertyville this winter.
    I liked Elmer 'Fudd' too. He let me take a Forester out for an unaccompanied test drive, even gave me change for the Tollway!

    Mid City is only about ten minutes from me, so that combined with my positive impression means I will probably go there when it's time to buy. However Liberty City would be a good second choice. I've also been to Evanston Subaru but wasn't impressed.


    Best wishes,

    Alan
  • lambchopslambchops Member Posts: 5
    We just purchased a 2000 Outback from Becker Subaru in Allentown, PA. We had gone to Fred Beans in Doylestown, where we live and they do live up to their bad reputation in my book. The sales guy was nice but they have no good deals right now I found! Becker is where I have purchased two other subaru's and I loved each of them. Family is growing and we needed to upgrade from the Legacy to Outback. I highly recommend Bob Hackman at Becker. We have always dealt with him and he is low key and gives you a great price up front. I wanted to compare with others on the OB to see how the numbers matched up. We got the 2000 OB-automatic, all weather package, CD player, woodgrained trim, and alarm upgrades. We paid $19,700 that includes a 92 Legacy five speed trade in with 82,000 miles in good condition. We saw the invoice and it was listed at 22,500-close to it. Edmunds says that it is 20,588. What is up with that? Was it really a great deal? We love our new car!!!!!
  • mcj13mcj13 Member Posts: 85
    Anyone have any good or bad experiences that with dealer's in western Massachusetts or northern Connecticut?

    And does anyone know why prices seem higher in Connecticut?

    Mary
  • gearhead4gearhead4 Member Posts: 122
    Alan,

    It sounds like you have made some good decisions. Allow me to offer a few points.

    The Forrester is a fine vehicle ... unless you are intending to transport full size people in the back seat. It was my first choice until I sat in the back seat. Headroom was good, leg room was poor.

    I looked at the Legacys. There is the Outback and the Legacy Wagon that share the same body and drivetrain. The Outback has a raised suspension and some trim and option differences, but otherwise is the same vehicle. The Legacys have been redesigned for 2000 and feature a reinforced body structure. I purchased the Legacy.

    If you compare the Forrester and Legacy wagon you will find similar pricing. For you, maybe the Forrester is more appealing.

    There are several options for Chicago Subaru dealers. I am very satisfied with Gerald Subaru in Naperville. I considered Libertyville Subaru when I saw an ad for a Forrester at invoice. But Naperville is much closer for me, and Jack Zimmerman was careful to make sure I got what I wanted.

    Dealers can sell at below invoice. Sometimes there are factory to dealer incentives where the factory gives some money back to the dealer. And there are always "Holdbacks" where the factory gives 2% of the MSRP back to the dealer after the sale. To be fair, you have to allow the dealer to make some money. I consider it fair to pay invoice. If you insist on paying actual dealer cost, the dealer has no reason to work with you.

    -Jim Walsh
  • davemcldavemcl Member Posts: 2
    I have a question about pricing on a "demonstrator." Actually it's an Outback wagon, no extras except tweeter kit, which was driven about 7,000 miles by someone connected to the dealership. In addition to over 1/6 of the warranty coverage (in miles), a little over two months' worth is gone also. The car looks clean but I haven't take a careful look yet or driven it.

    The big question is -- what kind of price should I expect? The salesman proposed selling it at invoice price (plus taxes & the usual) and that didn't seem a very good price to me. He more or less admitted that to be the case, pointing out that the newer ones on the lot are subject to some kind of Subaru incentive but this slightly older isn't.

    Maybe I'm paranoid, but do you think there's any point in having the car's mechanical condition checked elsewhere before I buy?

    TIA...
  • texsubarutexsubaru Member Posts: 242
    It probably is a wee bit paranoid, but, ya know, if you're having any qualms about it at all -- especially if you're not entirely comfortable with the dealership or salesperson, go ahead and get it checked out. it can't do any harm, probably not that expensive (depending on the level of diagnostics you want done) and the time it'd take could be worth the extra peace of mind.
    Personally, I think they ought to charge notably less than invoice on a car with 7K on it, but admittedly have never tried bargaining for a demo before.
  • befishmanbefishman Member Posts: 8
    I have a problem on my hands and need some advice. On April 1 I factory ordered a Forester 2001 S from the dealer in Santa Fe, NM. I was told that the car would take 4 - 6 weeks to arrive. Yesterday (8 weeks later) the salesperson called me to ask when I was coming to get the car...it had been on their lot for 2 weeks and I was not notified. Then this morning the manager called to tell me that the car had been test-driven and has 30 miles on it and did I mind? I turned the phone over to my husband, thinking that this may be one of those terrible times when car folks take advantage of women. The manager told him that the previous manager (recently fired) did not put a "sold" sign on our car when it arrived, that the car was not registered as having arrived at the dealership at all and that according to the dealer's records the car had "disappeared" for "a while." Also that the car had arrived without the autodimmer mirror and armrest extension that I had specified. No answer has been forthcoming as to why I was not notified immediately when the car arrived, nor why it was apparently used as the dealer's test vehicle for at least the last 2 weeks (how many test drives equals 30 miles??!!) The dealer offered to give us our deposit back, or to lower the price by $400 (making the total price about 1% over invoice). I don't know what to do. Who knows what damage might have been done to the engine in the first 30 miles? And it is a manual transmission so there's the clutch to consider. And of course this dealership is mud in my book at this point. So I have to decide whether to accept the car or not. This is my first new car and my first subaru. I would truly appreciate the perspective of those on this list to assist me with this decision.

    Thank you all for responding.
    Beth
  • nvynvy Member Posts: 74
    IMHO is not a lot of miles. But I think that
    the answer relies on how much of a tolerance
    level you have for things that don't go
    as you expect.

    I had 40 Clicks on my Outback 20 of which I
    put on myself before I signed the dotted line.

    As long as a manufacture is going to backup
    their products, without a penny out of my
    pocket, why worry!

    How much damage can be done in 30 Clicks is
    a wild wild guess! But if you can't live
    with it, take proper action.
  • deniceedenicee Member Posts: 14
    I had a bad experience with the Subaru dealer in San Jose, CA. They told me one price over the phone, then the salesman told me a higher price, then the manager told me an even higher price. It made me really uneasy and I decided to go elsewhere. My local dealer quoted me an unbelievable price on the phone. I decided to go with them because they offered free maintenance and I had a bad experience trying to get a car fixed that I had bought from a dealer out of the area. I called to confirm the price with Subaru of Santa Cruz, then went down to buy the car. When I got there the price had gone up $400 dollars! I talked him down a hundred and still bought the car. I didn't feel good about it, but I couldn't bear to be in the sales office with one more dealer. And the price was a little lower than San Jose, $500 over invoice. I hope to never have the very unpleasant experience of dealing with a car salesman again!
  • tta3tta3 Member Posts: 5
    Hi. Any advice on pricing of 2000/2001 Outback Limited Wagons in the Minneapolis/St. Paul area? Any advice on good dealers to work with, or dealers to avoid? Any special frostbelt packages that have been good? Any comments on extended warranties? Thanks. TA
  • rochcomrochcom Member Posts: 247
    The real excess is having a car that can go 155 miles per hour and then slapping on a speed governor in the ECU that prevents it from going over 125. For those of us who drive occasionally on the track, it is capacity we can't use unless we have the equipment to reporgram the ECU. We are told that the limit is placed to prevent overdriving the tires. But most of the vehicles that have this speed capability are equipped with V or Z rated rubber that can handle the speed.
  • gearhead4gearhead4 Member Posts: 122
    Beth,

    I agree with nvy. 30 miles could be just one test drive. Perhaps someone was very serious about buying that Forester and then the dealer found they could not sell it because it had been sold. The story about losing the Forester for two weeks is a little wild, but if there was a change in mangement, it's possible.

    Any mechanical abuse on the Forester during the "test drive" will be covered under warranty.
    My suspicion is that some body damage could have occurred (either during shipment to the dealer, or while in the possession of the dealer). It could take two weeks to repair the body. In my state (Illinois), any party selling a vehicle must indicate if bodywork in excess of $500 (?) was done. I would look for telltale signs ... paint color mismatch, paint overspray on the tires, trim or undercarriage, trim pieces that look as if they have been refitted.

    The dealer offering $400 means:
    He's really embarrassed about losing your car for two weeks and wants to protect his reputation, or
    He knows something he is not telling you and is trying to buy his way out of the problem.

    If it were me, I would make a very careful inspection and take a good test drive. If everything seemed in order, I'd accept the $400 and buy the Forester.
    If I saw a body panel out of alignment, color mismatch, a smell of fresh paint.. or if there were squeaks or rattles during the test drive, I would order a Forester from a different dealer. There is probably a few of them in Albuquerque.

    gearhead4
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    I tend to agree that 30 miles is very little. I'm happy to hear the previous manager no longer has a job there, too! Hopefully, they fired him for his incompetence!

    Knocking off $400 seems to be in good faith, IMHO.

    tta3: get the cold weather package. It's a bargain, and you get heated seats plus the rear viscous limited slip differential for side-to-side distribution of power. Plus, I like the word "viscous" :o)

    You can get quotes for extended warranties on-line, though I think they aren't necessary. Check it out:

    http://www.edmunds.com/partners/1source/index.html

    Mary: isn't everything in CT expensive? Gas, shopping, taxes, you name it. I guess in colder climates demand for Subarus are higher.

    Lambchops: it's hard to say without knowing the condition of your trade-in. Sounds like you're happy with the deal and were treated with respect, and that's what counts.

    DaveMcl: 7,000 miles is no longer a demo, that's just plain a used car. I believe the limit is 5k miles, but it may vary by state. Forget invoice, they should take a loss and sell it way below cost. I'd subtract the holdback and another 10% or so since it is USED.

    Better yet, just buy new. That incentive he hinted at is a $500 regional dealer incentive, so a new one could be cheaper!

    -juice
  • luckyrollover1luckyrollover1 Member Posts: 14
    my choice. between a passat sedan or a subaru. was in a wreck and am VERY safety aware this time around. have checked all the crash tests, consumer reports is at my side, drove a passat gls and a glx. any advice or help here will be appreciated. i have always driven a stick, i really want a car with some type of safety cage around passengers. and i'm not up on awd- ie. is it better than traction control for snow? please click on my name if you want more info. i live one hour from lafayette,in or 1.5 hours from chicago. there are no subaru dealers closer to me. need it within 2-3 weeks as my ranger was totaled.
    thanks
    mary ann
  • mcj13mcj13 Member Posts: 85
    Yeah, especially gas is outrageous in CT, but why would a car before tax be more expensive then MA?

    Like you say, maybe because everything is more.

    Mary
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    Mary Ann: you have narrowed it down to two fine choices. I'll try to list pros/cons from my perspective:

    Passat Pro: V6 is quick, roomy, 10 year powertrain warranty, 4Motion now availalbe on high end versions.

    Passat Con: requires expensive premium fuel with either engine, only 2 years basic warranty, unproven long term reliability, costs more.

    Legacy Pro: AWD traction standard, upscale interior, versatile, roomy, class leading safety scores, good torque, and proven long-term reliability.

    Legacy Con: a bit heavy, not as quick, must wait for H6 engine.

    Of note is that the Passat does offer AWD now, they call it 4Motion. It's offered on their higher-end V6 models only, for about $29-32k or so.

    Meanwhile, the Outback will offer a 6 cylinder this fall (too late for you, I realize), and it should fall in the same price range.

    As for safety, both score well. You get softer deploying 2nd gen air bags in the Legacy, with side bags on some models. ABS is standard on all but the Brighton, and AWD is standard period. The safety cage held up extremely well in IIHS offset tests, part of why it's a bit heavier than most competitors. Finally, the seat belts are height adjustable and have both pre-tensioners and force-limiters.

    Traction control on the VW is still front wheel drive. So at best you still only get traction to the two front tires. Probably adequate to get around, but no comparison to the versatility AWD offers, especially in models with the rear limited slip differential (Outback w/cold package, Outback Limited, GT, GT Limited). VW realizes this, and now offers 4Motion.

    Given your price range, I'd drive a well equipped GT Limited and an Outback Limited and compare them to the Passats you drove. Your profile says under $25 grand, which is impossible with the Passat 4Motion, easy with GT Limited, and just barely possible with the Outback Limited.

    Happy shopping.

    -juice
  • texsubarutexsubaru Member Posts: 242
    I'm a bit of a crank on the topic (this will be the 2nd or 3rd time I've mentioned it around here), but I'd also add, to Juice's excellent list, the "con" that the Legacy and Impreza sedans don't have a folding rear seat. Just a very narrow "pass-through port" in the center of the rear seat for the Legacy and nothing at all in the Impreza. The Passat does have a 60/40 split folding rear seat, EXCEPT, interestingly, for the model most competitive with the Subarus, the 4Motion option, which apparently also just has a pass-through port.
    This non-folding-seat issue doesn't bother seem to most Legacy/Impreza sedan owners at all, but thought it'd be worth mentioning since you're coming from a Ford Ranger and might miss the lack of hauling space. Obviously not an issue at all with the Outback/Subaru wagons if you're considering one of those rather than a sedan.
  • texsubarutexsubaru Member Posts: 242
    I'd also say that 30 miles really isn't all that much. You've obviously had a poor dealership experience, and if you're absolutely set on getting a new car with as close to 0 miles as possible, then you should pass on it if you're going to be uncomfortable with your purchase. But if it's really just worry over something being seriously mechanically wrong with the car because of the 30 miles of test drives, I doubt there's that much to fear.
  • luckyrollover1luckyrollover1 Member Posts: 14
    please. i really love a stick. i know in passat i can't get one with 4 motion. the passat is really sweet to drive and run thru those gears. i tested a subaru outback but not limited model. seemed a little slow on the uptake but my main concern is safety. can i get awd subaru with a stick preferably 5 speed. i did like the interior amenities on the subaru i tested. nearest dealer one and a quarter hour drive for me, so when i go shopping i will most likely buy the same day. got all my info on prices too! thanks for any help.
    btw i'm not a gearhead but 44 and female and just like to drive sticks!

    mary ann
This discussion has been closed.

Your Privacy

By accessing this website, you acknowledge that Edmunds and its third party business partners may use cookies, pixels, and similar technologies to collect information about you and your interactions with the website as described in our Privacy Statement, and you agree that your use of the website is subject to our Visitor Agreement.