By accessing this website, you acknowledge that Edmunds and its third party business partners may use cookies, pixels, and similar technologies to collect information about you and your interactions with the website as described in our
Privacy Statement, and you agree that your use of the website is subject to our
Visitor Agreement.
Comments
I expect our Florida members, abacomike, sandman, and others are in the same situation, no ice shield.
About 5 years back, I had a storage building built in my back yard. The crew doing the install were real go-getters, finishing the job in about 5 hours total. They used nail guns, of course, and overdid the nailing. Which hurt absolutely nothing as far as I can tell. My only complaint was the really cheap roofing shingles, which only lasted about 2 years.
And the crew which just did the roof next doors definitely used nail guns. They were very quick and efficient, only took a little over one day for the entire job, including cleanup.
Also - if you can see the metal flashing in the valleys after they are done, they didn't do it right - even by todays standards.
Jmonroe is right as usual. Why would anyone want to hand nail shingles?
2025 Forester Limited, 2024 Subaru Legacy Sport
I never heard of shingles that only lasted 2 years. In my hood every one seams to use the Owens Corning architectural product not the cheapo brand that @driver100 is getting that is hand nailed.
As for roofs in Florida, they don’t use asphalt products down there if they want the roof to last. Tile is the only way to go down there and Arizona too.
jmonroe
'18 Legacy Limited with 3.6R (Mrs. j's)
That’s exactly what it is and any roofer today that installs a roof where you get snow and says you don’t need the ice shield product because tar paper is just as good should be avoided. Tar paper is OK where you don’t have freeze and thaw conditions but where have those conditions you BETTER use the ice shield product.
As for hand nailing shingles I can’t believe a roofer would prefer hand nailing to using a pneumatic nailer. Talk about work for the sake of work that would be it. When I had my roof replaced 2 years ago I joked with a few of the installers about cheating because they used pneumatic nailers vs. hand nailing and there response was, “those days are LONG GONE”. One even said he’d quit if he had to hand nail shingles today and I don’t blame him. That would be akin to a house framer today not using a pneumatic framing nailer. Hell, I wouldn’t even attempt helping my son do flipping if we didn’t have an assortment of pneumatic nailers both framing and trim. Yep, those days are LONG GONE.
jmonroe
Some people say air nailing and hand nailing are the same. They aren't and there are several reasons why hand nailing is preferred if the guy installing has the experience and does it properly. Almost anyone can use an air nailer, but only a skilled craftsman is going to do hand nailing, and he can hit the right spot, and nail it to perfection....not overdoing it or under doing it. If you read the article you will see why hand nailing is better....and I will list only a few reasons in case you want the short version.
https://www.billraganroofing.com/blog/hand-nailing-vs-air-gun-which-is-best
*Warranty will be voided if the nails aren't put in properly. More misses with an air gun. A person using an air gun can certainly place the nail correctly, but finding a company with a history of high-quality installation with air guns can be hard.
*The key difference between the two is accuracy. A good nailer puts the nail in the right position, and will put the nail in at the right level....not too far and not far enough. That is a big reason a for failed roof job.
*It's very uncommon to have nails that have been over-driven when hand nailing simply because they don't have the pressure from the compressor like the air guns do.
*Air pressure is regulated by an air compressor which remains on the ground. The pressure has to be changed depending on where the work is being done....most roofers won't want to keep changing the pressure.
*An air gun crew will nail a shingle on in a split second with little to no care of their nail placements, sacrificing quality for speed. More than 60% of all roof repairs are due to shingles being improperly air nailed on
*The biggest mistake with nailing is not putting a nail in far enough and the shingle will get blown up and away....and the manufacturer won't warranty a shingle not nailed properly.
Hand nailing is like driving....you have the feel of the nail....better chance of placing it properly and hammering it to the right depth.
2017 MB E400 , 2015 MB GLK350, 2014 MB C250
I never heard of shingles that only lasted 2 years. In my hood every one seams to use the Owens Corning architectural product not the cheapo brand that @driver100 is getting that is hand nailed.
As for roofs in Florida, they don’t use asphalt products down there if they want the roof to last. Tile is the only way to go down there and Arizona too.
jmonroe
=============end quoted material===================
Owens Corning is the primary brand around here as well. That is what I purchased at Home Depot when I replaced the roof on that shed. Well, I didn't do the work personally. I purchased the shingles, and paid a handyman $250 to do the actual work.
Why don't they use asphalt shingles in Florida? To the best of my knowledge, it isn't really much hotter or more intense sunshine in Florida compared to where I am in Texas. And tile roofs are pretty rare in these parts. With that said, Tile Roofs Of Texas (possibly the biggest tile roof installer in Houston) is located about 4 blocks from my house.
I knew you’d find something on the internet to support why hand nailing is best. If you want to believe that go for it.
FWIW, air compressors have regulators to maintain the pressure so you don’t have to climb down to the ground constantly to adjust the air pressure like your link would have us believe. Keep going to the internet for support if that makes you feel good. I’ll go with real world experience any day rather than book learning for everything.
jmonroe
'18 Legacy Limited with 3.6R (Mrs. j's)
To answer your question about asphalt roofs in Florida it has to be because of the intense heat from the sun. I don’t know how intense the heat is from the sun in Houston but it must not be equal to Florida otherwise you’d probably see more tile roofs in Houston.
What I have noticed from my many trips to South Florida is the only homes that have asphalt roofs are mobile homes and what appears to be inexpensive stand alone homes where if they installed a tile roof it would cost more than the house itself and I’m not exaggerating when I say that so of course they don’t go the tile route on those houses.
jmonroe
'18 Legacy Limited with 3.6R (Mrs. j's)
To answer your question about asphalt roofs in Florida it has to be because of the intense heat from the sun. I don’t know how intense the heat is from the sun in Houston but it must not be equal to Florida otherwise you’d probably see more tile roofs in Houston.
What I have noticed from my many trips to South Florida is the only homes that have asphalt roofs are mobile homes and what appears to be inexpensive stand alone homes where if they installed a tile roof it would cost more than the house itself and I’m not exaggerating when I say that so of course they don’t go the tile route on those houses.
jmonroe
We have asphalt shingles on our Florida home as do many other homes....probably most homes. They may not be the best but there is nothing wrong with them....they are the least expensive but worth it. If you want protection for 130 mph winds and longer life but for a much higher price go with Corning....probably a better buy if you are under 40 years old.
As far as my research I guess it is just a conspiracy theory that the old fashioned craftsman say hand hammering gives better results than an air gun that anyone can use......but then again there are people appreciate a car with great engineering, attention to details and true craftsmanship etc., and then there are people who settle for the wannabe....and think it is just as good.
2017 MB E400 , 2015 MB GLK350, 2014 MB C250
To answer your question about asphalt roofs in Florida it has to be because of the intense heat from the sun. I don’t know how intense the heat is from the sun in Houston but it must not be equal to Florida otherwise you’d probably see more tile roofs in Houston.
What I have noticed from my many trips to South Florida is the only homes that have asphalt roofs are mobile homes and what appears to be inexpensive stand alone homes where if they installed a tile roof it would cost more than the house itself and I’m not exaggerating when I say that so of course they don’t go the tile route on those houses.
jmonroe
You are falling into the trap.
2025 Forester Limited, 2024 Subaru Legacy Sport
More like the rabbit hole:
Shingle roofing materials. By far, the most common type of roof material used in South Florida is the standard three-tab asphalt shingle. This is a very affordable option for most homeowners.
https://www.wflx.com/story/13876467/most-common-roof-types/
2017 MB E400 , 2015 MB GLK350, 2014 MB C250
I looked up "trap" on the internet and saw a mouse in one. I better not go researching there again. Might ruin another day.
jmonroe
'18 Legacy Limited with 3.6R (Mrs. j's)
I looked up trap and found this;

2011 Hyundai Sonata, 2014 BMW 428i convertible, 2015 Honda CTX700D
Houston is about the same latitude as St Augustine. Sea breeze influences will limit the temperatures in much of Florida, but even down to Orlando it can get at least as hot as Houston.
And the microphone for the bluetooth is installed, tested and working well. Which leaves only the backup camera to install. I was originally thinking I would just keep this as basic truck, a work truck. I am going to leave the steel wheels alone, they're plenty good enough for a work truck. But I decided I really needed bluetooth and a backup camera as basic safety features, so I threw in SiriusXM while I was at it.
2017 MB E400 , 2015 MB GLK350, 2014 MB C250
During the months of June-October roofs here in south Florida have to sustain air temperatures in the mid 90’s and surface temperatures exposed to direct sunlight in the 110-150+ degree range at least 8 hours every day with evening temperatures in the 80’s. That is why clay and composite roof tiles are the preferred shingles for single family homes and townhomes or duplexes. Asphalt and other pliable nailed shingles do not tend to last as long due to the extreme surface temperatures.
When I lived in Palm Desert CA, I do not remember seeing asphalt or other pliable roof shingles on homes - just clay and composite roof shingles (masonry). Again, due to the extreme temperatures in the 105-120+ degree range and significantly higher temperatures on surfaces in direct sunlight.
Masonry roofs are much more costly than other shingled roofs which is why we are seeing more asphalt type shingles being used. But in the long run masonry roofs are the preferred roof shingles in this climate.
2024 Genesis G90 Super-Charger
I wonder if I was exposed to kryptonite.
2019 Kia Soul+, 2015 Mustang GT, 2013 Ford F-150, 2000 Chrysler Sebring convertible
2017 Cadillac ATS Performance Premium 3.6
2020 Acura RDX tech SH-AWD, 2023 Maverick hybrid Lariat luxury package.
I have a neighbor who was fixing his eves troughs when he was in his late 60s. He fell off the ladder....from the 2nd story and he has had to use a walker ever since...about 10 years now. You can't take that moment of foolishness back.........be safe.
2017 MB E400 , 2015 MB GLK350, 2014 MB C250
2017 MB E400 , 2015 MB GLK350, 2014 MB C250
The masonry roofs are much heavier and work best when heavy-duty rafters and concrete or concrete block walls are employed for adequate strength. In heavy winds such as those produced by hurricanes, masonry roofs tend to withstand the winds better. It’s the soft-shingled roofs that sustain the most damage.
My brother’s house is all masonry shingles and concrete block walls and heavy-duty wood rafters. The newer houses being built in his development are not constructed with concrete block walls - they use wood instead which does not afford the same protection during hurricanes.
2024 Genesis G90 Super-Charger
I Got A Guy Automotive
5.0
36 Google reviews
Auto repair shop in Escondido, California
Address: 1210 Industrial Ave, Escondido, CA 92029
Speaking of the "guy" I hired one today to do a full detail on the red S4 at 1:30 PST. I've used him before and he does a good job using old fashioned good ol' wax instead of the new techie stuff people use today.
Price went up about $20 since pre-COVID. I'll post pics of the $140 full detail job later. '
It took a while to book this "guy" so that's a good sign that he's being kept busy.
Perfect for everyone here? OK if you say so, I'm a 30 hour drive away so I'm not sure how perfect it is for me.
2011 Hyundai Sonata, 2014 BMW 428i convertible, 2015 Honda CTX700D
2017 Cadillac ATS Performance Premium 3.6
Perfect for everyone here? OK if you say so, I'm a 30 hour drive away so I'm not sure how perfect it is for me.
Escondido has some very fine restaurants to make it worth your while. Plus, check out the 5.0 Google review rating. Google never lies.
And yes my life is boring enough that I watch videos of a guy building garages in Vermont. At least I learn a lot!
2020 Acura RDX tech SH-AWD, 2023 Maverick hybrid Lariat luxury package.
2017 MB E400 , 2015 MB GLK350, 2014 MB C250
2017 MB E400 , 2015 MB GLK350, 2014 MB C250
We have some very fine restaurants here too. So I can save myself a lot of time by staying local.
2011 Hyundai Sonata, 2014 BMW 428i convertible, 2015 Honda CTX700D
We have some very fine restaurants here too. So I can save myself a lot of time by staying local.
Stone Brewing is located in Escondido. They have an amazing restaurant and grounds.
Wouldn't drive 30 hours for it, though....
Edmunds Price Checker
Edmunds Lease Calculator
Did you get a good deal? Be sure to come back and share!
Edmunds Moderator
Unfortunately, it seems that almost no insurance will cover a prescription for Cialis. And without insurance, a 3-month supply is $791. Looking around, I found a site in India which sells these drugs by mail. I was able to purchase 120 pills, 20 mg, for $197. That included shipping from India and an international money transfer fee. The most common daily dose of Cialis is 5 mg, which was what my cardiologist prescribed. Taking the one hundred twenty 20 mg pills, cutting them twice with a pill cutter, gives me 480 daily doses of 5 mg each.
My apologies if this breaks any rules, or offends anyone. My intent was to help anyone in a similar situation.
One of the biggest complaints of "Socialized Medicine" is wait times. The wait times for many specialists or procedures cam be years. One thing is they have to keep costs down and that mean rationing health care. Sure we pay more for Healthcare but we have nowhere near the wait times that some countries have.
2011 Hyundai Sonata, 2014 BMW 428i convertible, 2015 Honda CTX700D
Wouldn't drive 30 hours for it, though....
I'd go if it was only 30 hours driving time but for me it would be 38 hours....just over my limit.
2017 MB E400 , 2015 MB GLK350, 2014 MB C250
Check your PM.
2011 Hyundai Sonata, 2014 BMW 428i convertible, 2015 Honda CTX700D
Sounds like back peddling to me.
jmonroe
'18 Legacy Limited with 3.6R (Mrs. j's)
Sounds like back peddling to me.
jmonroe
Not really, just sane and rational. The mistake was in taking sides and making it into a big deal. I am saying both methods, hand or air hammering get good results, from what I have heard and read a good hand nailer has to have better skills.....real skills so I would say he is going to do a better more refined job.....but, the air hammer guy if he is good can come close....and it isn't a big enough factor to insist on hand hammer....but if I have a choice I would choose Hand over Air.
At least I take the sane rational approach instead of being pig headed
2017 MB E400 , 2015 MB GLK350, 2014 MB C250
NO, NO, NO, I’m not inclined.
jmonroe
'18 Legacy Limited with 3.6R (Mrs. j's)
I’m surprised that any roofer that chooses to hand nail shingles doesn’t like throwing a third of a square of shingles on his back and hiking up the ladder to the roof. He must not be as old schooled as he pretends.
jmonroe
'18 Legacy Limited with 3.6R (Mrs. j's)
@henryn
Methinks you mean Prostate, unless you are laying flat on the ground face down as a sign of reverence.
I’m trying to send as many cases to felony mediation that I can; I’d rather spend several hours in a mediation than several days at trial. Still, some victims can be so unreasonable. I have one case that the defense attorney wants to mediate because his client thinks he’s going to skate on the charges. The attorney thinks his client needs to hear a retired judge tell him that there’s a good chance he’s going to spend 20+ years in the pen. My victim refuses to mediate- “I WANT TO GO TO TRIAL!!!” is what she screamed at my assistant. I’m afraid that she isn’t going to come across as a very sympathetic witness, but if she wants to go to trial I won’t have much choice. In theory I can work the case out however I want but in reality my judge won’t accept a plea unless law enforcement and/or the vic are onboard with it. So I’ll just go to trial and if she’s unhappy with the outcome it’s on her.
Mine: 1995 318ti Club Sport-2020 C43-1996 Speed Triple Challenge Cup Replica
Wife's: 2021 Sahara 4xe
Son's: 2018 330i xDrive
I’m surprised that any roofer that chooses to hand nail shingles doesn’t like throwing a third of a square of shingles on his back and hiking up the ladder to the roof. He must not be as old schooled as he pretends.
jmonroe
Why waste energy and talent on lugging shingles up to the roof when you can have them conveyer belted up to the roof....where the hired help can unload them and the hand nail Guy can be in top form to do his magic?
2017 MB E400 , 2015 MB GLK350, 2014 MB C250
I’d bet it isn’t so much the hammer that makes a difference, rather that only a real old school expert would be doing it.
Putting on lug nuts with an impact wrench is the same concept.
2020 Acura RDX tech SH-AWD, 2023 Maverick hybrid Lariat luxury package.
I’m always amazed how fast a crew can rip through an install. And that I’ve yet to see anyone fall off. And almost never is any safety gear used.
2020 Acura RDX tech SH-AWD, 2023 Maverick hybrid Lariat luxury package.