Thanks to everyone here. The dealer has now managed to locate the "right" page and honored the 68% residual. They claim they were looking at the Jan page.
Also - any advice on if its better to roll in the one-offs (acq, tags, doc fees) into cap cost or pay them upfront? If I roll it into the lease will the state tax (my state will tax 10% of both dep + interest) apply to the one offs - if thats the case seems like better to pay up front.
Also - any advice on if its better to roll in the one-offs (acq, tags, doc fees) into cap cost or pay them upfront? If I roll it into the lease will the state tax (my state will tax 10% of both dep + interest) apply to the one offs - if thats the case seems like better to pay up front.
It's better to pay those items up front, as you've noted, so that tax isn't applied.
Can someone weigh in on this for me? Dealer in Northern California has 2 cars I'm interested in.
Option A: a 2015 sDrive. MSRP is $32,825. It was a demo, so they're offering it for $28,900, full warranty and service with it. If I put down $2,100 in MSDs, MF is 0.00101 , 36 months at 12K per year, 67% residual, so it looks like a killer deal.
Option B: a 2015 xDrive28i MSRP is $41,050. It was also a demo so they're offering it for $37,500. If I put down $3,510 in MSDs, MF is 0.00101, 36 months at 12K per year, 67% residual.
But for option A they're saying the monthly payment pre-tax is $268, and I'm getting $243, and option B they're saying $394 pre-tax and I calculate $343. When I questioned them on it, they said its because I am not factoring depreciation for miles. Car A has about 5,300 miles on it so they're depreciating it by $960, and Car B has about 9,700 miles on it so they're depreciating it by $1,850.
My trouble is I don't understand how to evaluate these deals with the depreciation factored in.
Anyone have experience with this or thoughts on these offers?
I just realized what this means --They're saying it's a 67% residual BEFORE they depreciate the residual for existing miles. So my "67%" residual on option A is actually a residual of 64%, and my "67%" residual on option B is actually 62%. I don't like that they weren't more up front with me about the "true" residual when quoting these cars for me.
So my questions is, is this fair? Or can I reasonably ask them stick to the original residual, despite the car already being significantly discounted?
I just realized what this means --They're saying it's a 67% residual BEFORE they depreciate the residual for existing miles. So my "67%" residual on option A is actually a residual of 64%, and my "67%" residual on option B is actually 62%. I don't like that they weren't more up front with me about the "true" residual when quoting these cars for me.
So my questions is, is this fair? Or can I reasonably ask them stick to the original residual, despite the car already being significantly discounted?
Thanks!
Those extra miles do affect the residual that the dealer has to use.
The only question I have is on the MSD - the base MF is .00130 and BMW security deposits reduce the MF by .00007 each. I sense that the dealer is inflating the base MF to .00150 before applying the MSDs.
Are you making the maximum 7 MSDs for these deals? If so, the net MF would be .00081, not .00101.
Still, both are pretty decent deals. But, I'd ask if they would reduce the base MF to .00130.
I was told the dealer I went to had a program in place with local corporations allowing for the lower mf. I work one of those larger corporations that they partnered with and was given 20% off the mf.
Additionally, I was told because I took an "in stock vehicle" they were able to discount it more and I suppose it also helped that we got buried with over 4' of snow the past month and no one was out buying cars.
I was told the dealer I went to had a program in place with local corporations allowing for the lower mf. I work one of those larger corporations that they partnered with and was given 20% off the mf.
Additionally, I was told because I took an "in stock vehicle" they were able to discount it more and I suppose it also helped that we got buried with over 4' of snow the past month and no one was out buying cars.
I learned something new today -- thanks for sharing.
And, I can completely understand the need for the dealer to have one less vehicle on the lot that needs snow cleared off of it.
I just realized what this means --They're saying it's a 67% residual BEFORE they depreciate the residual for existing miles. So my "67%" residual on option A is actually a residual of 64%, and my "67%" residual on option B is actually 62%. I don't like that they weren't more up front with me about the "true" residual when quoting these cars for me.
So my questions is, is this fair? Or can I reasonably ask them stick to the original residual, despite the car already being significantly discounted?
Thanks!
Those extra miles do affect the residual that the dealer has to use.
The only question I have is on the MSD - the base MF is .00130 and BMW security deposits reduce the MF by .00007 each. I sense that the dealer is inflating the base MF to .00150 before applying the MSDs.
Are you making the maximum 7 MSDs for these deals? If so, the net MF would be .00081, not .00101.
Still, both are pretty decent deals. But, I'd ask if they would reduce the base MF to .00130.
I just realized what this means --They're saying it's a 67% residual BEFORE they depreciate the residual for existing miles. So my "67%" residual on option A is actually a residual of 64%, and my "67%" residual on option B is actually 62%. I don't like that they weren't more up front with me about the "true" residual when quoting these cars for me.
So my questions is, is this fair? Or can I reasonably ask them stick to the original residual, despite the car already being significantly discounted?
Thanks!
Those extra miles do affect the residual that the dealer has to use.
The only question I have is on the MSD - the base MF is .00130 and BMW security deposits reduce the MF by .00007 each. I sense that the dealer is inflating the base MF to .00150 before applying the MSDs.
Are you making the maximum 7 MSDs for these deals? If so, the net MF would be .00081, not .00101.
Still, both are pretty decent deals. But, I'd ask if they would reduce the base MF to .00130.
Thanks Michael. You're right, they are marking up the MF before applying MSDs. They weren't willing to bring the MF back to base before applying the MSDs but I negotiated the price down to $28,150 on the sDrive with 6 SDs down (I can't figure out why they won't let me do the max SDs and get it down further, but we're talking a difference of about $135 over the course of the next 3 years so I'm gonna let it go), and a monthly payment of about $270 including our local (9%!) sales tax. So the final deal is:
MSRP $32,825 Purchase price $28,150 Residual 67% less $960 depreciation (64% effective residual) Terms 36 months/12K per year MF 0.00101 after 6 security deposits Base payment $248.04 plus tax
I think it looks pretty good, so I'll probably go do paperwork this weekend.
I just realized what this means --They're saying it's a 67% residual BEFORE they depreciate the residual for existing miles. So my "67%" residual on option A is actually a residual of 64%, and my "67%" residual on option B is actually 62%. I don't like that they weren't more up front with me about the "true" residual when quoting these cars for me.
So my questions is, is this fair? Or can I reasonably ask them stick to the original residual, despite the car already being significantly discounted?
Thanks!
Those extra miles do affect the residual that the dealer has to use.
The only question I have is on the MSD - the base MF is .00130 and BMW security deposits reduce the MF by .00007 each. I sense that the dealer is inflating the base MF to .00150 before applying the MSDs.
Are you making the maximum 7 MSDs for these deals? If so, the net MF would be .00081, not .00101.
Still, both are pretty decent deals. But, I'd ask if they would reduce the base MF to .00130.
I just realized what this means --They're saying it's a 67% residual BEFORE they depreciate the residual for existing miles. So my "67%" residual on option A is actually a residual of 64%, and my "67%" residual on option B is actually 62%. I don't like that they weren't more up front with me about the "true" residual when quoting these cars for me.
So my questions is, is this fair? Or can I reasonably ask them stick to the original residual, despite the car already being significantly discounted?
Thanks!
Those extra miles do affect the residual that the dealer has to use.
The only question I have is on the MSD - the base MF is .00130 and BMW security deposits reduce the MF by .00007 each. I sense that the dealer is inflating the base MF to .00150 before applying the MSDs.
Are you making the maximum 7 MSDs for these deals? If so, the net MF would be .00081, not .00101.
Still, both are pretty decent deals. But, I'd ask if they would reduce the base MF to .00130.
Thanks Michael. You're right, they are marking up the MF before applying MSDs. They weren't willing to bring the MF back to base before applying the MSDs but I negotiated the price down to $28,150 on the sDrive with 6 SDs down (I can't figure out why they won't let me do the max SDs and get it down further, but we're talking a difference of about $135 over the course of the next 3 years so I'm gonna let it go), and a monthly payment of about $270 including our local (9%!) sales tax. So the final deal is:
MSRP $32,825 Purchase price $28,150 Residual 67% less $960 depreciation (64% effective residual) Terms 36 months/12K per year MF 0.00101 after 6 security deposits Base payment $248.04 plus tax
I think it looks pretty good, so I'll probably go do paperwork this weekend.
Thanks again for the feedback.
Congratulations - that is an excellent deal. Enjoy the new BMW!
Any crystal ball on what the lease deals will look like next month? I have an offer for an X1 x28 msrp $38275 with a selling price of $32900. It is a demo with 2,500 miles. The MF is marked up to .0017 and the dealer was unwilling to move on it. Monthly payment with only first payment, plates and fees is $369 for 10k miles. The dealer would not tell me the rv used and would not provide the other figures used to get to the payment. Is this a good deal or is it not possible to say without the other numbers?
Any crystal ball on what the lease deals will look like next month? I have an offer for an X1 x28 msrp $38275 with a selling price of $32900. It is a demo with 2,500 miles. The MF is marked up to .0017 and the dealer was unwilling to move on it. Monthly payment with only first payment, plates and fees is $369 for 10k miles. The dealer would not tell me the rv used and would not provide the other figures used to get to the payment. Is this a good deal or is it not possible to say without the other numbers?
Thanks, Nick
$369/mo for a car that originally stickered at over $38K is pretty decent deal.
No idea what will happen to the numbers next month ... I suspect the MF will stay the same or only move slightly. It's the residual that can fluctuate from one month to the next, especially on the SAV's (X1, X3, X5)
Any crystal ball on what the lease deals will look like next month? I have an offer for an X1 x28 msrp $38275 with a selling price of $32900. It is a demo with 2,500 miles. The MF is marked up to .0017 and the dealer was unwilling to move on it. Monthly payment with only first payment, plates and fees is $369 for 10k miles. The dealer would not tell me the rv used and would not provide the other figures used to get to the payment. Is this a good deal or is it not possible to say without the other numbers?
Thanks, Nick
I'm surprised a dealer would tell you the marked-up money factor (where he might have competition), but wouldn't disclose the residual value, which is the same, everywhere..
It can't be a bad deal at those numbers, but if you want to bargain, you really need to know the selling price, CAP cost and the actual residual, so you can check the numbers... Of course, the money factor is marked up, and that alone is adding $30/mo.+ to the deal.
If you are going to make a deal, I'd try to do it before next month (which starts Tuesday). The residuals offered on the X1 aren't likely to hold up, long term.
With expiration of March residuals, please let me know if i got a good deal on either of below - took a lot of fighting I locked down version A, but was 99% close to getting version B.
Version A: x28 msrp: 43,600 cap: 40,200 lease: 36mo/10K (68% res, .00130mf) $2,975 upfront for taxes, fees, including first month $385/mo after that
Version B: x35 msrp: 48,925 cap: 44,950 lease: 36mo/10K (68% res, .00130mf) $3,600 up front including first month $420/mo after that
Any hint on what rates are going to be tomorrow (March 3rd?)
With expiration of March residuals, please let me know if i got a good deal on either of below - took a lot of fighting I locked down version A, but was 99% close to getting version B.
Version A: x28 msrp: 43,600 cap: 40,200 lease: 36mo/10K (68% res, .00130mf) $2,975 upfront for taxes, fees, including first month $385/mo after that
Version B: x35 msrp: 48,925 cap: 44,950 lease: 36mo/10K (68% res, .00130mf) $3,600 up front including first month $420/mo after that
Any hint on what rates are going to be tomorrow (March 3rd?)
I think money factor will be about the same, but residuals will be lower... just guessing..
I think money factor will be about the same, but residuals will be lower... just guessing..
Thanks - thats what i am expecting as well - i ended up putting down a deposit on A above. Do numbers above make sense? This was in north NJ earlier today.
I think money factor will be about the same, but residuals will be lower... just guessing..
Thanks - thats what i am expecting as well - i ended up putting down a deposit on A above. Do numbers above make sense? This was in north NJ earlier today.
Thanks again. Another question, if I were to order one from my local BMW dealership, I assume that would I lock in all the terms at current rates. What happens when the car is actually ready in 6-8 weeks and there is a new incentive (such as loyalty), would I be able to get that upon delivery?
Thanks again. Another question, if I were to order one from my local BMW dealership, I assume that would I lock in all the terms at current rates. What happens when the car is actually ready in 6-8 weeks and there is a new incentive (such as loyalty), would I be able to get that upon delivery?
If you ordered this month, you can lock in the program through the end of May. You should be able to take advantage of the May program, if you take delivery in May, but you have to use it, in its entirety. If you use a special incentive from that month, then you also have to use that month's lease numbers.
I don't really know what the MF means ( I will be doing research ) but I thought I would throw this in here. Thanks for any help, or direction for this.
I don't really know what the MF means ( I will be doing research ) but I thought I would throw this in here. Thanks for any help, or direction for this.
Not a good deal .. MF is marked up (base MF is .00129) and $3500 is too much up front cash.
I don't really know what the MF means ( I will be doing research ) but I thought I would throw this in here. Thanks for any help, or direction for this.
Not a good deal .. MF is marked up (base MF is .00129) and $3500 is too much up front cash.
What is the selling price?
The selling price is $33,200. So I can ask for a lower MF? I'm not sure what I can negotiate for a lease so I asked that the starting point be from the selling price. Thank you for the help.
I don't really know what the MF means ( I will be doing research ) but I thought I would throw this in here. Thanks for any help, or direction for this.
Not a good deal .. MF is marked up (base MF is .00129) and $3500 is too much up front cash.
What is the selling price?
The selling price is $33,200. So I can ask for a lower MF? I'm not sure what I can negotiate for a lease so I asked that the starting point be from the selling price. Thank you for the help.
Politely but firmly explain to the dealer that you won't sign a deal with a MF that is marked up.
Yes, you negotiate the selling price on a lease just like you would for a purchase ... for BMW, shoot for 4-6% off MSRP before any incentives.
Using your MSRP and selling price, along with the base MF and residual of 66%, I get a $0 down pre-tax payment of $362.89.
I don't really know what the MF means ( I will be doing research ) but I thought I would throw this in here. Thanks for any help, or direction for this.
Not a good deal .. MF is marked up (base MF is .00129) and $3500 is too much up front cash.
What is the selling price?
The selling price is $33,200. So I can ask for a lower MF? I'm not sure what I can negotiate for a lease so I asked that the starting point be from the selling price. Thank you for the help.
Politely but firmly explain to the dealer that you won't sign a deal with a MF that is marked up.
Yes, you negotiate the selling price on a lease just like you would for a purchase ... for BMW, shoot for 4-6% off MSRP before any incentives.
Using your MSRP and selling price, along with the base MF and residual of 66%, I get a $0 down pre-tax payment of $362.89.
Thank you for the advice! I'll be meeting with him later today.
So without a down payment, the payments were still as low as $368.89? And this is why you never buy on the first visit to the dealership
I don't really know what the MF means ( I will be doing research ) but I thought I would throw this in here. Thanks for any help, or direction for this.
Not a good deal .. MF is marked up (base MF is .00129) and $3500 is too much up front cash.
What is the selling price?
The selling price is $33,200. So I can ask for a lower MF? I'm not sure what I can negotiate for a lease so I asked that the starting point be from the selling price. Thank you for the help.
Politely but firmly explain to the dealer that you won't sign a deal with a MF that is marked up.
Yes, you negotiate the selling price on a lease just like you would for a purchase ... for BMW, shoot for 4-6% off MSRP before any incentives.
Using your MSRP and selling price, along with the base MF and residual of 66%, I get a $0 down pre-tax payment of $362.89.
Also, where are you basing the MF? Is it the same nationwide? I'm just waiting for him to say that it is different in every region or something.
I don't really know what the MF means ( I will be doing research ) but I thought I would throw this in here. Thanks for any help, or direction for this.
Not a good deal .. MF is marked up (base MF is .00129) and $3500 is too much up front cash.
What is the selling price?
The selling price is $33,200. So I can ask for a lower MF? I'm not sure what I can negotiate for a lease so I asked that the starting point be from the selling price. Thank you for the help.
Politely but firmly explain to the dealer that you won't sign a deal with a MF that is marked up.
Yes, you negotiate the selling price on a lease just like you would for a purchase ... for BMW, shoot for 4-6% off MSRP before any incentives.
Using your MSRP and selling price, along with the base MF and residual of 66%, I get a $0 down pre-tax payment of $362.89.
Also, where are you basing the MF? Is it the same nationwide? I'm just waiting for him to say that it is different in every region or something.
The MF is nationwide for BMW - dealers love to give you a song and dance as to why they have to mark it up.
I don't really know what the MF means ( I will be doing research ) but I thought I would throw this in here. Thanks for any help, or direction for this.
Not a good deal .. MF is marked up (base MF is .00129) and $3500 is too much up front cash.
What is the selling price?
The selling price is $33,200. So I can ask for a lower MF? I'm not sure what I can negotiate for a lease so I asked that the starting point be from the selling price. Thank you for the help.
Politely but firmly explain to the dealer that you won't sign a deal with a MF that is marked up.
Yes, you negotiate the selling price on a lease just like you would for a purchase ... for BMW, shoot for 4-6% off MSRP before any incentives.
Using your MSRP and selling price, along with the base MF and residual of 66%, I get a $0 down pre-tax payment of $362.89.
Also, where are you basing the MF? Is it the same nationwide? I'm just waiting for him to say that it is different in every region or something.
The MF is nationwide for BMW - dealers love to give you a song and dance as to why they have to mark it up.
I don't really know what the MF means ( I will be doing research ) but I thought I would throw this in here. Thanks for any help, or direction for this.
Not a good deal .. MF is marked up (base MF is .00129) and $3500 is too much up front cash.
What is the selling price?
The selling price is $33,200. So I can ask for a lower MF? I'm not sure what I can negotiate for a lease so I asked that the starting point be from the selling price. Thank you for the help.
Politely but firmly explain to the dealer that you won't sign a deal with a MF that is marked up.
Yes, you negotiate the selling price on a lease just like you would for a purchase ... for BMW, shoot for 4-6% off MSRP before any incentives.
Using your MSRP and selling price, along with the base MF and residual of 66%, I get a $0 down pre-tax payment of $362.89.
Also, where are you basing the MF? Is it the same nationwide? I'm just waiting for him to say that it is different in every region or something.
The MF is nationwide for BMW - dealers love to give you a song and dance as to why they have to mark it up.
So he was able to drop the MSRP ($34,195) a bit. The MF would now be .00149, $3500 down, and $350/month. And then throw in some all weather floor mats. I don't ask for much.
I don't really know what the MF means ( I will be doing research ) but I thought I would throw this in here. Thanks for any help, or direction for this.
Not a good deal .. MF is marked up (base MF is .00129) and $3500 is too much up front cash.
What is the selling price?
The selling price is $33,200. So I can ask for a lower MF? I'm not sure what I can negotiate for a lease so I asked that the starting point be from the selling price. Thank you for the help.
Politely but firmly explain to the dealer that you won't sign a deal with a MF that is marked up.
Yes, you negotiate the selling price on a lease just like you would for a purchase ... for BMW, shoot for 4-6% off MSRP before any incentives.
Using your MSRP and selling price, along with the base MF and residual of 66%, I get a $0 down pre-tax payment of $362.89.
Also, where are you basing the MF? Is it the same nationwide? I'm just waiting for him to say that it is different in every region or something.
The MF is nationwide for BMW - dealers love to give you a song and dance as to why they have to mark it up.
So he was able to drop the MSRP ($34,195) a bit. The MF would now be .00149, $3500 down, and $350/month. And then throw in some all weather floor mats. I don't ask for much.
Don't you mean the selling price was dropped? MSRP is the window sticker.
You might want to contact a second BMW dealer and see if they will offer you a deal that uses the base MF of .00129
I don't really know what the MF means ( I will be doing research ) but I thought I would throw this in here. Thanks for any help, or direction for this.
Not a good deal .. MF is marked up (base MF is .00129) and $3500 is too much up front cash.
What is the selling price?
The selling price is $33,200. So I can ask for a lower MF? I'm not sure what I can negotiate for a lease so I asked that the starting point be from the selling price. Thank you for the help.
Politely but firmly explain to the dealer that you won't sign a deal with a MF that is marked up.
Yes, you negotiate the selling price on a lease just like you would for a purchase ... for BMW, shoot for 4-6% off MSRP before any incentives.
Using your MSRP and selling price, along with the base MF and residual of 66%, I get a $0 down pre-tax payment of $362.89.
Also, where are you basing the MF? Is it the same nationwide? I'm just waiting for him to say that it is different in every region or something.
The MF is nationwide for BMW - dealers love to give you a song and dance as to why they have to mark it up.
So he was able to drop the MSRP ($34,195) a bit. The MF would now be .00149, $3500 down, and $350/month. And then throw in some all weather floor mats. I don't ask for much.
Don't you mean the selling price was dropped? MSRP is the window sticker.
You might want to contact a second BMW dealer and see if they will offer you a deal that uses the base MF of .00129
I don't know how he dropped the MSRP number and he did drop the selling price too. The car was the same just different color interior. I'll put a call in to another dealership today. As you can tell I'm not so good at hardball. lol.
I don't really know what the MF means ( I will be doing research ) but I thought I would throw this in here. Thanks for any help, or direction for this.
Not a good deal .. MF is marked up (base MF is .00129) and $3500 is too much up front cash.
What is the selling price?
The selling price is $33,200. So I can ask for a lower MF? I'm not sure what I can negotiate for a lease so I asked that the starting point be from the selling price. Thank you for the help.
Politely but firmly explain to the dealer that you won't sign a deal with a MF that is marked up.
Yes, you negotiate the selling price on a lease just like you would for a purchase ... for BMW, shoot for 4-6% off MSRP before any incentives.
Using your MSRP and selling price, along with the base MF and residual of 66%, I get a $0 down pre-tax payment of $362.89.
Also, where are you basing the MF? Is it the same nationwide? I'm just waiting for him to say that it is different in every region or something.
The MF is nationwide for BMW - dealers love to give you a song and dance as to why they have to mark it up.
So he was able to drop the MSRP ($34,195) a bit. The MF would now be .00149, $3500 down, and $350/month. And then throw in some all weather floor mats. I don't ask for much.
Don't you mean the selling price was dropped? MSRP is the window sticker.
You might want to contact a second BMW dealer and see if they will offer you a deal that uses the base MF of .00129
I don't know how he dropped the MSRP number and he did drop the selling price too. The car was the same just different color interior. I'll put a call in to another dealership today. As you can tell I'm not so good at hardball. lol.
Just be polite and keep asking questions .. eventually the truth will come out.
I don't really know what the MF means ( I will be doing research ) but I thought I would throw this in here. Thanks for any help, or direction for this.
Not a good deal .. MF is marked up (base MF is .00129) and $3500 is too much up front cash.
What is the selling price?
The selling price is $33,200. So I can ask for a lower MF? I'm not sure what I can negotiate for a lease so I asked that the starting point be from the selling price. Thank you for the help.
Politely but firmly explain to the dealer that you won't sign a deal with a MF that is marked up.
Yes, you negotiate the selling price on a lease just like you would for a purchase ... for BMW, shoot for 4-6% off MSRP before any incentives.
Using your MSRP and selling price, along with the base MF and residual of 66%, I get a $0 down pre-tax payment of $362.89.
Also, where are you basing the MF? Is it the same nationwide? I'm just waiting for him to say that it is different in every region or something.
The MF is nationwide for BMW - dealers love to give you a song and dance as to why they have to mark it up.
So he was able to drop the MSRP ($34,195) a bit. The MF would now be .00149, $3500 down, and $350/month. And then throw in some all weather floor mats. I don't ask for much.
Don't you mean the selling price was dropped? MSRP is the window sticker.
You might want to contact a second BMW dealer and see if they will offer you a deal that uses the base MF of .00129
I don't know how he dropped the MSRP number and he did drop the selling price too. The car was the same just different color interior. I'll put a call in to another dealership today. As you can tell I'm not so good at hardball. lol.
Just be polite and keep asking questions .. eventually the truth will come out.
Thanks for the pep talk. Will keep trying. Last day of the month and all.
I don't really know what the MF means ( I will be doing research ) but I thought I would throw this in here. Thanks for any help, or direction for this.
Not a good deal .. MF is marked up (base MF is .00129) and $3500 is too much up front cash.
What is the selling price?
The selling price is $33,200. So I can ask for a lower MF? I'm not sure what I can negotiate for a lease so I asked that the starting point be from the selling price. Thank you for the help.
Politely but firmly explain to the dealer that you won't sign a deal with a MF that is marked up.
Yes, you negotiate the selling price on a lease just like you would for a purchase ... for BMW, shoot for 4-6% off MSRP before any incentives.
Using your MSRP and selling price, along with the base MF and residual of 66%, I get a $0 down pre-tax payment of $362.89.
Also, where are you basing the MF? Is it the same nationwide? I'm just waiting for him to say that it is different in every region or something.
The MF is nationwide for BMW - dealers love to give you a song and dance as to why they have to mark it up.
So he was able to drop the MSRP ($34,195) a bit. The MF would now be .00149, $3500 down, and $350/month. And then throw in some all weather floor mats. I don't ask for much.
Don't you mean the selling price was dropped? MSRP is the window sticker.
You might want to contact a second BMW dealer and see if they will offer you a deal that uses the base MF of .00129
I don't know how he dropped the MSRP number and he did drop the selling price too. The car was the same just different color interior. I'll put a call in to another dealership today. As you can tell I'm not so good at hardball. lol.
Just be polite and keep asking questions .. eventually the truth will come out.
My guy is not budging. lol. If need be I can walk away from the deal. I don't know if it's the color and that they don't have it locally.
I don't really know what the MF means ( I will be doing research ) but I thought I would throw this in here. Thanks for any help, or direction for this.
Not a good deal .. MF is marked up (base MF is .00129) and $3500 is too much up front cash.
What is the selling price?
The selling price is $33,200. So I can ask for a lower MF? I'm not sure what I can negotiate for a lease so I asked that the starting point be from the selling price. Thank you for the help.
Politely but firmly explain to the dealer that you won't sign a deal with a MF that is marked up.
Yes, you negotiate the selling price on a lease just like you would for a purchase ... for BMW, shoot for 4-6% off MSRP before any incentives.
Using your MSRP and selling price, along with the base MF and residual of 66%, I get a $0 down pre-tax payment of $362.89.
Also, where are you basing the MF? Is it the same nationwide? I'm just waiting for him to say that it is different in every region or something.
The MF is nationwide for BMW - dealers love to give you a song and dance as to why they have to mark it up.
So he was able to drop the MSRP ($34,195) a bit. The MF would now be .00149, $3500 down, and $350/month. And then throw in some all weather floor mats. I don't ask for much.
Don't you mean the selling price was dropped? MSRP is the window sticker.
You might want to contact a second BMW dealer and see if they will offer you a deal that uses the base MF of .00129
I don't know how he dropped the MSRP number and he did drop the selling price too. The car was the same just different color interior. I'll put a call in to another dealership today. As you can tell I'm not so good at hardball. lol.
Just be polite and keep asking questions .. eventually the truth will come out.
My guy is not budging. lol. If need be I can walk away from the deal. I don't know if it's the color and that they don't have it locally.
Lots of BMW dealers ... and, I've got the April numbers. MF of .00130 and residual for 36/10 stays the same at 66%
Comments
Edmunds Price Checker
Edmunds Lease Calculator
Did you get a good deal? Be sure to come back and let us know! Post a pic of your new purchase or lease!
MODERATOR
2015 Subaru Outback 3.6R / 2014 MINI Countryman S ALL4
Option A: a 2015 sDrive. MSRP is $32,825. It was a demo, so they're offering it for $28,900, full warranty and service with it. If I put down $2,100 in MSDs, MF is 0.00101 , 36 months at 12K per year, 67% residual, so it looks like a killer deal.
Option B: a 2015 xDrive28i MSRP is $41,050. It was also a demo so they're offering it for $37,500. If I put down $3,510 in MSDs, MF is 0.00101, 36 months at 12K per year, 67% residual.
But for option A they're saying the monthly payment pre-tax is $268, and I'm getting $243, and option B they're saying $394 pre-tax and I calculate $343. When I questioned them on it, they said its because I am not factoring depreciation for miles. Car A has about 5,300 miles on it so they're depreciating it by $960, and Car B has about 9,700 miles on it so they're depreciating it by $1,850.
My trouble is I don't understand how to evaluate these deals with the depreciation factored in.
Anyone have experience with this or thoughts on these offers?
So my questions is, is this fair? Or can I reasonably ask them stick to the original residual, despite the car already being significantly discounted?
Thanks!
The only question I have is on the MSD - the base MF is .00130 and BMW security deposits reduce the MF by .00007 each. I sense that the dealer is inflating the base MF to .00150 before applying the MSDs.
Are you making the maximum 7 MSDs for these deals? If so, the net MF would be .00081, not .00101.
Still, both are pretty decent deals. But, I'd ask if they would reduce the base MF to .00130.
Edmunds Price Checker
Edmunds Lease Calculator
Did you get a good deal? Be sure to come back and let us know! Post a pic of your new purchase or lease!
MODERATOR
2015 Subaru Outback 3.6R / 2014 MINI Countryman S ALL4
2015 BMW x1 2.8i
ultimate package
lighting package
sport package
silver with red leather
36 month lease
15k miles per year
420 a month with MA tax included
First payment of 420 was total out of pocket
I was able to get the mf down lower than the .00130 to .0011
Edmunds Price Checker
Edmunds Lease Calculator
Did you get a good deal? Be sure to come back and let us know! Post a pic of your new purchase or lease!
MODERATOR
2015 Subaru Outback 3.6R / 2014 MINI Countryman S ALL4
Additionally, I was told because I took an "in stock vehicle" they were able to discount it more and I suppose it also helped that we got buried with over 4' of snow the past month and no one was out buying cars.
2014 X1 xDrive 28i 36 Months / 15k miles per year.
2015 X1 xDrive 28i 36 Months / 15k miles per year.
Thanks, in advance.
And, I can completely understand the need for the dealer to have one less vehicle on the lot that needs snow cleared off of it.
Enjoy your new BMW!
Edmunds Price Checker
Edmunds Lease Calculator
Did you get a good deal? Be sure to come back and let us know! Post a pic of your new purchase or lease!
MODERATOR
2015 Subaru Outback 3.6R / 2014 MINI Countryman S ALL4
2015 - .00130 and 65% for 36/15
Edmunds Price Checker
Edmunds Lease Calculator
Did you get a good deal? Be sure to come back and let us know! Post a pic of your new purchase or lease!
MODERATOR
2015 Subaru Outback 3.6R / 2014 MINI Countryman S ALL4
MSRP $32,825
Purchase price $28,150
Residual 67% less $960 depreciation (64% effective residual)
Terms 36 months/12K per year
MF 0.00101 after 6 security deposits
Base payment $248.04 plus tax
I think it looks pretty good, so I'll probably go do paperwork this weekend.
Thanks again for the feedback.
Those extra miles do affect the residual that the dealer has to use.
The only question I have is on the MSD - the base MF is .00130 and BMW security deposits reduce the MF by .00007 each. I sense that the dealer is inflating the base MF to .00150 before applying the MSDs.
Are you making the maximum 7 MSDs for these deals? If so, the net MF would be .00081, not .00101.
Still, both are pretty decent deals. But, I'd ask if they would reduce the base MF to .00130.
Thanks Michael. You're right, they are marking up the MF before applying MSDs. They weren't willing to bring the MF back to base before applying the MSDs but I negotiated the price down to $28,150 on the sDrive with 6 SDs down (I can't figure out why they won't let me do the max SDs and get it down further, but we're talking a difference of about $135 over the course of the next 3 years so I'm gonna let it go), and a monthly payment of about $270 including our local (9%!) sales tax. So the final deal is:
MSRP $32,825
Purchase price $28,150
Residual 67% less $960 depreciation (64% effective residual)
Terms 36 months/12K per year
MF 0.00101 after 6 security deposits
Base payment $248.04 plus tax
I think it looks pretty good, so I'll probably go do paperwork this weekend.
Thanks again for the feedback.
Congratulations - that is an excellent deal. Enjoy the new BMW!
Edmunds Price Checker
Edmunds Lease Calculator
Did you get a good deal? Be sure to come back and let us know! Post a pic of your new purchase or lease!
MODERATOR
2015 Subaru Outback 3.6R / 2014 MINI Countryman S ALL4
Thanks, Nick
No idea what will happen to the numbers next month ... I suspect the MF will stay the same or only move slightly. It's the residual that can fluctuate from one month to the next, especially on the SAV's (X1, X3, X5)
Edmunds Price Checker
Edmunds Lease Calculator
Did you get a good deal? Be sure to come back and let us know! Post a pic of your new purchase or lease!
MODERATOR
2015 Subaru Outback 3.6R / 2014 MINI Countryman S ALL4
I'm surprised a dealer would tell you the marked-up money factor (where he might have competition), but wouldn't disclose the residual value, which is the same, everywhere..
It can't be a bad deal at those numbers, but if you want to bargain, you really need to know the selling price, CAP cost and the actual residual, so you can check the numbers... Of course, the money factor is marked up, and that alone is adding $30/mo.+ to the deal.
If you are going to make a deal, I'd try to do it before next month (which starts Tuesday). The residuals offered on the X1 aren't likely to hold up, long term.
Edmunds Price Checker
Edmunds Lease Calculator
Did you get a good deal? Be sure to come back and share!
Edmunds Moderator
Version A: x28
msrp: 43,600
cap: 40,200
lease: 36mo/10K (68% res, .00130mf)
$2,975 upfront for taxes, fees, including first month
$385/mo after that
Version B: x35
msrp: 48,925
cap: 44,950
lease: 36mo/10K (68% res, .00130mf)
$3,600 up front including first month
$420/mo after that
Any hint on what rates are going to be tomorrow (March 3rd?)
I think money factor will be about the same, but residuals will be lower... just guessing..
Edmunds Price Checker
Edmunds Lease Calculator
Did you get a good deal? Be sure to come back and share!
Edmunds Moderator
Yes.. my calculations are within $1/mo.
Edmunds Price Checker
Edmunds Lease Calculator
Did you get a good deal? Be sure to come back and share!
Edmunds Moderator
Thanks!
Edmunds Price Checker
Edmunds Lease Calculator
Did you get a good deal? Be sure to come back and let us know! Post a pic of your new purchase or lease!
MODERATOR
2015 Subaru Outback 3.6R / 2014 MINI Countryman S ALL4
Edmunds Price Checker
Edmunds Lease Calculator
Did you get a good deal? Be sure to come back and let us know! Post a pic of your new purchase or lease!
MODERATOR
2015 Subaru Outback 3.6R / 2014 MINI Countryman S ALL4
Edmunds Price Checker
Edmunds Lease Calculator
Did you get a good deal? Be sure to come back and share!
Edmunds Moderator
Edmunds Price Checker
Edmunds Lease Calculator
Did you get a good deal? Be sure to come back and share!
Edmunds Moderator
15XA X1 sDr28i
Valencia Orange
MSRP $34,445
Residual 66%
adj res: $22,733
10k mi/yr
36months
MF : .00169
$3,499.99 down
$390 / month
I don't really know what the MF means ( I will be doing research ) but I thought I would throw this in here. Thanks for any help, or direction for this.
What is the selling price?
Edmunds Price Checker
Edmunds Lease Calculator
Did you get a good deal? Be sure to come back and let us know! Post a pic of your new purchase or lease!
MODERATOR
2015 Subaru Outback 3.6R / 2014 MINI Countryman S ALL4
Yes, you negotiate the selling price on a lease just like you would for a purchase ... for BMW, shoot for 4-6% off MSRP before any incentives.
Using your MSRP and selling price, along with the base MF and residual of 66%, I get a $0 down pre-tax payment of $362.89.
Edmunds Price Checker
Edmunds Lease Calculator
Did you get a good deal? Be sure to come back and let us know! Post a pic of your new purchase or lease!
MODERATOR
2015 Subaru Outback 3.6R / 2014 MINI Countryman S ALL4
So without a down payment, the payments were still as low as $368.89? And this is why you never buy on the first visit to the dealership
Edmunds Price Checker
Edmunds Lease Calculator
Did you get a good deal? Be sure to come back and let us know! Post a pic of your new purchase or lease!
MODERATOR
2015 Subaru Outback 3.6R / 2014 MINI Countryman S ALL4
You might want to contact a second BMW dealer and see if they will offer you a deal that uses the base MF of .00129
Edmunds Price Checker
Edmunds Lease Calculator
Did you get a good deal? Be sure to come back and let us know! Post a pic of your new purchase or lease!
MODERATOR
2015 Subaru Outback 3.6R / 2014 MINI Countryman S ALL4
Edmunds Price Checker
Edmunds Lease Calculator
Did you get a good deal? Be sure to come back and let us know! Post a pic of your new purchase or lease!
MODERATOR
2015 Subaru Outback 3.6R / 2014 MINI Countryman S ALL4
Edmunds Price Checker
Edmunds Lease Calculator
Did you get a good deal? Be sure to come back and let us know! Post a pic of your new purchase or lease!
MODERATOR
2015 Subaru Outback 3.6R / 2014 MINI Countryman S ALL4
Edmunds Price Checker
Edmunds Lease Calculator
Did you get a good deal? Be sure to come back and let us know! Post a pic of your new purchase or lease!
MODERATOR
2015 Subaru Outback 3.6R / 2014 MINI Countryman S ALL4
Edmunds Price Checker
Edmunds Lease Calculator
Did you get a good deal? Be sure to come back and let us know! Post a pic of your new purchase or lease!
MODERATOR
2015 Subaru Outback 3.6R / 2014 MINI Countryman S ALL4
Edmunds Price Checker
Edmunds Lease Calculator
Did you get a good deal? Be sure to come back and share!
Edmunds Moderator