Edmunds dealer partner, Bayway Leasing, is now offering transparent lease deals via these forums. Click here to see the latest vehicles!
Options
Popular New Cars
Popular Used Sedans
Popular Used SUVs
Popular Used Pickup Trucks
Popular Used Hatchbacks
Popular Used Minivans
Popular Used Coupes
Popular Used Wagons
Comments
Apparently, these types of TSBs have to go through the Ministry of Transportation etc since we have stiffer environmental and safety standards than our brotherin down South... but do not fear, Toyota US and Toyota Canada do share a common database and communicate regularily. Remember, Toyota US sells 10X or more Camrys a year and will thus have a larger pool of complaints and concerns to address and work with. But, I do believe it will be coming North in a matter of time, the other TSBs such as the A pillar garnish came through quicker.
btw... don't lie to me! I went through 8 years of university... I know you can find the time!! lol.
I know with this post I'm going to make some of you guys uncomfortable but anyway, here's my problem:
I bought my car in May and immediately noticed, that something is not right with transmition. Car was very slow on start and was hunting between the gears. I did some research, found this website and realized that this is very common problem and there's no fix for that. So I've waited for Toyota's move... Few days ago I read here about new TSB for my car and brought it in for service last Wednesday. Everthing was great for 3 days, I started even liking my camry again, than on Saturday i noticed, that the gap between pushing the gas pedal and reaction of the transmition was getting longer and longer. Today I took my car for a ride and while I was entering highway i floored the gas pedal and... nothing happend, the car didn't accelerate!!! I don't know about you guys but I don't feel any difference in transmition performance now. I'm really disappointed and I don't know what to do... Is it possible that toyota service did a bad job recalibrating engine and trany? What should I do next?
Thanks for any help.
I feel sad
1) the car doesn't like the way you modulate the throttle - an all-on/all-off driving style is difficult for the transmissions control program to handle. Many Toyota vehicles (as well as o0ther mfgrs.) do not 'like' abrupt accelerator changes to the point that even your foot position can make a difference. The clue to this is in that TSB which effectively says exactly this.
2) however you drive, the computer also 'learns' to compensate for what it thinks is 'unauthorized' driving style. Sounds ridiculous, doesn't it? But, I would bet, the reason why the reappearance of the problem.
The bottom line - is that all these new electronic control systems that can (and do) improve FE, emissions, mitigate torque steer, and allow for the VSC/TRAC/ABS safety features are NOT without a price in overall drivability. It is not a problems exclusive to Toyotas (by a long shot), a problem that will be much more common as more and more mfgrs. adopt systems like this, and will change the way we drive.
The Camry should be a bit better simply because the mechanical components (exc. for the 6 speed) have been around for awhile. Toyota 'quality' is suffering a bit more than usual simply because of all the new technologies combined with demand they can barely keep up with.
You forgot to mention that Toyota RECALLS jumped 41 times the last two years!! not 41% 41 times. There recall rate is the highest in the world! I don't think the demand will be as high next year when the decline of Toyota's quality is realized by the public. What is just as bad as the transmission problem is Toyota's refusal to admit it.
Or replaced...
The head of NHTSA said it himself, that you simply can't judge the quality of a car company's products based on one or two years worth of recalls.
Have no idea what you are talking about with your recall stats, these figures are easily accessible on the NHTSA website. The Avalon (which for obvious reasons has always been Toyota's most 'troublesome' model), for example, shows 4 recalls over almost 3 years of production, and was a totally new car at the time. Much less than almost anything else on the market. But believe what you will or let me know where your 'statistics' come from.
The 2GR engine in my Avalon, the Camry V6, and several other Toyota/Lexus products is the sweetest combination of power, economy, and smoothness possibly in the history of the automobile, in some part because of these high tech computer systems. Doesn't sound like you own one?
http://www.iht.com/articles/2006/08/04/business/recall.php
The only way you can get accurate stistics is by accurate documentation. NHTSA will not have accurate statistics if they are given garbage. Toyota has gone to great lengths to hide the transmission problems that have been affecting several models for three years. When I had the TSB EG056-06 ECM performed on my car last week the tech wrote reprogramed ECM. Not performed TSB EG056. Call 800-331-4331 Toyota Customer Experience and ask about the hesitation problem with the Toyota transmissions. No one there has ever heard of it, in fact a friend of mine called and they never heard of the TSB. But you can go on any internet auto forum and thousands of people are complaining about it. To answer your question yes I do have a car that has a combination of power and smoothness it is my other car a 2003 Nissan Murano. No, I am not comparing the two. I do not know where you get your white washed statistics but I like your definition of the transmission "The 'transmission problem' as you perceive it really has little to do with the tranny itself in a mechanical sense - it has to do with some idiosycransies in how the computer program controls the silly thing." You must have been one of the guys that designed it.
captain2 - I really don't see how this can by my fault. All-on/all-off is not my driving style but sometimes I find myself in the situation that I really need all the power my car can give me. Just to make it clear. Hesitation, delay, jerking doesn't occur only when I floor the gas pedal. It happens during everyday driving! It feels like my car starts from 3 or even 4th gear. It's heavy like a cow and moves like one. I don't know if it makes any difference but my car was manufactured on 04/06.
Thanks. I'll keep you posted.
http://www-odi.nhtsa.dot.gov/cars/problems/recalls/recallsearch.cfm
And then compare the Camry (or the Avalon because it has been around longer) and see how they measure up. Unless, of course, you still think our erstwhile government is 'whitewashing 'statistics on perceived 'Japanese' mfgrs.
In any case, you never heard me say that I liked the way our trannies operate and I can certainly understand that that it is more bothersome without the extra 100 HP. But, they are working the way they are designed to work - like it or not and it may, indeed, cost Toyota more than a few customers.
The real points that I'm trying to make:
- as our government mandates (and the US autobuyer apparently wants) things like VSC/TRAC/ABS, systems that require electronic (computer) control of our throttles, trannies, brakes, steering etc. the manner in which we cooperate with our car's computers will dictate, to some degree, how we drive. Retraining will be required!
- Toyota has possibly put a little too much emphasis on FE. It is FE after all that sells. I would be willing to bet you that your car (as well as mine) has a habit of holding onto higher gears particulary on coastdown to a stop, creating a multiple gear downshift on heavy reapplication of the throttle - and the now infamous 'hesitation/lurch'. Compound that with the apparent importance (acknowledged in the reprogramming section of the 6 speed TSB) of foot position and pressure modulation, and again you might reach the conclusion that the car is now somehow dictating the way we drive.
- Toyota has become an acknowledged technolgy leader these days with things like the hybrids, 268 hp fullsize cars that can crack 30 mpg rather easily, etc. These 'innovations' are not without a price, and are also present in many many other cars that don't happen to be Toyotas.
The CVT, like in your Murano, is likely a good solution simply because there are no gears to select just a few variable diameter pulleys and a belt or two - Nissan's version the first one to really stand up in a higher HP application. My wife's car incidentally, an 03 Altima 3.5 with an 'old-fashioned' tranny that doesn't have any sort of behavorial issues and, in fact, has never been in the shop for 70k now. It is interesting to me that now both this car and the Maxima are supplied with CVTs. Wonderful engine the Nisaan VQ....
The advent of the computer controlled car will leave us all wanting for the good ole days when a car did what you told it to - and possibly a Cntrl-Alt-Del button on the dashboard!
All this said, I will tell you that I have learned how my car wants to be driven and very very rarely experience any hesitation issues. If Toyota does finally come up with some sort of 'solution' that improves drivability at the expense of a few mpg (which I suspect would be the case) I probably will NOT take the car in. Bottom line is that I don't find it that objectionable even when driving the car hard, likely because after 40k miles I have learned how to drive it - and damn, it is a helluva ride!
There are no 'hesitation' recalls for the Highlander, ES330, Solara, Avalon, or '07 Camry simply because while the hesitation issues are present in all of these it's a performance related issue not a safety issue. There is nothing hidden it's well known all over the forums and it appears that Toyota is finding solutions vehicle-by-vehicle to what is a programming matter.
The other recalls noted in the article are more a reflection of new standards and a new political environment since Ford/Firestone. Now the guiding criteria is if there is a misdesign or mismanufacture let the NHTSA know about it and if needed issue a recall and put the burden on the owner to have the item fixed.
Did you hear about the safety recall for carpeting on the Highlanders? Or the one about the cupholders in the Durango? These are safety recalls within the last 6 months. The recall statistics for all manufacturers are very likely to go up in this new legal/political environment.
Of course not, because as you noted it is not a safety issue, although I think a few drivers of these cars might disagree with that. There are, however TSBs and complaints filed on the hesitation issue and available on NHTSA, a site on which any of us are free to use. In this internet driven information era, I think it is fair to surmise that Toyota as well as the other mfgrs. do pay some attention to our gripes.
And if I'm understanding your tone right, the last place I want to find some idiot lawyer is in my car?
to be fair, some owners with the issue have claimed it to be an annoyance more than anything else.
let's, assume the issue's severity is distributed gaussian (we don't know but that's a good first-principles choice). for some it will be mostly a satisfaction problem, but not necessarily so for others...
we should acknowlege this fact since it is rather absurd to be telling people who feel their safety is compromised in their vehicle that there is no safety issue. they experience and perceive what they experience and perceive.
there's no doubt many situations can be accomodated by lots of mental preparation in terms of anticipating the response, or lack there of of the vehicle to heavy throttle application in a number of scenarios.
it's those other situations that would force me to find the implementation completely unacceptable... even if i as a driver of one of these vehicles could "re-train" myself away from decades of driving and causality experience and learning (not just in the driving domain, but just about every other domain in the man/machine realm), the interaction which happens at a very unconscious manner when the scenario is unplanned or is pressed for time...
that needs to be addressed. toyota doesn't seem to get this point - but it is very real and not something i'd be risking or willing to dismiss in a push for higher fuel economy or an infrastructure for other safety functionality.
To use an old saying, YOU HIT THE NAIL ON THE HEAD! However I don't think everyone will understand some of your terminology.
My replacement Nissan has no hesitation whatsoever.
Bought my new 4 cylinder CAMRY a few weeks ago. Purchased at Schaumburg Toyota in Illinois. My wife and I love the car.Came home that night and THEN read all this hesitation stuff going on. Is the problem the computer software guiding the trans or the mismatch of the "heavyfoot" driver with the new computer driven trans?? This is my first non-American car. I am 48 years old. By the way,my 2000 Ford Taurus drives just as good as the day I bought it. It has had limited service issues. I have always heard that CAMRY can't be beat,so of course when I buy one it has issues. I only have driven 150 miles. No issues,YET!
Then he mentioned about the new platform, tranny etc and said that every manufacturer goes through the same thing when they introduce new model. As toyota sells significantly higher number of vehicles compared to other manufacturer, they hear more complains.
These do make sense.
I'll have to check. The dealer said they just got the car in a few days earlier. (Purchased around the end of September.) The car is great looking. I love the new style.
Our Camry is the LE in bright silver.
this is exactly the issue
And taking it a step further - these safety systems (VSC/TRAC/ABS)that can and do make driving decisions for you by disabling/slowing throttle and tranny responses, applying brakes for you, slowing steering responses etc. MUST be programmed to intervene at some level below the car's actual dynamic capabilities - given different driver abilities. Otherwise, they wouldn't be safety features in the first place. BUT, also possibly creating a safety hazard as well.
Using the same logic you are using here, does this implementation also become a manufacturer problem and even liability given that the US government has mandated the things and the US consumer apparently wants them? Technology is NOT all good all of the time.
PS - Hello Alan, hope you are contniuing to enjoy your new Altima!
for me, far and away more important that FE or VSC/TRAC and ABS features is vehicle responsiveness to change in throttle and direction.
i have experienced both ABS and TRAC activation in my wife's ODY. i have no history with VSC. TRAC has surprised me a few times, but did it's thing and I'm OK with it.
however, when i demand power from the ODY, it is consistently there. i will not compromise on that.
i'm positive toyota will eventually get it all right, but until that is done, i'll drive something else and be a late adopter of the maturing technology.
i'm going to be vigilant about what i drive and it's response to my control input changes no matter what the manufacturer banner. if i loose confidence in my vehicle, i am not as safe a driver as i could or should be for myself, my family and others on the road in my proximity.
Any "lift-throttle" event results in a transaxle upshift in order to moderate, reduce, the level of engine compression braking. Now with the transaxle having just begun an upshift sequence as you reapply the throttle the upshift must COMPLETE and now the engine/transaxle ECU can command a downshift. With the engine now at idle RPM there is not sufficient hydraulic fluid pressure to complete a second sequential shift quickly...
1-2 seconds later and the downshift is complete, the clutches have been fully and firmly seated, and the DBW firmware can now "release" the throttle.
Now suspend your disbelief if you think otherwise.
Ford Motor Company has just been granted a patent which pertains very closely to the above.
The Ford Escape Hybrid and the Mercury Mariner Hybrid use a newly patented technique which REDUCES, apparently significantly so, the level of regenerative braking if the OAT, Outside Air Temperature is "hovering" near or below freezing.
Additionally, regardless of OAT level, if the ABS, Anti-locking braking system activates due to the need to RELEASE the brakes momentarily (tens of milliseconds) the regenerative braking level is instantly dropped to zero.
Obviously this is a strong indication that the effects of regenerative braking can be detrimental should the roadbed be slippery enough.
Wouldn't the same be true of engine compression braking? Especially for FWD or front torque biased AWD?
So I suggest that "maybe" the new TSB simply reduces the instances of lift-throttle upshifts to those times when the OAT is near or below freezing. But I suppose we won't really know the answer to that until enough folks having had the TSB applied start encountering freezing or sub-freezing temperatures.
Could that also be why the TSB isn't available in Canada? Canadian LS400s and Prius' get windshield heaters and we don't....
the government mandating this stuff - well that is a different matter. and the manufacturer in my opinion has an obligation to see to it they don't negatively impact safety by introducing these and other artifacts.
Then he mentioned about the new platform, tranny etc and said that every manufacturer goes through the same thing when they introduce new model. As toyota sells significantly higher number of vehicles compared to other manufacturer, they hear more complains.
These do make sense.
I wish I could believe that all will be well next year, but I can't. I just have a hard time believing that it will take less than a year to fix this in the '07 Camry, when it has been a problem in the Highlander and Avalon for around 5 years with no apparent fix to date.
By what we talking about here, the 'hesitant' tranny is assumed dangerous, and the ecobox is not when, in fact, both the Camry models can merge more quickly and safely?
Not to mention previous v6 5speed Camry, Lexus 300, and Lexus 330.
Whether we've adjusted to the vehicle or it to us over the last 2 years I don't know. It is though just as powerful and responsive as we need it to be in any and all circumstances.
I do agree wholeheartedly that Toyota has to react immediately to complaint about the lack of enjoyment of the driving experience. This is what keeps people coming back.
October 11,2007. I just hope it corrects the issues I have with this car.
Yes, I am still enjoying the Altima 3.5. One dynamite of a car. Wouldn't trade it for an Avalon - an M35 perhaps
Your point of performance capability is well taken, however I think the issue here is predictability. Humans can adapt to machines providing that the machines react consistently every time. Having a vehicle respond variably to the same input at different times makes it very difficult and potentially dangerous to drive because the driver doesn't know what it is or isn't going to do next.
Take my example - sometimes the Avalon would take off like a rocket. It could be accelerated into traffic with ease and knowing it's capabilities, one would drive it accordingly. If I were driving the Yaris, I would adjust my habits accordingly, and perhaps wait for wider traffic gaps etc.
The problem was the Avalon responded differently every time. If there was a consistent 2 second delay in throttle response, one could conceivably adjust to it and drive it accordingly, however in my case, sometimes it would take off like a rocket and at other times it would leave me hanging... all within seconds of each "event". The variability compounded the hesitation issue, so one couldn't develop a "feel" for the car's capabilities and the last thing I want to do when I'm negotiating traffic is to try to figure out what the car is going to do next.
My Altima is a very responsive and obedient machine - fast, predictable and always at MY command. Ditto with our Honda.
There must be some reason why Toyota have taken so long to address these issues and why the same problems are manifesting themselves in the brand-new Camry transmission. Perhaps their design is overly complicated with just too many sensors and too many variable sources of input that they just plain well outsmarted themselves. How about back to the old philosophy of K.I.S.S!
I'm still following these forums because we were going to get a Camry for our son in a few months, but I'm not buying any more Toyotas until I can see a clean bill of health over an extended period of time.