Did you recently take on (or consider) a loan of 84 months or longer on a car purchase?
A reporter would like to speak with you about your experience; please reach out to PR@Edmunds.com by 7/22 for details.
Options

CR-V vs Escape

1106107109111112167

Comments

  • scape2scape2 Member Posts: 4,123
    This CRV fire issues is all over other chat rooms around the net. I will use a line Honda folks used when the Escape was having its recall/stalling issues... "I wonder how many people have fires in thier CRV's that don't get reported to the NHSTA"? The fact is there is an issue. The Honda ranks are trying like mad to stamp this out, make it go away. Ford had a problem, and issued recalls. Honda won't it is against their beliefs and they will try and try to hope it goes away. The internet will not let it go away...
  • baggs32baggs32 Member Posts: 3,229
    Since points need to be spelled out here. Mine was that no vehicle is perfect. When you buy that perfect, zero defect vehicle feel free to criticize others. I don't think the Escape qualifies.

    Neither does the CR-V (Combustible Recreational Vehicle for those of you just tuning in :) ). Sure does make starting a camp fire easy though!

    My Mazda6 has had zero problems or recalls. Does that qualify as perfect to you? Can I criticize now too?

    Oh wait, CR, JD, IC, etc. didn't give it all of their awards so I guess it must be junk. But it's my junk and it puts a big fat smile on my face EVERY SINGLE DAY. The Escape does the same thing for my wife and that my friend, is all she wrote. ;)
  • varmintvarmint Member Posts: 6,326
    "If Honda is all about safety then why does the new Element rank so terribly in crash tests?" - Scape2

    Define "terribly".

    It does better than a similarly equipped Escape. If the Element is terrible, what word describes the Escape?
  • kizhekizhe Member Posts: 242
    1. How much is motor oil capacity of 6 cyl engine?
    2. What is the recommended regular/severe schedule for filter/oil change? 3K? or 5K?
    3. How much oil do you usually add BETWEEN oil changes?
    Thank you.
  • baggs32baggs32 Member Posts: 3,229
    1. 6 quarts with the filter

    2. 3K

    3. None. Sometimes it could take about a half quart near the 3k mark but not often.
  • snowmansnowman Member Posts: 540
    I don't remember hearing this around June. THis must be one of those that runs under the rug...

    Make : HONDA Model : CR-V Year : 2004
    NHTSA CAMPAIGN ID Number : 04V255000 Recall Date : JUN 02, 2004
    Component: AIR BAGS:FRONTAL
    Potential Number Of Units Affected : 130617
    Summary: ON CERTAIN SPORT UTILITY VEHICLES, THE WIRE HARNESS OF THE DRIVER'S FRONT AIR BAG WAS INCORRECTLY WIRED.
    Consequence: IN THE EVENT OF A CRASH, THE AIR BAG INFLATION RATE WOULD BE INCORRECT, WHICH COULD INCREASE THE RISK OF INJURY TO THE DRIVER.
    Remedy: DEALERS WILL REPAIR THE WIRING. OWNER NOTIFICATION BEGAN ON JULY 6, 2004. OWNERS SHOULD CONTACT HONDA AT 1-800-999-1009.
    Notes: HONDA RECALL NO. P34. CUSTOMERS CAN ALSO CONTACT THE NATIONAL HIGHWAY TRAFFIC SAFETY ADMINISTRATION’S AUTO SAFETY HOTLINE AT 1-888-DASH-2-DOT (1-888-327-4236).
  • bshelbshel Member Posts: 232
    that one has been around for a while, with a good amount of discussion. Affects some vin's from the UK plant. Do a search and you'll find more.
  • scape2scape2 Member Posts: 4,123
    I was ready to link you to www.crashtest.com and its results for the Elements crashtest. However, it has changed??? I remember when the Element was first introduced its crash rating was terrible.. I wonder how it changed..
  • scape2scape2 Member Posts: 4,123
    CRV= Combustable Recreational Vehicle!! this is a good one...

    Baggs, you are wrong on the oil amount.

    IT is 5.5 quarts with filter for the 3.0 Duratec V6 in the Escape. Check your handbook. Please, do not overfill your oil, it will cause you problems. I change my oil about every 3-4K miles. After 47,000 miles I have never had to add any oil between changes.
  • baggs32baggs32 Member Posts: 3,229
    Baggs, you are wrong on the oil amount.

    Nope. The old one's require 5.5 quarts. The '05s require 6 now. It's all in the manuals.
  • varmintvarmint Member Posts: 6,326
    Scape2 - The only bad rating for the Element was for the IIHS side impact crash. The vehicle was tested without side airbags and the crash results were poor. (Same for the Escape.)

    The frontal crash tests have always been five star from the NHTSA and "Good" from the IIHS.

    Perhaps you were thinking of the 1996-2001 CR-V? That vehicle scored 5 and 4 in the NHTSA and only "Marginal" in the IIHS test.
  • snowmansnowman Member Posts: 540
    Bags is wright, my manual and engine compartment sticker says 6 QT as well...
  • scape2scape2 Member Posts: 4,123
    What year of Escape do you have? Mine is an 01 and my handbook says 5.5 quarts for the 3.0 Duratec engine..
  • baggs32baggs32 Member Posts: 3,229
    Our former '02 took 5.5 quarts as well. The new '05 takes 6 quarts for some reason. Ford must have added something or made something bigger in there to require the extra oil.

    Supposedly all '05 Escapes have an oil cooler now. Maybe they improved upon that same part from the one that was bolted on to the older models, with the tow pkg., and somehow it requires the extra .5 quarts of oil.

    All I know is that my dealer filled it with 6 quarts, because I let them do the first oil change, and so will I when I start doing them myself. The manual says to do so.
  • drive62drive62 Member Posts: 637
    An '01 Escape huh. Better not get into a frontal crash.

    Engine fires on a miniscule percentage of CR-Vs seems to get you excited to the point that oyu go to threads for a vehicle you don't own to tell the rold about the conspiracy, etc.

    How about a buckling A-Pillar on EVERY '01 Escape sold? How come you don't go screaming like Chicken Little about that one.

    Is it because you own the vehicle as opposed to the CR-V which you don't own? Seems to me someone likes to spread untruths about one vehicle and when someone else posts documented findings about their vehicle they are (to use someone's favorite expression) swept under the rug.

    To use another of someone's favorite sayings. It's all over the internet. The early Ford Escapes have safety issues. Both structurally and mechanically.

    People in glass houses...
  • drive62drive62 Member Posts: 637
    Don't have to try to make the '01 Escape unsafe. The NHTSA already did.

    So all SUV's tip? The article didn't mention any others tipping to the point that they won't recommend the vehicle. But they found that with Escape. As for what magazine? Do you not read posts before you respond? Or do you just choose to ignore what is written? The magazine was listed.

    But of course the NHTSA and the magazine are wrong and you are right.
  • scape2scape2 Member Posts: 4,123
    Once again spreading fear and garbage about Ford Escapes. The 01 is not "unsafe" I have a 5 star safety rating in all categores but one. The passenger side gets a 4 star. Yes, I am aware of all the crashtest for the 01 Escape. Your post 5536 says "A magazine article.." You do not give a magazine name nor month of publication.
    Now lets talk about the rear tailgate of the CRV and its horrific crash issues. How about flying chunks of glass from a shattering tailgate window? or the huge repair bill on the 5mph rear bumper crashtests??
    Drive62, the fire issues on the CRV are REAL. They are all over the net and I see new issues by the day. You are one of those that want it to just go away. You intimidate anyone that enters the CRV fire issues board. You hope these people will just go away. I am surprised that you think it is ok for a car company to hide its defects just because it has a silver "H" on the hood. CRV has a problem and you want to hide it..
  • tidestertidester Member Posts: 10,059
    Let's all take a deep breath and proceed without attempting to characterize others' posting in personal terms. :-)

    tidester, host
  • drive62drive62 Member Posts: 637
    If it's "all over the net" why do people need to be informed? Many vehicles have problems. So how come someone doesn't post on EVERY thread related to those vehicles?

    As for intimidation. LOL. I post occasionally, even saying that other years of the CR-V should be looked at but I'm the ultimate Honda supporter?

    And also you are wrong about the Escape. A buckling A-pillar does not make a vehicle safe. I'm not sure which is a bigger issue though. A potential fire from a poorly done oil change or a vehicle's passenger cabin being compromised in a frontal crash?
  • scape2scape2 Member Posts: 4,123
    In your mind the CRV fires are due to improper oil changes. However, why doesn't this happen on Accords and Civics? I have asked you this and you fail to answer.
    Try as you will to make the Escape look unsafe the NHSTA still rates the 01 Escape as 5 star in every category but 1. Even here at Edmunds it is rated just fine.
    Kind of funny how when the shoe is on the other foot. Now the CRV is having issues you come out swinging. I cannot understand why someone would defend a car company that is trying its best to hide a serious issue. At least Ford did a recall for the stalling issue and FIXED it..
  • scape2scape2 Member Posts: 4,123
    These recalls for the CRV never make the news or newspapers??
    Here is another one I found out on the net. Honda is doing a great job at hiding these and keeping these quiet.
    NHSTA campain # 04v25t000, Jun of 02. 130,617 CRV's affected for air bag issues..
  • mikefm58mikefm58 Member Posts: 2,882
    << Honda is doing a great job at hiding these and keeping these quiet. >>

    And why is it that, in your view, only Honda can do a great job keeping them quiet. Come on scape2, recalls are public info. If the news media wants to report it, it's their choice.
  • snowmansnowman Member Posts: 540
    If GM, DC or Ford issues a recall, it is all over the press and tv, if Honda issues a recall, I don't see a bit of it on TV or press, as in that airbag recall...
    go figure
  • drive62drive62 Member Posts: 637
    The belief in a great Honda conspiracy of keeping things secret seems to be catching. Or is that called paranoia? And apparently now the media is also in on it. LOL.

    Not sure what newspaper someone reads (but I do know their comprehension skills) but my newspaper (one of the largest in the country) lists current recalls every week.

    Do specific newspaper articles really need to be written about every recall? Owners are informed. That seems sufficient.
  • bshelbshel Member Posts: 232
    That airbag recall was in the news immediately. And owners were advised when they would be receiving notices. Also, information on what to look for as in which VIN numbers that may have been included in the recall.
  • scape2scape2 Member Posts: 4,123
    THANK-YOU!! I am not the only one seeing a pattern here. If Ford/GM or Dodge issues a recall I read it in my paper, here it on the radio, see it on the news... I have yet to even read one recall notice in the paper on ANY Honda vehicles. There have been plenty of issues with Honda over the last 2 years. Civic, Accord, Oddessy have all had recalls, yet the only place I here of them is here at Edmunds or on another car/truck chat room on the Internet.
  • scape2scape2 Member Posts: 4,123
    No owner informed is NOT sufficient. Because the media and folks as yourself believe Honda vehicles are the most reliable and best built in the world. Get it? I am reaching 50,000 trouble free miles on my 01 Ford Escape. Mind you, its an 01. The dreaded year of "all these recalls" that were a constant thorn in Fords side. I have had no problems whatsoever, yet you feel the CRV is still more reliable and better built. Why? because you never here of any TSB's or other recalls for the CRV. Honda hides information, its porven.
  • suvtimesuvtime Member Posts: 58
    If Honda is trying to hide recalls and problems with their vehicles from the media their not doing a very good job of it. I've see reports in Canadian newspapers about CR-V recalls concerning the possibility of it slipping out of gear when in park as well as the fire issue. I've also seen news reports on TV about the fire issue.

    Scape just because you haven't heard or seen it in the media doesn't mean it wasn't reported. Your theory proves nothing.
  • mikefm58mikefm58 Member Posts: 2,882
    Scape2 and snowman you sound like paranoid schizophrenics (sp?). You honestly believe the media is out to get the big 2.5 and keep Honda squeekly clean?

    Scape2, you're '01 Escape has been trouble free, I'm happy for you. But you and snowman really need to get off your soapbox.
  • snowmansnowman Member Posts: 540
    Mike, may be you need to get off your soap box huh?!
    I am just passing my observations, whether you like/believe it or not. Giving a news on a prime page is different than giving it on a side column.

    And you are very naive not to think that big corporations manages what media publish (or may be don't know how corrupt capitalistic system works). The biggest income source for media is the ads that they get...

    And honestly, I don't give a rat @#$ what is going on with Honda and it's products...
  • mikefm58mikefm58 Member Posts: 2,882
    < Mike, may be you need to get off your soap box huh?! >

    I'm not on any soapbox, though I know you believe I am solely because I own a Honda. Unlike you, I don't have an agenda here. You're mission seems to be to pop the suppossed (according to you) Honda quality bubble.

    < And you are very naive not to think that big corporations manages what media publish (or may be don't know how corrupt capitalistic system works). The biggest income source for media is the ads that they get >

    I've worked for large corporations all my life so I know how these things work. My take is all auto manuf. are large corporations with as much influence as each other on the media. Your take is that there is a Honda conspiracy theory going on.

    < And honestly, I don't give a rat @#$ what is going on with Honda and it's products... >

    Good. Then why are you wasting your time posting. I care about Honda products, as well as Toyota, Ford, GM, Harley's, Dodge, etc. All are fine companies.
  • tidestertidester Member Posts: 10,059
    Let's all get off our soapboxes and onto CR-V and Escape.

    tidester, host
  • snowmansnowman Member Posts: 540
    Unlike you, I don't have an agenda"
    Oh really, then tell me what my agenda is, huh?
    Honda quality is down the drain already, look at problem forums. You&#146;ll see many complaints about almost every make and model of Honda…
    So you don&#146;t need me to burst so called &#147;the quality&#148; bubble…

    "Good. Then why are you wasting your time posting."
    Besides of the point that I post wherever I like to post …
    I am here to respond CRV crowd&#146;s baseless allegations against Escape. You CRV guys having extreme problem to accept the fact that Escape is much better vehicle than CRV.
  • snowmansnowman Member Posts: 540
    Slipping out of gear in park...
    Engine fire...
    Vehicle pulls right...
    Airbag Recall....

    Must be nice to have a "Honda quality" ...

    No further comments...
  • baggs32baggs32 Member Posts: 3,229
    http://automobiles.honda.com/images/banners/2005/cr-v/exterior_ga- - llery/large11.jpg

    Have fun cleaning those!

    Not very sporty either IMOH. They look like they belong on a Mercury.
  • mikefm58mikefm58 Member Posts: 2,882
    LOL at snowman....

    < Oh really, then tell me what my agenda is, huh?>

    I did that in my last post. Go read it again.

    < Must be nice to have a "Honda quality" ... >

    As bad as some of the Honda bigots are here (we both agree on that), you are just as bad as they are. But you just don't see it!!

    Enough said, sorry Host.
  • varmintvarmint Member Posts: 6,326
    "Not very sporty either IMOH. They look like they belong on a Mercury."

    Isn't Mercury supposed to be a step up from Ford?
  • suvtimesuvtime Member Posts: 58
    It would seem you know a lot about Honda recalls as well every other problem with the CR-V.

    Honda really must start doing a better job covering these up if it's such common knowledge.

    "You CRV guys having extreme problem to accept the fact that Escape is much better vehicle than CRV."

    Better why? Because you say so. If you take towing out of the equation there really is no clear cut advantage.

    Engine stalling while driving...
    Seat Belt Recall...

    Lets face it they've both had problems. Buy what you like and if that's an Escape in your case then so be it.
  • suvtimesuvtime Member Posts: 58
    I agree with you. Those rims are terrible looking and are going to be a royal pain to clean.
  • baggs32baggs32 Member Posts: 3,229
    Isn't Mercury supposed to be a step up from Ford?

    That depends. Content wise you can get a little more in a Mercury but you pay for it. OTOH they also tend to be "softened", and therefore less sporty, to appeal to older folks.

    When I see busy wheels like those above I always think of my dad's Sable. The leather is a little softer, the stereo a little better, and the ride a little softer than the Taurus' of that day. However, the wheels on the Sable are very detailed and require a toothbrush to clean all of the tiny crevices. The Taurus wheels were a simple, yet sporty, 5-spoke design.

    I take things like that into consideration because I'm the sole car washer in our house and I like to keep the vehicles as clean as my time allows. Spending extra time on the ground cleaning wheels does not make good use of my time.

    For comparison's sake check out the Mariner's wheels. I wouldn't want them either.

    http://www.mercuryvehicles.com/vehicles/mariner/
  • snowmansnowman Member Posts: 540
    "It would seem you know a lot about Honda recalls as well every other problem with the CR-V."

    b/c I am a car enthusiastic but very limited people come here and read those some thousands postings.

    "Better why? Because you say so"

    No, sales figures talks...

    As of 09/2004:
    Escape 140,718
    CR-V 109,985
  • varmintvarmint Member Posts: 6,326
    Snowman - In 2002 the CR-V outsold the Escape. Using your logic, that would make the 2002 CR-V better than the 2002 Escape. Similarly, the CR-V must be a better vehicle than all years of the Tribute.

    Truth be told, the Escape didn't start selling at the current rate until Ford started paying $1,000 - 2,000 to each person who bought one. That's when Escape sales took off. The fact that Ford buys many of their cars as fleet vehicles (for their rental companies) also inflates Ford's sales figures.
  • explorerx4explorerx4 Member Posts: 20,722
    i had an '89 taurus sho with 'basket rims'. i think there were about 48 surfaces to be cleaned on each wheel. after that, minimizing the number of 'spokes' became important to me. i like a clean vehicle, but 15 minutes per wheel was too much. good thing they didn't use the same pads as an '04 escape uses!
    2024 Ford F-150 STX, 2023 Ford Explorer ST, 91 Mustang GT vert
  • juliajulia Member Posts: 74
    My 2004 CR-V jerk to the curb in very slow speed at right turning lane recently. It cause suspension system replacement, etc. It cost about $3000 repair. I felt like the car was made by "paper".
    I had once that my Toyota car hit the curb, then the car drove over the curb by the front passenger tire. The car was fine. No any damage. While the CR-V didn't drive over the curb (although it has higher ground clearance), but it pushed the tire at passenger side towards to the back. It makes me feel that CR-V really like made by "paper", not by metal. So CR-V will be total impossible to drive on wild road.
    I think my next car will be either Ford Escape or Tribute.
  • mikefm58mikefm58 Member Posts: 2,882
    Sorry to hear about another problem with your CRV Julia, but how did your CRV suddenly jerk to the right? Without sounding dis-respectful, are you sure it wasn't driver error or something slippery in the road? And you can't compare two vehicles like you did in such an unscientific scenario.

    You are so unhappy with your CRV, why don't you just bite the bullet, take your losses, and go buy an Escape or Tribute like you mentioned? Life is too short.
  • dc_driverdc_driver Member Posts: 712
    Had the opportunity to take a long drive with some friends in their new 05 Escape XLT (sunroof, 6 disc changer, etc), and offer my impressions:
    -Quick acceleation and good offline torque
    -Better than average passing power (a must in DC)
    -Comfortable seats (was in the car for about 200 miles)
    -Decent legroom (driver was 6'6", and their was plenty of room behind him for my wife)
    -Very quiet ride. Much better than my 03 Altima SE even at acceleration.
    -Thought the interior was a little low grade with regards to the materials, but not excessively so (but then again for the price it is not bad).
    -We took the vehicle (4x4) offroad and was impressed with the way it handled mud/grass.

    Too be honest, I have never been a Ford person. I have always favored Japanese vehicles (big time Nissan family, and very haapy with them). But, I have to admit that I was very impressed with this vehicle. So much so that I will seriously consider either the Escape or Tribute when I decide to purchase a new vehicle. I was leaning towards a Subaru Outback, but I can save about 6K if I go with the Ford/Mazda...
  • dc_driverdc_driver Member Posts: 712
    Now for my CRV experience (I test drove one less than 2 years ago)
    -Thought the CRV had quite a bit of functionality
    -Plenty of legroom.
    -Quick off the line, but power was not always there when trying to pass.
    -Seats were uncomfortable after about 30 minutes in the car.
    -Not a fan of the placement of the shifter.

    Overall, I thought the CRV was a well thought-out automobile and drove well. HOWEVER, the dealer was awful. They were extremely arrogant, and while they seemed fairly knowledeable about the vehicle, they were not helpful. The biggest issue I had was the markup they had on the vehicle (about 1.5K OVER MSRP!) The salesman told me that this is somewhat negotiable, but that the car was in demand and they could pretty much sell it with the markup. Wrong answer. Walked out the door. This is the third different Honda dealer I have been to in the last 5 years and every experience has been similar.. Not the same with Nissan, Ford, and Mazda dealers I have visited.. Honestly, this is the biggest reason why I would not give Honda my money... Are you listening Honda???
  • dc_driverdc_driver Member Posts: 712
    I am tired of people complaining about recalls.. My 03 Nissan Altima SE has had several of the past couple years, but the dealer has been great and has given me loaner cars everytime the work was being done. Look, in this modern age of automobiles with hundreds of components and safety features, cars are bound to have recalls. Overall, this is for OUR safety and I personally would rather choose a car make that is honest, and responsible. No car whether it is a Ford, Nissan, Mercedes, or yes, even a Honda is perfect...

    My .02 cents..
  • baggs32baggs32 Member Posts: 3,229
    I hear ya!

    I used to wash my dad's 87 Taurus LX (the car I learned to drive on) with the "basket" wheels. I tried everything to get the brake dust out of those nooks and crannies but the only thing that worked was a toothbrush or a bottle brush.
      
    Plus it had white walls that needed cleaning too!

    The '05 Escape wheels are worlds cleaner than those on the older models. Plus our Limited doesn't have the OWL tires so cleaning the wheels takes about 2 min. per wheel. It was about 5 min per wheel when we had the '02 Escape with the OWL tires.
  • mikefm58mikefm58 Member Posts: 2,882
    In regards to your Honda dealer experiences, I too agree that the dealer plays a major role in shaping ones opinion of a vehicle. I avoided Toyotas like the plague for the same reason you avoid Hondas, just too much "crap" dealing with the sales folks. It took me quite awhile to find a decent Toyota salesman, of which I bought 2 new vehicles from him this year.

    But, there's not much the manufacturer can do in this. If enough stupid people are willing to pay 1.5K over MSRP, then dealers will charge that.
Sign In or Register to comment.