Kia Sedona (2005 and Earlier)

1202123252688

Comments

  • bluedevilsbluedevils Member Posts: 2,554
    It appears that some U.S.-market Sedonas are being delivered with a 3rd row mat and some (including mine) are not. It sounds like Kia of America doesn't really know what's going on. Or perhaps they do, but they aren't explaining it to customers. Their explanation that some dealers are installing aftermarket mats is not very believable or likely, IMO.

    Maybe only certain parts of the country get 3rd row mats included. Or perhaps it's based on the manufacture date (earlier ones have it, newer ones don't-- or vice versa). Ours was built on 12/20/2001, I think. We bought it around 2/19/2002.
  • jondotjondot Member Posts: 63
    No rear mat installed in my EX delivered in mid September. Now am past the 10K mark and no problems except Torque steer to the left. Pull is proportional to amount of power applied and reduces with higher speed. Still a slight pull at highway speed. Kia rep Frank Kruse said some torque steer is expected in a front wheel drive. ANYBODY ELSE OUT THERE EXPERIENCING THIS PROBLEM???
  • jster381jster381 Member Posts: 17
    Well it took over three weeks of full-time searching, but I finally drove home last night in my Misty-Blue Sedona. The color is darker than the picture I've seen in the brochure, and it was not one of my top choices but it is starting to "grow" on me. I paid $22,400 for a fully loaded EX(all six options, I live in NJ) and the dealer also included a leather bra for the front and a sunroof deflector. I am very excited and happy with the car, but the shopping experience was not as easy as it should have been. It is definitely hard to find EX models with most or all of the options (for a good price). I did find an honest dealer (Dave Lewis) at Burlington KIA, but would warn prospective buyers to beware Value Kia in Philly. I had a terrible shopping experience there. With the warm weather this weekend, I can't wait to to take her for a spin and try out all the gadgets. I would like to thank everyone for providing excellent feeback in response to many of my questions, and can say that many of you (through word of mouth) we a major factor in my decision to become a Sedon owner. Thanks again and happy driving to all!!
  • excelent3excelent3 Member Posts: 197
    Congrats on your new addition! Most of regulars on this board are just sharing out enthusiasm which is very contagious! Others no doubt will follow. The Misty Blue in a two tone is sharp, looks very professional. You got a great deal too!
  • momonthegomomonthego Member Posts: 14
    We didn't get a third row mat on our Kia Ex either. We got misty blue and I love the color. Bought it in Kansas City back in September. We grumbled about the missing mat at the time...because the one in the showroom had a third row mat... our salesman was completely clueless...even tried to tell us the keyless remote wasn't a standard feature. He promised to order us the mat, but we never got it... I could go on and on, but Ex's were in short supply back then and after two previous bad dealership experiences we were just happy to actually SEE an Ex. We were absolutely clear with them that we were only interested in EX's and we kept being promised Ex's and when we would drive over an hour there they would only have LX's...rrrrr.

    We probably should have looked for yet another dealer, but we were having a baby in November and with the lack of Sedonas in this area at that time we were afraid I was still going to be driving my Mustang when the baby came and we became a family of five... which wouldn't work in my car or his Chevy S10.

    What's with this interchangeable mat logic ??? assuming you would never have people in both rows at the same time??? Oh well, we picked up some deep track front seat rubber mats and turned them sideways to fit over the existing carpet mats anyway (messy winters)for the middle row so we just got the same for the back.

    Somebody mentioned passenger seat leg room. I am primarily the driver of our van but when I'm in the passenger seat at first I really noticed that I feel taller over there and there's no seat lowering option, but I have adjusted now and it doesn't bother me.

    However, one other issue I have with the van regarding leg room is that we have an infant car seat with a base. In order to get the seat belt tight enough in the second row you have to scoot the seat quite a ways forward. Infant seats stick out in front of the seat quite a bit so then in order to get the seat into the base you have to scoot the passenger seat forward a lot. This meant in order to used our carseat with its base (which we purposely chose for its ease of click in click out - not having to deal with the seat belt every time) the passenger has their knees in the dash. The resolution was we had to quit using our base. This didn't make me happy. The reason we can't get the base tight enough with the middle seat back in a normal legroom position is because of that button like thing that is in the middle of the belt. If anybody has any suggestions I'd appreciate it.
  • sritrovatosritrovato Member Posts: 20
    Congratulations! Can't wait to hear how you feel about the van down the road a bit. I really like the blue. If you don't mind (and to save me from looking through about a thousand pages of notes) can I ask what the sticker on the Sedona was? At a glance, you seem to have gotten a very good deal. I guess it pays to be persistant. How did you locate "your" dealer in the end? I had previously sent you a response referring you to Faulkner (pretty out of the way for you I suppose), but they, like many, don't have much inventory. Burlington would be a haul for me, but once the "decision" is a lock, I'm not going to want to wait forever for dealers to get more vans in stock. By the way, did they tack on charge for Scotch Guarding and such? Thanks for whatever info you can provide!
  • jster381jster381 Member Posts: 17
    The MSRP on the fully loaded Sedona EX was $24,100. I went to one dealer in Philly who was also adding about a $1,500 mark-up fee (above MSRP) on the car due to market demand. I had a fairly easy time using the internet and email to get price quotes that were about $1,000 - $1,200 below MSRP. Yes, I worked the local dealers pretty hard and was happy to get the price I did ($22,400). I ended up buying at Burlington, but I only went there one day to look at the various colors...since I didn't act interested in buying I think they worked "harder" to give me a good price. I also really liked the sales manger there, I thought he was the "most honest" of all the dealers I spoke to. Overall I had to wait several weeks for my van to be delivered, but I am now very happy that I did wait. I know the sales manager at Burlington told me that he was not going to honor the same price he gave me (to prospective new buyers) because the demand has gone up recently. The only "extra" I paid (other than taxes) was an $80 paperwork/registration fee. They did not try to "push" any other BS fee (they did not even ask If I wanted the interior Scotch Guarded, but then again it has leather seats). Good luck with your search! By the way...my 3rd row did come with a floor mat.
  • sritrovatosritrovato Member Posts: 20
    Congratulations on a job well done! Thanks for the info. Though I did find my printout of MSRP for this configuration, it helps to know about the "side track" issues. $1500. markup over sticker for high demand??? Yuk Yuk. I wonder if some of these salespeople think we just fell off the turnip truck yesterday. Good luck and keep us posted on how you like it!
  • gregoriusmgregoriusm Member Posts: 61
    This may sound like a dumb question, but going from a car with a trunk to a van with not a lot of space behind the rears seats, where does one put the essential tool box, jumper cables (I live in 40 below weather), windshield washer antifreeze, etc. In other words, whatever you normally keep in your trunk, out of sight, but there for emergencies, etc.

    What do you people do in your Sedona's?? - Greg
  • korlingkorling Member Posts: 5
    We went down to Walmart and bought a RubberMaid storage container about 12X24 inches. It fits behind the rear seat without taking up all the cargo space. I store our jumper cables, tools and other items there. The lid seals well preventing everything from spilling out. Works for us...
  • tommcd66tommcd66 Member Posts: 2
    Well, after searching the Van market, my wife and I are going with a Sedona. However, my wife noticed that the Sedona took a long time to come to a comlete stop. We have quite a bit of hills in our neighborhood and I'm concerned about the Sedonas brake system. Has anyone had a problem stopping? I'm also curious of the Sedonas handling on icy roads. Anybody?
  • wberndtwberndt Member Posts: 18
    Just curious. Did the test Sedona you drove have ABS brakes?
    Also, there is a button on the shift lever that cancels out overdrive "around town" driving. This prevents the van from shifting into 5th gear and allows the engine to help slow it down when you take your foot off the gas.
  • tommcd66tommcd66 Member Posts: 2
    The model we tested was an LX without ABS. Would the addition of ABS make a difference for everyday driving?
  • jondotjondot Member Posts: 63
    I have found the brakes in my EX (no ABS) far superior to what I had in my '96 Dodge Grand Caravan WITH ABS.
    .....
    .
    BTW, am I the only one experiencing Torque steer???
  • hoyahenryhoyahenry Member Posts: 399
    Did you swap the tires yet? I think I may be having some of that, but haven't tried it yet. The dealer calibrated the tire pressures as posted here, but it hasn't completely damped the pull leftward. At higher speeds, the problem would be more pronounced, not necessarily for torque reasons - do you only notice it when you jump on the gas, or just at higher speeds?
  • hoyahenryhoyahenry Member Posts: 399
    Crossposting...

    The Honda is a great van and a safe purchase, but it's not perfect. Some of us "bargain" shoppers have better standard sound systems, standard fog lights (something I consider a safety feature), 3500lbs towing capacity with the required STANDARD factory-installed engine accessories for towing, and a better standard warranty. This bargain shopper also got a leather interior and a moonroof - all for less than the cost of an ODY LX -as someone compared it. (And one can't get factory leather in a Honda LX. No moonroofs in Odyland either.)

    To anticipate counter-arguments, I got less engine power, but a vehicle that is better for towing. I did not get a magic seat, but the seating arrangements in my van are quite versatile nonetheless- enough to get myself and 4 coworkers to the airport (try that with the magic seat down). I got less total cargo volume, but enough to easily meet my needs - bunkbeds and mattresses from BJs were no problem. And I got other interesting standard goodies like window controls in the rear passenger compartment.

    And the family just returned from 9 days at Steamboat Springs and I can still buy a boat and trailer with the $8K I didn't spend. It all comes down to value - to each his/her own - but I see no reason to preach the gospel of Honda the way some others do.
  • hoyahenryhoyahenry Member Posts: 399
    Do you own a minivan already or is this a new vehicle type for you. Vans in general require a whole new driving methodology, especially braking. The timing and visual distance cues used by the driver need to change, hills or just yellow lights. I felt this every time I drove the in-laws DC van. I also switch between the Cavalier (commuting) and Sedona (cruising/cargo errands). ABS or no should not matter on a dry road and only moderate braking. The brakes work the same until the wheels lose traction/contact with the road and stop turning. Then the brake pedal will tell you that the line in the laws of physics has been crossed and modulation willbe activated.

    Your vehicle does not have that system, but the effect I think you are experiencing is driver adjustment. The best way to find out is to drive a similar vehicle in type and weight and see if you notice a difference.
  • jondotjondot Member Posts: 63
    Thanks hoyahenry; yes, with different tires on front, started getting pull to other side. Then, they finally did an alignment and made adjustments which centered the steering wheel and made it track straight. I made them give me a copy of before and after numbers from the alignment machine. However, now on initial acceleration, it pulls to the left- the more throttle,the more pull. Slight pull there at highway speed on application of power but it's as not severe.I talked with a Kia rep and he said some torque steer is to be expected with any front drive vehicle. That is hard to believe in this day and age. I need to know if I'm alone with this problem. Nobody else has reported it.
  • hoyahenryhoyahenry Member Posts: 399
    Took out the tape measure today, and much to my surprise, the Sedona is Home Depot approved!

    Someone will no doubt point out that picking up drywall on a rainy day is a bad idea, but here's the scoop. With all four seats laid flat, there's over 48" of width to work with - enough for plywood and drywall. The length is about 1 foot short of 8 feet, so the trunk won't close. I didn't think 4' of width was available, so I was envisioning diagonally placed cargo if as and when I need it.

    With the seats removed, this remains true, but there are some floor obstructions off of the rear saddle bags. My suggestion is to use 2 2x4s or 2x6s, 8' in length laid flat to overcome that - will also provide a smooth sliding surface for loading the cargo. Bungee the trunk down, and voila - off for home.

    This may not impress anyone else, but I was pleasantly surprised.
  • steverstever Guest Posts: 52,454
    And if you use a 2x12 that is around 8 foot (or longer) you can confortably carry the 4x12' lengths of sheetrock too :-). Dry weather may be better for this trick, but it worked like a charm in my minivan. (credit to the local Ace Hardware).

    Steve
    Host
    SUVs, Vans and Aftermarket & Accessories Message Boards
  • davemakdavemak Member Posts: 3
    We picked up our Kia Sedona EX about three weeks ago. So far so good. We really do like this car much more than our Grand Voyager. We only received one remote key fob with the car. Is this normal or should we have gotten two?

    Thanks,

    Dave Mak

    BTW, I pull our original paper work on our Grand Voyager. We paid just as much three and a half years ago for a base Grand Voyager as we did for a loaded Kia.
  • dkritzdkritz Member Posts: 1
    I test drove a Kia Sedona EX today (loaded) and was more impressed than I expected to be. At this point, I've narrowed my choice to the Ody or Sedona. A few questions/comments:
    1) I found that, with the headrests in the 3rd row bench seat,that much of my view out of the center, rear-view mirror was blocked as compared with the Ody or T&C. Any one else experience this? Despite the comments in various reviews that I've read, I found the acceleration in the Sedona impressive and the car, overall, to be a good value.
    2) Anyone have comments (favorable/unfavorable) on dealers in the greater, Washington D.C. area? I didn't discuss price with the Sedona dealer, but judging from the number of cars on the lot, suspected their was some room for negotiation -- which, from reading this board, seems isn't necessarily the case in other parts of the country. I'd appreciate hearing what people have paid for a loaded EX in the D.C. area & whether my assumption re: possibility of negotiation in this part of this country is correct. Thanks.
  • mobilmacmobilmac Member Posts: 60
    oops i guessed i yesed one time 2 many,yes jondot my wife has been complaining about a strong left hand pull. I checked the air in the tires and found out it was 15 pounds to much,i thought that would cure it, didn't work. Let us know how you fixed it. We got 665 miles on it now, had it a week today, bought it with 20 miles on it, trying to collect all problems before taking it in. Everyone check your oil, these things run crazy if they are a half quart low, like my olds silhouette. I checked the oil, it was exactly 1/2 quart low, topped it off, the cars whole personality changed. I was ticked that the dealerships tech hadn't done his preinspection job, overall though my wife really likes her sedona. I will continue my other yes on the next post.
  • mobilmacmobilmac Member Posts: 60
    more responsive, with less stopping distance, since i don't drive it, i thought the brakes were going threw a break in phase, anyone else with that problem keep us posted.

    Yes, 1 key fob. Did everyone get their full tank of gas with their purchase.You better get it while you are their, it right on the window sticker. I didn't yet, we picked up our sedona late that night out of town after faxing in a credit app. that was instanly approved. So they waited for us and claimed that the only 2 persons on the premisses didn't have access to pump and they would mail me a fuel voucher, which i haven't seen yet. We will see.
    How about that radio, i think it has potential, but the speakers sound crappy, anyone made any changes yet.
  • mobilmacmobilmac Member Posts: 60
    using your rearview mirrorm, especially when she is backing, definitely needs refinement, i'm going to try to remove the head rest, if not, keep the seats folded down.
  • mobilmacmobilmac Member Posts: 60
    the colors of some the vehicles, example; on the front and on page 14 of the sedona brochure, it shows a sedona with there version of emerald green with platinum, have you you seen the real emerald green, if any of you found a color that matches the one on the front cover, let me know. We look every where for it, until we realized it didn't exist. It doesn't even come close.
  • gregoriusmgregoriusm Member Posts: 61
    1) I've driven a Green/Beige Sedona (don't have brochure handy to find out real name), and it is actually darker than what the brochure shows. It is impossible to accurately portray certain colours in a brochure using 4-color printing technology. Some printers are able to do it better than others.

    2) Thanks to the person who told me about the 12" x 24" rubbermaid box for the "trunk". That makes me feel much better!

    3) Torque steer. These days there should be minimal or no torque steer on a front wheel drive vehicle. When I test drove the Sedona, I wasn't looking for it, but will check it out next time I take one for a drive. VERY NOTICEABLE torque steer should be checked out by the dealer, for sure. - Greg
  • hoyahenryhoyahenry Member Posts: 399
    - Dulles Motorcars, Leesburg
    - 22.5k is a good target (median?) price for a loaded EX with ABS depending on dealer incentives (not the fin programs, but free oil changes, etc.) including dest charge. You are right, though, demand is growing and keep in mind that at least 1/2 of those on the lot were probably LX's.
  • marcoliusmarcolius Member Posts: 69
    Greg: one of the very few things I don't like about the car is lack of "stuff" space, like you described: cables, tools, and the like. I have an old shaving bag I keep a few tools in, and I wedged the cables in between the seats. I miss that underseat space.

    Another thing taking up space in the back is the rear headrests. Took 'em off. Didn't like the rear view obstructed. I just pop 'em back on if I have rear seat passengers.

    dkritz: Got my fully loaded EX at Sheehy in Springfield for just over 23,000. I'm sure you can do bettter but they had what I wanted, when I wanted it, and I was happy with the service department.

    Ex3: you were right again, dude. The hitch itself was a 20-30 minute task. AFTER I found a 2 foot pipe to use as a breaker bar on my rachet to loosen those bumper/frame bolts. SHEESH. Just about ruptured all my shoulder ligaments yanking on the thing without the bar. Now, do I need to cover the new bolts holding on the hitch with rubber cement or paint or something to reduce their rust likelihood, since I've breached the rustproofing barrier? And hey, you were right about the "burnt rubber" smell I had for a couple months. Big blob of rustproofing on the tail pipe.

    Oh, and I don't feel any torque steer on mine, either. And the Kia people tell me only one keyless remote, Kia "can't" make a second.
    Mark
  • laurelaggielaurelaggie Member Posts: 6
    We just bought our Kia Sedona LX on February 15. It has about 1,000 miles on it. This weekend we noticed that it was leaking a reddish fluid which we identified to be transmission fluid. We took it to the dealer this morning and they said it was a gasket leak, but they would have to replace the entire transmission! It will take a few days for them to get the parts in, but it is driveable until then. I was very happy with my Kia until this happened. Has anyone had a similar problem or this just a fluke? I haven't found any info online about the Sedona having a transmission problem.
  • marcoliusmarcolius Member Posts: 69
    I haven't seen that problem on this board, or in any other forum. Bummer. Glad to see they're addressing it without jerking you around, though.
  • bluedevilsbluedevils Member Posts: 2,554
    Sounds like a fluke, at least within the Edmunds owner community here. It's hard to tell at this point if that will turn out to be a common problem on the Sedonas. I sure hope not!

    To me, how the dealer handles problems is more important than the vehicle having few problems to begin with. At some point, every vehicle will need warranty service. The difference between the dealer handling things promptly and correctly, and being unable/unwilling to resolve a concern, can be the difference between sanity and insanity for many owners.
  • bluedevilsbluedevils Member Posts: 2,554
    Two words for you: Mighty Tite!

    I'm not sure that this will work with the car seat base, but I think it will...

    A friend told me a couple months ago about a product called Mighty-Tite. It's a device you connect to the lap portion of the seatbelt. It ratchets the belt tighter and tighter until the car seat is snug enough for your liking. It works well and is quick and easy to use. I've bought 3 of them so far (2 for our vehicles and 1 for my mother-in-law). Our 9-month old is in the middle right seat of our Sedona EX. Her car seat is rear-facing. We are not using the base (she's not in those small, comes-with-a-base car seats any more), but I see no reason why Mighty-Tite wouldn't work with a base. You slide it onto the lap belt within a couple inches of the car seat, on the side opposite the seat belt buckle. Once it's on, the device wraps the belt around a metal cylinder as you push down the yellow ratchet-handle thing. It works quite well.

    I've never been able to get car seats installed tight enough to be safe, until I heard about the Mighty-Tite. I've bought ours at Meijer (here in Michigan) for $17 or $18 each.

    I just checked to see if www.mightytite.com is the correct web address, and it is. There's a link on the left side of the home page for where to buy Mighty Tite.

    In the Sedona, our front seat must be moved forward a fair amount because the rear-facing seat in the middle row needs a fair amount of clearance. However, I think there's still enough room for someone under 6' to sit in the front passenger seat.

    I hope this helps.
  • bluedevilsbluedevils Member Posts: 2,554
    One of the first things I did after we drove home our new Sedona EX was to remove the 2 rear headrests. We will rarely use the third row seat, and our chocolate lab doesn't need a headrest, so we gained visibility with no real drawbacks. The headrests slide in and out easily enough that I don't see it as a problem to leave them out until they are needed.

    Alternatively, you could leave the headrests in and just fold the seats down, as mobilmac suggested.
  • bluedevilsbluedevils Member Posts: 2,554
    I have heard over the past few years that torque steer is a legitimate situation and I do believe it's more common in front-wheel drive vehicles than rear-drivers. Note that torque steer should occur mostly/only when the vehicle is accelerating. At a constant speed, it shouldn't be noticeable. When you really jam on the throttle, you will probably notice it quite a bit. That has been my experience on several other vehicles. The more torquey the engine, the more torque steer you are likely to get, in my opinion.
  • bluedevilsbluedevils Member Posts: 2,554
    I've found the Sedona's braking to be just fine. Stopping seems fairly smooth and short considering it's a minivan and not a sports car. Our EX has ABS, by the way. Car & Driver magazine recently (April 2002 issue?) tested the Sedona and they noted the brakes had good feel and good performance. Their test van had ABS.

    In normal, good-traction driving, a non-ABS vehicle should exhibit the same braking performance as the same vehicle equipped with ABS.
  • jster381jster381 Member Posts: 17
    I tried to buy an EX but found out that it had transmission problems (would not always go into reverse) and the dealer installed a brand new transmission on the car before it ever left the lot. That car only had about 150 miles on it, and at that point my wife would not let me continue to negotiate for the car (even though is was exactly what I was looking for color/options ect...)

    As far as the brochure and colors...I own a Misty Blue EX, and I don't think it looks anything like the picture on the front cover (it's darker, and I've gotten several compliments on the color).

    bluedevils...regarding your car seat...I was told not to put a rear facing car seat in the middle row (by the salesman). He suggested the third row (which is a pain). Did someone tell you the middle row was ok for a carseat?
  • laurelaggielaurelaggie Member Posts: 6
    I have read reports that say putting a car seat in the 3rd row is not a good idea unless you absolutely have to. They say its because there isn't much space between the back row and the back of the van. If you were rear ended the people in the 3rd row could be seriously injured. This is more of a problem in the SUV with the optional 3rd row (Buick Rendezvous, Ford Explorer) because those seats almost touch the rear windshield. Anyway, both my kids ride in the middle row. The oldest, who is 5, will ride in the back when we have extra people, but the baby, who is still rear facing, will always ride in the middle row.
  • jondotjondot Member Posts: 63
    Steering pull? Make them do an alignment but insist on a copy of the before and after readings from the alignment machine. You're not using the same dealer I got mine at are you? It took them five tries before they fixed my pulling. They finally made alignment adjustments on the 5th visit! Just did a five wheel tire rotation (at Walmart) since I have 10K miles on my EX. Steering seems ok, but I'm not sure about the torque steer--it may have gone away but I need to drive a little more to be sure. The roads were a little wet and slick but the left pull an acceleration seems to be gone
  • marcoliusmarcolius Member Posts: 69
    Who knows? We're buyers who liked the car and the warranty, and are hoping that Kia has learned from history. For details, move up 1141 messages and start reading.
  • bb8bb8 Member Posts: 60
    Yes, I saw the Green/platinum two tone in the dealer lot, dark green kind of, I browsed over and passed. It did exist.
  • mcperrmcperr Member Posts: 74
    The brakes in our EX scared the cr*p out of me several times for about two months after we purchased our van last August. Approaching a stop light or sign I would apply the brakes, and apply the brakes, AND APPLY THE BRAKES with not much deceleration occuring. I was about to take the van back to the dealer and threaten legal action when the brakes began to work much better. They now are very good and stop the vehicle in a straight line with no fuss. Just a long break-in period for the pads/disks, I guess.

    All front-wheel drive vehicles torque-steer somewhat, as discussed exhaustively elsewhere above. Our Sedona exhibits very little torque-steer, even with the six adults we had in a recent load. I only notice it under hard acceleration (I love this engine)when one front wheel slips a bit and when accelerating while turning a sharp corner. Very minor. It should not occur under steady throttle. If the van pulls then, it is not torque steer.
  • bluedevilsbluedevils Member Posts: 2,554
    I have never heard anything about this being a hazard. All I've heard is that you do NOT put kids/infants/babies in the front row, no matter what kind of vehicle.

    Logically, the middle row seems a safer place than the 3rd row, for the reasons laurelaggie explained above.
  • bluedevilsbluedevils Member Posts: 2,554
    "Reliability" is not a single "problem" that a company can simply attack and magically declare "Okay, we're all set. No more problems with reliability." Reliability is measured on a scale, as are other things such as initial quality.

    It seems safe to say that in the case of the Sedona, Kia has started reliability and quality on the upswing. The fit and finish on this vehicle and overall build quality are nothing like the cheap, crappy small Kia sedans of a few years ago.
  • 1badhippie1badhippie Member Posts: 10
    As bluedevils pointed out, Car and Driver tested the Sedona in the latest issue. One point that they made is that the payload capacity is rather small, due to the weight of the van. I think they listed it as 1032 lbs., but Edmunds lists it as 1186 lbs. Car and Driver pointed out (using their numbers) that this is equivalent to 6 passengers weighing 172 lbs., with no cargo.

    I do not see this as being a "problem" in most situations, but when you want to load up the family (incl. in-laws) for a trip to the beach, or a short trip out of town for a few days, it might be an issue. You don't really want to pull out the scales and weigh everyone and their luggage, but then again you don't want to compromise the handling or the safety of the vehicle.

    Thoughts, anyone?
  • bluedevilsbluedevils Member Posts: 2,554
    It's amazing how many vehicles list a payload capacity that is much lower than it should be. 1,000 pounds for an SUV or minivan? People are exceeding their vehicle's specified payload maximum all the time. And probably by quite a bit, in many cases.

    I guess this is CYA for the manufacturers, but I don't worry about it. If the vehicle feels like it has the same handling, braking, etc. characteristics and you are technically over the payload limit, I don't see what the problem is. Many vehicles have a practical safe payload that far exceeds the manufacturer's stated maximum, in my opinion.

    Would this ever result in the manufacturer denying a warranty claim? I don't see how. I'm not sure what kind of items would realistically be damaged by exceeding the payload-- shocks, perhaps? Well, if you bring the vehicle to the dealer with bad shocks at 5k miles, how do they know if you have exceeded the payload max? Do vehicles come with a sensor and computer that registers this fact and stores the information (how much weight, how many miles, how many times, etc.)? I believe the answer to that is "no."

    I'm not dismissing this concern simply because I own a Sedona and it has a wimpy specified payload. I just feel this way in general.
  • bluedevilsbluedevils Member Posts: 2,554
    I was reading this issue last night. The "car guide" article includes lots of vehicle data. The depreciation stats are from the Insurance Services Office, an industry-supported research organization. I've never heard of 'em, but their minivan depreciation numbers were pretty interesting.

    They defined resale value as a percentage of sticker price after 5 years. Here are some of their estimates for 2002 models. The Odyssey was by far the leader, and Sienna was firmly in second place. The rest of the vans spread out pretty gradually below those two models. Here are some of the numbers:

    Honda Odyssey EX 46%
    Honda Odyssey LX 47%
    Toyota Sienna LE 42%
    Toyota Sienna CE 40%
    Kia Sedona EX 34%
    Kia Sedona LX 33%
    Chrysler Town & Country LX 36%
    Chrysler Town & Country LX 34%
    Chrysler Voyager 28%
    Dodge Grand Caravan eX 31%
    Dodge Grand Caravan Sport 30%
    Chevy Venture LS 29%
    Chevy Venture Value 27%
    Dodge Caravan 26%
    Ford Windstar 25%
    Ford Windstar LX 29%
    Mazda MPV ES 33%
    Mazda MPV LX 33%
    Mercury Villager Estate Plus 31%
    Mercury Villager Plus 31%
    Nissan Quest SE 36%
    Nissan Quest GXE 35%
    Olds Silhouette GL 30%
    Pontiac Montana 1SA 31%
    Pontiac Montana 1SV 30%

    Other than Sienna and Odyssey, the vans were distributed between 25% and 36%. The Sedona's predicted resale value is actually better than most of its competitors. It bested most of the American models, some (Windstar, Venture/Silhouette, most DCX vans) by a significant margin. Granted, the Sedona numbers are more estimate than fact-based since the van is so new, but the numbers are still encouraging.

    When you consider actual market price instead of MSRP, some vans' numbers will get better and some will get worse. Comparatively, the Odyssey gets worse than others that are sold below MSRP because Ody typically goes for MSRP or more.

    I was optimistic about Sedona's resale value, and this article confirms that my assumptions might be valid.
  • akwilliamsakwilliams Member Posts: 40
    I am not sure where Car and Driver gets thier numbers, but on our recent trip down south, we loaded 4 men (average 200 lbs) 4 suit cases (average 50 lbs) 4 small bags (average 20 lbs) and four golf bags (average 45 lbs. Add to that an ice cooler that holds at least a case and a half and you are close to 1300 lbs. The vehicle NEVER felt over loaded or under powered. In fact, we never gave it a thought until I read theses posts. Clearly, the van can handle much more than is being suggested. Does anyone know where the payload numbers come from?
  • 1badhippie1badhippie Member Posts: 10
    Thanks for the replies!

    I assume Car & Driver (C&D) got the payload numbers from Kia (maybe a press kit?). Edmunds lists it as 1186 lbs., so the numbers are close.

    C&D gave the Sedona a fairly positive review...one of the few minor "gripes" they had dealt with the weight of the van. They were impressed with the "astute feel of the controls," specifically mentioning the steering and braking. "Kia hasn't overtaken Chrysler for carlike driving dynamics yet, but it's looming in the Voyager/Caravan's rear view mirror" they say.

    The 0-60 mph time was clocked at 9.6 seconds...not too bad.

    One of the minor gripes that I had about their review concerns their reference to none of the seats rolling on wheels or rails (just "heavy and awkward cargo" when not being used as seats). However, the brochure indicates the rear seats do roll on wheels when removed, and I was sure that I have read that the middle and rear seats to adjust fore and aft to improve leg room & comfort. Maybe their test model had different equipment...?

    In the Counterpoint section, one of the writers wonders why it should matter how the van drives, seeing as how Kia has taken so long to introduce a minivan that is four years old into a segment for which the "party is over" (referencing a soft minivan market and the various rebates from the other brands), and is outclassed by most of the competition. Ummmm...that is why I read the *&^% magazine...it IS called Car and DRIVER, after all. Besides, the minivan market is not the only segment that has "gone soft."

    Other segments have gone soft, as well. One Chevy/Chrysler/Dodge/Jeep/Kia dealership near my town was offering up to $5000 in rebates on ALL makes of cars on their lot. As well, I believe that Chevrolet is offering a $2002 rebate on most, if not all, of their models.

    Lastly, the PT Cruiser, for which most buyers paid up to $10,000 over MSRP (including the U.S. Government, who bought 2 for crash testing and gave the dealer a nice $20000 profit), is now included with a $1000 rebate in some sections of the country.

    Chris
  • bluedevilsbluedevils Member Posts: 2,554
    They evaluated the Sedona pretty thoroughly, but I agree that some of their comments seemed strange and/or worthless.

    The counterpoint about the guy griping that the Sedona is 4 years late or something was just plain dumb. Is the van competitive now or not? If not, fine-- just say so. But don't knock the van just because it wasn't introduced 4 years ago. Those comments made no sense.

    In the end, I really couldn't tell whether CD's overall spin on the Sedona was positive or negative. They had some compliments and some criticisms. But the article included several statements that I couldn't even understand. The subheading about the van being 20% off or something like that-- I didn't know if that was a slam or a kudo. Ditto with the pluses/minuses/verdict comments in the small box on the second page. I didn't understand the "verdict" at all.

    Sometimes I think the writers in the auto magazines are more into their prose than the analysis of the vehicle.
Sign In or Register to comment.

Your Privacy

By accessing this website, you acknowledge that Edmunds and its third party business partners may use cookies, pixels, and similar technologies to collect information about you and your interactions with the website as described in our Privacy Statement, and you agree that your use of the website is subject to our Visitor Agreement.