Did you recently take on (or consider) a loan of 84 months or longer on a car purchase?
A reporter would like to speak with you about your experience; please reach out to PR@Edmunds.com by 7/22 for details.
Options

CR-V vs Escape

1114115117119120167

Comments

  • drive62drive62 Member Posts: 637
  • mikefm58mikefm58 Member Posts: 2,882
    Nice one drive62. But I can see it coming from the Escape corner....

    "No, it's because CRV owners are too busy. If they're not putting out a fire, they're too busy making sure the dealer does the oil change right".
  • steverstever Guest Posts: 52,454
    lol, maybe the CR-V owners can start getting their oil changed at the Ford dealers and burn the stores down with the CR-V's in them. Then the rest of us won't have to deal with CR-V and Escape owners carping at each other. :-)

    Steve, Host
  • snowmansnowman Member Posts: 540
    Has Honda discovered why CRVs have been pulling left or right?...LOL
    Well, at least Ford is trying to fix the issue by issuing recalls. What is Honda doing? Blaming lube techs...
    What is next? Accusing assembly line workers not knowing how to install suspension components or pointing fingers to parts suppliers...
  • stu269stu269 Member Posts: 1
    Scaper,
    Firstly, the 2.3l (4wd) in the Mazda/Escape bites. A little torquey perhaps, but not worth all the moaning noise produce by the motor and transfer case. It should come with a box of Tylenol for headaches. Although the mileage is not bad, this vehicle difinitely needs refinement as well as more flexible trim packages. Crv had side curtain airbags...not so with 4 cyl excape/trib.
    The CRV is MILES ahead in technology, comfort, resale value, cargo space, quality of trim and plastics. If you say you need horsies over economy, maybe you should be in a v8 Cherokee, I heard they rock.
    Nowadays we are being held hostage by oil companies, people should understand that power is mental control issue and driving defensively doesn't require a 250hp vehicle.
    Unfortunately, the Honda dealerships are a bunch of hams when buying this vehicle new, they stick together like a Mafia, wheeling and dealing is not an option. Domestic dealers are way more flexible. I guess Honda knows people just pony up the cash and shut up...especially people who are afraid of buying a vehicle that may require some maintenance. Obviously, Hondas are not bullet proof as people think, but they are the leaders when it comes to reliability, you gotta give that (even though I don't want to).
    Choice given if I had the cash?? Honda, no questions asked.
  • dc_driverdc_driver Member Posts: 712
    If cash was no obstacle, I would have picked a Subaru Outback XT (turbo wagon), or perhaps an Acura MDX... But, I still smile when I think of how much lower my Tribute payment is (about 10K for the Subaru, 20K for the Acura)...

    Anyway, to be fair I never even bothered to drive the 4cyl Tribute after driving both the CRV and the Rav4 and realizing that I preffered a 6cyl. Like Stu implied, one of my biggest reasons for not choosing the CRV was the Honda dealership experience (arrogant, dealers who just did not want to make the sale). The Mazda dealer was completely honest and up front and wanted my business. When I was buying a new sedan in 02, I had the exact same experience when comparing the Accord to the Nissan Altima. In the end, the Altima won out and I have had zero problems with this car over the last three years. My co-worker purchased an 03 Accord and has had his car back to the dealer about five times over the past year, and is now stressing because his warranty is almost out. The funny thing is that he loves my Altima and is seriously considering selling the Accord for a new Altima. Personally, I think Hondas are very well engineered automobiles, but are overrated. Just like Subaru owners, Honda owners are very passionate about their vehicles and do not mind paying more money because they love the brand and the image that Honda represents. But, there is a ton of competition right now, and I think you will see Honda lose some market share over the next few years...
  • crimdoccrimdoc Member Posts: 36
    Perhaps this should be on the "buying and selling experiences" forum ... but anyway ...

    I too ran into the arrogant Honda salesman. He basically acted like he was doing me a favor showing me my CRV, and told me that the sticker price was firm ... MAYBE he could knock $500 off, but that was about it ...

    I had him write up a quote, shook his hand, told him I was still shopping and walked out.

    I then e-mailed dealers all over Michigan asking for internet quotes on the same car. I eventually got an "at invoice" quote back (about $2000 less than the list price).

    I then walked back into the dealership and very simply said:

    "Hi, I've made up my mind, I want to buy a CRV. If you can sell it to me for this price I'll sign papers right now, if not, I'm getting in the car and driving over to this other dealership."

    I had my car within an hour.

    Now, I can't say that this will work for everyone, but I found it to be a simple, stress free experience. No haggling and no arguing.

    Use the internet and e-mail to do your negotiations / shopping.

    Now, to be fair, some dealerships won't want to do deals over the net ... I did get calls and e-mails back that said "it would be best if you came in so we could talk about this". I simply responded:

    "I'm sorry, I'm organizing my car search in e-mail ... it's most convenient for me because then I have a written record of all my offers. If you aren't able to work with me this way then I guess you don't want my business. Thank you."
  • drive62drive62 Member Posts: 637
    For those who follow the financial performance of the two automakers:

    "GM lost $1.24, to $35.65, a 52-week closing low. Ford dropped 35 cents, to $12.65, also a 52-week closing low. An analyst at Banc of America Securities cut his rating on the automakers to "sell" from "neutral."

    "We believe we have been wrong not to be more negative on the domestic automaker stocks, and their suppliers, because we have underestimated the repercussions of their market share loss," wrote analyst Ron Tadross in a client note.

    Honda stock BTW is at a 52 week HIGH.
  • mikefm58mikefm58 Member Posts: 2,882
    I hope you worked with a different Honda salesman on your return trip. The original arrogant sales person didn't deserve your business.

    You still need to do your research though as with your method, you'll get lots of low ball offers just to get you in.
  • steverstever Guest Posts: 52,454
    hmmm, sounds like a good time to buy Ford and GM. Anyone want to pop 100 shares of each in a dummy portfolio and see where we are in a year?

    Steve, Host
  • explorerx4explorerx4 Member Posts: 20,723
    welcome to the cheapshot board. neither of these are the be all - end all of vehicles.
    2024 Ford F-150 STX, 2023 Ford Explorer ST, 91 Mustang GT vert
  • stevedebistevedebi Member Posts: 4,098
    "hmmm, sounds like a good time to buy Ford and GM. Anyone want to pop 100 shares of each in a dummy portfolio and see where we are in a year? "

    Dummy portfolio, appropriate name.
  • steverstever Guest Posts: 52,454
    lol, thanks for the belly laugh.

    Then again, if they pop up 20% or more?

    Steve, Host
  • drive62drive62 Member Posts: 637
    "Honda owners are very passionate about their vehicles and do not mind paying more money because they love the brand and the image that Honda represents."

    You know that for a fact? Read the buying experience topics right here to find all the people who are paying invoice or less for their Hondas. Perhaps you think invoice is still "more money" but I don't. I have shown dozens of times that a CR-V will cost less than a comparably equipped Escape. People are paying invoice, close to, or below for their CR-Vs so I don't understand your statement.

    In my opinion it is the Ford buyer who is paying too much for the Escape (based on what you get).
  • drive62drive62 Member Posts: 637
    Since when is making money being a "dummy"? HMC is up ~40% in the last year. That's a result I'll take any day of the week.

    Investing in quality companies usually pays off in the long term.
  • steverstever Guest Posts: 52,454
    Sounds like it's too rich to buy now. :-)

    Besides, this is an auto forum - no one buys and holds when there are new models hitting the showroom every fall.

    Anyone have sales numbers for Feb.?

    Steve, Host
  • stevedebistevedebi Member Posts: 4,098
    "Since when is making money being a "dummy"? HMC is up ~40% in the last year. That's a result I'll take any day of the week. "

    Take a look at the original post, they were referring to investing in GM and Ford.
  • scape2scape2 Member Posts: 4,123
    I have been away far too long. I wish I had the time to respond to the many posts about recalls... I notice none of the Honda crowd mentinos the CRV recalls?? or engine fires? or pulling to the right issues, or how bad the CRV does in rear end collsions, as far as that repair bill.. Or how Honda does not give out TSB information on www.alldata.com? .. I know my 01 Escape XLT V6 is very, very reliable. Check MSN reliability data and you will be surprisd. Escapes/Tribs rate very well for reliabitliy. I am a Honda owners worst nightmare. I own an Escape with just over 50,000 trouble free miles. As far as V6 vs 4cyl.... the MPG difference is about 2miles...Keep trying and trying to make the 4cyl in the CRV more powerful or "better". Fact s the Escape can pull, tow and haul more than the CRV.. and do it with confidence...
  • stevedebistevedebi Member Posts: 4,098
    I didn't buy the CR-V over the Escape because of the I4 engine. I bought my CR-V because I prefer Honda engineering and handling over the Escape. It was a personal preference.

    I've seen very few vehicles that handle like the CR-V, especially parking and turning radius.
  • tidestertidester Member Posts: 10,059
    I notice none of the Honda crowd mentinos ...

    That's because they are being good members and staying on topic! If you're truly interested in those topics try Honda CR-V Owners: Problems & Solutions or Honda CR-V engine fires. :-)

    tidester, host
  • anythngbutgmanythngbutgm Member Posts: 4,277
    50k is nothing to gloat about IMO. That's a drop in the bucket to most drivers, something that can be achieved in less than 2 years, hardly equates to superior long term durability/reliability over the CRV. If and when you hit 150k, come back and glaot all you want because as of now your situation is far from impressive.
  • varmintvarmint Member Posts: 6,326
    "I notice none of the Honda crowd mentions ..." Don't we already have a broken record for that?
  • drive62drive62 Member Posts: 637
    Oops my error. Kind of hard to follow these threads sometimes. Obviously I'm not the only one otherwise how would you explain someone thinking I was supporting the V6 argument.

    Seeing they were talking about GM and Ford, ignore my comment about quality companies.

    BTW, HMC at another 52 week high today. F? Another 52 week low.
  • scape2scape2 Member Posts: 4,123
    Handling? this is funny most reviews pick the Escape over the CRV for this category... Honda engineering? Once again the stigma, Ford engineering is just plain sub-par.. This is garbage and just and old wives tale. Lets see now.. parallel park your CRV, then try to unload it with another parked car right behind you.... OOPs.. tailgate swings out and is in the way!
    If Honda makes such fantastic 4cyl engines.. then why did they put a V6 in the Accord??
  • scape2scape2 Member Posts: 4,123
    Double standard once again....
    Honda folks brag and brag about how reliable thier vehicles are and how all Fords are just going to fall apart the minute you leave the parking lot. Get out on the net and visit other chat rooms. There are Escapes/Tribute owners now reaching 100,000 trouble free miles. The word is spreading. These are NOT unreliable low quality vehicles. The 80's are over, Honda no longer has the market of reliability or quality wrapped up.
  • anythngbutgmanythngbutgm Member Posts: 4,277
    "Honda folks brag and brag about how reliable thier vehicles are and how all Fords are just going to fall apart the minute you leave the parking lot."

    Well that's quite the generalization... Actually quite the opposite my friend. I like Honda's and I like Ford's. I think Ford truck are the best in the business (Only mid-pack engine wise though). Owned a couple myself. Not bad cars (miles ahead of a Garbage Motors offering) but sticklers for maintainance. They were only as good as the service dept. and in my case I have a Linclon/Merc dealer nearby that is by far the best dealership I've ever had of any make, even Honda. Thing is, I don't visit the Honda/Acura dealers for anything other than 15k maintainance. My Ford's, a different story. Couple of O2 sensors and bad wheel bearings on one and an Explorer with 28k miles that needed a steering rack and 2 new hubs because thay would not engage fully causing hard bangs while taking left turns.

    "There are Escapes/Tribute owners now reaching 100,000 trouble free miles. The word is spreading."

    I don't doubt there are are. But that's hardly a pinnacle of success.
  • mikefm58mikefm58 Member Posts: 2,882
    Excellent post anythngbutgm, and my thoughts exactly. Ford makes some of the best trucks and SUVs as pretty much that entire lineup of vehicles are among the leaders in their class.

    But their cars are another story, mostly due to fleet sales to Hertz. Their value drops like a boat anchor.

    However, that fact is a huge plus for someone who keeps a vehicle a long time and can fix things. A 1-2 year old low mileage Taurus is a phenominal value for someone like that.
  • dc_driverdc_driver Member Posts: 712
    That may be true (paying invoice on a Honda CRV SE) for buyers in many regions, but not in my case back in November. I mostly tried negotiating over the Internet, and most of the dealers would ask me to "come down and lets see what we can do, I think we are close" and then the sales droid would try to sell me one for about $1000-1500 OVER invoice.. After about three such attempts, I gave up and bought the Tribute (took 2 emails, and I was in and out of the dealer in less than 2 hours). A truly wonderful experience. I did not buy the Escape I bought the Tribute (V6, AWD, completely loaded, compare to a CRV SE for 21,888 plus TTL). No way a Honda CRV was going to match or beat that price in the Northern Virginia area. Any even if they did, no way am I going to give my hard earned $$ to an arrogant, untrusty dealer....
  • scape2scape2 Member Posts: 4,123
    are changing. New 500 is getting good reviews. Kind of funny how some call it "Boring" yet the Accord/Camry/Avalon aren't???? New engine due for the 500, a 3.5 V6. The Fusion is also getting some good coverage. Focus is doing very well in Europe with its new version. The U.S. won't get this for another 2 years though. Things are changing for Ford and GM. There will always be those who never can imagine a Ford actually being "Better" than a Honda.
  • drive62drive62 Member Posts: 637
    I guess we have different philosophies when it comes to big ticket purchases. I negotiate a fair price and buy my first choice. And even if I pay a few hundred dollars more than I should it really doesn't matter as I know I've made a good choice. And how much will those few extra dollars matter in five years time anyway. It's the quality of the vehicle that matters most to me.

    Like I said I hope you keep the vehicle a long time. And somehow I think you could have found a CR-V for a good price in Virginia. But it doesn't really matter.
  • mikefm58mikefm58 Member Posts: 2,882
    I think besides price, the other significant factor in dc_driver's decision was the arrogant Honda dealers. That would also make me run out the door to Honda's competitors.
  • stevedebistevedebi Member Posts: 4,098
    "Handling? this is funny most reviews pick the Escape over the CRV for this category... Honda engineering? Once again the stigma, Ford engineering is just plain sub-par.. This is garbage and just and old wives tale. Lets see now.. parallel park your CRV, then try to unload it with another parked car right behind you.... OOPs.. tailgate swings out and is in the way!"

    Well, I prefer my own likes/dislikes to the reviews. The CR-V is the best handling vehicle I've ever driven for in-town maneuverability.

    A lot of people would prefer a top loading rear door, but I prefer that large under cargo floor well that comes with the spare tire on the rear door.
  • snowmansnowman Member Posts: 540
    "Focus is doing very well.."
    I think Focus is doing very well here too. Honda made big mistake by removing regular Civic hatcback from production (Si is too expensice for a hatcback car). The market is taken by Ford and Dodge (Neon). Majority of young people -college kids, new graduates, high school kids, and professionals are driving Focus Hatcback in my area.
  • stevedebistevedebi Member Posts: 4,098
    "I think Focus is doing very well here too. Honda made big mistake by removing regular Civic hatcback from production (Si is too expensice for a hatcback car). The market is taken by Ford and Dodge (Neon). Majority of young people -college kids, new graduates, high school kids, and professionals are driving Focus Hatcback in my area."

    Well... since we appear to be off topic, I think that Honda has a problem with costs here. While they build a very good car in the Civic, the lower cost of the Focus appeals more to the budget minded college folk...

    Still don't see what the heck this all has to do with the Escape or CR-V...
  • drive62drive62 Member Posts: 637
    Well I tried to allude to that in my response.

    Again this is my way of doing things: I don't care about an "arrogant" dealer (or appliance shop owner or travel agent--whatever). I buy what suits my needs. Unless you live in a one horse town I think there are usually multiple dealers to choose from. The generalization about Honda dealers being "arrogant" is just that, a generalization. There are plenty of good Honda dealers and also plenty of bad ones. Just like there are for Ford, Mazda, Chevrolet etc. The exact way dc_driver bought his Mazda I have bought Hondas.

    To not buy a quality product that I have thoroughly researched and will best meet my needs because of an "arrogant" salesperson isn't what I would do. YMMV.
  • anythngbutgmanythngbutgm Member Posts: 4,277
    It was a tangent of Scapes opinion that Ford's are equal if not better than Honda's based on his experience with his Escape. And with whopping 50k on it!!!

    "Things are changing for Ford and GM. There will always be those who never can imagine a Ford actually being "Better" than a Honda."

    The only thing changing at Ford is that the Escape is proving to be better than your typical Ford product.
  • drive62drive62 Member Posts: 637
    Again OT but your Marketing Degree is in....?

    In announcing the next generation Civic Honda specifically mentioned how hatchback sales are nowhere in North America (at least for these small vehicles) so they made the decision to discontinue that body style---the Si will again be a coupe.

    I'm thinking some pretty good Market Research went in to that decision. So let Ford and DMC have the small hatchback market. We all see how well it adds to their bottom line.
  • snowmansnowman Member Posts: 540
    "but your Marketing Degree is in...."

    I don't pose as Marketing Professor, I am an observer...Perhaps you should help Ford to gain some market share since you know more than Ford execs on marketing.

    "how hatchback sales are nowhere in North America..."

    Probably you can be more clear on this. Whose hatcback sales are we talking? Honda or from all car manufacturers?

    "So let Ford and DMC have the small hatchback market. We all see how well it adds to their bottom line."

    Why you guys are so mean to Ford and other domestic manufacturers? Everything they do is bad dudu, everything Honda does is excellent...
  • anythngbutgmanythngbutgm Member Posts: 4,277
    All brands. Saab for instance, dropped the hatchback when they redesigned the 9-5 back in 1997? and sales went up like 20%. So they did the same with the 9-3. Even Saab who sold mainly hatchbacks realized the dwindling demand for them and went to the conventional 4-door. Even the MZ 6 hatch hasn't been to hot if I recall.

    My wife had an 02 MB Kompressor coupe and while handy, never got the recognition and MB dropped it. Same with the old 318 Bimmer. Hatchbacks just aren't in demand.
  • snowmansnowman Member Posts: 540
    In my view, hatchback cars are designed to lure young drivers ( age 16-26 may be). Not too much should be expected from those people financially. Keeping this in mind, the price of the hatchback car is very important.
  • snowmansnowman Member Posts: 540
    "Still don't see what the heck this all has to do with the Escape or CR-V..."

    I found it as relevant as discussing financial markets here...or there is an irony here that I don't see...
  • stevedebistevedebi Member Posts: 4,098
    " I found it as relevant as discussing financial markets here...or there is an irony here that I don't see..."

    Heck, on this thread, there always seems to be irony here; no one seems to understand the other people's posts (including me)...

    Sometimes it seems like there are really strange conversations, sort of like asking "what time is it?" and getting back an answer "well, it sure is hot in Bombay!"

    Be afraid, be very, very afraid...
  • snowmansnowman Member Posts: 540
    LOL...
  • scape2scape2 Member Posts: 4,123
    A typical quote from your typical silver "H" worshiper. "The only thing changing at Ford is that the Escape is proving to be better than your typical Ford product". Wrong! Why has the F Series, Explorer, Ranger and Focus keep popping up as top sellers all these years? If all these vehicles are so bad why do people keep buying them and comming back to buy them again? Get out on the net my friend, you will find many peeved off Honda owners expecting perfectiong and getting otherwise..
  • scape2scape2 Member Posts: 4,123
    Just read in my Motor Trend Toyota is coming out with an all new RAV4 in 05 sometime. The new RAV4 will be larger to compete against the CRV/Escape/Liberty group. Guess what Honda fans... The new RAV4 is going to offer a 3.3 V6! LOL! Honda missed the boat again... I still have to ask.. if the 4cyl is so powerful and great in the Accord why does Honda offer a V6???...
  • snowmansnowman Member Posts: 540
    Do CRV I4 and Accord I4 (LX model) carry the same engine?
    I had 99 Accord LX with 150 HP. Even though it was 5spd, the car seemed very thirsty for passing power on highway.

    Before I bought my Trib/Escape, I had test drive 04 CRV in city traffic and on semi highway. It felt like lacking acceleration/passing power on semi highway. It was adequate on traffic light take offs.
  • tidestertidester Member Posts: 10,059
    no one seems to understand the other people's posts...

    I suppose it's definite progress if one is at least understanding one's own posts! ;-)

    tidester, host
  • mikefm58mikefm58 Member Posts: 2,882
    " The new RAV4 is going to offer a 3.3 V6 "

    I think that's just Toyota following the trend in "more power is always better". And I'd expect Honda to eventually do the same.

    " if the 4cyl is so powerful and great in the Accord why does Honda offer a V6???... "

    Ummm, maybe because the competition does?
  • mikefm58mikefm58 Member Posts: 2,882
    " Things are changing for Ford and GM "

    Blah blah blah, I'll be holding my breath when things change.
  • mikefm58mikefm58 Member Posts: 2,882
    " Why you guys are so mean to Ford and other domestic manufacturers? Everything they do is bad dudu, everything Honda does is excellent "

    I don't think that's the general feeling here from the Honda side. I still see a fair amount of criticism of Honda from them. And I know most feel that Ford trucks and SUVs are fine vehicles.
Sign In or Register to comment.