Buying American Cars What Does It Mean?

1254255257259260382

Comments

  • fintailfintail Member Posts: 58,531
    And what about the multiplier effect of workers wages, which will be put into the economy in much greater amounts than tax revenues or corporate profits?
  • berriberri Member Posts: 10,165
    C'mon Fin - workers don't make the sizeable political donations!
  • motorcity6motorcity6 Member Posts: 427
    Back yonder in the 70's, I was the owner of 27' Magnum Sport w/T-280, 24' Donzi Doral w/T-280s, and a 28' Cigarette w/T-280s..All outdrives were the Mercury TRS version, engines were Vette with 4-bolt mains.

    The Magnum was the fun boat, the Cigarette was party boat, and the Donzi took the honors of "chime walking", horrible handling at speed, too much weight aft w/Vette engines plus the TRS outdrives..

    After going through 23 boats, my last venture was in 1985, joined a country club and took up golf..Boating season in Michigan is too short, however golf can be done 8 mos, and the other 3 in Florida, take 1 mo off..

    The boating world when I was active in it was all-American merchandise game..Too expensive today..too old for the 90 mph haulers
  • steverstever Guest Posts: 52,454
    Last time I checked, Detroit is not in Canada"

    No, but you can see it from here. Flew in this afternoon and the skyline and view of the Detroit River flowing into Lake St. Clair was really pretty. The highlight was flying over the Ford Proving Grounds. Couldn't identify the car, but one was cruising on the track.

    (Go Tigers! - dang, I'm turning into a Michigander. :shades: )
  • cannon3cannon3 Member Posts: 296
    Recently I was at an outside gathering. A young woman approached and proceeded to converse with us. There was a group of about 4 men and 3 women. Talked about kids, school, ect.. She had graduated 2 years earlier with a BS degree from a college well known in my area. She also proceeded to complain about how she could not find opportunity for decent employment. She is part of the under employed over educated here in the U.S. She was however happy she bought a KIA SOUL!. I took this opportunity and ran with it. Wrong guy to complain too about not being able to find a good job, then send your money overseas!!??. By the end of the conversation, she understood, she could see the connection. She vowed to buy products/services as close to home as possible. We are all connected folks! WAKE UP!
  • imidazol97imidazol97 Member Posts: 27,700
    >view of the Detroit River flowing into Lake St. Clair

    When I first read that post, I thought something wasn't right. I believe the Lake St. Clair flows into the Detroit River which then flows into Lake Erie and on to the Atlantia ocean. Is my geography right?

    2014 Malibu 2LT, 2015 Cruze 2LT,

  • steverstever Guest Posts: 52,454
    edited October 2011
    Oh, I'm sure you are. You've lived around this part of the world lots longer than I have. Had to pull up a map to get the name of the lake since I just assumed flying in that it was one of the Great Lakes (and don't all rivers flow south? i.e., downhill :D )
  • tlongtlong Member Posts: 5,194
    We are all connected folks! WAKE UP!

    Perhaps you should convince that machinist's union in Seattle to quit trying to get Boeing's new plant in S.C. closed. We ARE all connected!
  • iwant12iwant12 Member Posts: 269
    I own a 1978 S2 7.3 (24") sailboat, which was made in Holland, Michigan. It's been a great boat. I bought it back in 98. In a few years, I plan on upgrading to a J-28. Love those J Boats.

    I'd say the S2 is one of the few things I have that's paid for, but can you really say a boat is ever truly paid for?
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    but you can see it from here

    Kinda like Palin can see Russia from her house. :D
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    She vowed to buy products/services as close to home as possible

    Fair enough, but the Chevy Spark is also Korean designed and will be built there. The Sonic is also Korean designed. Chrysler might be happy to sell you an (Italian) Fiat 500 made in Mexico, also. The Fiesta is European designed.

    I cannot even pronounce Cuautitlán and I'm fluent in Spanish.

    Help your fellow Cuautitlanians! Buy a Fiesta!

    ¡¡andale andale, arriba arriba!!

    We live in a global economy, get used to it.
  • imidazol97imidazol97 Member Posts: 27,700
    edited October 2011
    >Kinda like Palin can see Russia from her house.
    Or obama can see all 57 states from his Chicago home. :blush:

    2014 Malibu 2LT, 2015 Cruze 2LT,

  • marsha7marsha7 Member Posts: 3,703
    "Fair enough, but the Chevy Spark is also Korean designed and will be built there. The Sonic is also Korean designed. Chrysler might be happy to sell you an (Italian) Fiat 500 made in Mexico, also. The Fiesta is European designed." (from the post of another person)...

    Cannon, how do we respond to this, under your logic???...if the Ford Fusion is built in Mexico, and the Chrysler 200 or 300 is built in Canada, define for me how we "buy American" when some Hondas and Toyotas have more American content than Big 3 products that like to deceive us as American products but they are not...

    If GM was based in Detroit but imported all their products from Mexico, would you not be supporting the American worker more by buying a Honda made in Ohio???

    Just because the company has an American name does that mean you blindly buy its products because you WANT to think the stuff is made here when you know it isn't???
  • berriberri Member Posts: 10,165
    Every one's got their own feelings and no one is going to win this argument. Personally, since stock ownership and profits are really global these days, I go by domestic content. I really do try to buy only cars that have significant US content, but that also means I consider transpants and D3 equally in this respect. I also think quality improvements in Detroit and perhaps a little backsliding in Asia, combined with increasing commonality of vendors, has resulted in most new cars getting pretty similar in reliability. Most of the issues with today's cars seem more related to electronics and new gizmo's like infotainment.
  • tlongtlong Member Posts: 5,194
    Or obama can see all 57 states from his Chicago home.

    Did you know that GMs are perfect because the parts are cheap and readily available? :blush: :P
  • berriberri Member Posts: 10,165
    I'll add one more thing. I know it is sometimes difficult to know, but if I find out a vehicle has any significant Chinese content I will avoid it even if it is primarily domestic in content. This isn't just because of quality concerns. China has strong ties with countries like North Korea, Iran and with Mr. Chavez in Latin America. These are all countries and leaders that openly advocate the destruction of America. Therefore, I have to conclude China wants to eventually destroy us too. I understand the conundrum US companies are in. China has the fastest growing middle class, but they also steal technology, ignore patent rights and cheat on open markets. But I will do my best to avoid Chinese products whenever possible. Please don't tell me I'm foolish because of Boeing, since China is working on taking away their airline business too probably wirth stolen US and European technology. Remember, China is also very active in hacking.
  • fintailfintail Member Posts: 58,531
    China doesn't really have a middle class as we know it. You don't succeed there without government connections and towing the party line.

    I agree with your sentiments entirely. I will never own a Chinese car.
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    I will never own a Chinese car

    So Saab still has hope to earn a sale?

    http://www.autoblog.com/2011/10/24/saab-shirks-takeover-bid-by-chinas-pang-da-an- d-youngman-termin/

    ;)
  • fintailfintail Member Posts: 58,531
    Maybe a used one, as they have the resale value of day old bread.

    I wouldn't buy a used Chinese car either.
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    You're not nostalgic for 1960s era safety?

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Mbe5ILICT4M

    (well known Brilliance crash test)
  • fintailfintail Member Posts: 58,531
    "BS" fits that car well. I guess they couldn't steal safety engineering, so they have just went out and bought it.
  • berriberri Member Posts: 10,165
    ...or hacked a fake computer site.
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    The scary thing is when they copy they basically steal a mold, but don't engineer the frame the same way.

    Update on Brilliance, here's their copy of the BMW SAV:

    http://www.burlappcars.com/2011/03/bmw-x1-vsbrilliance-a3.html

    So they're still at it, even now.
  • marsha7marsha7 Member Posts: 3,703
    "Every one's got their own feelings and no one is going to win this argument"...I agree with you, and no one is "trying to win"...but the constant refrain from cannon (no this is NOT an attack, just me being inquisitive) is that the lady's neighbor is out of a job because she bought a Kia...

    But, if I lived 50 miles from here near West Point, Georgia, my neighbor HAS a job paying good money because he makes Kias here in GA...and if I lived there, it would be a high probability that my friend the pizza maker may open a store and serve those workers pizza for lunch and dinner, and if his business takes off, he may hire 3 servers and a driver for take-out, all American jobs within an American business, enabling THOSE workers to buy other things like piano lessons, and blue jeans, and get their cars serviced by local mechanics, etc...

    And, if I understand cannon correctly, he would complain because the profit for the Kias go back to Korea, but all those OTHER jobs are right here for Americans...and don't forget that by not having the UAW here, we don;t live with that entitlement attitude that pervades the north and we don't have to worry about the militants going on strike, so life here is much more peaceful...when you deal with UAW products, every three years the entire town goes into bunker mentality until the new contract is ratified, causing great stress on the local businesses who wonder if they will last long enough until the strike ends...until you have lived in Detroit, that is a concept that an outsider simply does not understand...

    Buying Kia supports American jobs, and they give that 100K warranty...why doesn't Ford/GM/or C give that???...after all, they now have the same suppliers making the same parts, why such a lousy warranty from the Big 3???...why blindly buy "American" with a car that was made in Mexico or Brazil by Ford???...does he believe that is really buying American???

    I am confused, very confused...
  • fintailfintail Member Posts: 58,531
    Ha, I hadn't seen the X1 copycar yet. Just shameful.
  • cannon3cannon3 Member Posts: 296
    You fail to see the whole picture, or the longterm consequences from buying forgien goods and services. As you try to justify the Kia plant in Georgia. I would bet my house that the tooling (robotics/automation), the parts the support, the higher paying jobs, higher level positions are all Korean. How is an American supposed to get these positions if they have the same eduation, same ability? You justify these transplants by saying minimum wage jobs spun off from these plants is enough, and ok for the American worker? Buying Kia does NOT support American jobs, oh, if you mean minimum wage jobs, I will agree with you.
    My whole point with this young lady not being able to find higher paying jobs prospects is: You send your money overseas, you create opportunity, jobs/taxes ect overseas. It is amazing how people respond and understand the logic of keeping your money as close to home as possible benefits them, thier community/city/state/country.
    I am in no way a union supporter, nor am I for those who feel entitled. However, I am in full support of AMERICA and AMERICANS. Time, way past time to take of our own, our house. AMERICA.
  • marsha7marsha7 Member Posts: 3,703
    Explain to me why buying a Ford made in Mexico is, in your eyes, a better purchase that does ntohing for anyone here in America, but buying a Kia made in GA with American labor is a bad thing...and do you know for sure that the stamping machinery used here by GM is made here or possibly imported from germany or japan...

    When a foreign maker makes their product here, you have failed to explain to me why Americand are hurt but that Ford made cars in Mexico are good for America...
  • cannon3cannon3 Member Posts: 296
    First off, if you are speaking of the Fusion, the engine, and many of the parts for the Fusion are made in America. The Transmission is actually made in Japan. The Fusion was also designed here in the U.S. Granted the Fiesta is another story. I believe the Fiesta is 100percent forgien made parts. This is why I would never buy a Fiesta.
    You can still buy from U.S. car manufacturers many vehicles made here in the U.S. Just to name a few. Malibu, Cruze, Sonic, Focus, Escape, Fseries, and many more.
    The same agrument can go for your Kia plant. Where do you think Kia gets most of its parts from? The Hyundai Sonata is 39% U.S. sourced parts. Yet they fool Americans into thinking it is all manufactured here in the United States. Making it look like it is all made here in the U.S.
    Plus, there is this thing called profits. Where do you think the profits go for the Kia plant? Where to you think the profits go from the GM plants/Ford plants?
    My whole point here is the majority of the labor in the forgien plants are menial labor. Assembly labor. The higher paying jobs/positions go to the imported workers while Americans become the menial laborers. If you think this is ok, then this country is in worse shape than I thought.. :cry:
  • tlongtlong Member Posts: 5,194
    I don't get why it's bad that some foreign cars are designed overseas (although many are designed in the US), yet GM can design the Cruze or the G8 or the Spark or the Regal overseas and somehow that's ok. It's FAR more complex than just Buy a D3 brand and it's all American. Lots of other D3 cars made in Canada, too. And we aren't even talking about the longer term harm done by supporting noncompetitive companies that are failures. Why not want the US to have successful companies instead? Germany tried this - the eastern Trabants were state-supported junk, while the free market in the west made BMWs and MBs.

    I'm sure we all want the US to be successful, but please recognize that intelligent people can differ on what it takes to get there. IMHO your approach is simplistic and short term improvement for longer-term decline. I want longer-term ascendancy, and supporting junky products is NOT the way to get there. And it's long term strength that will REALLY create lasting jobs in this country.
  • lemkolemko Member Posts: 15,261
    edited October 2011
    Amen, brother! My wife was looking for bedsheets that were made in the U.S. and was unsuccessful even searching online. It's disgusting you can't even find bedsheets made in this country, even when you go to an upscale store like Bloomingdales. All the sheets sold there were made in India! Philadelphia was once known as the "Workshop of the World" where many diverse products from locomotives to Stetson hats were once made. About the only things now made in Philly these days are crack rocks and blunts.

    This is a city that once made fine Budd Silverliner railcars back in the 1960s that are still in service today. Budd is no longer in business in Philly, it's massive Hunting Park Avenue plant is a now a gigantic pigeon loft and its newer Northeast Philly plant was demolished and replaced by a golf course for corporate criminals. SEPTA, the regional bus and rail transportation authority, had to contract out to Hyundai-Rotem to replace some of its rolling stock. The Hyundai-Rotem people hired low-wage unqualified workers to build these new cars which are riddled with more defects than a 1985 Yugo.
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    Bad example, Sonic is actually a Korean design.

    GM acquired the pieces left from Daewoo and those guys are designing their small cars.

    I'm not sure, but isn't the Cruze also Korean designed?

    The Escape replacement, i.e. the Kuga, is a European design. Given how old the current design is, I don't think an American engineer has worked on that for a decade or so.

    We're in a global economy, that's just the way it is.
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    My wife was looking for bedsheets that were made in the U.S.

    Why does the USA have to make everything?

    I say specialize on the things you do best.

    If the US can make Product A best, and {insert favorite other country here} can make Product B best, then let each focus on that strength and then trade.

    I realize cars are not quite that simple, but GM has never done well at designing small cars. Vega? Chevette? Cavalier? Cobalt? No wonder they keep changing names.

    GM-DAT specializes in small cars, so let them do what they do best, and design a competitive small car, the Chevy Sonic.

    Spark? You guessed it, being designed in Korea also.
  • berriberri Member Posts: 10,165
    My approach remains go by the sticker domestic content. It's probably the easist and most reliable indicator a consumer has without significant research effort. That means a Camry or Accord is preferable to a Ford Fusion, but a Kia built in Georgia with 39% domestic is still an import in my book. Can't really go by parent corporate HQ profits because stock is held globally. Also, GM does similar volume overseas as in the US.

    I also have a question to ask, why do German cars get ignored compared to Asian vehicles when people argue buy American? Germany is no more an American ally than most Asian countries.
  • andre1969andre1969 Member Posts: 26,056
    I also have a question to ask, why do German cars get ignored compared to Asian vehicles when people argue buy American? Germany is no more an American ally than most Asian countries.

    My guess would be because the German cars aren't produced with cheap labor like an Asian car is (or, gasp, a Mexican-built car?)
  • tlongtlong Member Posts: 5,194
    My guess would be because the German cars aren't produced with cheap labor like an Asian car is (or, gasp, a Mexican-built car?)

    There are German makes produced in low cost countries. VW in China, Brazil, Mexico. Audi in Hungary. Just to name two.
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    You beat me to it...just look at the poor quality cars VW has dumped on the US market that were made in Mexico.

    I'd argue that's far worse. The reliable and durable cars actually raise the industry standard and make everyone better. Pressure from Japanese brands indeed made American cars better.

    Can't say the same for VWs built in Mexico.
  • lemkolemko Member Posts: 15,261
    The U.S. used to make just about everything and just about everything was well-made from clothes and textiles to military weapons systems. My Dad had to take a job at age 60 at Lowe's after losing his job of 24 years in a manufacturing plant. He once commented, "If everything in this store was made here, nobody would be out of work!"
  • tlongtlong Member Posts: 5,194
    edited October 2011
    The U.S. used to make just about everything and just about everything was well-made from clothes and textiles to military weapons systems.

    That was before transportation was much cheaper. Largely due to Boeing. Do we not want them to have sold airplanes all over the world as one of our biggest exporters? And it was before the internet. Do we not want Dell, Apple, IBM, Cisco to have been highly successful US companies in creating the information age?

    We lament what we lost, but not what we gained. It's not so simplistic that we could have preserved the old-style manufacturing situation WITHOUT other losses or lack of opportunities we eventually did gain. The economy is always a moving target.

    We lost a TON of farmers over the years due to mechanization when compared to the 1800's. We don't seem to lament that. Perhaps because those who remember it are now gone. We aren't lamenting the availability of produce -- almost 12 mos/year-- due to South American fruits and vegges - something we didn't have when the US made everything. And overseas oil - in the old days, the US used only its OWN oil. Why are we still driving 15mpg tanks, yet using foreign oil? Isn't that terrible?

    We seem to want our cake and eat it too. Is that very realistic?
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    just about everything was well-made

    Our Vega certainly proved otherwise. One time the door fell off.

    Do I feel sorry for the UAW guy who fastened that door? No.

    When it comes to cars, pressure from imports certainly made American cars better. We would not have seen as much improvement if we only had the Big Three.

    Vega had the Pinto an as excuse. It was the less bad one, so why bother improving it?

    Small cars became competent when the Big Three had to compete with the imports from Japan.

    Look at the Cruze Eco today - 42mpg, direct injection, 87 octane for a turbo, decent interior, good space efficiency, 138hp from just 1.4 liters of displacement. Wow!

    Would the Vega ever have evolved into such a competent small car today? Heck no!

    Competition improves the breed, plain and simple.

    Now, having said that, you don't just open the doors wide and let anybody in. Make 'em play by the rules, and if they use underpaid labor overseas, without health insurance, then tax those imports at a higher rate to keep them out (if you're thinking China, so am I).

    The Japanese have been playing by the rules. "Build them here", Iacocca said. Fine, they did. Not only are the Camry and Accord made here, they are unique from the JDM models and actually designed in the USA.

    Wisely, they've avoided the UAW and most of those employees have been able to avoid layoffs at age 60.
  • coontie66coontie66 Member Posts: 110
    This whole issue of jobs has been obvious to me for 15 years as all of the mills left the South for China and India.

    Our country will never have adequate number of jobs again as long as we buy all that STUFF from China.

    In the past 15 years I heard just one President even mention this issue and it was Obamma in his debates 3 years ago. Then he did nothing.

    I told my wife 12 years ago that issue would some day be a key issue in a Presidential election. Maybe this year!

    I still have not heard anyone mention the issue of lost jobs in this country this year other than in the normal political BS. A world wide FREE Market sure sounds good until you drive around the South and look at all the closed factories that now grow pigeons.
  • dieselonedieselone Member Posts: 5,729
    I still have not heard anyone mention the issue of lost jobs in this country this year other than in the normal political BS. A world wide FREE Market sure sounds good until you drive around the South and look at all the closed factories that now grow pigeons.

    It's not just China. Productivity is a huge part of it. The steel mill my FIL retired from produces more tonnage of steel with less than half the number of employees from 30 years ago. When LTV went bankrupt in 2000 my FIL had 30 years of service and was still near the bottom of the seniority list in his department.
  • imidazol97imidazol97 Member Posts: 27,700
    edited November 2011
    >they've avoided the UAW and most of those employees have been able to avoid layoffs

    Employees? There were stories that something on the order of 40% of Georgetown toyota employees were part timers. So does that mean most of those weren't laid off as things slowed down in toyotaville? Or just the 60% who were full time?

    I can understand not wanting the flagrant work rules of the UAW. Reason is obvious. But then there are abuses by management in firing people just for convenience and expense reasons. The sword cuts both ways.

    Actually, that is the position GM needs to be in rather than with the albatross of UAW around their neck from the Obama bailout union preservation program.

    2014 Malibu 2LT, 2015 Cruze 2LT,

  • steverstever Guest Posts: 52,454
    edited November 2011
    I remember the old textile mill buildings in the South; they were dying off when I was a kid.

    The mills got cranked up in the US in the early 1800s. Start up was difficult because England had the textile business and they passed a law in 1765 prohibiting export of textile machinery. Being a third world country at the time, the US was able to take over the industry anyway, and at first the labor force was just about all child labor. (clemson.edu)

    All that seems familiar eh? Nothing new under the sun. Once the standard of living in China and India rises, those countries will be looking over their shoulder at Africa as that continent takes over their industrial jobs with cheaper labor and production costs.
  • imidazol97imidazol97 Member Posts: 27,700
    > Nothing new under the sun. Once the standard of living in China and India rises, those countries will be looking over their shoulder at Africa, taking their industrial jobs with cheaper labor and production costs.

    Interesting point in a good post. Those who don't learn from history are doomed to repeat it (was that an Abraham Lincoln quote like those others? ;) ).

    2014 Malibu 2LT, 2015 Cruze 2LT,

  • steverstever Guest Posts: 52,454
    Abe, yeah, the fat guy with the John Lennon glasses.

    So, why is Germany's industrial base apparently thriving? Smaller, more manageable country? "Free" health care? Longer union/management history? Better schools, better engineers, better training for the trades?

    Detroit's only saving grace at this point is that it's a lot cheaper to ship clothing around the world than cars.
  • lemkolemko Member Posts: 15,261
    Heck, I don't even have to leave my city to see hundreds of abandoned factories that now breed nothing but pigeons, crackheads, junkies, etc. This is just a short list of all the things that were once manufactured in Philadelphia not all that long ago:

    Budd railcars
    Baldwin locomotives
    Botany 500 suits
    Breyer's ice cream
    Philco appliances
    Fleer bubblegum
    Flexible Flyer sleds
    Dodge steel castings
    Stetson hats
    General Electric industrial electrical equipment
    Quaker lace
    Goldtex apparel
    Marcus-Pincus menswear
    Bill Blass formalwear
    Bachmann plastic products

    Nearby Camden, NJ was once home to a huge RCA plant.
    Chester, PA had Sun Ship and a huge Ford plant.
    North of Philadelphia, United States Steel had the massive Fairless Works.
  • steverstever Guest Posts: 52,454
    edited November 2011
    Meanwhile, Toyota is making Siennas in Indiana.

    And shipping them to South Korea.

    "Korea makes the nineteenth country to which Toyota exports U.S.-made models."

    South Korea To Get U.S.-Made Toyota Minivans (AutoObserver)

    Gets a bit mind-bending. Maybe it's not the US that's the problem, it's Philly. :)
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    The plant in Georgetown, KY has kept busy, AFAIK.

    North American production didn't slow down nearly as much as Japan, and now Thailand.
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    edited November 2011
    Once the standard of living in China and India rises

    Good point. I've read of many strikes and labor disputes.

    Japanese brands didn't have the pension and health care costs of the UAW-affected Big Three. The 2nd OPEC oil crisis is what really gave them a segue, though. Big Three didn't have good small cars, and small cars were the *only* thing the Japanese had at the time.

    Now the Koreans have officially arrived in a big way, and their cost structure is lower than Japan's. Back at ya. Korea has been stealing Japanese market share in a big way. Toyota's and Honda's losses have mostly ended up in Hyundai/Kia gains. Check the numbers, they coincide.

    Next China, then India. Then who? Who knows.

    I just don't get why China gets most favored trading nation status. As if they need that help.
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    why is Germany's industrial base apparently thriving?

    I think they've carved out a premium niche for themselves, ably exlpoiting both old money luxury themes as well as Nurburgring-inspired heritage.

    They had to fight, though, when Lexus arrived suddenly things like quality mattered. The Germans had to (and did) respond.
Sign In or Register to comment.

Your Privacy

By accessing this website, you acknowledge that Edmunds and its third party business partners may use cookies, pixels, and similar technologies to collect information about you and your interactions with the website as described in our Privacy Statement, and you agree that your use of the website is subject to our Visitor Agreement.