By accessing this website, you acknowledge that Edmunds and its third party business partners may use cookies, pixels, and similar technologies to collect information about you and your interactions with the website as described in our
Privacy Statement, and you agree that your use of the website is subject to our
Visitor Agreement.
Comments
I never had a Honda with a leather like case. You must be a former Ford driver.
Mileage approx 30000 mile
Year 2002
Year 2003
I would like to know what sort of prices can I actually get on these. The prices on dealers websites are way over the top - close to new ones !!!!
please advise. I am inm rochetser NY
any ideas who is a good dealer to deal with
john holtz
dick ide
ontario
ralph
Peter
Rochester, NY
I would say that the price on these will be very close to the new, and sometimes higher than the new. You are better off buying a new one. IF you are financing, any difference in savings in price will be eaten up by the higher interest rate. Don Davis Honda (Amherst, NY) has a 2002 EX, manual, with a $15K tag on it. I am sure there is room to negotiate.
$15K financed for 60 months at 7% is about $310/month -- used
$20K financed for 60 months at 3% is about $350/month -- new
I even read the confessions article, which actually stressed me out a bit. Who wants to face the wolves in order to buy a car? Well, we finally took the plunge and started shopping in earnest using the blast fax method. Let me say that it wasn't as easy as Edmund's or the Motley Fool suggested it would be, but it really wasn't that bad. You just have to stand your ground and contact a lot of places (>20 if possible and over a broad area). Some dealers really jerk you around, not itemizing their prices, forgetting that the car has their clear coat protectant, front mud flaps, and wheel locks (!! $400, 300, and 100, respectively). Others gave an OTD price that didn't include tax, tag title or destination- even though I had listed my tax rate and the fee schedule for registration etc. That wouldn't have been a big deal if they had just mentioned that the OTD price lacked tax etc. Instead they were deceptive and led me to believe that it was truly OTD.
I got several bids for a CRV-SE that were all within $50 of each other. I ended up with the following deal
$23500 price of car including destination charge
199 processing fee
--------------------------
Total $23699 not counting tax tag etc (and these will obviously vary based on where you live). my tax was ~700 and tag/title was $55
I was pretty happy with this price, especially since the invoice is approximately 23321 and destination has been described as non-negotiable and $515. And, most importantly, when I arrived to take delivery there was no funny business. They politely offered an optional extended warranty and I politely declined. They told me that I could purchase it up to 36k miles later from them or any one else, but that it would probably cost a little more and it couldn't be financed with my car loan if I bought it later. That's not a hard sell, that's just informing the customer. I signed the papers and drove away with my car 5 minutes later. We'll buy our next car from them (they don't know it, but probably in the next 6 months) because it was such a great experience.
Good luck to all of you potential buyers out there!
I mentioned your deal with Tempe Honda and they agreed to match. Tax is lesser in Scottsdale.
The CRV I test drove had the PTTR problem. I will test drive the one that I am going to buy and it PTTRs as well, I will not buy it.
I will keep you posted.
Thanks
No. I'm nolonger in the Sunshine state. Now we're in southwestern VA. The only accessory was a set of mud flaps. After we came home with the car I received an email from another dealer who had told me earlier in the day that there was no way she could come close to my best bid. They were quoting 25400 all inclusive OTD. Well, she changed her mind and was willing to meet the other guy's quote and throw in mudguards, wheel locks and a cargo tray for the back. Maybe she would have. i was just so turned off by the tone of her reply email telling me that she couoldn't give the car away that even if I had known I would have gotten the extra accessories from her I still would have purchased from the dealer that we used.
I initially requested quotes for a Honda alarm, but most people were charging 225-550 for it installed. A few even discouraged me from buying from the dealer at all, saying that I could get it for considerrably less from an aftermarket dealer. And, yes, the same people that were trying to charge $400 for clear coat protectant were also trying to sell the alarm for 550.
In my limited experience the dealerships who try to tag on extras on every vehicle are the ones who are least likely to want to deal.
Now, my father-in-law checked around for us in Jax (specifically on the West-side and at Steve Lucas). They were pretty quick to quote an OTD while standing in the parking lot that was pretty darn close to Edmunds TMV. They knew he wasn't in the market and that he was just trying to get a feel for the deals out there to help us out. I bet they'd probably be willing to work with you.
Scott
Dawn
My preference is to just deal with the local dealer but try to get him below the 3%. How do I do that? Do I just walk in and say "we would like to offer $xxx", or "so and so down state can get it for me for $xxx, how close can you get to that?"
Is there an appropriate way to communicate this without getting the dealer angry? Are they 'expecting' me to counter their first offer?
Should I offer 1% over invoice, or 1.5% over - or is that too low?
(Next closest dealer to me is 90 miles, and their price was better, but not good enough to warrant the trip down).
Any advice?
Thanks,
Dawn
Dennis
Shop other dealers and compare the bottom line: the difference between the new price less the trade allowance + dealer or doc fees.
Dennis
I don't think I can get any more out of the trade, so the only thing left is the selling price. I could just accept what they offered (though it is a bit high), but if they expect me to counter offer, I want to do that if I can save a few hundred dollars.
Now, the dealers downstate haven't seen my trade and it is very possible they would offer less than the $10K, which is why I would like to try to work with this local dealer, but I want to get a good price for the car at the same time
Dawn
If it is a Honda that a Honda dealer could easily resell then you can expect more from them on a trade. If it is not something they will want to sell then they wholesale it out to another deal (one that sells that make or a small lot) or takes it to the auction. Unless they can sell it to someone at retail, none of these options will net the dealer much money if they give you any kind of decent trade allowance.
It is likely the dealer is allowing too much for your trade then making it up by not discounting the new truck as much as you would like. They have to make money (and will) on the deal so you have to decide what your trade is really worth and try to get that. You would probably be a lot better off selling it yourself, then you can get the new truck for invoice or less and not worry about it.
Dennis
If they take it, you have your trade-in price and 1% over..
Everyone goes home happy...
Edmunds Price Checker
Edmunds Lease Calculator
Did you get a good deal? Be sure to come back and share!
Edmunds Moderator
Dawn
You are not there to make them happy, just get what you want for as little as possible :-)
Dennis
Not everyone can find a deal like that, but it makes it more likely that your dealer will accept it...
You don't get what you don't ask for...
regards,
kyfdx
PS: Without reading this forum, I would be thrilled with what you have already been offered, so you aren't in bad shape, either way..
Edmunds Price Checker
Edmunds Lease Calculator
Did you get a good deal? Be sure to come back and share!
Edmunds Moderator
Sale price $22,050 including destination
Add dealer fee, roof rack and wheel locks $22,400
Lia didn't have silver moss metallic at their Enfield store, but got one from another location for me. Then switched OE tires from Bridgestone to Goodrich. Didn't charge me add'l for either transaction.
I e-mailed five area dealerships asking for lowest acceptable price not including TTL on the exact car I wanted. Lia was first to respond (within 24 hrs). Two other dealerships responded, but with higher prices or with the caveat that there would be an additional cost for a car that wasn't on their lot or for changing OE tires to BFGs. Two other dealerships never gave me a firm price, one after phoning me to talk about my previous highly satisfactory relationship with the dealership. (Sure you've been great, but please tell me: "What is the lowest price you will accept for this vehicle?")
Got 4.25 financing from COMTrust Federal Credit Union.
I'm happy.
Two FYIs:
I started out looking for a compact PU to lug around me, my sporting gear and to function as a mobile man cave. Was finally scared off PUs by rising gas prices and observing that the "problems and solutions" threads were long and often frequented by owners whose mechanical expertise is way above mine. Sitting on a tail gate sucking down a beer has always seemed like the perfect ending to a day of fishing to me. But I'll get over it.
I don't know why dealerships won't respond to e-mail requests for a quote. At most, it takes 10 minutes to respond, especially for a CR-V that basically comes in vanilla, chocolate or strawberry. What have they got to lose?
Somewhere around 500 miles is where they need to start discounting them...
Just my $0.02.. enjoy your new car..
regards,
kyfdx
Edmunds Price Checker
Edmunds Lease Calculator
Did you get a good deal? Be sure to come back and share!
Edmunds Moderator
I would not worry about 20, that is no big deal. Congrats on your first new truck!
Dennis
You keep preaching this "holdback" thing ... it's not a profit center and never has been ... it's an amount of money the dealer gets from the manufacturer to "offset" the cost of the floor plan, which I might add they have to wait 90 to 150 days depending on how it falls in the quarter .....
You do the math ... 150 vehicles, average Honda store sits at $23,450 per copy, then figure a quarter point over prime per month, dealers are paying the floor plan when they receive the invoice, not the vehicle and that can be 7/15 days away -- where's the profit .?
Terry.
Not my problem. I buy into the hold back every chance I get. Let the dealer overcharge the next person to make up for it. We are all adults in the finance office and no one is making either party sign anything they don't want to. Most folks over pay so badly I feel no pity for the poor car dealer when I hammer out a good deal. Some folks negotiate a good price then give it all back in the finance office in bloated interest rates, over priced add ons and questionable service contracts. Nope, don't feel bad for them at all.
The answer to the question IN CONTEXT was "how does the dealer make any money selling at invoice" - the answer is they have the hold back no matter what else.
As I posted to Dawn, "You are not there to make them happy, just get what you want for as little as possible :-) "
Dennis
Like Kyfdx has mentioned, work your deal from 1 to 3% over invoice and you'll do fine .....
Terry
If you want to help - fine, help .... but don't give people irresponsible information with a chip on your shoulder - it doesn't become you ..
Terry.
And, I, for one am tired of hearing from you how people "overpay". I doubt if there are any other business that operates on such slim profit margins!
Sounds like you feel a dealer should "overcharge" others so they can lose money on people like yourself!
2) Holdback is designed to pay for flooplan
On the other hand....
A) The dealer's overhead is not my concern.. At least knowing the gross profit margin gives me an idea of what deal might be acceptable.. I want to pay the least amount possible, and also actually be successful in buying the car.
I don't believe Dennis ever said you should bring up holdback during your negotiations... He was just responding to someone asking how a dealer could sell below invoice...
This forum works a lot better for explaining the nuts and bolts of pricing, than it does to actually prepare someone for the buying experience..
If it makes the rest of you feel better, here it is:
Don't ever bring up the term "holdback" in your negotiations with the dealer. It may cause him to blow a blood vessel.
regards,
kyfdx
Edmunds Price Checker
Edmunds Lease Calculator
Did you get a good deal? Be sure to come back and share!
Edmunds Moderator
Thanks - that is exactly the case.
Don't ever bring up the term "holdback" in your negotiations with the dealer. It may cause him to blow a blood vessel.
You mean like those two dealers just blew up? I guess you are right :-)
I am working a deal right now where I will get a new car below invoice (that must be into that thing which we can't mention) and they will give me more than Terry says they should for my trade. Call me nuts if I fail to take them up on it. They can figure out how to keep the lights on with the next deal
Dennis
They recommend negotiating UP from the bottom line (which in the dealer holdback) not down from the MSP. CU says you should not pay any more than 4-8% above that price.
You will pay the higher percentage for vehicles in demand.
Thanks,
Dennis
You are correct...cars in short supply and high demand will command a higher price. It's always the MARKET that determines pricing in the end.
Same applies to houses and lots of other commodity items.
Sorry Kyfdx, but thats a totally incorrect statement .. you musta been asleep during finance 101 ..... there's no 2 ways about it unless your running a Kool-Aid stand .... dealers are looking at the total cost, because that's exactly what it is, you can't margin units because you don't know what the "tomorrow" cost is .... they will do a wash-out at the end of the month and usually holdback doesn't even cover 90% of the balance, because it's a daily incurred cost.
A better way to explain it, home builders ...... build 10 homes - first house sells in 25 days, lender has only charged the builder 25 days of finance (floorplan), next house sells in 33 days - the same, now the 3rd house is sold in 49 days - the finance cost is twice what the first house was .. house 4 sells in 66 days ---- and on and on it goes ... by the time the 10th home is sold, the home builder is paying for the last 3 ..... and none of this is even reflective of the "cost to build" ........... get it.?
Terry
After I got to that point, I then sent out an e-mail to Internet managers at five dealers describing exactly what I wanted and asking for the lowest sales price they would accept sans TTL for that vehicle. Once I had the low bid (and it looked very good based on my at-home research), I confirmed my understanding with the dealer by phone and by e-mail before venturing out for a sit down.
When I sat down with the Internet manager, I was there to do the paper work, not negotiate. We'd already arrived at an acceptable price.
If that price fell apart, I was prepared to walk, because I had a fallback dealer to go to. Using the e-mail approach, even the high bid was still pretty good. But if the whole thing fell apart, I was prepared to repeat the process with a fallback brand of vehicle. If that fell apart, I'd wait until the 4thQ when dealers are eager to sell $40K cars for $16 because they came off a 3-year lease.
No need for drama. I was sending out e-mails, not driving all over creation to different dealerships. But in my case the dealer honored his price and 20 minutes later I'd bought my CR-V.
Remember that the number you're building is sales price -- i.e., the dealer's lowest acceptable price for the vehicle plus delivery plus any applicable fees. You want to put that all in one number and confirm it. This prevents a dealer from giving you a below-invoice price by tacking on the delivery and other fees later. There goes your great deal. Title, tax and registration are a given, so ignore them until the sit down.
Finally, if you've done your homework and bought a car, stop fretting and drive. Your loud-mouthed brother-in-law won't tell you that his "below invoice price" looks good only because the dealer hit him separately for delivery and other fees. And if he asks what you paid, the answer is always, "Oh, I got it below invoice."
Good post.! ...
The reason why most people drone on and on, is because someone just posted that they bought an ABC or an XYZ vehicle for $200 less then they "think" they can purchase the same vehicle for (whether real or not) ...
The dealer in Seattle might not be able to match the price in Oakland because of inventory, maybe the guy in Kansas City can't match the price in Tulsa or the guy in Orlando can't beat the price in Atlanta ........ but then again, these are usually the same folks that pay $500 for a new golf club that can be bought for $350 or pay $2,900 more in closing costs then the guy down the street ........ so what price glory.?
Terry
Anyway, at this time of year shouldn't be hard to negotiate to invoice. Good argument is that in a few months this is going to be the last year's model.
I vote for buying the '05 now...
Edmunds Price Checker
Edmunds Lease Calculator
Did you get a good deal? Be sure to come back and share!
Edmunds Moderator
But.. I totally disagree...
If.. the manufacturer rebates you $750 (holdback) on a particular unit, after it is sold... then that lowers your cost on that unit... regardless of what the payment is designed to cover... That is Finance 101..
As I stated before... Gross profit doesn't equal net profit.. Car dealers have many expenses, and floorplan is one of them.. I don't worry about how much the car dealer is making... just whether I'm getting the best price that I can... Whether the dealer makes $5000 or loses $500, if I got the best price, then I'm happy..
But.... I get it... don't mention holdback.. Heck.. I don't even mention invoice.. I'd just as soon they think I'm a pinhead, who only knows one number... The price I'm willing to pay..
TGIF!!
regards,
kyfdx
Edmunds Price Checker
Edmunds Lease Calculator
Did you get a good deal? Be sure to come back and share!
Edmunds Moderator
But does it or does it not reduce the the dealer's cost of doing business? If the former, semantic issues as to whether it is "profit" strike me as something of a quibble. Above the line addition, or below the line subtraction, the end result is very similar.
Got the trade value I was looking for, 1% over invoice - I'm satisfied.
Deposit is refundable, as the vehicle is just off the truck and not prepped yet. I will have a chance to drive it on Monday to make sure there is no PTTR or extraordinary vibration. Anything else I should look for?
Would really like the light-colored fabric scotchguarded - is there a better way to do it than through the dealer (or doing it by myself - as I do not trust myself to do it properly). Does anyone else offer the service cheaper than the dealers $595 protection package?
Thanks for all the advice...
Dawn
You did fine .... $595 for a what.? .. call the dealer and tell him you don't want the protection package, so don't apply it -- if they do, you wonta tacka the el caro ... you can get scotchguard anywhere for $50 or less and get the whole deal for $99 somewhere .....
Terry.
I agree with Terry.. You can get all of that done by a detail shop for under $200....
Enjoy your new car... sounds like a great deal..
regards,
kyfdx
Edmunds Price Checker
Edmunds Lease Calculator
Did you get a good deal? Be sure to come back and share!
Edmunds Moderator
Let me run this by you one more time, since you've been using your 9 year old paperboy to do your taxes lately .....
**You do the math ... 150 vehicles, average Honda store sits at $23,450 per copy, then figure a quarter point over prime everyday per month, dealers are paying the floor plan when they receive the invoice, not the vehicle and that can be 7/15 days away -- where's the profit .?**
I know your saving money using your paperboy .. but try using a CPA next time or maybe even an Abacus might help ya, even toes work ..l.o.l.........................................
Terry.
But..if they rebate you any money, due to you selling a specific unit, it lowers your cost on that particular unit..... If they give you a bonus of $500 per unit, once you sell 300 units per month... that lowers the cost per unit by $500... If they give you double secret probation money (Animal House was on last night) of $300 per unit, that lowers the cost of each unit by $300...
AND... if they give you $750 of holdback per unit... that lowers the cost of each unit by $750....
No matter where your CPA puts that amount.... and no matter what your expenses are.... It is $750 you wouldn't have otherwise, if they didn't rebate it...
Repeat after me..... I never said it was profit...
You are still my favorite car dealer, though.... :surprise:
regards,
kyfdx
Edmunds Price Checker
Edmunds Lease Calculator
Did you get a good deal? Be sure to come back and share!
Edmunds Moderator